
Industry Discussions on Peer Review Processes
Industry Discussions on Peer Review Processes Home Insights News Industry Discussions on Peer Review...
Press Esc to close

Industry Discussions on Peer Review Processes Home Insights News Industry Discussions on Peer Review...

Explore how educational resources and workshops enhance learning, professional skills, and academic engagement.

May 2025 | Source: Sage Publishing SAGE Publications has implemented a response to reviewers...
The publisher templates covered in this collection share a common structure, and it works whether or not a journal supplies one. Number every reviewer comment and copy it verbatim. Under each, give your response, then say exactly what changed and where, with page and line numbers in the revised manuscript. Quote the new text where it is short. Where you have not made a change, say so plainly and give the reason. A response that summarises several comments together, or says only “revised as suggested”, makes the editor do the cross-checking and often triggers another round.
Not every comment should be accepted. A reviewer may ask for an analysis your data cannot support, misread a method or request a change that conflicts with another reviewer. In these cases:
The tone should stay factual throughout. Editors read the response to judge whether authors engaged with the review, not only whether they complied.
Most journals ask for a clean revised manuscript and a version with changes highlighted or tracked. Prepare both from the same final file, and check that line numbers cited in the response refer to the right version, usually the one with changes marked. Update linked documents as well: the reporting checklist page references, the abstract if results changed, figure legends, supplementary files and the cover letter. Inconsistency between these is a frequent reason for a revision to be returned before re-review.
A minor revision usually needs a careful, complete response but limited new work. A major revision may require new analyses, and it is reasonable to ask the editor for more time before the deadline rather than submitting an incomplete response. A reject-and-resubmit decision means the journal will treat the paper as new, so the response document should be thorough enough to show what has changed since the first version. Our template collection includes a reviewer-response template, the Academy has more on responding to reviewers, and Pubrica's responding to reviewers service prepares the response and revised manuscript together.