Response to Reviewer Comments
Pubrica’s subject experts support researchers who have received a major or minor revision decision. We draft the point-by-point response to reviewer comments and make the revisions it describes, conceding, defending or declining each point with a stated reason and in a professional tone. You receive the response letter and a tracked revised manuscript, with every answer cross-referenced to the supporting change.
Comments answered individually23 of 23
Conceded and revised17
Answered with evidence, not changed5
Declined, with a stated reason1
Manuscript edits cross-referenced17 of 17
Decision → drafted 5d → your approval → resubmitted
- Point-by-point response letter
- Revisions made, tracked
- Every answer cross-referenced
- Next round included
Service Scope
Response to Reviewer Comments for Life Sciences and Pharmaceutical Research
A Pubrica subject expert reviews the reports and editorial feedback as the handling editor will, writes the response letter, makes the scientific editing changes it commits you to, and checks the letter against the revised manuscript.
Why the Response Letter Matters
A handling editor rarely rereads a revised manuscript in full. The editor reads the response letter, checks that the contested points were addressed and often returns it to the original reviewers, who compare their comments with your answers. A letter that argues rather than answers, or that claims changes the manuscript does not contain, can lead to rejection even when the revisions themselves are sound.
Common Reviewer Comments
Five Common Reviewer Comments and How to Respond to Each
Most reviewer comments fall into a small number of types. Select one to see what the reviewer is asking, a weaker reply and a reply that addresses the concern directly.
Reviewer 2, comment 4Major
“The sample size is not justified and no power calculation is presented. The authors should explain how 248 participants was arrived at.”
What is actually being asked: The reviewer suspects the study was under-powered and the sample size chosen by convenience. They are not asking you to defend the number so much as to show that the number was decided before the data were seen.
✗A weaker reply
We thank the reviewer. A power calculation has now been added. The sample size of 248 was adequate as the results reached statistical significance.
Two errors in one sentence. A post-hoc justification from the p-value is circular and every statistical reviewer knows it, and an added calculation that was not pre-specified invites the follow-up question you least want.
✓A stronger reply
We agree this was not clearly stated and have added it. The target of 240 was set at protocol stage to detect a 12% absolute difference at 80% power and a two-sided alpha of 0.05, assuming a 20% control event rate; 248 were enrolled to allow for loss to follow-up. The protocol registration and date are cited so the reviewer can confirm this preceded recruitment.
Concedes the point without apology, supplies the parameters, and anchors it to a registered protocol so the reviewer can verify that it was pre-specified rather than reconstructed.
Manuscript change
Methods, Sample size subsection added at p.6, lines 141–149, with the registry identifier. Cross-referenced in the response so the reviewer can find it without searching.
These examples are adapted from real revision rounds, with details changed and identifying particulars removed. Your reviewers’ comments will differ, but most will fall into one of these five types.
Response Letter Drafting
Full Drafting of Point-by-Point Response Letters
Pubrica subject experts draft the response letter from the reviewer reports, rather than only editing the tone, grammar and structure of a letter you have already written.
We offer both services, and they are priced differently. If you have already written your letter and want it checked, our entry-level letter check is the lower-cost option. If you need the response written from the reports, our drafting service is designed for that.
What the drafting service includes: a subject expert reads every comment from every reviewer and the editor’s note, classifies each one as concede, answer with evidence or decline with a reason, and shares that triage with you before any drafting begins. You can approve or change it. The letter is then written according to the approach you choose, the promised revisions are made in the manuscript, and every answer is cross-referenced to the supporting page and line.
What remains your decision: we do not make scientific decisions for you. Which criticisms to accept, which to contest and how to handle a request you cannot meet are decisions for the authors. We will recommend a position and tell you clearly when we think one is not defensible, but you sign the letter, and it must be one you can defend to the editor.
Types of Editorial Decisions
Minor Revision, Major Revision and Revise and Resubmit Decisions
These three decisions use similar wording but require different responses. Identify your decision type before you start drafting.
Best outcome
Minor revision
The paper requires only minor changes. The editor usually assesses the revision without returning it to reviewers, so the letter is typically read once, by the editor.
