Free scoping read. A written assessment of your manuscript in two business days, at no cost.

Start one
Contents

Academy · Research Publication · Peer review and its benefits

Peer Review of a Manuscript: The Process, the Evidence and the Benefits of Reviewing

Two distinct questions are frequently conflated. The effect of peer review on a manuscript is less well established than is commonly assumed, and the methodology reviews acknowledge that the evidence is limited. The benefit of reviewing to the reviewer is better documented, and it is the benefit most often overlooked by authors who decline an invitation.

Pubrica AcademyWritten by the medical writing and biostatistics teams Reviewed byPubrica biostatistics team Published9 October 2026 Last checked9 October 2026 Reading time11 minutes Sources41 peer-reviewed

Peer review is a stage on which every author depends, yet few researchers receive formal training in conducting it. The process itself should be distinguished from the outcomes claimed for it, because the evidence for the latter is weaker. The available randomised trials, on open review, reviewer training and structured checklists, show small effects, and the methodology reviews conclude that the evidence for an effect of peer review on report quality is limited. These findings do not indicate that review lacks value; they inform the expectations appropriate to a received report and strengthen the case for researchers to learn to review.

Learning objectives

  • The progress of a manuscript between submission and decision, and the decisions made at each stage
  • The four review models in use (single-anonymous, double-anonymous, identified and post-publication) and the findings of trials that compared them
  • The randomised evidence on reviewer training and review quality
  • The motivations reported by reviewers, from two surveys that rank them differently
  • The interpretation of a received review without overstating its authority
  • The writing of a review on which an editor can act and which an author can use

Common misconceptions

  • “Peer review reliably improves a manuscript.” The Cochrane methodology review of editorial peer review and the JAMA systematic review by Jefferson and colleagues both concluded that the evidence for an effect on report quality is limited. This conclusion concerns the evidence base, not a finding that review has no effect.
  • “Anonymity is necessary for an honest review.” In van Rooyen and colleagues’ randomised trial in the BMJ, reviews written by reviewers who agreed to be identified scored 3.09 for quality against 3.06 for anonymous reviews, a difference of no practical importance. Identification did affect willingness to review: 35% of those asked to sign declined, compared with 23% of those reviewing anonymously.
  • “Reviewer training resolves the problem.” Across 10 randomised trials in the Cochrane review of reviewer training, trained reviewers identified about 3.25 of 9 deliberately inserted errors against about 2.7 for untrained reviewers, a mean difference of 0.55 errors. The effect is measurable but considerably smaller than the expectations underlying most training programmes.
  • “Reviewing is unpaid work that offers no benefit to the reviewer.” In a survey of 275 journal reviewers, 71% said they review in order to learn, and a structured mentoring programme raised median review-quality scores on the same manuscript from 26.6 to 31.
  • “A reviewer’s criticism is an objective measurement.” It represents one informed reading. Lee and colleagues, in the Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, describe the extent of systematic bias in the process; a report should be evaluated on its arguments rather than accepted on the basis of its status.

Stages of the peer review process

Peer review is the stage at which an editor asks individuals outside the journal whether a submission is sound, novel and worthy of publication in the journal, and then reaches a decision. The steps should be distinguished, because authors frequently attribute to reviewers decisions that an editor made alone.

An editor or editorial assistant first checks the submission against the journal’s formal requirements and its scope. This triage stage ends in a desk rejection or a decision to seek external opinions, and at many journals it disposes of the majority of submissions before any reviewer sees them; the submission stage page indicates the size of that proportion 5,7. Invitations are then issued, usually to more individuals than will accept. Reviewers return a written assessment and a recommendation. The editor weighs the reports against each other and against the journal’s own priorities and issues a decision. The recommendation is advisory; the decision belongs to the editor.

Two consequences follow. A rejection after review is not necessarily a reviewer’s verdict, since editors reject manuscripts despite positive reports and publish them despite negative ones 20,37. Furthermore, conflicting reports are not so much a failure of the system as a visible instance of its nature: two readings by two individuals. This is the strongest reason to regard any single report as an argument rather than a measurement.

Peer review models and the findings of comparative trials

Journals use four broad arrangements. In single-anonymous review, the reviewer knows the identity of the authors, but the authors do not know the identity of the reviewer. In double-anonymous review both are concealed. In identified or open review, the reviewer signs the report, and some journals publish the reports alongside the paper. Post-publication review places the critique after the article is published, either formally or through correspondence 19,35.

