Free scoping read. A written assessment of your manuscript in two business days, at no cost.

Start one
Home·Academy·Journal submission·Indexed vs non-indexed journals

Indexed vs. Non-Indexed Journals: Why It Matters for Your Research

Almost every journal says it is indexed. The word does different work in different claims, and some of those claims can be checked in about two minutes while others cannot be checked at all. Knowing which database is being named, and looking the journal up in that database rather than on the journal’s own website, is most of the skill.

What you will learn
  • Why “PubMed indexed” is not one claim but three, and how to tell which one is being made
  • What MEDLINE, Scopus, Web of Science and DOAJ each actually select for, in their own words
  • How to check any indexing claim against the database’s own record, including the case where coverage has quietly ended
What to unlearn
  • “If it comes up in a PubMed search, the journal is indexed in PubMed.” The citation information in PubMed “is derived from three main sources”, of which MEDLINE is one.2 The others include PMC, which is “also the repository for author manuscripts that are required under the NIH Public Access Policy”.3 Retrieval is not selection.

What “indexed” actually means

A bibliographic database is a curated collection. Somebody decides which journals go into it, records their contents in a structured form, and makes those records searchable. A journal is indexed in a database when that database has decided to cover it and is doing so.

Three things follow, and each is a place where claims go wrong.

Indexing is specific to one database. There is no general state of being indexed. A journal is indexed in MEDLINE, or in Scopus, or in neither. A claim that names no database has said nothing that can be checked.

Indexing is a decision made by the database, not by the journal. That is why the database is the authority on the question. The journal is an interested party reporting its own status.

Indexing is not permanent. Databases re-evaluate what they cover and stop covering titles that fall below their standards. Scopus states that its advisory board “will decide to either continue a journal’s coverage or to discontinue the forward flow”;9 Clarivate states that “any journal that fails to meet the 24 quality criteria will be removed from the Web of Science Core Collection”.10 A journal that was accurately describing itself as indexed three years ago may not be doing so today.

Where this article sits

Choosing a journal involves more than its indexing: scope, quartile, speed, cost, audience and the screening of questionable publishers all bear on the decision, and those are covered in how to choose the right journal. That article tells you to confirm an indexing claim against the database concerned. This one is the detail behind that instruction — what each database covers, and what checking it actually involves.

The claim that causes the most confusion

“PubMed indexed” is the most frequently made indexing claim in biomedical publishing and the least informative, because PubMed is not a single selected collection.

The National Library of Medicine describes PubMed as its “free, searchable bibliographic database”, and is explicit about where its contents come from: the citation information in PubMed “is derived from three main sources”.2 Those sources are MEDLINE, “the primary database of citations and abstracts that PubMed searches”; PMC, “a full text archive that includes articles from journals reviewed and selected by NLM”; and Bookshelf, “a full text archive of books, chapters, reports, databases, and other documents”.2

So a record retrieved by a PubMed search may have arrived by any of three routes, and only one of them is MEDLINE selection. NLM says so directly in its documentation of the journal list: “the non-MEDLINE journals include those whose content is deposited in PMC (PubMed Central)”.3

The mechanism by which a non-selected journal’s articles reach PubMed is a funding condition rather than an editorial judgement. PMC “is also the repository for author manuscripts that are required under the NIH Public Access Policy”.3 An author with a qualifying grant deposits the manuscript because the grant requires it, whatever the journal is.

This loophole has been described in the peer-reviewed literature

Manca and colleagues set out how it works in a CMAJ analysis titled, plainly enough, how predatory journals “leak into PubMed”.8 Their account is that “open-access journals that do not qualify for inclusion may be indexed in PubMed Central” because of “the need to deposit research funded by the National Institutes of Health under the Public Access Policy”, and that in consequence “PubMed may well include journals that either did not apply for MEDLINE indexing” or did not meet its standard.8

NLM staff replied in the same journal, and the reply is worth reading alongside, because it narrows the claim rather than denying it. Journals applying to PMC “undergo a rigorous assessment of scientific and editorial quality”, and the error they identify is “conflating the appearance of 1 or more individual journal articles that are included in PubMed Central” with “the inclusion of articles from an accepted journal”.7 Both sides of that exchange point the same way for an author: the presence of an article is not a statement about the journal.

