Assessment and Exam Review Services
Pubrica provides assessment and exam review for universities, examination boards, accreditation agencies, training providers and EdTech platforms. Our assessment reviewers and psychometricians check every item for ambiguous wording, learning outcomes that no item assesses, rubrics that markers apply inconsistently and questions that are harder for some learners for reasons unrelated to the subject. You receive the reviewed assessment, an outcome-to-item matrix, a cognitive level distribution, a rubric analysis and a findings report with recommendations.
- Ambiguous and unclear questions identified and rewritten, so each question measures subject knowledge rather than reading skill
- Every learning outcome mapped to the items that assess it, including any outcomes that no item assesses
- Cognitive levels balanced using Bloom’s taxonomy, so an exam that claims to test analysis does not test only recall
- Rubrics and marking schemes validated for consistency between markers, transparency to students and alignment with the outcomes
- Bias and fairness reviewed: cultural, linguistic and contextual, so the assessment measures the same construct for every learner
Question clarity and structureReviewed
Outcome alignment and coverageReviewed
Cognitive level balanceReviewed
Rubric consistency and transparencyReviewed
Writing new questions for youOn request
Setting the pass markClient decision
Written → reviewed → mapped → validated → sat
- Every item mapped to an outcome
- Cognitive level marked against Bloom
- Rubric checked for marker consistency
- Bias and fairness reviewed
- Each finding located in the assessment
Service Scope
Six Review Checks and a Detailed Findings Report
The scope is written on your order. Decisions on what should be taught and where the pass mark is set remain yours throughout.
From the item reviewQ14. Which of the following is not an example of a factor that would not be excluded from the analysis?The stem contains two negatives and has been rewritten as a positive question. Sixty per cent of the cohort answered incorrectly, and the item discriminated on reading ability rather than on content.
From the alignment matrixTwo outcomes unassessed. The module states that learners will appraise evidence and design a study. No item in the exam or coursework assesses either outcome. Accreditation panels typically check for this first.
From the cognitive map40 items · 31 Remember · 7 Understand · 2 Apply · 0 aboveRemapped to 12 Remember, 14 Apply, 10 Analyse and 4 Evaluate, matching the levels the outcomes state. The subject content did not change.
From the rubric reviewBand 3: “Shows good understanding and a reasonable attempt at analysis.”Two markers applied this band to scripts that differed by 14 marks. We rewrote it with observable criteria that describe what a band 3 script contains, so that a second marker can check the grade.
From the fairness reviewQ22 uses a cricket scoring scenario. It assesses proportional reasoning, but only for candidates who understand cricket scoring. We rewrote it with a context familiar to every candidate, and the mathematics is unchanged.
From the compliance mapOutcome-to-item matrix · cognitive distribution by outcome · rubric criteria mapped to outcome statements · cross-course consistency table. Formatted for submission to a reviewer.
The samples shown are illustrative and anonymised. Hover over a sample to replay it.
Our Services
Six Types of Assessment and Exam Review
These services are priced as packages because they depend on each other. For example, rewritten items usually require a revised rubric.
Assessments we review: Exams and question papers, quizzes and assignments, rubrics and marking schemes, certifications and standardised tests. Client decisions: the pass mark, the standard and the curriculum. We report whether the assessment does what your own documents state; we do not decide what those documents should say.
Who We Serve
Clients We Support with Assessment and Exam Review
Requirements differ by client in the stakes involved and the framework the assessment must meet. Our review method is the same for each.
Compliance and Standards
Seven Assessment Standards and Frameworks
An assessment review is measured against a recognised framework. Your accrediting body’s requirements apply in addition to these standards.
Bloom’s revised taxonomy (Anderson & Krathwohl, 2001)
The framework used to classify and count cognitive levels, and to check whether an exam that claims to assess analysis in fact tests recall.
Standards for Educational and Psychological Testing (2014 edition)
The reference work on validity, reliability and fairness in testing, against which high-stakes assessments are reviewed.
Validity and reliability evidence (Content, construct and consequential)
Evidence that the assessment measures what it claims, measures it consistently and does not produce unintended effects.
Fairness and bias review (Cultural, linguistic and contextual)
An item that is harder for one group for reasons unrelated to the subject is a validity problem.
Universal Design for Learning (CAST, version 3.0)
Inclusive assessment design, so that the format does not create a barrier for part of the cohort.
