Free scoping read. A written assessment of your manuscript in two business days, at no cost.

Start one

Home›Services›Editorial & journal services›Forensic & quality audit

Editorial and journal services for researchers and publishers

Forensic & Quality Audit Services

Pubrica provides forensic and quality audits of manuscripts, datasets, figures and research documentation. Our research integrity specialists, statisticians and image specialists work with researchers, institutions, publishers, healthcare organisations and CROs. They examine data accuracy, image authenticity, methodology reporting and guideline compliance before submission or in response to a query, and deliver an evidenced audit report graded by severity, with recommended corrective actions.

  • Two audit functions in one engagement: the forensic audit looks for manipulation, duplication and undisclosed non-compliance, and the quality audit tests whether the process and reporting meet the standard they claim
  • Image forensics on scientific visuals: microscopy, gels, flow cytometry plots and medical scans examined for duplication, splicing, contrast manipulation and resizing
  • Data integrity checked against the methods, including whether the described procedure is consistent with the reported numbers
  • Compliance audited against the named guideline: COPE, ICMJE, CONSORT, PRISMA, ARRIVE, GCP, GLP and IRB requirements, item by item
  • A report you can act on: every finding evidenced, located and graded by severity, with what to correct, what to disclose and what requires no action
Scope of a Forensic and Quality Audit What is included and what is excluded

Data and statistical integrityAudited

Image authenticityAudited

Plagiarism and authorshipAudited

Guideline compliance, item by itemAudited

Correcting the manuscript for youSeparate service

Concluding that misconduct occurredNot part of the audit

Submitted → audited → evidenced → you decide

Included in every audit
  • Every finding located and evidenced
  • Graded by severity
  • Guideline named and versioned
  • Under NDA
  • Corrective actions listed separately
COPE and ICMJEPlus CONSORT, PRISMA, ARRIVE, GCP and GLP
3–15 business daysBy depth · scoped before quoting
Confidential by defaultNDA, encrypted transfer, access controlled
ISO 9001:2015Quality management certified · cert. H3CR9TCU20251212INDQM10N

Service Scope

Six Components of Every Forensic and Quality Audit

The scope is written on your order, with the guideline and its version named. Every finding is evidenced and located so that you can check it yourself.

Data Integrity Checked Against the Methods We assess the consistency, completeness and authenticity of research data, including anomalies, raw dataset validation, statistical procedure checks and mismatches between the methods described and the data reported.

From the findingsD3 · High. The methods describe a per-protocol analysis, but Table 2 reports n = 126, which is the enrolled total. Either the analysis set or the table is incorrect. We have not assumed which.

Image forensics on scientific visuals We examine microscopy images, gels, flow cytometry plots, medical scans and graphs for duplication, splicing, contrast manipulation, resizing and internal inconsistency.

From the image auditI2 · Critical. Figure 3B and Figure 5A share an identical 180 × 140 px region at a different rotation. Flagged with coordinates and both crops attached. This requires your explanation before submission.

Manuscript quality and structural audit We audit technical, scientific and structural integrity against journal expectations, including methodology clarity, reproducibility, ethical statements, reference accuracy, figure-to-table alignment and consistency across sections.

From the structural auditAbstract: 17% reduction · Results: 21% · Discussion: “about a fifth”One result is reported with three different figures in the same manuscript. Each instance is located and listed for you to reconcile against the source data.

Plagiarism and authorship verification We verify text originality, citation accuracy, reference patterns, paraphrasing quality and authorship validity, using software tools and manual review, including self-plagiarism, mosaic plagiarism and improper attribution.

From the originality auditP1 · Moderate. 340 words in the introduction match your own 2021 paper at 94%, uncited. This is self-plagiarism under COPE guidance. It can be corrected quickly, and it is the most common finding we report.

Methodology and statistical quality check We assess the adequacy, transparency and reproducibility of the statistics, including sample sizes, hypotheses, tests applied, confidence intervals, p values, effect sizes and whether the interpretation follows from them.

