Author and Co-Author: Are They One and the Same?
In scholarly publishing the answer is yes, in the sense that matters. There is one standard of authorship, and everyone named in the byline must meet it. “Co-author” describes a position in a list of authors, not a lesser grade of author. The distinctions that genuinely exist are between an author and an acknowledged contributor, and between an author and the corresponding author.
- The four criteria an author has to meet, quoted from the source journals actually apply
- Why “co-author” and “corresponding author” are not the same thing, and why neither is a junior role
- What author order does and does not tell a reader, and how far it varies by field
- “An author writes the paper; a co-author helps them, and is the same as the corresponding author.” Three errors in one sentence. Writing alone does not earn authorship, and on the ICMJE account it is not even sufficient on its own. A co-author is an author, held to the identical four criteria. The corresponding author is a separate administrative role that any one of the authors may hold, and whose duties may be delegated “to one or more co-authors”.1
The short answer
An author is anyone who meets the agreed criteria for authorship of a particular paper. A co-author is one of several authors of the same paper. The prefix marks plurality, not seniority, and it carries no separate threshold. If a journal applies the ICMJE recommendations on defining the role of authors and contributors, every person in the byline must satisfy all four criteria, whether their name appears first, in the middle or last.1
The confusion is worth taking seriously, because the stakes are real. As the Committee on Publication Ethics puts it, “authorship conveys significant privileges, responsibilities, and legal rights”.2 Treating some of those named as lesser contributors misstates who is accountable for the work.
What every author has to meet
The ICMJE recommends that authorship be based on four criteria, all of which must be met.1
| # | Criterion, verbatim | What it rules out on its own |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | “Substantial contributions to the conception or design of the work; or the acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of data for the work”1 | Doing the intellectual work but never seeing the manuscript |
| 2 | “Drafting the work or reviewing it critically for important intellectual content”1 | Writing the text without having contributed to the research |
| 3 | “Final approval of the version to be published”1 | Being added to a submission you have not read |
| 4 | “Agreement to be accountable for all aspects of the work in ensuring that questions related to the accuracy or integrity of any part of the work are appropriately investigated and resolved”1 | Taking credit without taking responsibility |
The fourth criterion is the one most often skipped in summaries, and it is the one that gives the byline its meaning. An author is not merely someone who helped. An author is someone who has agreed to answer for the work after it is published.
The ICMJE recommendations are widely adopted but not universal. COPE notes that “all journals should have a basic policy on what constitutes authorship of a research paper”,2 and the operative definition is the one in the target journal’s instructions. COPE also observes that referring to established guidance “can help manage negotiations of authorship”,2 which matters most where there is a difference in seniority between the people negotiating.
What is a co-author?
Nothing in the four criteria distinguishes a first author from anyone else named, and no guidance defines a second standard for people further down the list. The term simply denotes one of multiple authors.
The clearest evidence sits in the ICMJE’s own wording. Describing the corresponding author’s administrative duties, it says they “may be delegated to one or more co-authors”.1 A person who could not be entrusted with authorship responsibilities could not be delegated them. The phrase presupposes that co-authors are full authors.
It follows that the common phrase “I was only a co-author” describes a position in a list rather than a reduced obligation. The fourth criterion applies in full. Every name in the byline is accountable for the integrity of the whole work, not merely the part that person contributed.1
The corresponding author is a job, not a rank
This is the distinction most often collapsed, including in guidance written for researchers. The corresponding author “is the one individual who takes primary responsibility for communication with the journal”.1 That is a communication function, taken on by one of the authors, not a tier above or below the others.
| Term | What it actually denotes | Who can hold it |
|---|---|---|
| Author | A person meeting all four criteria, named in the byline1 | Anyone whose contribution satisfies the criteria |
| Co-author | One of several authors of the same work. Same criteria, same accountability | Every author of a multi-author paper, the first author included |
| Corresponding author | The author who “takes primary responsibility for communication with the journal”1 | One of the authors, chosen by the group. Duties “may be delegated to one or more co-authors”1 |
The role carries practical obligations that outlast submission. The corresponding author “should be available throughout the submission and peer-review process to respond to editorial queries in a timely way”, and “should be available after publication to respond to critiques of the work”.1 Those duties are a reason to choose someone who will still be contactable in three years, rather than to award the role as an honour.
