Home/Insights/Copyediting reference/Indicating omission
Indicating omission
An ellipsis tells the reader that material has been removed. Used carelessly in a quotation it can reverse what the source said.
The mark itself
An ellipsis is three points. Styles differ on spacing: some set three spaced points, some use a single ellipsis character. Either is acceptable applied consistently; what is not acceptable is a varying number of points.
Four points at the end of a sentence means a full stop followed by an ellipsis, or an ellipsis followed by a full stop depending on the style. It is not a four-dot ellipsis.
Omission inside quotations — where the risk is
Removing material from a quotation is permitted; changing its sense is not. The obligation is that the shortened quotation still represents what the source said.
The failure mode is cutting a qualification. "The intervention reduced mortality … in the subgroup with baseline eGFR above 60" shortened to "The intervention reduced mortality …" states something the source did not. In a research or medico-legal context that is a misrepresentation, not a style error.
An ellipsis is not normally used at the beginning or end of a quotation, since the reader already understands that the quoted fragment was extracted from something longer.
Square brackets for what was added
Where a quotation needs a word to be grammatical or intelligible in its new context, that word goes in square brackets: "[The trial] enrolled 212 patients." The brackets mark it as the editor’s, not the source’s.
A change of capitalisation at the start of a quotation is also conventionally bracketed in careful styles.
[sic] marks an error present in the original. It should be used sparingly; it reads as pointed, and in most editorial contexts a silent correction or a rephrasing is preferable.
Omission outside quotations
In tables, an omitted or not-applicable value should be marked explicitly — an em dash, NA, or not reported — with the meaning given in the table note. A blank cell is ambiguous between "zero", "not measured" and "not reported", and those are different facts.
In practice
Fix, flag or query.
The distinction that keeps an edit defensible: what an editor may change silently, what must be shown to the author, and what only the author can answer.
- Fix silently: an inconsistent number of points in an ellipsis.
- Query always: an ellipsis that removes a qualification from a quoted claim.
- Require: an explicit marker and a table note for every empty cell.
What this follows
- The Chicago Manual of Style, on ellipses and interpolations
- ICMJE Recommendations, on accurate representation of sources
Where these authorities differ, the page says so. Pubrica applies the convention the target journal requires, and records which was applied.
Related