Free scoping read. A written assessment of your manuscript in two business days, at no cost.

Start one
Contents

Academy · Literature review · Importance of a literature review

The Importance of a Literature Review in Research: Requirements, Review Types and Citation

The Declaration of Helsinki requires thorough knowledge of the literature. It does not require a systematic review. Check the funder’s application guidance to determine whether a systematic review or another evidence synthesis is required.

Pubrica AcademyWritten by a research writing specialist Reviewed bya research methodology reviewer Published15 October 2026 Last checked15 October 2026 Reading time15 minutes Sources12 primary

A literature review establishes what is already known, which is what makes a new study answerable and, under the Declaration of Helsinki, an ethical requirement. It is distinct from a systematic review, and it is not mandatory in the way often claimed; this article therefore sets out what is required, by whom, and the purposes for which the alternative review types are suited.

Distinguishing a literature review from a systematic review

Different methods supporting different claims

A preliminary clarification is required, since the terms are often used interchangeably although they are not interchangeable. A literature review and a systematic review are not the same, and the difference lies in method rather than scale. A systematic review has pre-defined eligibility criteria, an explicit reproducible methodology, and a search that attempts to identify every eligible study. A traditional literature review, by definition, has none of these features and therefore, in the methodologists’ words, does “not normally present an unbiased, exhaustive and systematic summary of a topic”. Both are legitimate, but they support different claims.

The source wording: “should still not be confused with traditional literature reviews”9, because traditional reviews “do not normally present an unbiased, exhaustive and systematic summary of a topic”9

Actual requirements and their sources

Correction of an earlier claim on this page

It is sometimes stated, without a source, that “systematic reviews are now mandatory for most clinical research proposals”. The evidence does not support this statement. Applicants should check the funder’s application guidance to determine whether a systematic review or another evidence synthesis is required. Even NIHR’s own wording is conditional: “a systematic review should normally have been undertaken before a trial is considered”, and that applies to trials rather than to clinical research generally.

The funder survey examined what major research funders require of applicants2, so applicants should check the funder’s application guidance to determine whether a systematic review or another evidence synthesis is required.2 NIHR's own specification put it as “A systematic review should normally have been undertaken before a trial is considered.”3, and asked that the case for a trial “This should include an account of the existing evidence.”3

The existing obligation

What is required, and by whom, should be stated precisely. The Declaration of Helsinki, in its current October 2024 revision, requires at paragraph 21 that medical research involving human participants “be based on a thorough knowledge of the scientific literature” and be “likely to produce reliable, valid, and valuable knowledge and avoid research waste”. This constitutes an ethical obligation to know the literature — a knowledge standard. No paragraph of the Declaration names a systematic review or prescribes a method for acquiring that knowledge. The phrase concerning the avoidance of research waste is new in the 2024 revision, which is itself noteworthy.

Paragraph 21 in full as it bears on this: research must “be based on a thorough knowledge of the scientific literature”1, “must have a scientifically sound and rigorous design and execution”1, and be “likely to produce reliable, valid, and valuable knowledge and avoid research waste”1 And paragraph 22: the design “must be clearly described and justified in a research protocol”1 — which is where the review has to show up in a form someone else can assess. Our guide to writing protocols covers that document.

Origin of the false claim

The origin of the false claim merits attention, because the same slippage pervades this literature: advocacy gets read as regulation. Methodologists have argued for years that funders should mandate systematic reviews before funding new primary research. That recommendation is then quoted as though it described existing practice. When a source states that reviews are “required”, readers should check whether it is a funder’s own guidance or a proposal about what funders ought to do.

A sourcing note: the NIHR specification we verified dates from January 2012 and we could not locate the current programme wording, so it is quoted with its date and its “normally” intact rather than presented as today's rule.

Consequences of neglecting the existing literature

Interpreting a frequently misattributed figure

This figure requires careful handling, because it is the one most often quoted on pages of this kind and is almost always misattributed. The widely cited estimate that about 85% of health research is avoidably wasted is not a measurement, and it is not a figure about failing to review the literature. Its authors published a correction explaining that it compounds three successive stages, each of roughly half, and that it “did not account for waste in deciding what research to do”. Only the third stage concerns prior research. The appropriate figure for an article on literature reviews is therefore that stage alone: at least half of new studies do not systematically account for previous research. Quoting the 85% figure here would borrow authority from two stages concerned with other matters.