The strongest evidence on whether identification has any effect comes from van Rooyen and colleagues’ randomised trial in the BMJ. Reviews from reviewers who had agreed to be identified were rated 3.09 on the study’s quality scale against 3.06 for anonymous reviews 41. The decline rate changed considerably more than the quality did: 35% against 23% 3. In the same trial, of 400 author questionnaires sent, 346 were returned, and the balance of author opinion favoured identifying reviewers.

In summary, the models differ less in measured output than the debate about them suggests, but they differ considerably in who agrees to participate 41. Godlee, writing in JAMA, argued the case for visibility on grounds of accountability and credit rather than quality, which is where the argument properly lies 28.

The review models, and what has been measured about them

ModelWho knows whatWhat the evidence shows
Single-anonymousReviewer sees the authors; authors do not see the reviewerThe default in much of biomedicine. Lee and colleagues review the bias that this arrangement permits
Double-anonymousNeither side is identified to the otherThe Cochrane methodology review found no clear-cut evidence that concealing identities improves report quality
Identified / openThe reviewer signs; some journals publish the reportQuality essentially unchanged in the BMJ trial — 3.09 against 3.06 — but 35% declined to review against 23% anonymously
Post-publicationCritique is public and attached to the published articleHorton, in JAMA, describes what post-publication criticism contributes that pre-publication review cannot

Quality scores and decline rates from van Rooyen S, Godlee F, Evans S, Black N, Smith R. Effect of open peer review on quality of reviews and on reviewers’ recommendations: a randomised trial. BMJ. Other rows are qualitative summaries of the cited sources, not measured comparisons.

Costs of peer review to editors and reviewers

Peer review represents a transfer of unpaid expert labour, and its scale is readily underestimated. The Publons Global State of Peer Review report, drawing on a survey of about 11,800 researchers, estimated that peer review consumed roughly 68.5 million researcher hours in a single year (around 2.9 million researcher days) and that the average review took 19.1 days to complete from acceptance of the invitation 10.

These figures explain several experiences that authors may interpret as discourtesy. Reviewers decline because the workload is substantial: in the survey of 275 reviewers at the Journal of Urology, 86% had turned down an invitation for lack of time 3. Journals therefore invite considerably more reviewers than they require, and a paper may remain unassigned for weeks while invitations go unanswered 5,10. The cost also has an ethical dimension: authors who submit draw on a pool of reviewers that exists only because other researchers accept invitations.

68.5mresearcher hours spent on peer review in a year
19.1days for the average review, once accepted
11,800researchers surveyed

The scale of the unpaid labour on which peer review depends. Source: Publons (Clarivate Analytics), Global State of Peer Review.

Evidence on the effect of peer review on manuscripts

This aspect is frequently omitted from discussions of the subject. Jefferson and colleagues’ systematic review in JAMA, and the Cochrane methodology review of editorial peer review, both examined the studies that have attempted to measure whether review improves the reports of biomedical studies, and both concluded that the evidence is limited and of variable quality 2,25. Wager and Jefferson, in Learned Publishing, catalogued the shortcomings in greater detail 40. This finding is well known within editorial research but little known outside it.

Where effects have been demonstrated, they derive from adding structure rather than from review in general. Cobo and colleagues, in a masked randomised trial published in the BMJ, found that requiring reviewers to work against a reporting checklist measurably increased the proportion of manuscripts that improved from their submitted state; the same group’s earlier randomised trial in PLoS ONE found that adding a statistical reviewer improved the reporting of accepted articles 13,15. Day and colleagues, in the Annals of Emergency Medicine, showed by content analysis what dedicated methodology and statistics reviewers identify that subject reviewers do not 39.

Taken together, these studies carry a specific practical implication: generic review produces generic comments, and improvements arise from directing a reviewer to something specific, such as a reporting guideline, a statistical question, a checklist item. Authors can anticipate this problem by applying such a standard themselves before submission.

Motivations and benefits for reviewers

Two surveys have asked reviewers directly, and they rank the motives differently; the discrepancy should be acknowledged rather than concealed. Among 275 reviewers surveyed at the Journal of Urology, 80% named giving back to the field, 71% learning, 61% getting involved with the journal and 39% career development 3. In the International Union of Crystallography’s reviewers’ survey, with about 517 responses per question, the motive rated extremely important most often was reciprocating the review others do for one’s own work, at 37.33%, ahead of participating in the research community at 27.85%; improving one’s own writing came last, at 5.23% 11.

