Free scoping read. A written assessment of your manuscript in two business days, at no cost.

Start one
Home·Academy·Literature review·Tables for a systematic review

How to Structure Your Table for Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

A systematic review does not have a table. It has several, and they are not interchangeable. Each answers a different question for a different reader, and the commonest fault is a single sprawling table that tries to serve all of them. Two of the three core tables have explicit prohibitions on what may not appear in them, and both are routinely broken.

What you will learn
  • Which tables a review needs, and what each one is for
  • The two things that must not appear in the characteristics table
  • Why the summary of findings table is capped, and at what
What to unlearn
  • “The reporting guideline requires a table of study characteristics.” It requires the characteristics to be presented, and names a table or a figure as equally acceptable. No item in the checklist mandates a table anywhere.
  • “One good table can carry the characteristics, the risk of bias and the results.” The methodological guidance says the opposite, and says it as a prohibition rather than a preference.

What this article covers

This article is about the tables themselves: which ones a systematic review carries, what belongs in each of them, and what the reporting standards do and do not actually require.

It assumes the review has been conducted, and asks how to present what it found. That is a separate skill from conducting the review, and it is usually left until the end, by which time the choices have hardened.

Where this sits among the related articles

The review process end to end is covered in systematic review and meta-analysis: main steps, and registering the protocol before any of it begins in PROSPERO protocol registration. The surrounding article and its sections are covered in how to structure your research article.

This article takes the tables, which those three leave to it.

The tables a review carries

A review presents four distinct kinds of information, and conflating them is what produces the unreadable table. Each of the four has an audience and a purpose of its own.

The core tables, what each answers, and who reads it
TableThe question it answersIts reader
Characteristics of included studiesWhat was studied, in whom, and howSomeone judging whether the evidence applies to their situation
Risk of biasHow much each study can be trusted, domain by domainSomeone weighing the synthesis against its weakest inputs
Results of individual studiesWhat each study found, as numbersSomeone checking the synthesis, or reusing the data
Summary of findingsWhat the body of evidence shows, and how far it can be trustedEveryone else, which in practice is most readers

The last row is the one that changes how the others should be written. Most readers consult the summary of findings table and nothing else, which means the other three are written for the minority who go further than it.

Tables and plots are not alternatives

The question of whether to use a forest plot or a table has a settled answer in the methodological guidance, and the answer is both. Cochrane’s recommendation is that “data represented in a graph should be tabulated whenever it is reasonable to do so”.9

The reason is that the two serve different ends. The reporting guideline’s own explanation puts it precisely: visual display “supports interpretation by readers”, while “tabulation of the results makes it easier for others to reuse the data”.2 A plot is something a reader looks at, and a table is something a later researcher extracts from.

Figures: organising systematic review tables

Figure 1 shows the three standard tables in a systematic review and the information that should not move between them. Figure 2 breaks down a summary of findings table column by column. Together they give authors a reference to check their tables against before submission.

Figure 1 · Three tables, and what may not cross between them

The separation is not a matter of taste. Two of these boundaries are stated as prohibitions in the methodological guidance.

CHARACTERISTICSof included studiesstudy designparticipants, in enoughdetail to judge applicabilitythe intervention groupswhich outcomes weremeasuredfunding, as an extra fieldRISK OF BIASper study, per domainthe judgment for eachdomain assessedthe overall study-leveljudgmentthe justification for each,quoting the study reportRESULTSof individual studiessummary statistics foreach groupthe effect estimateits precision, such as aconfidence intervalmust NOT appear hererisk of bias judgmentsstudy resultsThose two exclusions are why there are three tablesand not one. Each has somewhere else to go.

What to look for. The left-hand column is the one most often overloaded, because it is written first and everything seems to fit. The guidance is explicit in both directions: risk-of-bias ratings belong in the risk-of-bias table, and results belong in the results table. A characteristics table carrying either is not merely crowded; it is doing another table’s job and leaving its own undone.

Schematic. The field lists show the minimum each table is expected to carry, rather than an exhaustive specification of it.

Figure 2 · Anatomy of a summary of findings table

One row per outcome, up to a stated maximum. The column that causes the most trouble is marked.

population and setting · the comparison addressedoutcomerisk withoutinterventionrisk withinterventionrelative effectparticipantsand studiescertaintyoutcome 1, criticaloutcome 2, critical… up to seven outcomes in allexplanations, formerly known as footnotesthe column readers most often misreadAn outcome judged critical keeps its rowwhether data were found for it or not.

