What it is
SAGE provides a response-to-reviewers template for authors preparing a revision, published with its author guidance. It gives a structure for setting out each reviewer comment, the author’s response, and the change made with its location in the revised manuscript.
Several publishers now provide something equivalent. The common form is a three-column or three-part layout: comment, response, and where the change can be found.
Why the response letter matters as much as the revision
An editor deciding on a revised manuscript reads the response letter first. It is the document that tells them whether the reviewers’ concerns were addressed, and a revision that made every necessary change but explains none of them can still be rejected.
Reviewers are usually sent the letter too, and are asked whether their points were met. A letter that does not point to the changed text makes them hunt for it, which is the wrong frame of mind in which to be re-reading a paper.
What a good response contains
Every comment reproduced in full, in the reviewer’s own words and numbered. Omitting one reads as evasion.
A direct answer to each: what was changed, or why it was not. Disagreement is legitimate when reasoned — editors do not require authors to make every change, only to engage with every comment.
The exact location of each change, by section and line or page number, and the revised wording quoted where it is short.
A neutral tone. The letter is read by people who gave their time without payment, and whose recommendation decides the paper.
What weakens it
Claiming a change was made when it was not — checkable, and fatal to credibility. Grouping several distinct comments under one vague response. Arguing at length without changing anything. Treating a request for clarification as an attack on the work.
In short
What to take from this.
- Reproduce: every comment in full, numbered.
- Point to: the exact location of each change.
- Disagree where justified — but engage with every point.
Sources
- SAGE, response to reviewers template and author guidance
- COPE, on the peer review and revision process
Related