The discrepancy is informative. When asked whether learning matters, most reviewers agree; when asked to rank it as extremely important against reciprocity, few do so. Both findings can be valid: the benefit is genuine but secondary to a sense of obligation 3,11. The same Journal of Urology survey found that 91% read other reviewers’ reports on manuscripts they had reviewed, and only 35% felt recognised for the work, which suggests an inexpensive area in which journals could direct effort 41.

One quantitative finding on learning is available. Lyons-Warren and colleagues, in Research Integrity and Peer Review, conducted a structured journal-led mentoring programme: 55 mentees enrolled, 42 produced paired reviews of the same manuscript before and after the programme, and median Review Quality Index scores rose from 26.6 to 31 4. This represents a measured improvement in a reviewer’s own critical reading, on identical material, over about six months 4.

Why reviewers say they review — two surveys, two rankings

MotivationJournal of Urology reviewers (n = 275)IUCr reviewers’ survey (about 517 responses per item)
Giving back to the field80% agreed—
Reciprocating review of one’s own work—37.33% rated extremely important
Participating in the research community61% named getting involved with the journal27.85% rated extremely important
Learning / improving one’s own work71% agreed they review to learn5.23% rated improving own writing extremely important
Career development39% agreed—
Declined an invitation for lack of time86%—

Dudley and colleagues, Motivations to Participate in the Peer Review Process at the Journal of Urology; and the International Union of Crystallography reviewers’ survey. The two instruments asked different questions (agreement with a motive against ranking it extremely important), so the columns are not directly comparable and are presented side by side to show the discrepancy.

Effectiveness and limitations of reviewer training

Reviewer training has been tested in randomised trials, which is more than can be said for most interventions in academic publishing. The Cochrane review by Hesselberg and colleagues pooled 10 randomised trials covering 1,213 units of analysis, 722 reviewers and 491 manuscripts 1. Trained reviewers detected about 3.25 of 9 deliberately inserted errors, and untrained reviewers about 2.7. The mean difference was 0.55 errors.

Two conclusions follow. First, the effect is genuine: a short intervention measurably improves error detection, and Schroter and colleagues’ randomised trial in the BMJ found an effect in the same direction 1,18. Second, the effect is small: even trained reviewers missed around two-thirds of the inserted errors. Callaham and Schriger, in the Annals of Emergency Medicine, found that structured workshop training produced little durable change in subsequent review performance, and Callaham and colleagues’ two randomised trials in JAMA found that written feedback from editors had limited effect 23,24.

The principal practical conclusion from this literature is that authors should not rely on peer review to identify their errors. Reviewers miss most of the errors deliberately placed before them 1.

Writing a review on which an editor can act

Most unhelpful reviews share the same deficiency: they state a judgement without supporting evidence, leaving the editor unable to act and the author unable to respond. The remedy is procedural. The reviewer should separate the summary of what the paper claims from the assessment of whether it supports that claim, number each point, mark each as either essential for the soundness of the work or desirable for its improvement, and quote the sentence to which the objection refers, together with its location.

The reviewer should also state what would resolve the objection. A reviewer who writes that the analysis is inappropriate has given the editor nothing; a reviewer who writes that the outcome involves repeated measures, that the model treats observations as independent, and who names the alternative, has given the editor a basis for decision and the author a defined task. Winck and colleagues, in Pulmonology, and Rowland, in Learned Publishing, both describe this structure for reviewers who undertake the role without training, which applies to most reviewers 14,38.

The recommendation and the report should be consistent. Reviewers frequently write a report of modest criticisms and then recommend rejection, or list fundamental objections and recommend minor revision. Editors notice such inconsistencies, and they reduce the value of the report.

The same objection, written two ways

Unusable by either party

The statistical analysis is inappropriate for this type of data and the conclusions are overstated. The manuscript would also benefit from English language editing. I recommend rejection.

No location. The editor cannot identify the object of the criticism, and the author cannot locate it.

No reason. “Inappropriate” is a verdict without a supporting argument, so the author can only dispute it or concede.

No remedy. Nothing indicates what would satisfy the objection, so any revision is conjectural.

Language bundled with method. Two unrelated problems are combined in one sentence, and neither is specified; if language is genuinely a problem, it should be raised as a separate minor point.

