Our Editors: Subject Specialists Assigned to Your Manuscript
Work is assigned by subject, not by who is free. A cardiology trial, for example, is assigned to an editor who knows the relevant CONSORT extension and can identify an effect size that is implausible against the published literature.
Subject matching is the slowest part of our scheduling, and we maintain it because it distinguishes a scientific review from a language edit. Our panel of 5,000+ subject experts covers biostatistics, medical writing and regulatory writing as well as editing.
How It Works
How We Assign Editors to Manuscripts
These rules ensure that each manuscript receives a scientific review from a subject specialist rather than a language edit from whoever has capacity.
Service Scope
What Our Editors Check Beyond Language
A scientific edit includes four checks that a language editing service does not provide.
Our Experts
Meet Nine of Our Subject Editors
Every project is matched to a subject matter expert who works inside its subject area. These are editors, not account managers.
-
Dr. Athira
Biotechnology
-
Dr. Benny K
Business
-
Dr. Carole J
Medicine
-
Dr. Katharine Hughes
Life sciences
-
Dr. Monika M
Pharmacology
-
Dr. Nalini Kannan
Biotechnology
-
Dr. Rajasekar
Chemistry
-
Heather Evans
English editing
-
Ross Taylor
Engineering
Institutional affiliations and editorial board positions are held for several of these editors and are not printed here, because naming somebody’s university or journal alongside their photograph needs that person’s agreement first. Ask and we will tell you the relevant experience of whoever is assigned to your work.
Deliverables
Contents of an Editor Profile
We send the profile of your proposed editor before work begins, so you can raise any concerns about the match at that stage.
Profile Exclusions
Information Not Included in Editor Profiles
We leave out four types of information deliberately, for the reasons explained below.
Our Process
How to Receive an Editor Profile
You receive the editor profile before work begins, not with the invoice.
Send your manuscript or brief
Provide enough material for us to identify the study design, field, target journal and applicable reporting guideline.
Subject matching
We match your work to the panel on sub-specialty and study design rather than availability. If no editor is a suitable match, we tell you rather than assign the nearest available person.
Profile review
You receive the six-part profile for the proposed editor. We will provide further detail on any part on request, including relevant institutional experience.
Confirmation
If the match does not seem right, please tell us. Reassignment is free before work begins, while reassignment after work starts delays the project.
Working Approach
Four Principles Our Editors Apply
Each of these statements reflects an editorial policy and affects the feedback you receive.
Editorial Limits
Statements Our Editors Will Not Make
Clients sometimes make these requests, and our answer is always the same.
Methodology
The Four Stages of a Scientific Edit
We review language last, because sentences may change during the earlier stages.
Reporting guideline check
We check the manuscript item by item against the reporting guideline your design requires, list any missing items and note what would satisfy each one.
Claims check
We compare every claim with what the analysis supports and adjust or flag its wording where the data does not support it.
Evidence check
We check citations against source records, numbers against the tables, and the methods against what the paper reports.
Language edit
Finally, we edit the language at the level you selected (proofreading, copyediting, line, substantive or developmental) once the content is settled.
FAQs
Frequently Asked Questions About Our Editors
If your question is not answered here, ask an expert without requesting a quote.
You can specify the field and the type of review you need, and you can tell us if the assigned editor does not seem right for the paper. We will reassign the work on request.
We will not assign an editor from outside your subject area because they are available sooner.
The most useful profile is the one for the editor assigned to your paper, and publishing a person’s institution or editorial positions beside their photograph requires their agreement.
We prefer to send a complete profile for the assigned editor rather than publish brief profiles for everyone.
For substantive and developmental editing, this is usually possible. For proofreading, a discussion is rarely necessary, and we will tell you so.
Once work begins, you can ask unlimited questions of the person doing it.
Please tell us early. For very narrow sub-specialties, we will tell you whether we have an editor who works within that area or in a closely related one, and you can decide how to proceed.
An editor in a related field who states this openly is more useful than one presented as a specialist.
The structure is the same, but the content differs: a statistician’s profile lists software and methods, and a medical writer’s profile lists document types and regulatory frameworks.
In every case, the profile states the field and the work handled rather than years of experience.
A quotation attributed to a named person requires that person’s agreement, and we prefer to publish the standards our editors work to rather than collect testimonials.
The four principles above describe how every editor here works.
You can overrule it. Each comment explains the reasoning so that you can decide, and the decision is yours. You can also discuss any flag directly with the editor.
We will not remove a flag from the record to make it appear that it was never raised.
Yes. We will tell you when we think a lighter level is sufficient. If you send 1,000 words, we edit them at both levels so you can compare the results on your own text, and then we carry out the level you choose.
For theses, the maximum level of editing is set by the IPEd guidelines, and we do not exceed it.
Yes. Editors decline work when no panel member is a suitable subject match, when a request would breach research integrity standards, or when the paper requires a different type of service.
We discuss this with you before quoting, not after invoicing.
Both. The panel includes staff editors and contracted subject specialists, all working under the same confidentiality terms and the same quality process.
Your manuscript receives the same subject matching and quality process in either case.
Our editors hold doctoral or clinical qualifications in the fields they edit, and members of our writing and regulatory teams hold professional credentials in medical writing.
We will tell you the relevant background of the editor assigned to your work, but we do not publish a person’s institution beside their photograph without their agreement.
Yes, wherever possible; this is our standard practice. Within the agreed scope, re-editing is free for one year from delivery for journal submissions, and the paper returns to the editor who knows it.
If that editor is unavailable, we will tell you rather than substitute another editor without notice.
Tell Us Your Field and Study Design to Find Your Editor
No quote is required. If no panel member is the right match for your paper, we will tell you.