From the statistical auditp = 0.0000 · “NS” · no confidence intervals · no effect sizeS2 · High. A p value is never 0.0000. No confidence interval or effect size is reported, which CONSORT 17a requires and a statistical reviewer is likely to request first.

Compliance and regulatory audit We audit adherence to the relevant guidance: COPE for publication ethics, ICMJE for authorship and manuscript requirements, CONSORT for trials, PRISMA for systematic reviews, ARRIVE for animal research, and GCP, GLP and IRB requirements.

From the compliance auditC4 · High. The registered primary outcome and the reported primary outcome differ, and the change is not reported. Reviewers who consult the registry will notice this, so it should be addressed in the methods now.

The samples shown are illustrative and anonymised. Hover over a sample to replay it.

Our Services

Six Types of Forensic and Quality Audit

Audits are priced as packages because the six types overlap. Your package depends on how many of these audits your question requires and in how much depth.

Data integrity auditConsistency, completeness and authenticity of research data, including anomalies, raw dataset validation, statistical procedure checks and mismatches between the methods and the outcomes.
Image forensics and authenticityMicroscopy, graphs, medical scans, flow cytometry plots and gel electrophoresis reviewed for duplication, splicing, contrast manipulation and resizing.
Manuscript quality and structural auditMethodology clarity, reproducibility, ethical statements, reference accuracy, figure-to-table alignment and consistency across sections, against journal expectations.
Plagiarism and authorship verificationText originality, citation accuracy, reference patterns, paraphrasing quality and authorship validity, checked with software tools and by manual review.
Methodology and statistical quality checkSample sizes, hypotheses, tests applied, confidence intervals, p values, effect sizes and whether the interpretation follows, examined by statisticians and subject experts.
Compliance and regulatory auditAdherence to COPE, ICMJE, CONSORT, PRISMA and ARRIVE, and to GCP, GLP and IRB requirements where the work is regulated.

Limits of an audit: We report what the evidence shows. We do not conclude that misconduct occurred, and we do not correct the manuscript as part of the audit. Correction is an editing service, quoted separately so that the audit remains independent.

Who we serve

Clients We Support with Forensic and Quality Audits

The intended reader of the report determines how the evidence is recorded. The care with which it is gathered is the same for every client.

Healthcare and life sciences organisationsHospitals, CROs, pharmaceutical companies and diagnostic networks, for compliance with regulatory guidance, ethical standards and data accuracy across research, trials and documentation.
Academic and research institutionsUniversities, laboratories and funding bodies, auditing research integrity, data accuracy and publication ethics in support of responsible research practice.
Government bodies and public sector unitsCompliance evaluation, governance and process review where the findings must withstand public scrutiny.
Non-profits and NGOsDocumentation, reporting accuracy and compliance for donor and programme accountability.
Legal and investigation firmsEvidence validation and expert reporting to support dispute resolution, with the chain of custody and evidentiary standard agreed before work begins.

Compliance and Standards

Seven Compliance Frameworks Used in Forensic and Quality Audits

An audit is meaningful only when measured against a standard. Each framework is listed at the version we work to, and every compliance finding cites the item number concerned.

COPE (Committee on Publication Ethics)

Sets out the flowcharts publishers follow when research is questioned. Our findings are graded so that they map onto these flowcharts.

ICMJE Recommendations (January 2026)

Covers authorship, contributorship, declarations and trial registration, checked for presence, consistency and agreement with the registry.

CONSORT (2025 statement)

Randomised trial reporting, audited item by item, including the items most often missed: outcome changes, blinding and harms.

PRISMA2020

PRISMA (2020, 27 items)

Systematic review and meta-analysis reporting, with the flow diagram numbers reconciled against the text.

ARRIVE2.0

ARRIVE 2.0 (Essential 10 and Recommended Set)

Animal research reporting. Audits most often find gaps in the Essential 10.

GCPICH E6(R3)

Good Clinical and Laboratory Practice (ICH E6(R3), January 2025)

For regulated work, the audit assesses compliance with the practice standard as well as the reporting guideline.