- Answer everything, including the trivial points
- Concede almost all comments, because contesting a minor point costs more than making the change
- Keep the letter short and the turnaround fast
- Typical deadline: 14 to 30 days
The common case
Major revision
This is the most frequent decision a sound paper receives and should be read as encouraging, because the editor remains interested in the paper. It normally returns to the original reviewers, who will compare their comments with your answers.
- Triage first — concede, answer with evidence, or decline with a reason
- Contest one or two points, not most of them
- Every promised change must exist in the manuscript
- Typical deadline: 30 to 90 days
Rejection with an invitation to resubmit
Revise and resubmit
This is formally a rejection but in practice an invitation to resubmit. The paper re-enters as a new submission with a new number, and the editor has indicated what would need to change.
- Treat the reports as a specification, not as criticism
- New work is usually required, not just new wording
- A covering letter must summarise the changes at the top
- Often there is no deadline, which is why these papers can stall for years
Appealing a rejection. A rejection you believe is incorrect, such as a reviewer misreading the design or a desk rejection on a scope judgement you can rebut, can be appealed. Most journals have a formal appeal process, although few authors use it. We draft appeal letters that set out the editor’s error calmly, with supporting evidence. Appeals rarely succeed, and we will tell you honestly whether yours has a reasonable prospect.
Who we serve
Five Author Groups We Support with Reviewer Responses
Each group faces different challenges when responding to reviewer comments.
Compliance and Standards
COPE, ICMJE and CONSORT Standards for Response Letters
Pubrica follows this guidance. A response letter is a formal part of the publication record and is assessed as such.
Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE)
COPE provides flowcharts for coercive citation, reviewers with undeclared conflicts and authors who claim changes they did not make. A response letter that overstates the revisions falls within this guidance.
International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE)
A revision can change who contributed what. Where reanalysis or new writing affects authorship, the ICMJE criteria apply, and editorial assistance should be acknowledged in the manuscript.
Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials (CONSORT and SPIRIT)
Reviewers frequently ask for items the reporting checklist already requires, such as allocation concealment, participant flow numbers or a pre-specified outcome. Answering against the checklist addresses both the comment and the compliance requirement.
Responsible Use of AI
Our Approach to AI Use and Disclosure
Journals now ask authors to declare any AI tools used in preparing a manuscript. Pubrica treats this declaration as part of the deliverable and tells you exactly what was used on your manuscript, so that you can complete it accurately.
Why We Do Not Publish AI Accuracy Figures
Accuracy figures for AI tools are usually reported by the companies that sell them.
Pubrica therefore quotes no self-generated accuracy figure, as it would carry the same conflict of interest. Instead, we tell you which tool was used on your project, at which stage, and what a human editor changed afterwards.
Revision Timeline
Revision Timeline for a Standard Major Revision
A revision involves several exchanges between you and our team, with your review in the middle. The timeline below applies to a standard major revision, so you can plan back from the journal’s deadline.
Day 1
Triage
Every comment is classified as concede, answer or decline and sent to you before drafting begins.
Day 2
Author approval
You approve or change the triage. You make the scientific decisions at this stage.
Days 3–5
Draft and revise
We write the letter, make the revisions in the manuscript and cross-reference every answer.
Days 6–7
Your review
You and your co-authors review the draft. Changes at this stage are expected.
Days 8–9
Finalisation and resubmission
We incorporate your edits, rerun the cross-check, prepare the files and resubmit through the portal.
Four of the nine days are allocated to your review, so a 30-day deadline is comfortable and a 10-day deadline is tight. Please send us the decision letter as soon as it arrives, even if you are not ready to start, so that we can plan around the deadline.
Methodology
How Our Reviewer Response Process Works
The process has six stages between receipt of the decision letter and resubmission. You make the scientific decisions; we handle the drafting and checking.
Editorial assessment of the reviewer reports
A subject expert works through every comment from every reviewer and the editor’s covering note, which is often the most important. Each point is classified as concede, answer with evidence or decline with a reason, and you review that classification before drafting begins.
Response strategy agreed with the author
Which criticisms to accept, which to contest and how to handle a request that cannot be met are scientific decisions for the authors. We set out the options and the implications of each, then draft according to the approach you choose.