Table 1. The three stages the 85% estimate compounds

StageWhat it means
About half of studies are never published in fullResearch that is done and not reported cannot inform anything.
At least half of published reports are not clear or complete enough to useThe reason reporting guidelines exist.
At least half of new studies do not systematically account for previous researchThis is the stage a literature review addresses — and the only one of the three that it addresses.

The authors' own account: “Our estimate that 85% of all health research is being avoidably 'wasted'”4 was built that way, and “In our 2009 paper, we rounded this down to 85%.”4 They note the estimate “did not account for waste in deciding what research to do”4, and the reason the first and third stages matter most: “we cannot retrospectively fix poor design”4

Two different 85% figures

A further reason for caution with this number is that there are two unrelated 85% figures in this literature, with nearly opposite meanings. One is the research-waste estimate above. The other is a finding that about 85% of trials funded by one UK programme did use systematic reviews to inform their design. Presenting both would be incoherent, so this article presents neither as a headline figure.

We could not open the original 2009 paper, because its publisher's site is closed to automated retrieval, so the estimate is cited through the authors' own later correction rather than second-hand from someone else.

Current practice

Gradual improvement from a low baseline without a mandate

Current practice, as distinct from what is required, is as follows. In one earlier study, 11 of 48 trial applications made no reference to a systematic review, and of the 37 that did, only 20 reported using it in the design of the trial. A later comparison of two cohorts from the same programme found that the proportion of trials lacking any reference to a systematic review fell from 19% to 9%, indicating that practice is improving, from a low baseline, without a mandate.

The figures: “11 out of 48 applications made no reference to a systematic review.”5 “Of the 37 trials referencing a systematic review 20 reported their use in the design of the trial.”5 Comparing two cohorts from the same programme, the authors report “nine (19%) and three (9%) trials from cohort I and II respectively where a systematic review was not referenced”5

Selecting the type of review

Table 2. Three kinds of review and what each supports

TypeThe question it answersWhat it requires
Systematic reviewDoes this intervention work, and how well?Pre-defined eligibility criteria, an explicit reproducible method, a search that attempts to find all eligible studies, validity assessment and synthesis.
Scoping reviewWhat evidence exists, and what shape is it?Systematically identifies and maps the breadth of evidence, often irrespective of source. Systematic in method, different in question.
Traditional or narrative literature reviewWhat is known about this subject?No pre-specified criteria and no exhaustive search, so it does not claim to be an unbiased summary. Useful for orientation, not for a claim about the whole evidence base.

Choosing between systematic and scoping reviews

The methodologists who wrote the guidance propose a decision rule. If the question is whether something works, or how well, “then a systematic review is likely the most valid approach”. If the question concerns what evidence exists and how it is distributed, “a scoping review is the better choice”. The most practical test is that “scoping reviews should not be conducted if the end users or the authors want to make specific recommendations for practice”, because mapping a literature does not justify a recommendation.

The sources: a systematic review “A systematic review attempts to collate all empirical evidence that fits pre-specified eligibility criteria”6 and “uses explicit, systematic methods that are selected with a view to minimizing bias”6 A scoping review, per JBI, is “Scoping reviews are a type of evidence synthesis that aims to systematically identify and map the breadth of evidence”8, “often irrespective of source (i.e., primary research, reviews, non-empirical evidence)”8 And on choosing, “Scoping reviews are designed to answer different types of questions from systematic reviews.”10, with the practical limit that “Scoping reviews should not be conducted if the end users or the authors want to make specific recommendations for practice.”10

A common misuse of the term scoping review

A further misuse is widespread, and JBI addresses it directly. A scoping review is not a quick preliminary look before the actual review. JBI notes that the term “is sometimes used to describe a non-systematic, preliminary approach to preparing to undertake a review protocol” and states that scoping reviews “should be conducted and reported systematically with the same rigorous processes”, so that “one cannot be viewed as easier than the other”. A preliminary look should instead be described as a scoping exercise or background work.