Treat “PubMed indexed”, then, as an unfinished sentence, and ask which of the routes is meant. If the answer is MEDLINE, the claim is checkable and meaningful. If the answer is that some articles sit in PMC because their authors had grants, the journal has told you something about its authors' funding. If no answer comes, that is itself informative.

What the major databases actually are

Each of the main databases publishes its own selection policy. Reading them in their own words is more useful than any summary, because the differences between them are differences of purpose rather than of rigour.

MEDLINE

MEDLINE is NLM’s “premier bibliographic database”, containing “more than 31 million references to journal articles” from “more than 5,200 worldwide journals in about 40 languages”.6 It is “a primary component of PubMed” rather than a synonym for it.6

Entry is by application and review. “Any journal that submits an application and meets all of the pre-application requirements undergoes an evaluation process”, and those requirements are concrete: the journal “must have a properly registered ISSN”, “must publish abstracts for all peer-reviewed content”, and must have published a minimum number of primary peer-reviewed articles.5 A journal that fails the initial screening is “eligible to reapply in 24 months”.5

What follows is called the Scientific Quality Review, “a rigorous, multi-step process” that “focuses on 5 critical elements”: Scope and Coverage, Editorial Policies and Processes, Scientific Rigor or Methodological Rigor, Production and Administration, and Impact.1 At least two consultants, usually one scientist and one medical librarian, review each journal, generally looking at “articles from the last two years of journal content”.1 Their “recommendations are taken into consideration by NLM in reaching a final decision”, and the question being answered is whether “the scientific and editorial character and quality of a journal merit its inclusion in MEDLINE”.1 It is deliberately not a scorecard: “NLM views each journal comprehensively, rather than basing a decision on a defined list of criteria”.1

A detail that dates older guidance

Many published guides, including some still in circulation, describe MEDLINE selection as the work of the Literature Selection Technical Review Committee. That body “was a federal advisory committee that was established in 1987 to review journals that had applied to MEDLINE”, and NLM records that “the LSTRC was terminated in 2025”.4 The review described above is the current process. Anything that presents the committee as still performing this role is out of date, which is a useful reminder that guidance about databases ages as fast as the databases change.

Scopus

Scopus is curated by a Content Selection and Advisory Board, whose members “have deep subject matter expertise” and “continually review new titles using both quantitative and qualitative measures”.9 Titles reach it by suggestion: “journals may be suggested to the CSAB for inclusion in Scopus by the publisher or editor(s) of the title”.9

There is a technical threshold before any judgement is made — a journal must “be published on a regular basis and have an International Standard Serial Number (ISSN)” — after which titles “will be evaluated on the following five categories of criteria”: journal policy, content, journal standing, publishing regularity and online availability.9

Acceptance is not the end of the assessment. Titles “can be flagged for re-evaluation in different ways”, including where “the journal shows outlier or unexpected publishing performance” or where “concerns about the publication standards of a journal indexed in Scopus can be raised by the research community”.9 While that runs, “the content flow for these titles will be suspended until the re-evaluation is complete”.9 The outcome may be that the board will “discontinue the forward flow”, though “for journals that are discontinued or put on hold, the content already indexed in Scopus remains”.9

Scopus publishes the resulting record. “Discontinued titles can be found in the Scopus source title list”, and “the file includes the list of discontinued sources and is updated monthly”.9 That file is what makes the middle outcome in Figure 2 checkable rather than hypothetical.

Figures: verifying a journal’s indexing

Figure 1 explains what a PubMed search covers and which of its sources apply formal selection criteria. Figure 2 sets out how to check an indexing claim at source. Authors can use both when shortlisting journals, so that claims made on a journal’s own website are verified rather than taken at face value.

Figure 1 · What a PubMed search is actually searching

PubMed is a search interface over several record sources. Only one of them involves selection against published criteria.

Records retrieved by a search in PubMed come from more than one placePubMeda search interface over several record sources, not itself a selected indexMEDLINEtitles selected by aformal review processagainst published criteriaselectionPMCa full-text archive;deposit can follow a fundermandate or an agreementdepositBookshelfa full-text archive ofbooks, chapters, reportsand other documentsarchiveAppearing in a PubMed search is not the same as being indexed in MEDLINE.“PubMed indexed” is therefore a claim that needs translating before it can be checked.