Point-by-point response drafting
Each comment is quoted in full in the reviewer’s numbering, with the answer directly beneath it, stating first what was done and then why. Reviewers are addressed separately within one document, so a comment raised by two reviewers is answered for both.
Manuscript revisions committed to in the response
We make scientific and structural edits, agreed reanalyses, added references, restructured sections and language corrections, all with tracked changes or the highlighting the journal specifies, so the reviewer can see exactly what changed.
Cross-check of the response against the manuscript
Every answer is matched to the page, section and line it refers to. This step identifies any claim in the letter that the manuscript does not support, which is one of the most common reasons a revision fails.
Resubmission and subsequent review rounds
We prepare the cover letter, response document and revised files to the journal’s requirements and deliver them within its deadline. Many papers go through a second round, and those comments are handled under the same engagement.
Point-by-Point Response Delivered in Four to Five Working Days
Send the decision letter, the reviewer reports and your manuscript. A Pubrica subject expert returns the point-by-point response and the revised file, with every answer cross-referenced to the change that supports it.
We also cover psychology and cognitive science, veterinary and agricultural science, health informatics and AI in healthcare, and the social sciences. Statistical objections are answered by a statistician.
Review Types Covered
Responses to Journal, Thesis, Grant and Conference Reviews
Journal reviewers, thesis examiners, grant panels and conference committees each require a different kind of response.
Our experts
Subject Experts Assigned to Your Revision
The same named team works on your project from scoping to delivery, and your project coordinator introduces each member before work begins.
Reviews the scientific content for accuracy and confirms that each conclusion is supported by the evidence. The expert is matched to your field.
Edits for clarity, grammar, structure and consistency while preserving the author voice and scientific meaning.
Checks the finished work independently against the agreed scope and the applicable checklist. Findings are logged and resolved before delivery.
Manages the timeline, keeps you informed at each stage and coordinates the team so that questions are answered and deadlines are met.
Sample work
Sample Resubmission Kit Contents
Every Pubrica revision is delivered with the response letter, the revised manuscript and a record linking the two. Use the tabs to view each part.
Resubmission kit
Original research · major revision · 2 reviewers
23 comments answered · 17 revisions made · tracked manuscript and clean copy
23 comments triaged before draftingStrategy approved by you
- Structure
- Reviewers addressed separately, in their own numbering, in one document
- Each entry
- Comment quoted in full, then the answer directly beneath it
- Order
- What was done stated first; the reasoning after it, not before
- Cross-reference
- Page, section and line for every change claimed
- Quoted text
- Substantive rewrites reproduced in the letter, so nothing has to be taken on trust
- Tone
- Grateful, specific and non-defensive, with a separate read by a second editor for tone
- Length
- As long as the comments require and no longer, because unnecessary length can read as evasive
17 revisions, all trackedEvery one cited in the letter
- Response letter
- Point-by-point, formatted to the journal's requirements
- Manuscript
- Tracked changes, plus a clean copy for review
- Cover letter
- For the handling editor, summarising the revision in one page
- Figures
- 2 rebuilt, supplied at the journal's resolution and naming
- Supplementary
- 2 new items, formatted for the portal
- Checklist
- Reporting checklist updated with the new page numbers
- Deadline
- Delivered inside the journal's revision window, with the date confirmed
Redacted extract · client and journal details removedPage 1 of 4
The kit contains the letter, the manuscript and the record linking them. Use the tabs to see each part.
The triage page is produced before any drafting and approved by you. It shows how each of the twenty-three comments was classified, including the one that was declined and the citation request that was only partly met. Nothing is contested on your behalf without your agreement.
The revisions page is the cross-check. Seventeen changes were made and all seventeen are cited in the letter by page, section and line, because promising a change the reviewer cannot find is one of the most common reasons a revision fails.
On request, we will send a sample kit for a revision similar to yours, with the same article type, decision and types of comment.
Redacted sample
Resubmission kit
Original research · major revision · 2 reviewers · 23 comments answered. Client names, journal names and identifying particulars have been removed or changed. On request, we can send a sample based on a manuscript similar to yours.