Where the real line falls
The meaningful boundary is not between authors and co-authors. It is between those named in the byline and those named in the acknowledgements. The ICMJE is direct about it: “contributors who meet fewer than all 4 of the above criteria for authorship should not be listed as authors”, but “they should be acknowledged”.1
Several contributions that feel substantial do not, on their own, reach the threshold. The ICMJE names “acquisition of funding; general supervision of a research group or general administrative support”, along with “writing assistance, technical editing, language editing, and proofreading”.1 Acknowledgement is not a consolation prize here. It is the accurate record of what a person did, and the ICMJE suggests specifying the contribution — “served as scientific advisors”, “collected data”, “participated in writing or technical editing of the manuscript”.1 COPE makes the same point: “acknowledgements can be used to denote contributions to the work that do not meet the criteria of authorship”.2
Language editing and proofreading do not qualify a person for authorship.1 The same logic now extends to software: the ICMJE states that AI writing assistance “should be reported in the acknowledgment section”.1 A tool cannot agree to be accountable for the work, so it cannot satisfy the fourth criterion and cannot be an author.
The test, and the byline, drawn
Two diagrams settle most of the confusion. The first shows where the real line falls. The second shows what a byline does and does not tell you.
All four must be met. Meeting three places a person in the acknowledgements, not lower down the byline.
What to look for. There is no third outcome. The ICMJE recommends that “all who meet the four criteria should be identified as authors”, and that contributors meeting fewer “should not be listed as authors” but “should be acknowledged”.1 Nothing in that test asks how senior a person is, how much they wrote, or where their name will sit.
Schematic representation of the ICMJE criteria, not data.1
Position carries convention, not a different authorship threshold.
What to look for. The asterisk marks the person who “takes primary responsibility for communication with the journal”, and that person may delegate duties “to one or more co-authors”1 — wording that only makes sense if co-authors are authors. Order itself is decided “collectively by the author group and not by editors”,1 and what it signifies varies so much by field that “interpretation of author sequence can be like a lottery”.6
Schematic. The names are invented for illustration and refer to no real person or paper.
Contributorship, and what CRediT adds
Because a byline compresses a great deal of varied work into a list of names, many journals now publish a contribution statement alongside it. The common vocabulary for this is CRediT, the Contributor Roles Taxonomy, which sets out fourteen roles.4
| Role | Definition, verbatim |
|---|---|
| Conceptualization | “Ideas, formulation or evolution of overarching research goals and aims”4 |
| Data curation | “Management activities to annotate (produce metadata), scrub data and maintain research data”4 |
| Formal analysis | “Application of statistical, mathematical, computational, or other formal techniques to analyze or synthesize study data”4 |
| Funding acquisition | “Acquisition of the financial support for the project leading to this publication”4 |
| Investigation | “Conducting a research and investigation process, specifically performing the experiments, or data/evidence collection”4 |
| Methodology | “Development or design of methodology; creation of models”4 |
| Project administration | “Management and coordination responsibility for the research activity planning and execution”4 |
| Resources | “Provision of study materials, reagents, materials, patients, laboratory samples, animals”4 |
| Software | “Programming, software development; designing computer programs; implementation of the computer code”4 |
| Supervision | “Oversight and leadership responsibility for the research activity planning and execution”4 |
| Validation | “Verification, whether as a part of the activity or separate, of the overall replication/reproducibility”4 |
| Visualization | “Preparation, creation and/or presentation of the published work, specifically visualization/data presentation”4 |
| Writing – original draft | “Preparation, creation and/or presentation of the published work, specifically writing the initial draft”4 |
| Writing – review & editing | “Preparation, creation and/or presentation of the published work by those from the original research group”4 |
This is the most common misreading of the taxonomy, and CRediT itself is explicit: “it is not designed to determine authorship”.4 Its purpose is “to capture information about the specific contributions of its authors”,4 and the roles “can also be used to describe the contributions of individuals in contexts not related to article authorship”.4 Holding one CRediT role does not make a person an author; the four criteria still decide that. Notice that funding acquisition and supervision are both CRediT roles, and both are named by the ICMJE as activities that do not on their own qualify someone for authorship.1
What author order signals
If every author meets the same criteria, position must be carrying something else. It carries convention, and the conventions conflict.