ISO9001:2015

Quality management (cert. H3CR9TCU20251212INDQM10N)

Covers how the audit itself is run, recorded and reviewed. It is not a finding about your work.

Responsible Use of AI

Our Approach to AI Use and Disclosure

AI tools support specific, checkable tasks. Editorial judgement, final wording and sign-off remain with Pubrica subject specialists.

How We Use AI ToolsWe use AI tools to find and group issues at scale, such as inconsistent terminology, reference formatting and style deviations, which a specialist then reviews and resolves.
How We Do Not Use AI ToolsWe do not use AI tools to write or rewrite scientific content, make editorial, ethical or integrity decisions, assess research quality or sign off any deliverable.
What Your AI Declaration Should IncludeYour declaration should name the tool, the stage at which it was used and the human oversight applied. Journals, funders, regulators and the ICMJE January 2026 update now expect this, and an undeclared tool found later is treated as an integrity matter.

Why We Do Not Publish an AI Accuracy Figure

Accuracy figures for AI tools are usually reported by the companies that sell them.

Pubrica therefore does not quote a self-generated accuracy figure, because it would carry the same conflict of interest. Instead, we tell you which tool was used on your project, at which stage, and what a specialist changed afterwards.

Methodology

Forensic and Quality Audit Methodology

A pre-submission check and a response to a journal query require different approaches, so scoping is a separate step that defines the audit before work begins.

Step one

Consultation and scoping

We establish what you need, what concerns you and where the risk lies. We then define the scope, set the objectives and agree the timeline, so the audit concentrates on the areas of greatest risk.

Step two

Preliminary assessment

We review the data, documentation and process to identify high-risk areas and obvious gaps. The detailed plan is based on this assessment, which is occasionally sufficient on its own.

Step three

Detailed audit planning

We select the methodology, define the control points and choose the tools before examining any material. Agreeing the plan in advance makes the findings defensible.

Step four

Evidence collection and examination

We gather and examine records, workflows, source files and systems using forensic techniques, and record the provenance of each item as it is collected.

Step five

Analysis and verification

We cross-verify findings before reporting them. A single anomaly is often an artefact; the same anomaly in three places is a finding.

Step six

Reporting and recommendations

Every finding is located, evidenced and graded, with recommendations that distinguish what must be corrected, what must be disclosed and what is a matter of judgement.

Step seven

Follow-up and support

We support you in implementing corrective actions and revising policies or the manuscript, and re-audit the affected areas where you need to demonstrate that a gap has been closed.

Request a Free Audit of One Figure Panel and Methods Section

You receive a written finding on each item, stating what we checked, what we found, how severe it is and what we recommend. The audit takes two business days and is free of charge. If we find no problems, the report will say so.

What you provide
The manuscriptOr the dataset or figures
The source filesOriginal files, not exports
The protocolOr registration, where one exists
The guidelineCONSORT, PRISMA, ARRIVE or none
The reasonPre-submission, query received, or routine
The deadlineAnd who is waiting for it

Please tell us why you are requesting the audit. A pre-submission check, a journal query and an institutional investigation need different depths and different reports, and scoping the audit to your question keeps the cost proportionate.

Our experts

Your Forensic and Quality Audit Team

A named team of subject specialists stays with your project from scoping to delivery. Your project coordinator introduces each team member by name before work begins.

Subject matter expertClinical or scientific expert matched to your topic

Reviews the scientific content for accuracy and confirms that each conclusion is supported by the evidence. Each expert is matched to your field of research.

OwnsScientific accuracy and interpretation
Reads againstThe journal's instructions and reporting guideline
FieldMatched to your topic
Senior editorEdits for language, structure and consistency

Edits for clarity, grammar, structure and consistency while preserving the author voice and scientific meaning.

OwnsLanguage, structure and consistency
Reads againstThe journal style and a project style sheet
OutputTracked-changes manuscript
Second reviewerIndependent quality check before delivery

Checks the finished work independently against the agreed scope and the applicable checklist. Findings are logged and resolved before delivery.