What to look for. The three boxes are reached by different routes, and only the first involves anyone judging the journal. MEDLINE titles are chosen by review against stated criteria;1 PMC is “a full text archive”, and the route in can be a funding condition, since it “is also the repository for author manuscripts that are required under the NIH Public Access Policy”;23 and PubMed itself is the interface that searches across them.2 A journal advertising itself as “PubMed indexed” may mean any of the three, which is why the phrase has to be resolved into a specific database before it can be verified.2

Schematic representation of the relationship between the three, not of their relative size.

Figure 2 · Checking a claim at source

The journal’s own website is never the evidence. The database’s own list is, and it has three possible answers rather than two.

One claim, three possible answersthe claim“indexed in<named database>”the checkthat database’s own list,searched by ISSNlisted, coverage currentthe claim holdslisted, coverage endedtrue once, not nownot listedthe claim failsThe middle outcome is the one that gets missed. Coverage can end without a journal changing its website,so a title may keep describing itself as indexed long after the database stopped covering it.

What to look for. The middle box is the point of the diagram. Checking is a two-step operation rather than a yes or no: resolve the claim to a named database, then look the journal up in that database’s own list rather than on the journal’s site.9 Searching by ISSN rather than by title matters because titles are imitated and ISSNs are not. The step cannot be skipped by trusting the claim, because claims of this kind are known to be made falsely: in a cross-sectional comparison of journals, Shamseer and colleagues found that “some potentially predatory journals indicate being indexed in well-known biomedical databases”, and were careful to add that they “have not verified the truthfulness of these claims by checking the databases”.14

Schematic representation of the verification steps.

Web of Science

The Web of Science Core Collection is selected by Clarivate’s “expert in-house editors who have no affiliations to publishing houses or research institutes”, an arrangement the company describes as “removing any potential bias or conflict of interest”.10

It applies “a single set of 28 criteria to evaluate journals”, divided into two groups that do different work.10 Twenty-four are quality criteria, which select for “editorial rigor and best practice at the journal level”; four are impact criteria, which select for “the most impactful journals”.10 That split explains the structure of the collection. Journals meeting the quality criteria enter the “Emerging Sources Citation Index (ESCI)”; those also meeting the impact criteria enter the flagship indexes, the “Science Citation Index Expanded (SCIE), Social Sciences Citation Index (SSCI) or Arts & Humanities Citation Index (AHCI)”.10

Coverage is conditional in both directions. The collection is “subject to periodic re-evaluation”, and the consequence is stated without qualification: “any journal that fails to meet the 24 quality criteria will be removed from the Web of Science Core Collection”.10

DOAJ

The Directory of Open Access Journals has a narrower remit, and understanding it prevents a common misreading. “DOAJ only accepts open access journals”, and its central requirement is about access rather than prestige: “the full text of all content must be available for free and open access without delay”.12

Its basic criteria are concrete. A journal “must be actively publishing scholarly research”, “must have at least one ISSN”, and must operate peer review in which “at least two independent reviewers must review each article, with an exception for arts & humanities journals”.12

As with the others, listing can end: “we undertake periodic re-evaluation of journals accepted into DOAJ”, and “journals will be removed if they no longer adhere to DOAJ criteria or publishing best practice”.12

That removal power is used at scale rather than kept in reserve. In 2016 DOAJ announced it would “remove approximately 3300 journals for failure to submit a valid reapplication” against criteria it had raised two years earlier.13 The directory was careful about what the removals meant, noting that it had made no analysis “about quality” beyond whether journals had responded,13 but the episode shows how much a listing can change in a single administrative round.

A subject-area journal that is not open access will never appear in DOAJ, and its absence says nothing adverse about it. Absence from a database whose scope excludes you is not a finding.

How to verify a claim, database by database

Every one of the databases above maintains its own record of what it covers. That record, not the journal’s website, is the evidence. The procedure is the same in each case: take the journal’s ISSN from its masthead, then search the database’s own list for that ISSN.