JBI's wording on that: “'Scoping review' is sometimes used to describe a non-systematic, preliminary approach to preparing to undertake a review protocol”8, whereas properly “they should be conducted and reported systematically with the same rigorous processes”8 as a systematic review, so “one cannot be viewed as easier than the other simply because they possess some different characteristics”8

Three topics are deliberately not covered in this article, because they could not be verified against an authoritative source: definitions of a rapid review and an umbrella review, and any figure for how often published reviews are redundant or overlapping. The relevant chapters and papers could not be accessed for verification, and identifying the gap is preferable to filling it with unsourced material.

Defining features of a systematic review

Five characteristics, from the Cochrane Handbook6:

  • A clearly stated set of objectives with pre-defined eligibility criteria for studies.
  • An explicit, reproducible methodology.
  • A systematic search that attempts to identify all studies that would meet the eligibility criteria.
  • An assessment of the validity of the findings of the included studies.
  • A systematic presentation, and synthesis, of the characteristics and findings of the included studies.

And the thing that has to come first: “Systematic reviews aim to minimize bias by using explicit, systematic methods documented in advance with a protocol.”7 One requirement worth quoting exactly, because it is often generalised too far: “'Risk of bias' assessments in Cochrane Reviews must be made independently by at least two people.”7 — that is specifically risk-of-bias assessment. Our guide to structuring review tables and page on meta-analysis cover the synthesis stage; the MeSH guide covers building the search.

Appropriate citation practice

Revision of earlier guidance on this page

Guidance on literature reviews should not be framed as advice on avoiding plagiarism detection. The appropriate framing is provided by the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE). The obligation is attribution, not evasion: “appropriate attribution of all quoted material, including full citations”, and authors “are responsible for citing references accurately”. Two further instructions bear directly on how a literature review should be written: “authors should provide direct references to original research sources whenever possible”, because “review articles do not always reflect original work accurately”; and “cite only directly pertinent references”. In practice, authors should read and cite the primary study rather than the review that summarised it, and should not pad the reference list.

The ICMJE's requirements, in its own words: “Humans must ensure there is appropriate attribution of all quoted material, including full citations.”11 Authors “Authors should be able to assert that there is no plagiarism in their paper”11, and “Authors are responsible for citing references accurately.”11 On which sources to use: “Authors should provide direct references to original research sources whenever possible.”11, because “review articles do not always reflect original work accurately.”11 And on how many: “Cite only directly pertinent references”11

That middle instruction is the one that matters most for a literature review, and it is uncomfortable: if you have cited a review for a finding, you have cited something that may not represent the original work accurately. Read the primary study.

Reuse of authors’ own earlier text

Regarding the reuse of authors’ own earlier text, which arises when a literature review is adapted from a thesis or an earlier paper, the ICMJE frames the issue as duplicate publication, defined as a paper that “overlaps substantially with one already published” “without clear, visible reference to the previous publication”. The fault lies in the absence of visible reference. The remedy is “appropriate citation of previous publications from the same data set to allow for transparency”, which again constitutes a disclosure duty rather than a prohibition.

The wording: “Duplicate publication is publication of a paper that overlaps substantially with one already published”12 “without clear, visible reference to the previous publication”12, and the remedy is publication “with appropriate citation of previous publications from the same data set to allow for transparency”12

Recommended working practices

Practical application

  1. The review should be conducted before the protocol is finalised and recorded in it. The Declaration of Helsinki requires the design to be justified in a protocol, and an undocumented review cannot justify anything.
  2. The type of review should be decided and stated. A traditional review cannot support a claim about the entire evidence base.
  3. A systematic review is appropriate where the question is whether something works; a scoping review is appropriate for mapping existing evidence and should not be used to make practice recommendations.
  4. The protocol should be written before the search and registered where a register exists.
  5. Primary research should be cited in preference to reviews wherever possible, because reviews do not always represent the original work accurately.
  6. Only pertinent references should be cited. A long reference list is not evidence of thoroughness.
  7. Where earlier text by the same authors is reused, the earlier publication should be cited visibly. The fault in duplicate publication is the missing reference.
  8. Systematic reviews should not be described as mandatory. Applicants should check the funder’s application guidance to determine whether a systematic review or another evidence synthesis is required. Authors should conduct one because it makes the study answerable.