OwnsIndependent quality control
Reads againstThe agreed scope and checklist
Signed off byProject lead
Project coordinatorYour single point of contact

Manages the timeline, keeps you informed at each stage and coordinates the team so that questions are answered and deadlines are met.

OwnsTimeline and communication
Reads againstYour brief and deadline
OutputDelivery and follow-up

Sample work

Sample Audit Findings

Step through the findings one at a time. Each is located, graded and evidenced, and none concludes that anything was done deliberately, because an audit cannot make that judgement.

6 changes, each explained

As submitted. A 6,200-word trial report, five figure panels, 41 references, declared as CONSORT-compliant.

  • “Reporting follows CONSORT 2025.”
  • Figure 3B and Figure 5A, different experiments
  • “Data were analysed per protocol.” Table 2: n = 126
  • Introduction, paragraph 2
  • “p = 0.0000” · “NS”
  • Primary outcome: 6-month event rate

Findings. Eleven items, graded, each with its location and supporting evidence.

  • C1 · Moderate — 6 of 37 CONSORT items unreported. Listed by number. Methods and Results
  • I2 · Critical — identical 180 × 140 px region, rotated. Crops attached. Needs your explanation
  • D3 · High — n = 126 is the enrolled total, not the per-protocol set. One of the two is wrong
  • P1 · Moderate — 340 words at 94% match to your own 2021 paper, uncited. Self-plagiarism under COPE
  • S2 · High — p is never 0.0000; no intervals or effect sizes anywhere. CONSORT 17a
  • C4 · High — registered and reported primary outcomes differ; change not declared. Registry NCT…

Grades are Critical, High, Moderate and Low, defined on the first page of every report. Extract redacted; field, values and identifiers changed.

Redacted extract · field, values and identifiers changedStandard review · CONSORT 2025 and COPE

Benefits

Benefits of a Forensic and Quality Audit

Every finding is located and evidenced on your own file. None of these benefits is a claim about whether the paper will be accepted, and none is a conclusion about intent.

01 Identification of Issues Journals Screen ForJournals increasingly run image screening, text matching and registry checks on submission rather than at review. A duplicated panel you find yourself can be corrected; one found by a journal may lead to an investigation.
02 Findings Graded by SeverityFindings are graded Critical, High, Moderate or Low, as defined in the report. A report with eleven findings may contain nine that are Moderate and quick to correct.
03 Evidence You Can VerifyEvery finding includes its location, the item number of the guideline concerned and an attachment showing the evidence, so you can verify each one on your own file.
04 Errors and Non-Disclosure Reported SeparatelyChanging a primary outcome is permitted, but failing to declare the change is a problem. The report distinguishes the two because the remedies are different.
05 Confidential HandlingEvery audit is carried out under NDA, with encrypted transfer, controlled access and no third-party tools.
06 No Conclusions About IntentWe report what is in the file. Whether anything was deliberate is for you, your institution or the journal to determine, because the evidence alone cannot establish intent.

Packages

Forensic and Quality Audit Packages

Pricing depends on how many of the six audit types your question requires, the volume of source material and whether the report must withstand third-party review, not on turnaround. Each package is therefore quoted after scoping.

Basic

Basic compliance check

A rapid review of a manuscript, a process or a set of documents

Quoted per projectPriced on volume

Delivery 3–5 business days

  • ✓Preliminary review of documents and workflows
  • ✓Red flags and compliance gaps identified
  • ✓Basic quality check of operational procedures
  • ✓Summary report with priority recommendations

Suitable before submission, when no specific problem has been identified.

View a sample Request a quote
Standard

Standard forensic and quality review

For a more detailed review of quality, risk and accuracy

Quoted per projectPriced on depth and volume

Delivery 7–10 business days

  • ✓Detailed review of records and processes
  • ✓Verification of processes, transactions and documentation
  • ✓Inconsistencies and quality deviations identified and located
  • ✓Risk assessment with a corrective action roadmap
  • ✓Comprehensive audit report, graded by severity

Most often chosen when a journal or reviewer has already raised a question.