Recommendation unmatched to the report. Three lines of unexplained criticism cannot justify a recommendation of rejection, and an editor reading both will discount the report.

Actionable for the editor and the author

Major, point 3. The primary outcome is measured at four visits per participant (Methods, page 6, lines 112–118), but the analysis compares groups with an independent-samples t test at each visit (page 8, line 143). This treats repeated observations from one participant as independent and inflates the precision of the estimate. A mixed model for repeated measures, or a single comparison at a pre-specified primary time point, would address this. If the authors prefer the latter, the primary time point should be the one named in the registered protocol. The conclusion on page 12 (lines 230–234) states that the intervention is effective across the follow-up period; that claim cannot be supported until the analysis accounts for the repeated structure.

The objection is located to the line, so the editor can verify it quickly without re-reading the paper.

The mechanism of the error is stated (repeated observations treated as independent), which makes the objection open to reasoned argument rather than mere assertion.

Two acceptable remedies are named, so the revision has a defined target and the author need not infer the reviewer’s preference.

The consequence for the paper’s stated conclusion is made explicit, which indicates to the editor the seriousness of the problem.

It is numbered and classified as major, so it can be tracked through a response letter point by point.

The function of a reviewer is to provide the editor with a basis for decision and the author with a defined task. The second version requires approximately ten minutes more and is the only one of the two that achieves either.

Interpreting a received review

Peer review carries documented bias. Lee and colleagues, in the Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, review the evidence on bias across author characteristics, institution and field; Tregenza, in Trends in Ecology & Evolution, raised the question of gender in refereeing; Marusic and colleagues, in the Croatian Medical Journal, compared how review functions at a small national journal and at The Lancet and found that the process is not uniform 12,30. Weber and colleagues, in JAMA, found that author satisfaction with review depends on the quality of the report as well as on whether the paper was accepted; authors can distinguish a careful rejection from a careless one 21.

In practice, a report can be divided into three categories: comments that are factually answerable, where the reviewer overlooked something already in the manuscript; comments identifying a genuine weakness that can still be addressed; and comments concerning something determined when the study was designed. Only the first two belong in a response letter; the third calls for a decision about the journal. The page on why manuscripts are rejected describes how to make that decision, and the peer reviewing hub summarises the findings of trials on each part of the process.

Key points

Key points

Peer review consists of editorial triage, external opinion and an editorial decision, in that order, and the reviewer’s recommendation is advice rather than the decision. Its effect on manuscripts is less well established than its authority implies: the Cochrane methodology review and Jefferson and colleagues’ JAMA review both found the evidence limited, identified review scored 3.09 against 3.06 for anonymous review in a randomised trial, and trained reviewers identified only about 3.25 of 9 planted errors against 2.7 for untrained reviewers. The benefit of reviewing to the reviewer is better documented: 71% of 275 surveyed reviewers reported reviewing in order to learn, and a structured mentoring programme raised median review-quality scores from 26.6 to 31 on the same manuscript. A received report should therefore be treated as one informed reading, and an invitation to review as a valuable form of training.

Application to your study

Application to your study

  1. Accept invitations to review within one’s own field. The documented benefit of review accrues most clearly to the reviewer, and 86% of surveyed reviewers decline because of time constraints, which contributes to delays in the review of submitted papers.
  2. Review against a defined standard. The trials that found an effect added a reporting checklist or a statistical reviewer rather than more general scrutiny. The reviewer should identify the guideline for the study design and assess the manuscript against it.
  3. Locate every objection precisely. Each objection should cite the page and line and quote the relevant sentence. A criticism that is not located cannot be verified by the editor or answered by the author.
  4. Classify each point as major or minor, and ensure that the recommendation is consistent with the list. Editors tend to discount reports in which the severity of the comments does not match the recommendation.
  5. Do not rely on peer review as a substitute for error checking. Even trained reviewers identified only about a third of the errors deliberately inserted into manuscripts; the authors’ own pre-submission check must perform that function.
  6. Classify each received report into three categories. The categories are factually answerable, remediable with feasible additional work, and determined at the design stage. The third category calls for a decision about the journal rather than a revision.
  7. Request that the journal record the review. Only 35% of surveyed reviewers felt recognised; most journals will acknowledge a review on request, and the record is relevant to promotion applications.

