Home/Insights/Copyediting reference/Joining clauses
Joining clauses
The comma splice is the commonest punctuation error in scientific manuscripts, and it has four correct repairs — which one you choose changes the emphasis.
The problem
Two independent clauses — each able to stand as a sentence — cannot be joined by a comma alone. The dose was reduced, the symptoms resolved is a comma splice.
It is frequent in manuscripts written by speakers of languages where comma-joining is permitted, and frequent in hurried drafting by native speakers too.
The four repairs
Full stop. The dose was reduced. The symptoms resolved. Neutral; states two facts without asserting a link.
Semicolon. The dose was reduced; the symptoms resolved. Signals that the two are closely related, without naming the relation.
Comma plus coordinating conjunction. The dose was reduced, and the symptoms resolved. The conjunction names the relation — and, but, or, so, for, yet, nor.
Subordination. After the dose was reduced, the symptoms resolved. Makes one clause dependent and asserts a sequence.
These are not interchangeable in scientific writing. The fourth implies a temporal or causal relation the data may not support; the first asserts nothing. An editor choosing between them is making a claim on the author’s behalf, which is why the safe default is the semicolon or full stop, with a query if a stronger link seems intended.
Conjunctive adverbs
However, therefore, moreover, nevertheless and thus are adverbs, not conjunctions. They cannot join two clauses with a comma.
Wrong: The dose was reduced, however the symptoms persisted. Right: The dose was reduced; however, the symptoms persisted. Or start a new sentence.
Restrictive and non-restrictive
A clause that identifies which thing is meant is restrictive and takes no commas: Patients who received the intervention improved — only those patients.
A clause that adds information about an already-identified thing is non-restrictive and takes commas: Patients, who received the intervention, improved — all patients, and incidentally they received it.
The two sentences make different claims. This is the punctuation error most likely to change what a paper reports.
In practice
Fix, flag or query.
The distinction that keeps an edit defensible: what an editor may change silently, what must be shown to the author, and what only the author can answer.
- Fix silently: a comma splice, using a semicolon or full stop.
- Query, never assume: whether a causal or temporal relation is intended before subordinating.
- Flag always: a restrictive/non-restrictive change, because it alters the finding.
What this follows
- The Chicago Manual of Style, on independent clauses and conjunctive adverbs
- AMA Manual of Style, on restrictive and non-restrictive clauses
Where these authorities differ, the page says so. Pubrica applies the convention the target journal requires, and records which was applied.
Related