What to look for. The table reports the same effect twice, in absolute and in relative terms, because neither alone tells a reader what to expect. The marked column is not a guess about where difficulty lies: it was identified in user testing by the table’s own designers, who found readers misunderstanding it and redesigned it in response.

Schematic. The column labels here are descriptive, and the exact headings vary with the review and with the software used to produce the table.

The characteristics table, and what must stay out of it

This is the table a reader consults to decide whether the review applies to the situation in front of them. Its job is description, and the standard for how much description is set by that purpose.

On participants, the guidance sets the bar at applicability: “sufficient information should be provided to allow users of the review to determine the applicability of the study”.4 On design, it asks for “study design (stating whether or not the study was randomized)”, and on interventions for “a clear list of the intervention groups included in the study”.4

One further field is worth adding deliberately. The guidance recommends using “an extra field to provide information about the funding of each study”.4

Two prohibitions, both commonly broken

The first prohibition concerns risk of bias. The methods entry “should not include measures of risk of bias; these should appear in a ‘Risk of bias’ table”.4

The second concerns results, and is stated more broadly still: “study results should not be included here (or elsewhere in this table)”.4 The outcomes field names which outcomes were measured. It does not report what they were.

Both habits come from the same instinct, which is to build one table a reader can consult without turning the page. The cost is a table that answers no question completely.

The reporting guideline asks for the same content without prescribing the vehicle. Its requirement is to “cite each included study and present its characteristics”,1 and its explanation adds that these should be presented “in a table or figure”, “considering a format that will facilitate comparison of characteristics across the studies”.2

Where interventions are complex, a second table may earn its place. The same explanation suggests authors “consider presenting an additional table that summarises the intervention details for each study”.2

The risk of bias table

This table carries the judgments the characteristics table may not. The requirement is to “present tables or figures indicating for each study the risk of bias in each domain/component/item assessed” together with the “overall study-level risk of bias”.2

A judgment without its reasoning is not usable, so the guidance also asks for “justification for each risk of bias judgment”, “in the form of relevant quotations from reports of included studies”.2 Quoting the source study is what distinguishes an assessment from an assertion.

One presentational option is worth knowing. The guidance suggests authors may “consider displaying risk of bias judgments on a forest plot, next to the study results”,2 which puts the caveat where the estimate is read rather than several pages away.

The summary of findings table

This is the table most readers will read, and for many it will be the only part of the review they consult at all. Its purpose is stated plainly in the guidance: such tables “present the main findings of a review in a transparent, structured and simple tabular format”.5

What it contains

The standard elements of the table are specified in the guidance. A table includes “a brief description of the population and setting addressed by the available evidence” and “a brief description of the comparison addressed”, then, for each outcome, “a measure of the typical burden”, “the absolute and relative magnitude of effect”, “the numbers of participants and studies contributing to the analysis”, and “a GRADE assessment of the overall certainty of the body of evidence”.5 It also carries “space for comments” and “explanations (formerly known as footnotes)”.5

Reporting the effect twice is deliberate. Such tables “should include both absolute and relative measures of effect for dichotomous outcomes”,5 because a relative effect without a baseline risk does not tell a reader what to expect. For continuous outcomes, “a difference in means or standardized difference in means should be presented with its confidence interval”.5

The absolute effect column is the hardest one, on evidence

This is not a matter of opinion. When the format was tested with readers, the researchers found that “many had actually misunderstood content in the SoF table”, and the column at fault was the absolute difference.7 Their response was structural: they “replaced this column with a column for intervention group risk”.7

Their general observation is worth carrying to any table: “we observed how small design details made a difference to participants’ experience of the table in user testing”.7

How many outcomes, and which

There is a cap on the number of outcomes, and it is a specific one. Such tables “include a row for each important outcome (up to a maximum of seven)”.5

Choosing those seven is not a presentational decision taken at the end. “Planning for the ‘Summary of findings’ table starts early in the systematic review”, and “the decision selecting which outcomes are critical or important to the review should be made during protocol development”.5 The guidance calls this “a crucial step, and one that review authors need to address carefully”.5

One instruction follows from that ordering and is easy to miss. The pre-specified critical and important outcomes belong in the table “whether data are available or not”.5 An outcome that mattered enough to pre-specify keeps its row, and the row records that nothing was found. Deleting it would hide the gap.