Triage, approved before drafting
| Verdict | Count | What it covers |
|---|---|---|
| Concede and revise | 17 | The reviewer is right and the change improves the paper. |
| Answer with evidence | 5 | The manuscript already supports the position, or a reanalysis settles it. |
| Decline, with a reason | 1 | External validation cohort — not achievable in a revision cycle. |
| Flagged to you | 1 | A suggested citation set showed a coercive pattern. Two of four added on merit. |
Two entries, in full
Reviewer 2, comment 4 · conceded
“The sample size is not justified and no power calculation is presented.”
We agree this was not clearly stated and have added it. The target of 240 was set at protocol stage to detect a 12% absolute difference at 80% power and a two-sided alpha of 0.05, assuming a 20% control event rate; 248 were enrolled to allow for loss to follow-up. The registry identifier and its date are cited at p.6, lines 141–149, so the reviewer can confirm this preceded recruitment.
Reviewer 2, comment 11 · declined, with substitutes
“A validation cohort from an independent centre is required before publication.”
We agree external validation would strengthen the work and intend to pursue it; it is not achievable within this revision, as it needs fresh ethics approval and prospective follow-up. In its place we have done three things the underlying concern warrants: split-sample internal validation with 500 bootstrap replications (Methods, p.9); a sensitivity analysis excluding the two highest-volume sites (Supplementary Table S4); and a limitations paragraph stating plainly that generalisability is unestablished (p.19).
Cross-check
Seventeen changes were promised and all seventeen are cited by page, section and line. This check identifies the most common error in revisions: a claim in the letter that the manuscript does not support.
| Section | Change | Cited at |
|---|---|---|
| Methods | Sample size and power added; internal validation subsection created. | p.6, p.9 |
| Results | Site-exclusion sensitivity analysis; two figures rebuilt with intervals. | p.12, S4 |
| Discussion | Causal language removed from Abstract and closing paragraph. | line 34, p.18 |
| Introduction | Cut 840 → 610 words; mechanistic paragraph added; remainder to S1. | p.3–4 |
The next round is included. If the same reviewers return follow-up comments on our responses, we handle them at no further charge, within the agreed scope.
Prepared by Pubrica. Pubrica is a trading name of Guires®, registered in England, Wales and India.
Download this as a PDFBenefits
Benefits of Expert Response to Reviewer Support
Our support provides an objective reading of the comments, a subject expert who can address the science, and a response letter written in a professional tone.
Packages
Response to Reviewer Comments Packages
Every package answers each comment individually and delivers the revisions with changes visible. The packages differ in how much of the manuscript is revised.
Response letter check
Review of a response letter you have written
$120up to 1,500 words
Turnaround 2 working days
The next round is included. If the same reviewers return follow-up comments on our responses, we handle them at no further charge, with no limit on rounds for 365 days from delivery, within the agreed scope.
- ✓Your letter edited for tone, clarity and structure, comment by comment
- ✓Every claim cross-checked against the revised manuscript to avoid unsupported statements
- ✓Defensive, evasive or unanswered points flagged before submission
This is our entry-level service.
View a sample Select Letter checkPoint-by-point, written for you
Minor comments and light revision
$200up to 1,500 words
Turnaround 3 working days
The next round is included. If the same reviewers return follow-up comments on our responses, we handle them at no further charge, with no limit on rounds for 365 days from delivery, within the agreed scope.
- ✓The response letter drafted from the reports rather than edited from your draft, with every comment triaged as concede, answer or decline and approved by you first
- ✓Minor revisions made in the manuscript with track changes
- ✓Every answer cross-referenced to the page, section and line that supports it
Longer letters quoted per 500 words. Optional: language editing; further revision rounds.
View a sample Select DraftedMajor revision support
Substantive content changes and reanalysis
$340per revision round
Turnaround 6–7 working days
The next round is included. If the same reviewers return follow-up comments on our responses, we handle them at no further charge, with no limit on rounds for 365 days from delivery, within the agreed scope.
- ✓Every comment from every reviewer answered, including the ones that contradict each other
- ✓Sections rewritten, figures rebuilt and analyses rerun where the comments require it
- ✓Cover letter for the handling editor, with all revisions highlighted in the manuscript
Optional: statistical reanalysis with the code returned; plagiarism recheck on rewritten text.
View a sample Select Major revisionFull resubmission
Strategy, revision and the portal
$520per manuscript
Turnaround 8–10 working days
The next round is included. If the same reviewers return follow-up comments on our responses, we handle them at no further charge, with no limit on rounds for 365 days from delivery, within the agreed scope.