Frequently asked questions

It is the stage at which a journal editor seeks written assessments of a submission from researchers outside the journal and then reaches a decision. Procedurally, there are three distinct steps: an internal triage against the journal’s scope and requirements, which ends in either a desk rejection or a round of invitations; the external reports, each ending in a recommendation; and the editorial decision, which weighs the reports against each other and against the journal’s priorities. The recommendation is advisory. Editors publish papers that reviewers criticised and reject papers that reviewers praised, and a decision letter and a review should therefore be read as separate documents.

The clearest benefits accrue to the reviewer. In a survey of 275 reviewers at the Journal of Urology, 80% reported reviewing to give back to the field, 71% to learn, 61% to become involved with the journal and 39% for career development; 91% read the other reports on manuscripts they had reviewed, which offers an uncommon opportunity to observe how a more experienced reader evaluates the same paper. The learning is measurable rather than notional: Lyons-Warren and colleagues conducted a structured mentoring programme in which 42 mentees reviewed the same manuscript before and after, and median Review Quality Index scores rose from 26.6 to 31. Reviewing also teaches, more rapidly than drafting does, which parts of a methods section a sceptical reader cannot verify.

Less reliably than its authority suggests, although the evidence is limited rather than negative. Jefferson and colleagues’ systematic review in JAMA and the Cochrane methodology review of editorial peer review both concluded that studies of the effect of peer review on the quality of biomedical reports are limited and methodologically variable. The effects that have been demonstrated derived from adding structure: Cobo and colleagues’ masked randomised trial in the BMJ found that reviewing against a reporting checklist increased the proportion of manuscripts that improved, and their earlier PLoS ONE trial found that adding a statistical reviewer improved reporting in accepted articles. Generic scrutiny produces generic comments; a specific instrument produces specific findings.

On measured review quality, the difference is negligible. In van Rooyen and colleagues’ randomised trial in the BMJ, reviews by reviewers who agreed to be identified scored 3.09 against 3.06 for anonymous reviews. Participation, by contrast, changed substantially: 35% of those asked to sign declined the invitation, against 23% of those reviewing anonymously. Author opinion in the same trial favoured identification, with 192 of 346 respondents in favour and 90 opposed. The Cochrane methodology review likewise found no clear-cut evidence that concealing reviewer or author identity improves report quality. The strongest arguments for signed review concern accountability and credit, which is how Godlee framed the question in JAMA — not measured quality.

Modestly, and the size of the effect should be understood before investing in a course. The Cochrane review of reviewer training by Hesselberg and colleagues pooled 10 randomised trials covering 722 reviewers and 491 manuscripts: trained reviewers detected about 3.25 of 9 deliberately inserted errors, against about 2.7 for untrained reviewers, a mean difference of 0.55. Schroter and colleagues found an effect in the same direction in the BMJ, and Callaham and Schriger found that gains from workshop training diminished in subsequent reviews. The practical implication concerns authors rather than reviewers: peer review should not be treated as a substitute for error checking, because even trained reviewers miss most of the errors deliberately placed before them.

The Publons Global State of Peer Review survey of about 11,800 researchers estimated the average review at 19.1 days once a reviewer has accepted. The delay that authors experience lies mostly not in those 19 days but in the rounds of invitations that precede them. Reviewing is unpaid expert work (an estimated 68.5 million researcher hours in a single year), and 86% of reviewers in one journal survey had declined an invitation for lack of time, so editors issue considerably more invitations than they require. If a paper has no reviewer assigned, a courteous status query to the editorial office is reasonable; it will not accelerate a review already in progress.

The review should open with a short summary of what the paper claims, so that the editor can see that the reviewer has read it as the authors intended. The points should then be numbered and each classified as major or minor. For every objection, the reviewer should quote the text and give its page and line, explain why it is a problem rather than merely asserting that it is, and name what would resolve it. Comments on language and formatting should be kept separate from methodological comments and labelled minor where appropriate. The recommendation should correspond to the severity of the list. The reviewer should also state explicitly what could not be assessed, for instance an analysis beyond the reviewer’s statistical expertise, so that the editor can refer that question to a statistical reviewer.

Usually not. The reviewer should inform the editor which parts can and cannot be assessed and review those that can. Editors assemble complementary reports deliberately, and a review stating plainly that the clinical rationale is sound but that the mixed model lies outside the reviewer’s competence is more useful than either a declined invitation or a confident opinion on a matter the reviewer cannot judge. An invitation should be declined when the topic is genuinely outside the reviewer’s field or the deadline cannot be met, and always when there is a conflict of interest, which should be declared rather than the reviewer simply withdrawing.