On harms, the guidance permits aggregation but not omission: review authors “should include serious adverse events, but it might be possible to combine minor adverse events as a single outcome”.5

Certainty, and the two table formats

The certainty rating in the final column comes from an explicit assessment. Certainty is “determined through consideration of five domains: risk of bias, inconsistency, indirectness, imprecision and publication bias”,5 and the approach “categorizes the certainty in a body of evidence as ‘high’, ‘moderate’, ‘low’ or ‘very low’ by outcome”.5 There is a floor: “it is not possible to rate lower than ‘very low certainty’ evidence”.5

What those four words mean is worth stating in the review rather than assuming. High certainty means “we are very confident that the true effect lies close to that of the estimate of the effect”; at the other end, very low means “we have very little confidence in the effect estimate: the true effect is likely to be substantially different”.6

An evidence profile is a different table

These two kinds of table are often conflated with one another. An evidence profile “includes a detailed quality assessment in addition to” a summary of findings, and “provides a record of the judgments that were made by review or guideline authors”.8

A summary of findings table also carries a certainty rating for each outcome, but it is “intended for a broader audience, including end users of systematic reviews and guidelines”.8 The profile shows the working; the summary shows the conclusion.

What the reporting standard actually requires

Two claims circulate widely about PRISMA and tables, and neither survives reading the checklist.

It does not require tables

The checklist specifies content, not format. Item 17 asks authors to “cite each included study and present its characteristics”; item 18 to “present assessments of risk of bias for each included study”; item 22 to “present assessments of certainty (or confidence) in the body of evidence for each outcome assessed”.1 None of them names a table.

The nearest the checklist comes is item 19, on the results of individual studies, which asks for summary statistics and an effect estimate with its precision, “ideally using structured tables or plots”.1 That is a recommendation, hedged, and it offers plots as an equal alternative.

What the checklist does require is a description of whatever was used. Item 13c asks authors to “describe any methods used to tabulate or visually display results of individual studies and syntheses”,1 and to “report chosen tabular structure(s)” and “chosen graphical methods”.3

It does not require a summary of findings table either

The checklist’s explanation describes evidence summary tables as “an effective and efficient way to report assessments of the certainty of evidence”, and it is worth noting where that sentence sits.2 It appears among the additional elements, as “consider including evidence summary tables, such as GRADE Summary of Findings tables”.2 That is an enhancement, not a requirement.

The checklist does ask for one thing about certainty that is easily overlooked: certainty should be communicated “wherever results are reported”, which it specifies as “abstract, evidence summary tables, results, conclusions”.2 A rating that appears only in the table has not met that.

Where the requirement does bite

A Cochrane review is governed more tightly, and the distinction is worth stating precisely because it is usually overstated. Reviews “should incorporate ‘Summary of findings’ tables during planning and publication” and “should have at least one key ‘Summary of findings’ table”.5

What is labelled mandatory, however, is the assessment rather than the table. The guidance states that GRADE considerations “should be addressed irrespective of whether the review includes a ‘Summary of findings’ table”.5 The judgment is required; the presentation is strongly expected.

What reviews actually report

Adherence is uneven in a consistent direction. An evaluation of 87 systematic reviews in three periodontology journals scored each PRISMA item. The descriptive items were well served: study characteristics 98%, results of individual studies 98%, risk of bias 89%.10

The items calling for interpretation were not served nearly so well. Heterogeneity investigations reached 43%, sensitivity analyses 15%, reporting biases 17%, and certainty of the evidence 15%.10 The authors record that “16 items were reported adequately in less than 75% of the included papers”.10

That is one specialty and three journals, so the figures should not be generalised. The pattern it shows is still instructive: the tables that describe get built, and the tables that judge get skipped.