Your accreditation standard (Institutional, national or professional)
Each accrediting body sets the mapping it requires. We work to your framework and deliver the mapping as a document.
Quality management (cert. H3CR9TCU20251212INDQM10N)
This certification covers how the review is run, recorded and signed off. It is not a claim about your assessment.
Responsible Use of AI
Our Approach to AI Use and Disclosure
AI tools support specific, checkable tasks. Editorial judgement, final wording and sign-off remain with Pubrica subject specialists.
Why We Do Not Publish AI Accuracy Figures
Accuracy figures for AI tools are usually reported by the companies that sell them.
Pubrica therefore does not quote its own accuracy figures, as they would carry the same conflict of interest. Instead, we tell you which tool was used on your project, at which stage, and what a specialist changed afterwards.
Methodology
How Our Assessment Review Process Works
Comments on individual questions form part of the review. The matrix showing which items assess each outcome is the main deliverable.
Initial review
We read the assessment material against its objectives, target learners, subject content and instructional outcomes, so the review is based on the purpose of the assessment.
Content and structure evaluation
Whether questions are clearly written, logically structured and properly related to the syllabus and the learning outcomes they claim to assess.
Rubric and scoring analysis
We analyse how the marking scheme was built and test whether it is applied consistently, fairly and transparently across markers.
Bias and quality check
We review items for bias, ambiguity, duplication and unintended difficulty arising from wording, context or format rather than from the subject.
Review and quality assurance
We compile the findings into a report with recommendations. Each finding is located and kept separate from its recommendation, so you can accept a finding without adopting our proposed change.
Final delivery
You receive the reviewed assessment, the outcome-to-item matrix, the cognitive distribution, the rubric analysis and the recommendations, ready to use or to submit to a reviewer.
Request a Free Review of One Exam
We return the exam with every question mapped to the outcome it assesses, its cognitive level marked, ambiguous items flagged with an explanation, and any unassessed outcomes listed. Delivered within two business days at no charge.
Please send the learning outcomes with the exam. Without them, the review can address wording but not whether the assessment measures what it is intended to measure.
Our Experts
Your Assessment Review Team
A named team of subject specialists stays with your project from scoping to delivery. Your project coordinator introduces each team member by name before work begins.
Reviews the scientific content for accuracy and confirms that each conclusion is supported by the evidence. Each expert is matched to your field.
Reviews content for accuracy, pedagogy and conformance with the applicable curriculum, assessment or accessibility standard.
Checks the finished work independently against the agreed scope and the applicable checklist. Findings are logged and resolved before delivery.
Manages the timeline, keeps you informed at each stage and coordinates the team so that questions are answered and deadlines are met.
Sample Work
Sample Review: Forty Questions Mapped to Six Learning Outcomes
Step through the six findings one at a time. Two of them are issues that accreditation panels typically identify first, and both became visible only once the exam was mapped.
As written. A 40-item end-of-module exam with a marking scheme, six stated learning outcomes, no mapping between them.
- 40 items, 31 of them recall
- LO3 “critically evaluate” · LO5 “design a study”
- Q14: two negatives in one stem
- Q22: scenario built on cricket scoring
- Rubric band 3: “good understanding, reasonable attempt”
- Q7 and Q31 test the same point
Findings. Each finding is located, graded and kept separate from its recommendation.
- B1 · Major — cognitive distribution does not match what the outcomes claim. Remapped, content unchanged
- A2 · Critical — two outcomes are not assessed anywhere. Typically checked first by accreditation panels
- Q14 · Major — double negative; 60% failure rate discriminating on reading, not content
- Q22 · Major — context-dependent bias. Same mathematics, new scenario
- R4 · Major — two markers, 14 marks apart on the same script. Criteria rewritten as observable
- D1 · Minor — duplicate coverage; one item freed for an unassessed outcome
Cognitive levels are classified using Bloom’s revised taxonomy. Marker variation comes from a blind double-marking exercise on eight scripts. The extract is redacted, and the subject and figures have been changed.
Benefits
Benefits of Assessment and Exam Review
Each benefit can be checked in your assessment after the review. None is a claim about learner performance, which depends on more than the assessment.
Packages
Assessment and Exam Review Packages
Each package is priced on the number of items, whether rubrics and cross-course consistency are in scope, and whether the output must meet an accrediting body’s requirements. We complete a free review first and quote on that basis.