References

  1. Hesselberg J-O, Dalsbo TK, Stromme H, Svege I, Fretheim A. Reviewer training for improving grant and journal peer review. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. 2023:MR000056. doi:10.1002/14651858.MR000056.pub2 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1002/14651858.MR000056.pub2
  2. Jefferson T, Rudin M, Brodney Folse S, Davidoff F. Editorial peer review for improving the quality of reports of biomedical studies. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. 2007:MR000016. doi:10.1002/14651858.MR000016.pub3 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1002/14651858.MR000016.pub3
  3. Dudley AG, Koch G, Rose K, Golan R, Regala J, Seideman C, et al. Motivations to Participate in the Peer Review Process at the Journal of Urology. International Congress on Peer Review and Scientific Publication (abstract). 2025. read 9 October 2026. peerreviewcongress.org
  4. Lyons-Warren AM, Aamodt WW, Pieper KM, Strowd RE. A structured, journal-led peer-review mentoring program enhances peer review training. Research Integrity and Peer Review. 2024;9(1):1-11. doi:10.1186/s41073-024-00143-x read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1186/s41073-024-00143-x
  5. Cyberpsychology: Journal of Psychosocial Research on Cyberspace (editors). Decisions and Reviews Statistics for 2024. Cyberpsychology: Journal of Psychosocial Research on Cyberspace. 2024. read 9 October 2026. cyberpsychology.eu
  6. Reed H, Dehn RW, Bushardt RL. Reasons for unsuccessful research submissions to JAAPA. Journal of the American Academy of Physician Assistants. 2022;35(5):54-56. doi:10.1097/01.JAA.0000824948.31791.0b read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1097/01.JAA.0000824948.31791.0b
  7. Menon V, Varadharajan N, Praharaj SK, Ameen S. Why Do Manuscripts Get Rejected? A Content Analysis of Rejection Reports from the Indian Journal of Psychological Medicine. Indian Journal of Psychological Medicine. 2022;44(1):59-65. doi:10.1177/0253717620965845 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1177/0253717620965845
  8. Goodman JH. Appreciation for Our Peer Reviewers. Journal of the American Psychiatric Nurses Association. 2018;24(6):480-481. doi:10.1177/1078390318805982 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1177/1078390318805982
  9. Science Editing (survey report). Authors' perspectives on academic publishing: initial observations from a large-scale global survey. Science Editing. 2018. read 9 October 2026. doaj.org
  10. Publons (Clarivate Analytics). Global State of Peer Review. Publons / Clarivate Analytics (report). 2018. read 9 October 2026. clarivate.com
  11. International Union of Crystallography. Reviewers' survey. International Union of Crystallography (IUCr Journals). 2016. read 9 October 2026. journals.iucr.org
  12. Lee CJ, Sugimoto CR, Zhang G, Cronin B. Bias in peer review. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology. 2013;64(1):2-17. doi:10.1002/asi.22784 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1002/asi.22784
  13. Cobo E, Cortes J, Ribera JM, Cardellach F, Selva-O'Callaghan A, Kostov B, et al. Effect of using reporting guidelines during peer review on quality of final manuscripts submitted to a biomedical journal: masked randomised trial. BMJ. 2011;343:d6783. doi:10.1136/bmj.d6783 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1136/bmj.d6783
  14. Winck JC, Fonseca JA, Azevedo LF, Wedzicha JA. To publish or perish: how to review a manuscript. Pulmonology. 2011;17(2). read 9 October 2026. journalpulmonology.org
  15. Cobo E, Selva-O'Callaghan A, Ribera JM, Cardellach F, Dominguez R, Vilardell M. Statistical Reviewers Improve Reporting in Biomedical Articles: A Randomized Trial. PLoS ONE. 2007;2(3):e332. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0000332 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0000332
  16. Jefferson T. Peer review and publishing: it's time to move the agenda on. The Lancet. 2005;366:283-284. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(05)66968-1 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(05)66968-1
  17. Gile D. Publishing in TS: the authors' and referees' viewpoint. European Society for Translation Studies (Research Issues). 2005. read 9 October 2026. est-translationstudies.org
  18. Schroter S, Black N, Evans S, Carpenter J, Godlee F, Smith R. Effects of training on quality of peer review: randomised controlled trial. BMJ. 2004;328(7441):673. doi:10.1136/bmj.38023.700775.AE read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1136/bmj.38023.700775.AE