Key points

A literature review is an ethical requirement in the sense stated by the Declaration of Helsinki, namely that research must be based on thorough knowledge of the literature and avoid research waste, but no authority mandates a systematic review; applicants should check the funder’s application guidance to determine whether a systematic review or another evidence synthesis is required. A literature review and a systematic review are different methods supporting different claims, and a scoping review is not a lighter version of either. The 85% research-waste figure does not concern failure to review the literature; the relevant figure is that at least half of new studies do not account for previous research. The citation obligation is one of attribution: primary sources should be cited accurately and where pertinent.

No, although the claim is frequently made. Applicants should check the funder’s application guidance to determine whether a systematic review or another evidence synthesis is required. Even NIHR’s wording is that a review “should normally have been undertaken before a trial is considered”.

An ethical obligation to know the literature. The Declaration of Helsinki, in its October 2024 revision, requires at paragraph 21 that research “be based on a thorough knowledge of the scientific literature” and be likely to produce valuable knowledge and “avoid research waste”. That is a knowledge standard; it does not prescribe a systematic review.

No, and the difference lies in method rather than scale. A systematic review has pre-defined eligibility criteria, an explicit reproducible methodology and a search that attempts to find every eligible study. A traditional literature review has none of these features, and therefore “does not normally present an unbiased, exhaustive and systematic summary of a topic”.

When the question is what evidence exists rather than whether something works. The methodologists’ test is as follows: where the question is whether an intervention works, “a systematic review is likely the most valid approach”; where the aim is to map a literature, “a scoping review is the better choice”. Furthermore, scoping reviews “should not be conducted if… authors want to make specific recommendations for practice”.

No, and JBI addresses this misuse directly. It notes that the term is sometimes used for “a non-systematic, preliminary approach” and states that scoping reviews “should be conducted and reported systematically with the same rigorous processes”, so that “one cannot be viewed as easier than the other”. A preliminary look is a scoping exercise, not a scoping review.

Five characteristics, according to the Cochrane Handbook: pre-defined eligibility criteria, an explicit reproducible methodology, a search that attempts to identify all eligible studies, an assessment of the validity of included studies, and a systematic synthesis. In addition, the method is documented in advance — reviews “minimize bias by using explicit, systematic methods documented in advance with a protocol”.

No; this is a misattribution that the authors of the figure have themselves corrected. The 85% estimate compounds three stages — studies never published, reports too incomplete to use, and studies not accounting for previous research — each roughly half. Only the third concerns prior research, and that is the appropriate figure: at least half of new studies do not systematically account for previous research.

The primary study should be cited, accurately, and only where pertinent. The ICMJE asks that authors “provide direct references to original research sources whenever possible”, cautions that “review articles do not always reflect original work accurately”, and advises authors to “cite only directly pertinent references”. Authors “are responsible for citing references accurately”.