Basic assessment review
Individual educators and small academic programmes
Quoted per projectPriced per assessment
Delivery 3–5 business days
- ✓Question clarity and structure reviewed
- ✓Alignment checked against the stated learning objectives
- ✓Difficulty level assessed
- ✓A summary review report with every finding located
Best for quizzes, short exams and assignments.
View a sample Request a quoteAdvanced assessment validation
Universities and professional training programmes
Quoted per projectPriced on item count and rubrics
Delivery 5–7 business days
- ✓Everything in Basic
- ✓Rubric and marking scheme validated
- ✓Bias and fairness review, item by item
- ✓Cognitive level mapping against Bloom’s taxonomy
- ✓Outcome-to-item matrix delivered as a document
- ✓Detailed improvement recommendations
Best for course exams, certifications and institutional assessments.
View a sample Request a quoteAssessment quality assurance
Accrediting bodies, large institutions and high-stakes examinations
Quoted per projectPriced on programme scope
Delivery 7–10 business days
- ✓Everything in Advanced
- ✓Full assessment framework review
- ✓Accreditation and Compliance Alignment
- ✓Cross-course consistency checks
- ✓Double-marking exercise to test the rubric in use
- ✓Expert QA review and a validation report
Best for standardised tests, large-scale exams and accreditation reviews.
View a sample Request a quoteSend one exam with its learning outcomes and we will review it free of charge, then quote based on the item count and scope. Exam banks and multi-programme work are quoted against a schedule.
Quality Assurance
Our Service Commitment
Our service commitment, its limits and the remedy we offer are set out below.
Our quality commitment
Every Item Mapped to a Learning Outcome
The main deliverable is a matrix showing each item, the outcome it assesses and the cognitive level of both, which shows clearly whether your outcomes are covered.
01
Mapping Delivered as a Document
The matrix is formatted for submission to an accreditation reviewer, which is the main reason most institutions commission this review.
02
Findings Kept Separate from Recommendations
You can accept that an item is ambiguous without adopting our proposed rewrite.
03
Academic Decisions Remain with You
The pass mark, the standard and the curriculum are yours. We report whether the assessment does what your documents state.
04
Free Re-review or a Refund
If the work does not meet the level on your order, we revise it at no charge within the agreed scope, or refund it if you prefer.
Client Stories
FAQs
Assessment and Exam Review FAQs
If your question is not answered here, ask an expert — no quote is required.
A poorly designed assessment can lead to unfair grading, learner dissatisfaction and accreditation risk, and these problems are not visible in the mark distribution.
The most common finding is also the most serious: outcomes that the programme states but the assessment does not test. This gap becomes visible only when the assessment is mapped.
Exams and question papers, quizzes and assignments, rubrics and marking schemes, and certifications and standardised tests.
For certification and high-stakes testing, we also run a double-marking exercise, because a rubric is best tested by applying it.
Yes, and it is the core of the review. Every item is mapped to the outcome it assesses and marked for cognitive level, so both coverage and level are visible.
The matrix is formatted as a document that you can submit to a reviewer.
We review each item for cultural, linguistic and contextual bias, meaning anything that makes a question harder for one group for reasons unrelated to the subject.
The most common source is the scenario context rather than the wording. A question set around a sport, a holiday or a household arrangement assumes knowledge that not all candidates share, and it can usually be rewritten easily.
Yes. The assessment is checked against your institutional and accrediting body requirements, and the mapping, cognitive distribution and rubric analysis are delivered as documents.
We recommend commissioning the review before an accreditation visit rather than after a finding, when gaps are easier to address.
Yes, on request, where you have defined what each item should measure. Without that definition, new questions cannot be written as valid assessment items.
We do not set your pass mark or your standard. Those are academic decisions for you and your institution.
Related Services
Related Learning Design and Publishing Services
This service checks whether the assessment measures what the programme states. The services below cover programme design and the production of assessment and course material.
1FOR COURSE DESIGNoften commissioned together
Learning design & pedagogyObjectives, sequencing, instructional strategy and outcome mapping.Insights
Further Reading on Assessment and Exam Review
Request a Free Review of One Exam
We map every question to the outcome it assesses, mark cognitive levels, flag ambiguous items with an explanation and list any unassessed outcomes. Delivered within two business days at no charge.