What to check, and what the answer means
If the claim namesCheckWhat a negative result means
PubMedNothing yet — resolve the claim first. PubMed covers MEDLINE, PMC and other records together3Nothing, until you know which of the three is meant
MEDLINENLM’s own record of the journal. Inclusion requires that the journal “apply and be selected by NLM”, with the final decision made by the Director of the NLM31The journal was not selected, or never applied
PMCWhether articles are deposited. PMC is an archive and “a repository for NIH and other funder research publications”3Little on its own, because deposit can follow a funder mandate rather than a journal-level decision
ScopusThe Scopus title lists. “The file includes the list of discontinued sources and is updated monthly”9Either never accepted, or coverage was discontinued — the file distinguishes the two9
Web of ScienceWhich index within the Core Collection: ESCI, or one of SCIE, SSCI and AHCI10Not covered, or removed for failing the quality criteria10
DOAJThe DOAJ listing for that ISSN12Not open access, never applied, or removed on re-evaluation12
Google ScholarNothing. It is a search engine over the web, not a curated database with selection criteria14Not applicable, because the claim was never an indexing claim
A name you do not recogniseWhether the service publishes selection criteria and a list at allA service with no stated criteria and no searchable list is not evidence of anything
“Indexed in Google Scholar” is not an indexing claim

This one deserves singling out, because it appears in a great deal of published advice as a way of checking a journal’s status. Shamseer and colleagues record the finding directly: “the majority of predatory journals indicated being ‘indexed’ in Google Scholar, which is not an indexing database”.14 In their comparison, Google Scholar was named by about half of the predatory journals examined.14

The same study documents the invented-metric version of the problem. “Thirty-one (33%) predatory journals promoted a bogus impact metric – the Index Copernicus Value”, against three per cent of the open access journals and none of the subscription journals compared.14 A number presented as a measure of standing is worth the same scrutiny as the indexing claim beside it.

Search by ISSN, and check the right one

Titles can be imitated; an ISSN cannot be adopted by another publication. Where a journal publishes in print and online it carries two, a print ISSN and an electronic ISSN, so a search returning nothing under one should be repeated under the other before any conclusion is drawn.

Indexing and the impact factor are not the same thing

The two are routinely spoken of as one, including on pages that set out to explain the difference. They are related, but the direction of the relationship is the opposite of what is usually assumed: the metric is a product of the index, not a property of the journal that the index happens to notice.

The Journal Impact Factor is calculated by Clarivate from citation data in the Web of Science Core Collection. Since the 2023 release of the Journal Citation Reports, “all Web of Science Core Collection™ journals will receive a Journal Impact Factor (JIF)™”, covering “all journals that have passed the rigorous Web of Science quality criteria”.11 That release extended the metric to journals in the Emerging Sources Citation Index and to “journals from the Arts and Humanities Citation Index”, on the stated grounds that it “helps level the playing field for all quality journals”.11

Three consequences follow for an author reading a journal’s website.

  • A journal outside the Web of Science Core Collection cannot have a Journal Impact Factor. Not a low one — none at all, because the number is computed only for titles the Core Collection covers.11 A figure presented as an impact factor by a journal that is not in the Core Collection is something else wearing the name.
  • A journal can be indexed somewhere and still have no impact factor. Coverage in Scopus, MEDLINE or DOAJ confers no JIF, because none of those is the database the metric is computed from. The absence of an impact factor is therefore not evidence that a journal is unindexed.
  • The two claims need checking in two different places. An indexing claim is checked against the relevant database’s own list; an impact factor is checked in the Journal Citation Reports. A journal website is not the source for either.

National and regional lists, and what happened to UGC-CARE

Alongside the international databases sit national lists, which some institutions treat as the operative definition of an acceptable journal. For authors in India the relevant list was the UGC-CARE list, and it no longer exists.

The University Grants Commission discontinued it. A public notice issued on 11 February 2025 recorded the decision “to discontinue UGC-CARE listing of Journals”, and a follow-up notice of 16 July 2025, approved by the Commission at its 591st meeting on 24 June 2025, refers to “UGC-CARE Journals (now discontinued)”.15 The list as it stood on 10 February 2025 contained 1,474 journals, and the notice states that its publication “does not imply validation or endorsement by the Commission”.15

What replaced it is not another list. The Commission issued “Suggestive Parameters for choosing Peer-Reviewed Journals”, and says that “using the above parameters, faculty members and students may choose peer-reviewed journals”.15 The judgement moved from the regulator to the author.

