Turning journal instructions into a working manuscript
Every journal publishes instructions for authors, but those instructions sit on top of shared standards. Most biomedical journals follow the ICMJE Recommendations for structure, authorship and disclosure, and many require a reporting guideline appropriate to the study design: CONSORT for randomised trials, STROBE for observational studies, PRISMA for systematic reviews, STARD for diagnostic accuracy and CARE for case reports. The articles in this category explain how these layers fit together and how to prepare a manuscript that meets them before it reaches an editor.
Where journal instructions and a reporting guideline appear to conflict, for example over word limits, the usual solution is to keep the required information and move detail to supplementary material, with a sentence in the main text directing readers to it. Editors generally prefer complete reporting to strict brevity.
Questions this category answers
- What does a reporting guideline actually require? The STROBE article explains how the Strengthening the Reporting of Observational Studies in Epidemiology statement improves reporting of cohort, case-control and cross-sectional studies.
- Why are manuscripts rejected? One piece sets out the main reasons editors and reviewers give, which commonly include poor scope fit, unclear methods, overstated conclusions and failure to follow journal requirements.
- How does peer review work, and what do reviewers look for? The peer review article explains the stages of review and how authors benefit from it.
- How should a manuscript be edited and kept consistent? Articles on copyediting, on style sheets and on editing before submission cover consistency of terminology, numbers, units and references.
- How do co-authors draft together? The Overleaf article describes a shared LaTeX workflow, which some journals and many quantitative fields prefer.
A pre-submission sequence that works
- Identify the reporting guideline for your design and complete its checklist against the draft, noting the page where each item appears.
- Check the target journal's article type limits: word count, number of tables and figures, abstract structure and reference limit.
- Build a style sheet covering spelling (UK or US), abbreviations, units, number formats and drug nomenclature, and apply it throughout.
- Prepare the declarations: ethics approval and consent, trial or review registration, funding, conflicts of interest using the ICMJE disclosure form, author contributions and data availability.
- Reformat references in the journal's style and check that every citation matches an entry.
- Ask a colleague who was not involved to read the abstract and conclusions against the results.
Where to go next
For formatting a finished draft to a particular journal's template, see manuscript formatting for journal submission. If a desk rejection is the concern, nine submission mistakes that lead to desk rejection covers the avoidable ones. Authors who want an independent critique before submitting can use our pre-submission peer review.
All articles in this category
Show all 8
- Copyediting a Manuscript: Benefits and Evidence
- Editing a Manuscript Before Submission: The Evidence
- Manuscript Categories in Cardiovascular CT
- Overleaf’s Collaborative process
- Peer Review of a Manuscript: Evidence and Benefits
- Reasons for Manuscript Rejection: Editorial Records
- Scientific and Academic Style Sheets Formatting Guide
- What do STROBE guidelines entail?