- ✓Everything in Major revision, plus rebuttal strategy worked through with a subject expert before drafting
- ✓Statistical reanalysis by a methodologist, with the reanalysis files and code handed back to you
- ✓Resubmitted through the portal inside the journal’s deadline, and unlimited revision within the scope of the original comments
Optional: appeal letter where you are contesting a rejection; consultation for later rounds.
View a sample Select PremiumPrices are per revision round on a manuscript up to 8,000 words. Grant-panel rebuttals, thesis examiner responses and conference resubmissions are quoted on the same basis.
Quality Assurance
Service Commitments Across All Packages
Four commitments that apply to every revision Pubrica works on.
Our service commitment
Revision Support Until Agreed Requirements Are Met
We do not offer refunds. Instead, we continue working on the deliverable until the agreed requirements are met, within the agreed scope.
01
Unlimited revisions
Revisions are not limited by number of rounds for 365 days from delivery, within the agreed scope.
02
Correction of our errors at no cost
If work is returned because of an error in something we prepared, formatted or wrote, we correct it free of charge.
03
Delivered on the date agreed
We quote a delivery date we can meet. If a deadline is at risk, we inform you early.
04
Authors retain final decisions
We advise, explain our recommendations and tell you clearly when we disagree, but you decide what is published under your name.
Limitations of our service. We cannot guarantee acceptance; that decision rests with the journal editor. Unlimited revision covers the work we were engaged to do, within the agreed scope; new analyses, a new study or a different manuscript are treated as new work. Revision support runs for 365 days from delivery.
Response letters that match the revised manuscript
Every change the response promises is checked in the file before delivery, and every answer includes the page and line. We do not allow an overstated revision to pass our checks.
Scientific decisions remain with the authors
What to concede, what to contest and how to handle a request you cannot meet are your decisions. We set out the options and the implications of each, draft according to your choice, and tell you clearly when we think a position is not defensible.
Authorship and acknowledgement in line with ICMJE
Editorial and writing assistance is acknowledged in the manuscript where the journal requires it, and we are not named as an author. Where a reanalysis changes who contributed what, the ICMJE criteria determine authorship.
NDA, encryption and white-label where you need it
Pubrica works with researchers in India, across the United Kingdom and Europe, in North America, throughout Asia-Pacific and the Middle East, and in Africa and Latin America. Wherever you are, every editor works under an NDA, files are encrypted in transit and at rest, and your manuscript is handled under GDPR. Agencies, CROs and freelance writers can take the work white-labelled, with nothing carrying our name.
Client Stories
Client Feedback on Reviewer Response Projects
Clients describe the outcome of our reviewer response work.
“The reviewers challenged my methodology and my first draft of the reply was defensive. They reworked the argument so it defended the design on the evidence rather than on my irritation. It was accepted.”
“Twenty-odd comments across two reviewers and I did not know where to start. Breaking them into what to accept and what to answer made the whole thing manageable in an afternoon.”
“Our clinical manuscript went through three rounds. Having the same editor across all of them meant the third letter was consistent with the first, which I would not have managed on my own.”
FAQs
Response to Reviewer Comments FAQs
If you have received a decision letter and are unsure how to respond, please ask an expert. No quote is required.
Answer every comment separately, in the reviewer’s own numbering, quoting each one in full. For each, state what you did before explaining why, because editors look first for the action taken. Where you made a change, cite the page, section and line so it can be found easily. Where you did not, give a reason and the supporting evidence. Keep the tone courteous throughout, however the comment was phrased.
The response should be a separate document from the manuscript, headed with the manuscript ID and the decision date. Reviewers are taken in turn and labelled as the journal labels them, with each comment reproduced verbatim and typographically distinct from your answer, for example bold or italic for the comment and plain text for the reply. Substantive rewrites are quoted in the letter so the reviewer need not open the file. Where a journal specifies its own layout, follow that layout.
Yes. Conceding an incorrect point makes the paper weaker, so disagreement is sometimes appropriate. Disagree on the evidence rather than on the reviewer’s competence, provide the citation, reanalysis or figure that supports you, and offer an alternative, such as a clarified sentence or a supplementary analysis, so the editor has something to accept. Contesting one or two points out of twenty appears considered; contesting most of them suggests an unwillingness to revise.