References

  1. World Medical Association. WMA Declaration of Helsinki: Ethical Principles for Medical Research Involving Human Participants. Adopted 1964; amended at the 75th WMA General Assembly, Helsinki, October 2024. Paragraph 21. read 15 October 2026. View on World Medical AssociationThe ethical duty to know the literature, which is a knowledge standard rather than a method mandate. The current version is October 2024, and that revision newly added the words about avoiding research waste.
  2. Nasser M, Clarke M, Chalmers I, Brurberg KG, Nykvist H, Lund H, Glasziou P. What do funders do to minimize waste in research? Cochrane Colloquium abstracts, Seoul, 2016. read 15 October 2026. View on Cochrane Colloquium abstractsA survey of what 11 major research funders actually require. The decisive source for correcting the claim that systematic reviews are mandatory for most clinical research proposals.
  3. NIHR Health Technology Assessment Programme. Specification document: HTA clinical evaluation and trials, an open call. January 2012. read 15 October 2026. View on NIHRThe funder whose requirement is strongest, in its own words. Note the wording is normally rather than always, the scope is trials rather than all clinical research, and the document dates from 2012 - we could not locate current programme wording.
  4. Glasziou P, Chalmers I. Is 85% of health research really ‘wasted’? The BMJ Opinion, 14 January 2016. read 15 October 2026. View on The BMJ OpinionThe authors of the 85% estimate explaining what it is and is not. Cited in place of the 2009 Lancet paper, which we could not open because the publisher's host is closed to automated retrieval.
  5. Bhurke S, Cook A, Tallant A, Young A, Williams E, Raftery J. How are systematic reviews used in the planning and design of health technology assessment funded trials? Trials. 2015;16(Suppl 2):O3. doi:10.1186/1745-6215-16-S2-O3 read 15 October 2026. View on University of Southampton repositoryCited for how often new trials actually reference prior reviews, and for the improvement between two cohorts. Read as the repository abstract record rather than the publisher's full text.
  6. Higgins JPT, Green S (editors). Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions, version 5.1.0, section 1.2.2. The Cochrane Collaboration, 2011. read 15 October 2026. View on CochraneThe definition of a systematic review and its five required characteristics. Cited from the archived edition, which is the version we could open.
  7. Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions, version 5.2.0, chapter 1 key points. read 15 October 2026. View on CochraneCited for the protocol requirement. Note we verified duplicate assessment only for risk of bias, so no claim is made here about duplicate screening.
  8. JBI. JBI Manual for Evidence Synthesis, section 10.1.2: scoping reviews compared to other types of review. JBI, 2024. doi:10.46658/JBIMES-24-01 read 15 October 2026. View on JBIThe definition of a scoping review, and an explicit rejection of the idea that it is a lighter or preliminary form of review. Note JBI has moved the manual off its main site to this wiki.
  9. Munn Z, Peters MDJ, Stern C, Tufanaru C, McArthur A, Aromataris E. Systematic review or scoping review? Guidance for authors when choosing between a systematic or scoping review approach. BMC Medical Research Methodology. 2018;18:143. doi:10.1186/s12874-018-0611-x read 15 October 2026. View on a university-hosted copyThe decision rule between the two, and the statement that neither should be confused with a traditional literature review. Read from a university course copy of the open-access PDF.
  10. Khalil H, Peters MDJ, Tricco AC, et al. Conducting high quality scoping reviews: challenges and solutions. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology. 2021;130:156–160. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2020.10.009 read 15 October 2026. View on a university repository copyThe sharpest practical test for choosing between the two review types. Read from a university repository rather than the publisher.
  11. International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing, and Publication of Scholarly Work in Medical Journals, sections II.A.4, III.B and IV.A.3. read 15 October 2026. View on ICMJEAn account of appropriate citation practice: cite the primary source accurately and only where pertinent.
  12. International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. Overlapping Publications, sections III.D.2 and III.D.5. read 15 October 2026. View on ICMJECited for reuse of one's own earlier work. Note ICMJE frames this as duplicate publication and does not use the terms self-plagiarism or text recycling, so neither phrase is attributed to it here.

Pubrica AcademyWritten and maintained by Pubrica’s subject matter experts. Articles are revised when the underlying standards change, and each article states the date on which it was last reviewed.

Related: structuring a review table · meta-analysis · building the search · review protocols.

How Pubrica can help

Pubrica’s information specialists and reviewers conduct evidence syntheses from start to finish: the protocol and its registration, a concept-by-concept search with controlled vocabulary and free text, screening and extraction, risk-of-bias assessment and synthesis, reported to the guideline governing the chosen review type.

Get a free quote

Regulations

Check your project against this rule

  1. 1Your work
  2. 2Your details
  3. 3Send
What do you need?

Material you send is held under signed confidentiality, with access limited to the assigned team and encrypted transfer. It is not used to train anything and is not passed to third-party tools. Ask for the agreement before you send anything you would rather cover first.