The ICMJE declines to arbitrate. The criteria used to decide order “may vary”, and they “are to be decided collectively by the author group and not by editors”.1 What fills that gap is disciplinary custom, which Tscharntke and colleagues set out in a widely cited correspondence.6
| Convention | What the order means | Where it breaks down |
|---|---|---|
| Sequence determines credit | “The sequence of authors should reflect the declining importance of their contribution”6 | Position becomes “increasingly arbitrary as the number of authors increases beyond two”6 |
| Equal contribution | “Authors use alphabetical sequence to acknowledge similar contributions or to avoid disharmony in collaborating groups”6 | A reader who assumes declining contribution will misread it entirely |
| First-last-author emphasis | The first author made the greatest contribution; “in many labs, the great importance of last authorship is well established”6 | The practice is unofficial and “not always followed”6 |
| Alphabetical | Order carries no information about contribution at all6 | Indistinguishable from sequence-determines-credit unless the paper says which it used |
Tscharntke and colleagues attribute the inconsistency to “very different traditions across countries and research fields”, and note that “there is no accepted yardstick in assessing the actual contribution of a group leader to given scientific publications”.6 Their conclusion is blunt: “interpretation of author sequence can be like a lottery”, and “one really does not know if being last author means that the overall contribution was the most or least important”.6
The practical consequence is that order is a poor channel for information a reader needs. A published contribution statement carries it reliably; the sequence of names does not.
Ghost, guest and gift authorship
Three failures of the byline have names, and COPE publishes a flowchart for editors who suspect them.3
- Ghost authorship. Someone who meets the criteria is left off. The person who did the work is invisible, and the accountability the fourth criterion is supposed to secure disappears with them.
- Guest or gift authorship. Someone who does not meet the criteria is added, often because they are senior, fund the laboratory or head the department. COPE’s remedy is to have such names removed or moved to the acknowledgements.3
These are not hypothetical. In a cohort study comparing trial protocols with the papers that reported them, Gøtzsche and colleagues “found evidence of ghost authorship for 33 trials (75%; 95% confidence interval 60%–87%)”.5 Counting acknowledged contributors who had in fact qualified for authorship, “the prevalence of ghost authorship was increased to 91% (40 of 44 articles; 95% confidence interval 78%–98%)”.5 The study examined industry-initiated trials approved by two Danish ethics committees in 1994 and 1995, so the figures describe that cohort rather than publishing as a whole — but they indicate how far a byline can drift from who did the work.
Common mistakes
| Mistake | Stage | What it costs | What to do instead |
|---|---|---|---|
| Treating “co-author” as a junior role | Planning | People accept listing without accepting accountability, which is what the byline asserts | Apply all four criteria to every name, in every position1 |
| Equating co-author with corresponding author | Submission | The communication role is confused with a rank, and nobody owns post-publication queries | Name one corresponding author for communication; the role can delegate1 |
| Adding a head of department who did not contribute | Drafting | Guest authorship; COPE’s remedy is removal or a move to the acknowledgements3 | Acknowledge general supervision, which does not itself qualify1 |
| Leaving out the person who wrote the first draft | Drafting | Ghost authorship, found in 75% of trials in one cohort5 | Test that person against the four criteria rather than against their job title |
| Assuming funding or supplying samples earns a place | Planning | Acquisition of funding and provision of resources are not authorship on their own1 | Record them as CRediT roles and acknowledge them4 |
| Treating a CRediT role as proof of authorship | Submission | CRediT “is not designed to determine authorship”4 | Decide authorship by the criteria, then describe it with CRediT |
| Leaving author order to the end | Writing | A dispute at submission, with no agreed basis for settling it | Agree the order and the convention in writing at the start; it is the group’s decision, not the editor’s1 |
| Reading seniority into the last position | Reading others’ work | “One really does not know if being last author means that the overall contribution was the most or least important”6 | Read the contribution statement, not the sequence |
| Listing an AI tool as an author | Submission | No tool can agree to be accountable, so the fourth criterion cannot be met | Report AI writing assistance in the acknowledgements1 |
Take-home message
There is one standard of authorship, and every name in the byline must meet it. “Co-author” marks a position in a list of authors, not a lower grade, and it is not another word for the corresponding author, who holds a communication role that any of the authors may take and may delegate. The real boundary runs between the byline and the acknowledgements, and it is decided by the four criteria rather than by seniority, funding or how much text a person wrote. Settle who qualifies, and in what order, before the draft is finished.
How to apply this to your work
- Read your target journal’s authorship policy first. Its definition is the operative one, and every journal should have one.2
- Test each person against all four criteria, not against their seniority or their job title.1
- Agree the order and the convention in writing at the outset. Order is the author group’s decision, not the editor’s.1
- Name one corresponding author who will still be reachable after publication, and say what has been delegated.1
- Write a CRediT contribution statement, so the record does not depend on the sequence of names.4
- Acknowledge everyone who helped but did not qualify, specifying what each one did, and obtain their written permission.1
- Disclose writing assistance, including AI tools, in the acknowledgements.1
- Revisit the list before submission. Contributions change during a project, and so should the byline.