The eight groups of suggestive parameters
GroupWhat it asks about
Journal preliminary criteriaISSN, periodicity, publisher details, access policy, archiving, a “transparent review policy” and a “website on a certified domain”15
Editorial board criteriaBoard details, subject expertise of its members, and an “efficient editorial/review process”15
Journal editorial policyAims and scope, subject areas, article processing charges, publishing timeline and acceptance rate15
Journal quality criteriaAcademic contribution of the content and its conformity to the journal’s stated scope15
Journal standardsBibliographic accuracy, design, visuals, citation record, print continuity and website quality15
Research ethicsPlagiarism prevention, conflict of interest disclosure, ethical author guidelines and an “AI generated content policy”15
Journal visibilityImpact factor or a similar factor, and indexation in reputed databases15
Journal impact criteriaSelf-citation score, total citation rate and CiteScore15
What the change means in practice

Two things, for anyone who used to check the list before submitting. The first is that a journal describing itself as “UGC-CARE listed” is making a claim about a list that was discontinued in February 2025, whatever was true before then. The second is that indexation now appears as one parameter among eight groups rather than as the whole test, sitting under journal visibility alongside the impact factor.15 An author who verifies indexing at source is doing part of what the parameters ask, not all of it.

Similar national and regional instruments exist elsewhere and work the same way: they are administrative lists built for a particular funding or assessment system, they are revised, and they are not themselves bibliographic databases. Where an institution requires one, it is the institution’s current rule that governs, not a claim on a journal’s website.

What indexing does and does not tell you

Indexing is evidence of something fairly specific. Reading more into it than that is the second most common error on this subject, after the PubMed confusion.

What an indexing decision is evidence of
The questionWhat indexing tells you
Does this journal meet a database’s stated standard?Yes, directly. That is exactly what the decision records. For MEDLINE the standard concerns “scientific and editorial quality”;1 for Scopus it is five categories covering policy, content, standing, regularity and availability9
Will my article be findable by people searching that database?Yes. This is the practical benefit, and it is the one least often disputed
Was the journal meeting that standard when it said so?Only if coverage is current. Titles are re-evaluated and coverage can be discontinued, which is why the discontinued list exists9
Is this particular article sound?No. Selection is made about the journal, comprehensively and at the title level1 — it is not a review of anything you submit
Does the journal have a high impact factor?Not from this. A Journal Impact Factor is computed for Web of Science Core Collection journals,11 so coverage elsewhere confers none
Is the peer review rigorous?Indirectly at best. Editorial policies and processes are among the elements assessed,1 but what a database evaluates is the stated process, not each review

The row that matters most is the fourth. A database selects a journal; it does not read your manuscript. Nothing about indexing substitutes for the judgement a reader applies to an individual paper, and an article is not made sound by the company it keeps.

Indexed and non-indexed, compared honestly

Comparisons of the two are usually presented as a list of respects in which indexed journals are better. Several of those differences are real; some are consequences of the comparison being drawn loosely, because “non-indexed” covers a new society journal that has not yet applied as well as a title no database would accept.

Where the difference is real, and where it is overstated
RespectIndexed in a major databaseNot indexedHow solid the difference is
DiscoverabilityReached by anyone searching that databaseReached by people who already know where to lookReal and direct. This is what a database is for
Institutional recognitionOften required by employers, funders and assessment systemsMay not count towards an assessmentReal, but local. It depends on the rule your institution applies, which can change — as the discontinuation of UGC-CARE showed15
Having passed a stated standardYes, the standard of that database1Not established either wayReal, but narrower than it sounds. Not indexed is not the same as rejected; many journals have never applied
Impact factorOnly if covered by the Web of Science Core Collection11NoneCommonly overstated. Indexing in MEDLINE, Scopus or DOAJ confers no impact factor at all
Quality of peer reviewEditorial processes were assessed at title level1Unknown from indexing status aloneWeakest of the comparisons. What was assessed is the described process, not the handling of any particular paper
CitationsEasier to find, and so easier to citeHarder to findPlausible and partly mechanical, but mediated by discoverability rather than conferred by the listing

Two practical conclusions follow. A journal that is not indexed anywhere deserves a question about why, since the answer may be that it is new, or small, or specialised, or that it has been declined. A journal that is indexed should still be assessed on scope, audience, cost and speed, because being covered by a database says nothing about whether it is the right home for your paper.