A separate study of 177 systematic reviews of COVID-19 interventions found that “only 37 (21%; 37/177) assessed and reported the certainty of the evidence using the GRADE approach”.11

Getting the numbers right, and the craft of the table

The numbers in the table are wrong more often than anyone expects

A reproducibility study examined data extraction in meta-analyses of adverse events, re-extracting from the source trial reports. Extraction “could not be reproduced in 1762 (17.0%) of 10386 trials”.12

Aggregated upwards, the figures are larger. “In 554 (66.8%) of 829 meta-analyses, at least one randomised controlled trial had data extraction errors”, and “171 (85.1%) of 201 systematic reviews had at least one meta-analysis with data extraction errors”.12

Most of those errors did not change the answer, and a minority did. Errors “led to 10 (3.5%) of 288 meta-analyses changing the direction of the effect”, and 19 of 288, or 6.6%, “changed the significance of the P value”.12

One scope note matters for how far this generalises. The study examined adverse-event data specifically, not outcomes of every kind, and the headline proportion counts reviews containing at least one affected meta-analysis. It is nonetheless the clearest available argument for independent duplicate extraction and for publishing the extracted data in a form others can check.

Constructing the table itself

Conventions for scientific tables are set out in the manuscript guidance and are largely about making a table readable on its own. Tables should be numbered “consecutively in the order of their first citation in the text”, and titles “should be short but self-explanatory”.13 Each column takes “a short or an abbreviated heading”.13

Explanatory material has a defined place. Authors should “place explanatory matter in footnotes, not in the heading” and should “explain all nonstandard abbreviations in footnotes”.13 Where numbers vary, authors must “identify statistical measures of variations, such as standard deviation and standard error of the mean”.13

One instruction governs the relationship between the table and the prose around it: “do not repeat all the data in the tables or figures in the text”.13

Concrete limits worth knowing
  • Width. A table should have “a maximum of 12 columns”.14
  • Empty cells. The style guidance is to “avoid blank cells in a table”,14 since a reader cannot tell whether a blank means zero, not measured, or not reported.
  • Alignment. Column headings are “bottom-aligned (instead of top- or middle-aligned)” and row headings “left-aligned unless there is good reason to do otherwise”.14
  • Footnote markers. “Use superscript lower-case letters to denote footnotes”, and “each footnote needs to be explained”.14
  • Numerals. “Use numbers instead of words in tables.”14

When a forest plot carries the data instead

A forest plot is the conventional display for a meta-analysis, and the guidance on it is specific. “The effect measure should be along the horizontal axis”, and “a reference line should be drawn at the position of no intervention effect”.9 The threshold for drawing one at all is lower than many authors assume: “the minimum number of studies appropriate for display in a forest plot is 2”.9

Two constraints apply to any graphic in a review. Graphs “should be robust to reproduction and reduction”, and “information must not be lost if the graph is reproduced in black and white”, so colour “must not be relied upon to distinguish different components”.9

The audience assumption behind that guidance is worth quoting, because it also applies to tables: “a high proportion of the readership have had no training in research methods or statistics”.9

Common mistakes

Faults in the tables of systematic reviews, and what each costs
FaultTableWhat it costsThe remedy
Risk-of-bias ratings in the characteristics tableCharacteristicsTwo tables are half-built and neither is completeMove the judgments to the risk-of-bias table, with their justifications
Study results in the characteristics tableCharacteristicsThe same, and a reader cannot tell description from findingName which outcomes were measured; report them elsewhere
A risk-of-bias judgment with no justificationRisk of biasAn assertion a reader cannot check or disagree withQuote the source study for each judgment
More than seven outcomes in the summary tableSummary of findingsThe one table most readers read stops being scannableSelect the critical outcomes at protocol stage
Deleting a pre-specified outcome with no dataSummary of findingsA gap in the evidence becomes invisibleKeep the row and record that nothing was found
A relative effect with no absolute effectSummary of findingsA reader cannot tell what the effect means at their baseline riskReport both, for dichotomous outcomes
Certainty stated only in the tableSummary of findingsThe abstract and conclusions imply more confidence than the evidence carriesCarry the rating into the abstract, results and conclusions
Blank cellsAnyZero, not measured and not reported become indistinguishableFill every cell, with an explicit marker where no value exists
Single extraction, uncheckedResultsErrors that in a minority of cases reverse the direction of effectExtract in duplicate, and publish the extracted data
Colour carrying the meaningAnyThe information is lost in black and white, and for some readers entirelyEncode in text or shape as well as colour
Take-home message

A systematic review carries several tables, and the discipline lies in keeping them apart. The characteristics table describes and may contain neither risk-of-bias judgments nor results, both of which are stated as prohibitions rather than preferences. The summary of findings table is the one most readers will read. It holds up to seven outcomes, chosen at protocol stage, and reports each effect in both absolute and relative terms. It also keeps a row for any pre-specified outcome, even where no data were found. The reporting checklist requires none of these tables by name; it requires the content, and leaves the vehicle to the author. What it does not forgive is a number that cannot be checked.