Say so directly, name the constraint — ethics approval, follow-up time, cohort access — and then do something that addresses the concern behind the request. Internal validation, a sensitivity analysis, a restricted claim or an honest limitations paragraph will often satisfy the worry that prompted it. “Beyond the scope of this study” on its own is read as a refusal. The same words with a substitute analysis attached are usually accepted.
Both reviewers will read your response, so do not choose between them by name. Find a solution that addresses both as far as possible, such as a shorter section that still includes the material the other reviewer requested, with the remainder moved to supplementary material. Explain the compromise to each reviewer and state that you will follow the editor’s preference if they would prefer the alternative. The editor makes the final decision, and a clear choice makes that decision easier.
Most journals give thirty to ninety days for a major revision and rather less for a minor one; the date is in the decision email and the portal usually shows it too. If the revision needs more time, ask before the deadline lapses — editorial offices grant extensions routinely when asked in advance and treat a lapsed window as a withdrawal. A manuscript that misses it can normally be resubmitted, but as a new submission with a new number and a new queue.
The editor reads your response letter first and decides whether to send it back to the original reviewers or to rule on it themselves. Minor revisions are often accepted by the editor alone. Major revisions usually go back, and the reviewers read their own comments beside your answers. Outcomes are acceptance, a second round of comments, or rejection; a second round is common and normally shorter, because only the contested points remain live.
They are valuable free feedback on your manuscript, and the next journal’s reviewers are likely to raise many of the same points. Revising against them before resubmitting elsewhere is almost always worth the delay. A rejection with an invitation to resubmit after major work is different and should be read as encouraging, because it indicates the editor’s interest in the paper if the objections can be addressed.
Yes, and they are not the same job. Funding panels from NIH, ERC, Horizon and national or private funders reward a direct answer to the stated weakness far more than a rewritten case for support, so the justification letter carries most of the weight. A thesis examiner is assessing you as well as the work, which changes the register entirely. We also handle conference paper resubmissions, poster and abstract revisions and white-paper review.
Yes. Editorial and language assistance is standard practice, and journals expect it to be declared. Where the journal requires it, we prepare the acknowledgement, and we are never named as an author, because we do not meet the ICMJE authorship criteria. The scientific decisions remain with you throughout, which is both the ethical and the practical position, because the authors must be able to defend the arguments in the paper.
Free Response Template
Free Response to Reviewers Template
The structure of a response letter is straightforward; applying it well is more difficult. Our template is freely available.
Free download · PDF
Response to reviewers template
The template has three parts: a triage table to complete before drafting, so that you decide what to concede and what to contest; the letter structure, with worked replies to the five common comment types; and a twelve-point cross-check that identifies promised changes the reviewer cannot find in the manuscript.
Free to use, adapt and share within your department. No email address is required.
Free · one business day
Free Comment Triage on Your Reviewer Reports
Send the decision letter and the reviewer reports, and we will classify every comment as concede, answer with evidence or decline with a reason. This is the same triage we carry out for clients, applied to your actual comments.
Many authors complete the revision themselves using the triage. It also shows you, before you commit to any cost, how much work the revision is likely to require.
Related services
Related Publication Support Services
Revision is the second stage of a submission, and the earlier stages affect how much work it requires.
1BEFORE PEER REVIEWidentifying issues early
Pre-submission peer reviewAn independent review that raises likely objections before submission, when addressing them takes a week rather than a review cycle. Journal selectionA mismatch in journal scope leads to reviewer comments that revision cannot address. Selecting the right journal avoids this.2ALONGSIDE THE REVISIONservices for the revised file
Manuscript formattingRestructured sections and added references mean the formatting has to be redone before the file goes back. Plagiarism checkRewritten passages and new literature can introduce similarity, so the revision should be screened as well as the original.Insights
Further Reading on Manuscript Revision and Peer Review
Three articles from our library on manuscript structure, journal selection and writing for readers.
Request a Free Triage of Your Reviewer Comments
A triage of your reviewer comments, classifying every point as concede, answer or decline, is free and takes one business day.