Common mistakes

What goes wrong, and when
MistakeStageWhat it costsWhat to do instead
Accepting “PubMed indexed” at face valueJournal selectionThe phrase can describe MEDLINE selection, PMC deposit or supplied citations — three different things3Ask which database is meant, then check that one
Taking the indexing claim from the journal’s websiteJournal selectionThe interested party is reporting its own statusCheck the database’s own list, searching by ISSN9
Not checking whether coverage is currentJournal selectionCoverage can be discontinued without the website changing9Look for the title in the discontinued list as well as the active one9
Treating an impact factor as proof of indexing, or the reverseJournal selectionThey come from different places and have to be checked separately11Check indexing in the database; check the metric in its own source11
Relying on a discontinued national listJournal selectionUGC-CARE listing was discontinued in February 202515Apply the parameters the regulator now suggests, and your institution’s current rule15
Reading indexing as a verdict on your articleInterpretationSelection is made about the journal, not about any submission1Judge the paper on its methods and reporting
Assuming “not indexed” means rejectedJournal selectionA credible new journal may simply not have applied yetAsk why, and weigh the answer alongside scope and audience
Take-home message

Indexing is a decision a named database has made about a journal, and it can be verified in that database’s own list in a couple of minutes. “PubMed indexed” is the claim to be most careful with, because PubMed searches MEDLINE, PMC and other records together, and only MEDLINE involves a journal applying and being selected. Coverage can also end, so the question is not only whether a journal was ever listed but whether it is listed now. What indexing gives you reliably is discoverability and evidence that a journal met a stated standard at title level. What it does not give you is an impact factor, a verdict on peer review of your paper, or any assurance about the article itself.

How to apply this to your work

Before you submit
  1. Write down which databases the journal names, and discard any claim that names none.
  2. Resolve “PubMed indexed” into MEDLINE, PMC or neither before treating it as meaningful.3
  3. Look the journal up by ISSN in each named database’s own list, not on the journal’s site.9
  4. Check the discontinued list too, since coverage that has ended is the case most often missed.9
  5. Check any impact factor separately, in its own source rather than alongside the indexing claim.11
  6. Check your institution’s current requirement, which may have changed, rather than a list you used before.15
  7. Record what you found and when, so the decision can be defended later if the journal’s status changes.

Common questions

What does it mean for a journal to be indexed?

It means a named bibliographic database has decided to cover that journal and is doing so. The decision belongs to the database, not the journal, and it is specific: a title is indexed in MEDLINE, or in Scopus, or in neither. A claim that names no database cannot be checked and does not mean anything on its own.

Is a journal that appears in PubMed indexed in PubMed?

Not in any useful sense. The citation information in PubMed “is derived from three main sources” — MEDLINE, PMC and Bookshelf.2 Only MEDLINE involves the journal applying and being assessed.5 Articles can reach PMC because a funder required deposit, since PMC “is also the repository for author manuscripts that are required under the NIH Public Access Policy”.3

How do I check whether a journal is really indexed?

Take the ISSN from the journal’s masthead and look it up in the database’s own record rather than on the journal’s website. Scopus publishes title lists, and “the file includes the list of discontinued sources and is updated monthly”.9 For Web of Science, establish which index within the Core Collection is meant.10 For MEDLINE, the question is whether the journal applied and was selected.5

Does “indexed in Google Scholar” count?

No. Google Scholar is a search engine rather than a curated database with selection criteria. The point has been documented: “the majority of predatory journals indicated being ‘indexed’ in Google Scholar, which is not an indexing database”.14

Can a journal lose its indexing?

Yes, and this is the case most often missed. Scopus may “discontinue the forward flow” after re-evaluation.9 Clarivate states that “any journal that fails to meet the 24 quality criteria will be removed from the Web of Science Core Collection”.10 DOAJ removes journals that “no longer adhere to DOAJ criteria or publishing best practice”,12 and in 2016 announced the removal of roughly 3,300 of them at once.13

Does being indexed mean the journal has a high impact factor?

No. A Journal Impact Factor is computed for Web of Science Core Collection journals, and since the 2023 release “all Web of Science Core Collection™ journals will receive a Journal Impact Factor (JIF)™”.11 Coverage in MEDLINE, Scopus or DOAJ confers none. DOAJ goes further and states that it “does not endorse using Impact Factors or other bibliometrics to assess the quality of journals or researchers”.12

Is the UGC-CARE list still in use?