View a sample Request a quote
Advanced

Advanced forensic investigation

For suspected misconduct, a major quality lapse or a report for a third party

Quoted per projectPriced on scope and evidentiary standard

Delivery 12–15 business days

  • ✓In-depth investigation of processes, data and records
  • ✓Evidence-based assessment with chain-of-custody controls
  • ✓Root-cause and gap analysis
  • ✓Quality assurance audit across all critical functions
  • ✓High-level compliance and risk report
  • ✓Recommendations for remediation and prevention

If the report will be read by an institution, a funder or a journal, please tell us at scoping, because this affects how the evidence must be recorded.

View a sample Request a quote

Send one figure panel and the methods section, and we will audit them free of charge and scope the remaining work based on the results. Institutional and publisher volume is quoted against a schedule.

Quality Assurance

Our Service Commitment

Our commitment states the standard of work, its limits and the remedy available if the work falls short.

The Pubrica guarantee

Withdrawal of Any Finding That Cannot Be Substantiated

Every finding includes its location, its evidence and the guideline item concerned. If you show that the evidence does not support a finding, we remove it from the report. If the audit did not cover the scope on your order, we repeat it free of charge within the agreed scope.

01

The scope is agreed in writing first

We agree which audits apply, against which guideline and version, and the purpose of the report before any material is examined.

02

Every finding can be located

Each finding gives the section, page, figure and item number, so you can check it directly.

03

Challenged findings are re-examined

A finding you can rebut with evidence is withdrawn and the report is reissued.

04

Confidential handling with no reuse of your material

We work under NDA, with encrypted transfer, controlled access and no third-party tools. Your material is never used for training.

Client Testimonials

“Detailed and evidence-backed. The findings let us close the gaps before the journal asked about them rather than after.”
Dr. Anouk BakkerChief compliance officer

Netherlands

FAQs

Forensic and Quality Audit FAQs

If your question is not listed here, ask an expert. No quote is required.

The audit includes data verification, document review, image forensics, compliance checks against the named guideline, process audit, risk assessment and a detailed report.

It does not include correcting the manuscript. Correction is an editing service quoted separately, because an auditor who also corrects the findings would be auditing their own work.

Pubrica subject-matter experts in the relevant field carry out the audit, working with statisticians on methodological findings and image specialists on the forensic review.

The report names the guideline and version each finding is measured against, so the work can be checked independently of who did it.

Universities, research groups, hospitals, laboratories, publishers, CROs and funders use the service wherever accuracy and compliance must be demonstrated.

The most common use is an author checking a manuscript before submission, which is also the lowest-cost point at which to correct problems.

We work under NDA, with encrypted transfer, controlled access at every stage and no third-party tools. Your material is not used for training, and access is limited to the assigned team.

If the audit concerns an active integrity question, please tell us at scoping, because this affects how the evidence is recorded and to whom the report can be addressed.

Yes. The report covers findings, discrepancies, compliance status, risk flags and recommended corrective actions, each located and graded by severity.

Recommendations are kept separate from findings, so you can act on the findings without adopting our recommendations.

No. An audit reports what the evidence shows, for example that two image regions are identical, that a declared outcome changed or that a passage matches an earlier paper.

Whether any of this was deliberate is for your institution, a journal or a regulator to determine through its own process. Our role is to provide an accurate basis for that process and, more often, to allow you to correct an honest error before submission.

Related services

Related Editing and Research Integrity Services

An audit identifies problems; these services correct them. They are quoted separately so that the audit remains independent.

Request a Free Audit of One Figure Panel and Methods Section

You receive a written finding on each item, stating what we checked, what we found, how severe it is and what we recommend. The audit takes two business days and is free of charge. If we find no problems, the report will say so.

Guides and articles in this section

Show all 1
Get a free quote

Regulations

Check your project against this rule

  1. 1Your work
  2. 2Your details
  3. 3Send
What do you need?

Material you send is held under signed confidentiality, with access limited to the assigned team and encrypted transfer. It is not used to train anything and is not passed to third-party tools. Ask for the agreement before you send anything you would rather cover first.