  19. Jefferson T. Glossary of peer review. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health. 2004;58:272. read 9 October 2026. drtomjefferson.com
  20. Jefferson T, Shashok K. Journals: how to decide what's worth publishing. Nature. 2003;421:209-210. read 9 October 2026. drtomjefferson.com
  21. Weber EJ, Katz PP, Waeckerle JF, Callahan ML. Author perception of peer review: impact of review quality and acceptance on satisfaction. JAMA. 2002;287(21):2790-2793. read 9 October 2026. garfield.library.upenn.edu
  22. Meadows J. Editorial peer review: its strengths and weaknesses. Journal of Documentation. 2002;58(1):104-106. read 9 October 2026. garfield.library.upenn.edu
  23. Callaham ML, Schriger DL. Effect of structured workshop training on subsequent performance of journal peer reviewers. Annals of Emergency Medicine. 2002;40(3):323-328. read 9 October 2026. garfield.library.upenn.edu
  24. Callahan ML, Knopp RK, Gallagher EJ. Effect of written feedback by editors on quality of reviews: two randomized trials. JAMA. 2002;287(21):2781-2783. read 9 October 2026. garfield.library.upenn.edu
  25. Jefferson T, Alderson P, Wager E, Davidoff F. Effects of editorial peer review: a systematic review. JAMA. 2002;287(21):2784-2786. doi:10.1001/jama.287.21.2784 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1001/jama.287.21.2784
  26. Rennie D. Fourth International Congress on Peer Review in Biomedical Publication. JAMA. 2002;287(21):2759-2760. read 9 October 2026. garfield.library.upenn.edu
  27. Paulus K. How to survive peer review. Learned Publishing. 2002;15(4):312. read 9 October 2026. garfield.library.upenn.edu
  28. Godlee F. Making reviewers visible: openness, accountability, and credit. JAMA. 2002;287(21):2762-2765. read 9 October 2026. garfield.library.upenn.edu
  29. Jefferson T, Wager E, Davidoff F. Measuring the quality of editorial peer review. JAMA. 2002;287(21):2786-2790. read 9 October 2026. garfield.library.upenn.edu
  30. Marusic A, Lukic IK, Marusic M, McNamee D, Sharp D, Horton R. Peer review in a small and a big medical journal: case study of the Croatian Medical Journal and The Lancet. Croatian Medical Journal. 2002;43(3):286-289. read 9 October 2026. garfield.library.upenn.edu
  31. Altman DG, Moher D, Schulz KF. Peer review of statistics in medical research: reporting power calculations is important. BMJ. 2002;325(7362):492. read 9 October 2026. garfield.library.upenn.edu
  32. Bacchetti P. Peer review of statistics in medical research: the other problem. BMJ. 2002;324(7348):1271-1273. read 9 October 2026. garfield.library.upenn.edu
  33. Gura T. Peer review, unmasked. Nature. 2002;416(6878):258-260. read 9 October 2026. garfield.library.upenn.edu
  34. DeMaria AN. Peer review: better than the alternatives. Journal of the American College of Cardiology. 2002;40(5):1017-1018. read 9 October 2026. garfield.library.upenn.edu
  35. Horton R. Postpublication criticism and the shaping of clinical knowledge. JAMA. 2002;287(21):2843-2847. read 9 October 2026. garfield.library.upenn.edu
  36. Callaham ML. Research into peer review and scientific publication: journals look in the mirror. Annals of Emergency Medicine. 2002;40(3):313-316. read 9 October 2026. garfield.library.upenn.edu
  37. Richardson JV. The peer review process: acceptances, revisions, and outright rejections. Library Quarterly. 2002;72(1):V-XI. read 9 October 2026. garfield.library.upenn.edu
  38. Rowland F. The peer-review process. Learned Publishing. 2002;15(4):247-258. read 9 October 2026. garfield.library.upenn.edu
  39. Day FC, Schriger DL, Todd C, Wears RL. The use of dedicated methodology and statistical reviewers for peer review: a content analysis of comments. Annals of Emergency Medicine. 2002;40(3):329-333. read 9 October 2026. garfield.library.upenn.edu
  40. Wager E, Jefferson T. Shortcomings of peer review in biomedical journals. Learned Publishing. 2001;14:257-263. read 9 October 2026. drtomjefferson.com
  41. van Rooyen S, Godlee F, Evans S, Black N, Smith R. Effect of open peer review on quality of reviews and on reviewers' recommendations: a randomised trial. BMJ. 1999;318(7175):23-27. doi:10.1136/bmj.318.7175.23 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1136/bmj.318.7175.23

Every source above is a peer-reviewed article, a publisher’s record of one, or a standard issued by the body that owns it. Each carries the date it was last read. Where a standard moves, this article is revised rather than left up with a note.

