What it is
The Journal of the Academy of Public Health is an open-access public health journal launched in 2025. Its distinguishing editorial feature is open peer review: reviews are published alongside papers, and reviewers are identified rather than anonymous.
It also publishes reviews of papers already published elsewhere, as a form of post-publication appraisal.
The context of its founding
The journal was founded by a group including figures who were critics of mainstream public health policy during the COVID-19 pandemic, several of whom were subsequently nominated to US federal research positions. Its founders describe it as a response to what they characterise as censorship and suppression of dissent in public health publishing.
That framing is contested. Supporters present the journal as restoring open scientific debate; critics argue it provides a venue for positions that did not survive conventional peer review, and question whether its editorial independence is genuine.
Both readings are in circulation, and this page does not adjudicate between them. What is reportable is that the journal exists, what its stated model is, and that its launch is politically disputed — which an author should know before submitting, because a journal’s reputation attaches to the papers in it.
On open peer review generally
Open peer review is an established and growing model, used by publishers including BMJ, eLife, F1000 and others, and it long predates this journal. Evidence on it is mixed: published reviews are more constructive in tone, and signed review makes some reviewers decline and others more cautious about criticism.
It is a legitimate model with known trade-offs, and should be assessed on its own terms rather than through the politics of any one journal that adopts it.
What to check before submitting anywhere new
Indexing status, since a new journal is not indexed in MEDLINE or Scopus at launch and may never be. Whether it is listed in DOAJ. The editorial board and whether members confirm their involvement. Archiving arrangements. APC and waiver policy. Whether your funder and institution will recognise publication there.
In short
What to take from this.
- Know: a journal’s reputation attaches to papers published in it.
- Check: indexing, DOAJ listing and archiving before submitting to any new journal.
- Assess: open peer review on its own evidence, separately from any one journal’s politics.
Sources
- Journal of the Academy of Public Health, stated editorial model
- Contemporaneous reporting on the journal’s launch and the dispute around it
- DOAJ and COPE, on evaluating a new journal
Related