How to apply this to your work

In order, from protocol to proof
  1. Choose the critical outcomes during protocol development, not when the table is drafted.
  2. Cap the summary table at seven outcomes, and keep a row for each pre-specified outcome regardless of whether data were found.
  3. Extract data in duplicate and reconcile differences against the source reports.
  4. Strip risk-of-bias judgments and results out of the characteristics table, and give each its own.
  5. Attach a justification to every risk-of-bias judgment, quoting the study report.
  6. Report both absolute and relative effects for dichotomous outcomes, and check the absolute column against a reader who was not involved.
  7. Carry the certainty rating into the abstract, results and conclusions, not the table alone.
  8. Check every cell is filled, every abbreviation is defined in a footnote, and no meaning rests on colour alone.

Common questions

How many tables does a systematic review need?

A review commonly carries four kinds of table: the characteristics of included studies, the risk of bias assessment, the results of individual studies, and a summary of findings. They are not interchangeable, since each answers a different question for a different reader. The reporting checklist specifies the content of each without requiring that any of them take the form of a table.

Can the characteristics table include the results?

No. The methodological guidance states that “study results should not be included here (or elsewhere in this table)”, and separately that risk-of-bias measures “should appear in a ‘Risk of bias’ table”.4 The outcomes field names which outcomes were measured; it does not report what they were.

How many outcomes belong in a summary of findings table?

Up to seven, and the cap is explicit. The guidance specifies a row for each important outcome “(up to a maximum of seven)”.5 Which seven is decided during protocol development rather than at the writing stage, and the pre-specified outcomes belong in the table “whether data are available or not”.5

Does PRISMA require a summary of findings table?

No. Its explanation lists evidence summary tables among the additional elements, as something to “consider including”.2 What the checklist does require is that assessments of certainty be presented for each outcome,1 and that certainty be communicated “wherever results are reported”.2

Is a summary of findings table mandatory in a Cochrane review?

The position is narrower than it is usually stated. Reviews “should have at least one key ‘Summary of findings’ table”, but what is labelled mandatory is the certainty assessment, and the guidance notes that GRADE considerations “should be addressed irrespective of whether the review includes a ‘Summary of findings’ table”.5

What is the difference between an evidence profile and a summary of findings table?

An evidence profile “includes a detailed quality assessment in addition to” a summary of findings and “provides a record of the judgments” made.8 A summary of findings table carries the resulting certainty rating but is “intended for a broader audience”.8 The profile shows the working; the summary shows the conclusion.

Should results be in a table or a forest plot?

Both, where a meta-analysis was performed. The guidance is that “data represented in a graph should be tabulated whenever it is reasonable to do so”.9 The two serve different ends: visual display “supports interpretation by readers”, while tabulation “makes it easier for others to reuse the data”.2

How often are the numbers in these tables wrong?

More often than most authors expect. A reproducibility study of adverse-event data found that extraction could not be reproduced in 17.0% of 10,386 trials. It also found that 85.1% of 201 systematic reviews contained at least one meta-analysis with an extraction error.12 Most errors did not change the answer: 3.5% of meta-analyses changed the direction of effect and 6.6% changed the significance of the p value.12 The study covered adverse-event data specifically.

Declared interest: Pubrica provides research and medical writing support commercially. Nothing on this page should be read as suggesting that presentation can repair a synthesis, or that a well-built table compensates for data extracted once and never checked. Where the extracted numbers have not been verified against the source reports, that is the task, and no amount of formatting substitutes for it.