Common questions
Is a co-author the same as an author?
Yes, in the sense that matters. “Co-author” means one of several authors of the same work, and every one of them must meet the same four criteria: a substantial contribution, drafting or critical revision, final approval, and agreement to be accountable for all aspects of the work.1 The prefix marks plurality, not a lower standard.
Is a co-author the same as the corresponding author?
No. These are different things. The corresponding author is “the one individual who takes primary responsibility for communication with the journal”,1 a role held by one of the authors. Its duties “may be delegated to one or more co-authors”,1 which shows the two terms cannot be synonyms.
Does writing the paper make someone an author?
Not on its own. Drafting is the second criterion, and all four must be met.1 The ICMJE lists “writing assistance, technical editing, language editing, and proofreading” among activities that do not by themselves qualify a person for authorship; they belong in the acknowledgements.1
Does funding the study or heading the department earn authorship?
No. The ICMJE names “acquisition of funding” and “general supervision of a research group or general administrative support” as activities that do not alone qualify someone.1 Adding such a person is guest or gift authorship, and COPE’s remedy is removal from the byline or a move to the acknowledgements.3
Does being last author mean you contributed least?
It is not safe to assume either way. Conventions conflict: some fields order by declining contribution, some use alphabetical order to signal equal contribution, and in many laboratories the last position is the senior one.6 As Tscharntke and colleagues put it, “one really does not know if being last author means that the overall contribution was the most or least important”.6 Read the contribution statement instead.
Can an AI tool be listed as an author?
No. The fourth criterion requires agreement to be accountable for the work and to help resolve questions about its accuracy and integrity,1 which a tool cannot give. The ICMJE directs that AI writing assistance “should be reported in the acknowledgment section”.1
Who decides the order of authors?
The author group. The criteria used “may vary”, and they “are to be decided collectively by the author group and not by editors”.1 Because there is no external arbiter, agreeing the order and the convention early is the practical safeguard, and COPE notes that referring to published guidance “can help manage negotiations of authorship” where seniority is unequal.2
Declared interest: Pubrica provides manuscript preparation, editing and publication support commercially. Editing and language support do not qualify a provider for authorship, and nothing on this page should be read as suggesting otherwise.
References and sources
- International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. Defining the role of authors and contributors. In: Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing, and Publication of Scholarly Work in Medical Journals. read 20 October 2026. View the ICMJE recommendation
- COPE Council. Authorship. COPE discussion document, version 2; September 2019. read 20 October 2026. View the COPE discussion document
- COPE Council. What to do if you suspect ghost, guest or gift authorship. COPE flowchart, first published 2006. read 20 October 2026; this is an archived version, and COPE directs readers to the current release. View the COPE flowchart
- CRediT — Contributor Roles Taxonomy. Contributor roles defined. National Information Standards Organization (NISO). read 20 October 2026. View the CRediT role definitions
- Gøtzsche PC, Hróbjartsson A, Johansen HK, Haahr MT, Altman DG, Chan A-W. Ghost authorship in industry-initiated randomised trials. PLoS Medicine. 2007;4(1):e19. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.0040019 read 20 October 2026. View on PLoS Medicine
- Tscharntke T, Hochberg ME, Rand TA, Resh VH, Krauss J. Author sequence and credit for contributions in multiauthored publications. PLoS Biology. 2007;5(1):e18. doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.0050018 read 20 October 2026. View on PLoS Biology
How to cite this article
Pick your referencing style and copy it. Your university or target journal may vary the punctuation — check its guide if it has one.
This article is written to be learned from. Cite it if you are referring to what it says; if you are using the evidence behind it, cite the sources listed above instead.
Work through these before you submit.
[ ] Read the target journal's authorship policy [ ] Every listed author makes a substantial contribution (criterion 1) [ ] Every listed author drafted or critically revised the work (criterion 2) [ ] Every listed author has approved this exact version (criterion 3) [ ] Every listed author agrees to be accountable for all of it (criterion 4) [ ] Nobody is listed for funding, seniority or supervision alone [ ] Nobody who meets all four criteria has been left off [ ] Author order agreed in writing, and the convention stated [ ] One corresponding author named, reachable after publication [ ] Delegated duties recorded [ ] CRediT contribution statement written [ ] Non-qualifying helpers acknowledged, with what each did specified [ ] Written permission obtained from everyone acknowledged [ ] Writing assistance disclosed, AI tools included
We help author groups settle authorship and order against the criteria their target journal applies, draft the contribution statement and the acknowledgements, and record what was delegated to whom before submission.