Digital Production QA Services
Pubrica provides independent digital production QA for publishers, journal editorial teams, repositories, universities and production vendors. Our production QA specialists check proofs, XML, metadata and final outputs before release, so that material is publication-ready and consistent across PDF, HTML, XML and EPUB. Small production defects can delay publication and affect indexing and discoverability. You receive a numbered findings report with the location, severity and recommended correction for each issue, followed by a final validation pass.
- Independent of the production vendor: the files are checked by specialists who did not produce them
- Consistency held across PDF, HTML, XML and EPUB, so a correction applied in one output is applied in all of them
- XML and metadata validated against DTD or JATS, which determines whether the content is indexed correctly
- Typeset proofs checked line by line for typographical errors, font and spacing faults, and alignment problems that appear at final size
- Post-publication audits, so errors in content already on your platform or in a repository are identified and corrected
Content, layout and proof accuracyChecked
XML structure and metadataValidated
Cross-format consistencyChecked
Accessibility and complianceChecked
Copyediting the textSeparate service
Auditing the research itselfSeparate service
Typeset → checked → reported → corrected → published
- Independent of the production vendor
- Checked against your checklist
- Every error located and numbered
- Correction guidance for each finding
- Final validation before sign-off
Service Scope
Six Production QA Checks and a Detailed Findings Report
The scope is written on your order against your checklist. Every finding is numbered, located and paired with a recommended correction.
From the QA reportFigure 4 caption reads “Figure 3” · Table 2 continues without a header rowL14 · Major. Caption number wrong and cited as Figure 3 twice in the text. L15 · Major. Table 2 runs to a second page with no repeated header.
From the validation log<aff> outside <contrib-group> · no ORCID · funding in free textJATS 1.3 validation passes; affiliations linked by id, 4 ORCIDs added, funding moved into <funding-group> with award ids so Crossref picks it up.
From the proof check41 findings, 9 major. Six widows, two orphaned headings, one figure at 300 dpi in a 600 dpi book, an em rule set as a hyphen throughout the references, and a running head still carrying the previous chapter’s title on pages 88–96.
From the link check41 references · 3 DOIs unresolved · 2 URLs dead · 1 citation with no entryTwo DOIs were mistyped and now resolve; one was withdrawn and is flagged for your decision. Dead URLs replaced with archived versions, and the orphan citation raised as a query.
From the compliance checkTagged PDF present; reading order correct in 38 of 41 pages; alt text missing on 6 figures; contrast below threshold on two chart series. Each finding located and verified.
From the format comparisonPDF corrected at proof stage · XML and EPUB built from the earlier fileC3 · Critical. The author correction to the results figure is in the PDF only. The HTML and EPUB still carry the pre-correction number, and the XML feeds the indexing.
The samples shown are illustrative and anonymised. Hover over a sample to replay it.
Our Services
Six Types of Digital Production QA
These services are priced as packages because they are carried out on the same files. Your package depends on how many formats you publish and whether live content is in scope.
Service exclusions: production QA is not copyediting, as it checks the file rather than the text, and it does not audit the research. Publication ethics, data integrity and reporting-guideline compliance are covered by our forensic and quality audit service, which is carried out by a separate team.
Who We Serve
Clients We Support with Digital Production QA
Requirements differ by client in the formats in scope and whether the check takes place before or after publication.
Compliance and Standards
Seven Production QA Standards and Specifications
Production QA is measured against the schema, the platform requirements and the publisher’s checklist. Research reporting guidelines are covered by a separate service.
JATS (NISO Z39.96, version 1.3)
The journal article tag suite used for most journal deposits. Validation against JATS supports correct indexing.
BITS (For books and chapters)
The book equivalent of JATS, used for monographs and edited collections.
Crossref deposit schema (Metadata and reference deposit)
The schema used to register DOIs, reference links, funder data and ORCID auto-update. Incomplete deposits can prevent citations from linking.
EPUB and EPUB Accessibility (W3C, EPUB 3.3)
The standard against which platforms validate a book or chapter, including its accessibility conformance statement.
ISO 14289-1 (Tagged PDF for universal access)
The specification for accessible PDF, against which accessibility checks are measured.