References and sources

  1. Page MJ, McKenzie JE, Bossuyt PM, Boutron I, Hoffmann TC, Mulrow CD, et al. The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. BMJ. 2021;372:n71. doi:10.1136/bmj.n71 read 21 October 2026 from the White Rose repository.View the full text
  2. PRISMA 2020 explanation and elaboration, item pages for study characteristics, risk of bias in studies, results of individual studies, and certainty of evidence. EQUATOR Network. read 21 October 2026, item by item.View the item pages
  3. PRISMA 2020 explanation and elaboration, item 13c: methods used to tabulate or visually display results. EQUATOR Network. read 21 October 2026.View the item page
  4. Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions, version 5.1.0, section 11.2.2: ‘Characteristics of included studies’ tables. read 21 October 2026 from the archived version 5.1.0; no equivalent section was reachable in the current Handbook, so this text is dated to that version.View the section
  5. Schünemann HJ, Higgins JPT, Vist GE, Glasziou P, Akl EA, Skoetz N, Guyatt GH. Chapter 14: completing ‘Summary of findings’ tables and grading the certainty of the evidence. In: Higgins JPT, Thomas J, Chandler J, Cumpston M, Li T, Page MJ, Welch VA, editors. Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions, current version. Cochrane. read 21 October 2026, in full.View the chapter
  6. National Health and Medical Research Council (Australia). Assessing certainty of evidence. Guidelines for Guidelines. Definitions attributed there to the GRADE Working Group, 2013. read 21 October 2026. Used for the wording of the four certainty levels, which the GRADE introductory paper names but does not define.View the guidance
  7. Rosenbaum SE, Glenton C, Oxman AD. Summary of Findings tables in Cochrane reviews improved understanding and rapid retrieval of key information. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology. 2010;63(6):620–626. read 21 October 2026 from a repository copy. The paper’s abstract and results section report its comparative percentages and group sizes inconsistently, so no directional figures from its trials are quoted here; only the user-testing findings are used.View the full text
  8. Guyatt G, Oxman AD, Akl EA, Kunz R, Vist G, Brozek J, et al. GRADE guidelines: 1. Introduction — GRADE evidence profiles and summary of findings tables. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology. 2011;64:383–394. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2010.04.026 read 21 October 2026 from a university-hosted copy. Its figure listing the rating criteria is garbled in that copy, so the five domains are quoted from the Cochrane Handbook instead.View the full text
  9. Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions. Graph recommendations, current version. Cochrane. read 21 October 2026.View the recommendations
  10. Alharbi F, Gufran K, Alqerban A, Alqahtani A, Asiri S, Almutairi A. Evaluation of compliance with the PRISMA guidelines for conducting and reporting systematic reviews in three major periodontology journals. The Open Dentistry Journal. 2024;18:e18742106327727. doi:10.2174/0118742106327727240905095525 read 21 October 2026. Eighty-seven reviews in one specialty and three journals; the figures are not generalised beyond that scope here.View the full text
  11. Martimbianco ALC, Pacheco RL, Latorraca C de OC, Ferreira RES, Riera R. Systematic reviews on interventions for COVID-19 have rarely graded the certainty of the evidence. São Paulo Medical Journal. 2021;139(5):511–513. read 21 October 2026. The study reports GRADE assessment only; it does not report how many reviews presented a summary of findings table.View the full text
  12. Xu C, Yu T, Furuya-Kanamori L, Lin L, Zorzela L, Zhou X, Dai H, Loke Y, Vohra S. Validity of data extraction in evidence synthesis practice of adverse events: reproducibility study. BMJ. 2022;377:e069155. doi:10.1136/bmj-2021-069155 read 21 October 2026 from the University of East Anglia repository. The study examines adverse-event data specifically, and its scope is stated wherever its figures are used on this page.View the full text
  13. International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. Recommendations for the conduct, reporting, editing, and publication of scholarly work in medical journals: preparing a manuscript for submission, sections on tables and figures. read 21 October 2026.View the recommendation
  14. Cochrane Style Manual: tables. Cochrane. read 21 October 2026.View the style manual

How to cite this article

Pick your referencing style and copy it. Your university or target journal may vary the punctuation — check its guide if it has one.