How to cite this article

Pick your referencing style and copy it. Your university or target journal may vary the punctuation — check its guide if it has one.

Pubrica Academy. (2026, October 9). Peer Review of a Manuscript: The Process, the Evidence and the Benefits of Reviewing. Pubrica. https://pubrica.com/academy/manuscript-guidelines/what-is-the-peer-review-of-a-manuscript-list-out-the-benefits-of-peer-reviewing-a-manuscript/

This article is written to be learned from. Cite it if you are referring to what it says; if you are using the evidence behind it, cite the sources listed above instead.

Structured review skeleton

This template should be completed in order within the review form. It separates what the paper claims from whether it supports the claim, requires every objection to carry a location and a remedy, and keeps the recommendation consistent with the list of points.

PEER REVIEW
Manuscript ID: ____________   Review due: ____________

CONFIDENTIAL TO THE EDITOR
  Conflicts of interest to declare: ______________________________
  Parts of this manuscript I can competently assess: _____________
  Parts I cannot (suggest routing elsewhere): ____________________
  Recommendation: [ ] accept  [ ] minor revision  [ ] major revision
                  [ ] reject  [ ] reject, resubmission encouraged

1. WHAT THE PAPER CLAIMS  (2-4 sentences, in your own words)
   Question asked: ______________________________________________
   Design used: _________________________________________________
   Principal claim: _____________________________________________
   Why it would matter if true: _________________________________

2. MAJOR POINTS  (must be addressed for the work to stand)
   M1. Location (page/line): __________
       What the text says: ______________________________________
       Why this is a problem: ___________________________________
       What would resolve it: ___________________________________
       Effect on the stated conclusion: _________________________
   M2. Location (page/line): __________
       ...

3. MINOR POINTS  (would improve the paper; do not block it)
   m1. Page/line ____ : _________________________________________
   m2. Page/line ____ : _________________________________________

4. REPORTING CHECK  (name the guideline for this design)
   Guideline used for this review: ______________________________
   Items not addressed in the manuscript: _______________________
   [ ] Reporting gap, not a conduct gap  [ ] Conduct gap

5. STATISTICS AND DATA
   [ ] Analysis matches the data structure (clustering, repeats)
   [ ] Primary outcome single, named, pre-specified
   [ ] Missing data handling stated
   [ ] Estimates reported with uncertainty, not only p values
   [ ] I am competent to judge the above    [ ] I am not

6. CONSISTENCY CHECK BEFORE SUBMITTING THE REVIEW
   [ ] Every major point has a location, a reason and a remedy
   [ ] No objection rests on a preference I have not argued for
   [ ] Recommendation matches the severity of the list above
   [ ] Nothing in the report identifies me unless I intend it to
   [ ] Tone is one I would be content to have signed

Pubrica AcademyWritten and maintained by Pubrica’s subject matter experts. Articles are revised when the underlying standards change, and each article states the date on which it was last reviewed.

How Pubrica can help

Pubrica reviews manuscripts as a methods reviewer would, against the reporting guideline for the study design and with the statistics checked separately, and returns located, numbered points rather than a general impression. Where a reviewer report has already been received, Pubrica classifies its points as factually answerable, remediable now or determined at the design stage, and drafts the response letter against that split.

Find something else

Search the Pubrica Academy

Access is free and requires no account. Enter a topic, or open the full library to filter by category, sub-topic or resource type.

Pubrica reviews manuscripts, or recently received reviewer reports, and identifies which points can be answered and how.

A scoping assessment is free and takes two business days. It provides a written assessment of what the work requires and which specialist would undertake it.

Get a free quote

Regulations

Check your project against this rule

  1. 1Your work
  2. 2Your details
  3. 3Send
What do you need?

Material you send is held under signed confidentiality, with access limited to the assigned team and encrypted transfer. It is not used to train anything and is not passed to third-party tools. Ask for the agreement before you send anything you would rather cover first.