PubMed Central requirements (NLM tagging guidelines)
PMC applies its own rules in addition to JATS, and XML that is valid against JATS can still fail PMC requirements.
Quality management (cert. H3CR9TCU20251212INDQM10N)
This certification covers how the QA is run, recorded and signed off, which supports the independence of the check.
Responsible Use of AI
Limitations of Automated Checking
A checker that returns zero errors does not, on its own, show that a document is accessible. Alt text that describes a chart only as a “chart”, a reading order that is technically valid but unusable, and tagging that passes validation but fails a screen-reader user can all pass automated checks.
Why We Do Not Publish AI Accuracy Figures
Accuracy figures for AI tools are usually reported by the companies that sell them.
Pubrica therefore does not quote its own accuracy figures, as they would carry the same conflict of interest. Instead, we tell you which tool was used on your project, at which stage, and what a specialist changed afterwards.
Our Process
How Our Digital Production QA Process Works
We map the checklist before reviewing any files, so the report is measured against a standard you have agreed.
Initial file review
We assess all production files, including the manuscript, proofs, XML, PDF and supplementary material, to establish which formats are involved and where the risks are.
Quality assessment and checklist mapping
We map the review to a checklist based on your guidelines, the journal’s requirements and the platform’s rules. We use your checklist if you have one; otherwise we share ours with you first.
Detailed QA review
We carry out line-by-line checks of accuracy, formatting consistency, metadata, URLs, citations and references, and the representation of graphical data.
Error reporting and resolution
We provide a detailed report listing every issue with its location and recommended correction, and support your production team while they make the corrections.
Final QA validation
We carry out a verification pass to confirm that each correction has been made in every format.
Request a Free QA Review of One Article
You receive a full QA report on one article, covering layout and proof errors, XML validation against JATS, metadata checked against indexing platform requirements, and a comparison of the four outputs. Delivered within two business days at no charge. Production vendors may also send their own work.
Please send every output, not only the PDF. Many QA findings are differences between files, which cannot be identified from a single format.
Our Experts
Your Digital Production QA Team
A named team of subject specialists stays with your project from scoping to delivery. Your project coordinator introduces each team member by name before work begins.
Reviews the scientific content for accuracy and confirms that each conclusion is supported by the evidence. Each expert is matched to your field.
Reviews content for accuracy, pedagogy and conformance with the applicable curriculum, assessment or accessibility standard.
Checks the finished work independently against the agreed scope and the applicable checklist. Findings are logged and resolved before delivery.
Manages the timeline, keeps you informed at each stage and coordinates the team so that questions are answered and deadlines are met.
Sample Work
Sample QA Report: One Article Compared Across Four Outputs
Step through the findings one at a time. The critical finding is a difference between files rather than an error within any one of them, which a single-format check would not identify.
As delivered. One research article: corrected proof PDF, XML, HTML and EPUB, signed off by the production vendor.
- PDF: author correction to Figure 3 applied at second proof
- XML: built from the first proof
- Caption reads “Figure 3” on Figure 4
- <aff> outside <contrib-group>, no ORCIDs
- Running head on pp. 88–96 from the previous chapter
- 41 references, 3 DOIs unresolved
Findings. 41 items, 9 major, 1 critical, each located and paired with a correction.
- C3 · Critical — the corrected figure exists in the PDF only. HTML, EPUB and XML carry the old number. The XML feeds indexing
- X1 · Major — JATS 1.3 validation fails; affiliations relinked by id, 4 ORCIDs added
- L14 · Major — caption number wrong, and cited as Figure 3 twice in the text
- T7 · Major — running head wrong across 9 pages
- R2 · Major — 2 DOIs mistyped and now resolve; 1 withdrawn, raised for your decision
- A5 · Minor — alt text missing on 6 figures; contrast below threshold on 2 chart series
Findings are graded Critical, Major or Minor, as defined on the first page of every report. The extract is redacted, and identifiers and values have been changed.
Benefits
Benefits of Independent Production QA
Each benefit can be checked in your own files. Independent review is a standard quality step and does not reflect on the production team.
Packages
Digital Production QA Packages
Each package is priced on the number of outputs per article, whether live content is in scope and the overall volume. Ongoing work is quoted against a schedule.