Pubrica Academy. (2026, October 20). PICO Framework in Evidence-Based Studies: A Complete Guide. Pubrica. https://pubrica.com/insights/study-guide/guide-to-evidence-based-research-on-pico-framework/
Pubrica Academy. “PICO Framework in Evidence-Based Studies: A Complete Guide.” Pubrica, 20 Oct. 2026, pubrica.com/insights/study-guide/guide-to-evidence-based-research-on-pico-framework/.
Pubrica Academy (2026) PICO Framework in Evidence-Based Studies: A Complete Guide. Available at: https://pubrica.com/insights/study-guide/guide-to-evidence-based-research-on-pico-framework/ (Accessed: 20 October 2026).
Pubrica Academy. “PICO Framework in Evidence-Based Studies: A Complete Guide.” Pubrica. October 20, 2026. https://pubrica.com/insights/study-guide/guide-to-evidence-based-research-on-pico-framework/.
Pubrica Academy, ‘PICO Framework in Evidence-Based Studies: A Complete Guide’ (Pubrica, 20 October 2026) <https://pubrica.com/insights/study-guide/guide-to-evidence-based-research-on-pico-framework/> accessed 20 October 2026.
Pubrica Academy. PICO Framework in Evidence-Based Studies: A Complete Guide [Internet]. Pubrica; 2026 Oct 20 [cited 2026 Oct 20]. Available from: https://pubrica.com/insights/study-guide/guide-to-evidence-based-research-on-pico-framework/
[1] Pubrica Academy, “PICO Framework in Evidence-Based Studies: A Complete Guide,” Pubrica, Oct. 20, 2026. [Online]. Available: https://pubrica.com/insights/study-guide/guide-to-evidence-based-research-on-pico-framework/
@misc{pubrica_srtables_2026, author = {{Pubrica Academy}}, title = {PICO Framework in Evidence-Based Studies: A Complete Guide}, year = {2026}, month = {oct}, day = {20}, howpublished = {\url{https://pubrica.com/insights/study-guide/guide-to-evidence-based-research-on-pico-framework/}}, note = {Accessed: 2026-10-20} }

This article is written to be learned from. Cite it if you are referring to what it says; if you are using the evidence behind it, cite the sources listed above instead.

Systematic review table checklist

Work through these before the tables are finalised.

CHARACTERISTICS OF INCLUDED STUDIES
[ ] Study design stated, including whether the study was randomised
[ ] Participants described in enough detail to judge applicability
[ ] Intervention groups listed clearly
[ ] Outcomes named, without reporting their values
[ ] Funding of each study recorded as an extra field
[ ] NO risk-of-bias judgments anywhere in this table
[ ] NO study results anywhere in this table

RISK OF BIAS
[ ] Judgment recorded for every domain assessed, for every study
[ ] Overall study-level judgment recorded
[ ] Justification given for each judgment, quoting the study report

RESULTS OF INDIVIDUAL STUDIES
[ ] Summary statistics given for each group where applicable
[ ] Effect estimate given with its precision
[ ] Data extracted independently by two people and reconciled
[ ] Extracted data published in a reusable form

SUMMARY OF FINDINGS
[ ] Critical outcomes selected at protocol stage, not at writing stage
[ ] Seven outcomes at most
[ ] Pre-specified outcomes retained even where no data were found
[ ] Population, setting and comparison stated at the head of the table
[ ] Absolute and relative effects both given for dichotomous outcomes
[ ] Confidence interval given for every estimate
[ ] Number of participants and studies given per outcome
[ ] Certainty rated for each outcome across the five domains
[ ] Reason for every rating down or up explained in a footnote
[ ] Certainty also stated in the abstract, results and conclusions

EVERY TABLE
[ ] Numbered in order of first citation in the text
[ ] Title short and self-explanatory
[ ] Twelve columns at most
[ ] No blank cells
[ ] Every non-standard abbreviation defined in a footnote
[ ] Measures of variation identified
[ ] No meaning carried by colour alone
[ ] Text not repeating all the data the table already carries
PA
Pubrica Academy

Written and maintained by the subject matter experts of Pubrica who do this work. Articles are revised when the standard underneath them moves, and each one carries the date it was last checked against its sources.

How Pubrica helps

We help you build the tables a systematic review needs, keep the characteristics, risk-of-bias and results tables properly separated, and present certainty of evidence to the standard reviewers expect.

Explore

Related reading in the Academy.

Picked from the same sub-topic and category as this piece, newest first.

Find something else

Search the rest of the Academy.

Open with no account. Type what you are working on, or open the full library to filter by category, sub-topic or resource type.

Get a free quote

Regulations

Check your project against this rule

  1. 1Your work
  2. 2Your details
  3. 3Send
What do you need?

Material you send is held under signed confidentiality, with access limited to the assigned team and encrypted transfer. It is not used to train anything and is not passed to third-party tools. Ask for the agreement before you send anything you would rather cover first.