Basic package
Small journals and individual publications
Quoted per projectPriced per article
Delivery 5–7 business days
- ✓Layout and content QA
- ✓Formatting and consistency checks
- ✓Reference and citation matching
- ✓A summary QA report with every finding located
Suitable for publications with a single output format.
View a sample Request a quoteStandard package
Journals and academic publishers
Quoted per projectPriced per article or per issue
Delivery 7–10 business days
- ✓Everything in Basic
- ✓XML and metadata QA against DTD or JATS
- ✓Proofreading and typesetting checks
- ✓DOI resolution and link testing
- ✓Cross-format consistency checks
- ✓Detailed correction reports, graded by severity
Our most commonly chosen package, including cross-format consistency checks.
View a sample Request a quotePremium package
Large publishers and institutions
Quoted per projectPriced against a schedule
Delivery 10–14 business days
- ✓Everything in Standard
- ✓End-to-end production QA across the full lifecycle
- ✓Accessibility and compliance checks on delivered outputs
- ✓Post-publication QA on live content
- ✓Independent audit of vendor output
- ✓Final validation and sign-off
Suitable for publishers who need independent QA of a production vendor’s output.
View a sample Request a quoteSend one article in every format and we will check it free of charge. Ongoing journal and list-level work is quoted against a schedule with an agreed turnaround.
Quality Assurance
Our Service Commitment
Our service commitment, its limits and the remedy we offer are set out below.
Our quality commitment
Every Finding Located and Documented
The report gives each issue a number, a location, a severity and a recommended correction.
01
Checklist Agreed in Advance
We use your checklist if you have one, or share ours with you before the review begins, so findings are measured against an agreed standard.
02
Independent of Production
We do not typeset the files we check. Where you use a vendor, our check remains independent of them.
03
Corrections Verified in Every Format
The final pass confirms that each correction has been made in every output.
04
Free Re-check or a Refund
If the QA missed an issue within the agreed scope, we re-check at no charge, or refund it if you prefer.
Client Stories
FAQs
Digital Production QA FAQs
If your question is not answered here, ask an expert — no quote is required.
Errors are difficult to identify in your own work. QA carried out by the team that produced the files tends to miss the same issues twice.
Independent QA also includes cross-format checking. Many remaining errors are differences between the PDF, XML, HTML and EPUB, which a single-format check cannot identify.
Yes. We validate XML and metadata against your DTD or JATS and check them against the specific requirements of indexing platforms.
XML can be valid against the schema and still fail PubMed Central requirements, and this check is designed to identify such issues.
Yes. We audit live content on journal and repository platforms, locate and grade the findings, and support corrections through your platform’s process.
Many publishers have not previously audited their live content, so the first audit often identifies a number of corrections.
Our services support academic publishers, journal editorial teams, authors and researchers, universities, repositories and production vendors.
Production vendors can use the service to provide an independent check of their own output to their clients.
You receive detailed correction guidance for each error, including its location, severity and recommended correction, and we support your production team while they make the corrections.
The final validation pass then confirms that each correction has been made in every format.
No. Production QA checks the file: layout, formatting, XML, metadata, links and consistency across outputs. It does not edit prose.
It also does not audit the research. Publication ethics, data integrity and reporting-guideline compliance are covered by a separate service and team.
Related Services
Related Content Production and Research Audit Services
This service checks the produced files. The services below cover content preparation and the audit of the research itself.
1BEFORE PRODUCTIONlanguage editing
Copy editingGrammar, usage, consistency and a style sheet for your records. ProofreadingA final check of a document before publication.2FOR ACCESSIBILITYoften required
Accessibility complianceWCAG and Section 508 for documents and course material. Visual & accessibility editingFigures, colour, typography and multimedia.3FOR RESEARCH INTEGRITYaudit of the research
Forensic & quality auditData integrity, image forensics and guideline compliance. Permission & metadataLicensing, DOIs and indexing metadata.Insights
Further Reading on Digital Production QA
Request a Free QA Review of One Article
Layout and proof errors, XML validated against JATS, metadata checked against platform requirements, and a comparison of all outputs. Delivered within two business days at no charge. Production vendors are welcome.