No. The University Grants Commission resolved “to discontinue UGC-CARE listing of Journals” by public notice of 11 February 2025, and a later notice refers to “UGC-CARE Journals (now discontinued)”.15 In its place the Commission issued “Suggestive Parameters for choosing Peer-Reviewed Journals”, under which “faculty members and students may choose peer-reviewed journals” themselves.15 Check your own institution’s current requirement as well.

Is a non-indexed journal always a bad choice?

No, though it warrants a question. Not indexed is not the same as rejected: a new, small or highly specialised journal may never have applied, and a journal outside DOAJ’s scope is simply not open access. What is reasonable is to ask why, and to weigh the answer against the journal’s scope, audience, cost and speed rather than treating the listing as the whole decision.

Declared interest: Pubrica provides journal selection and submission support commercially. Nothing on this page should be read as suggesting that any service can place a manuscript in an indexed journal, or that indexing status can be arranged. Indexing is a decision made by a database about a journal, and no third party can confer it.

References and sources

  1. National Library of Medicine. Journal Selection for MEDLINE. Last reviewed 24 July 2026. read 20 October 2026.View the NLM page
  2. National Library of Medicine, Office of Engagement and Training. PubMed Basics (Module 0, prerequisite for MeSH). read 20 October 2026.View the NLM training module
  3. National Library of Medicine. List of All Journals Cited in PubMed. Last reviewed 10 June 2021. read 20 October 2026.View the NLM page
  4. National Library of Medicine. About the Literature Selection Technical Review Committee (LSTRC). Last reviewed 24 July 2026. read 20 October 2026. This page is the source for the committee’s termination, which dates a great deal of older guidance on MEDLINE selection.View the NLM page
  5. National Library of Medicine. MEDLINE Application and Evaluation Process. Last reviewed 12 August 2026. read 20 October 2026.View the NLM page
  6. National Library of Medicine. About MEDLINE. Last reviewed 8 September 2025. read 20 October 2026.View the NLM page
  7. Topper L, Marill J, Kelly C, Funk K. Rigorous policies ensure integrity of NLM literature databases. CMAJ. 2019;191(10):E289. doi:10.1503/cmaj.71602 read 20 October 2026. The authors are National Library of Medicine staff, replying to the analysis cited next.View the full text
  8. Manca A, Moher D, Cugusi L, Dvir Z, Deriu F. How predatory journals leak into PubMed. CMAJ. 2018;190(35):E1042–E1045. doi:10.1503/cmaj.180154 read 20 October 2026.View the full text
  9. Elsevier. Scopus content policy and selection. read 20 October 2026.View the Scopus content policy
  10. Clarivate. Web of Science Core Collection: journal evaluation process and selection criteria. read 20 October 2026.View the selection criteria
  11. Clarivate. All Web of Science Core Collection journals, including arts and humanities, will have Journal Impact Factors. Press release, 26 July 2022. read 20 October 2026 from a copy hosted by the Society for Scholarly Publishing.View the announcement
  12. Directory of Open Access Journals. Guide to applying. read 20 October 2026.View the DOAJ guide
  13. Directory of Open Access Journals. DOAJ to remove approximately 3300 journals. DOAJ blog, 9 May 2016. read 20 October 2026.View the announcement
  14. Shamseer L, Moher D, Maduekwe O, Turner L, Barbour V, Burch R, Clark J, Galipeau J, Roberts J, Shea BJ. Potential predatory and legitimate biomedical journals: can you tell the difference? A cross-sectional comparison. BMC Medicine. 2017;15:28. doi:10.1186/s12916-017-0785-9 read 20 October 2026.View the full text
  15. University Grants Commission, Ministry of Education, Government of India. Public Notice: Suggestive Parameters for Peer-Reviewed Journals. F. No. 1-1/2018(CARE/JOURNAL), 16 July 2025, with Annexure-I. read 20 October 2026 from a university-hosted copy of the notice. It continues the Public Notice of 11 February 2025 and was approved at the Commission’s 591st meeting on 24 June 2025.View the public notice

How to cite this article

Pick your referencing style and copy it. Your university or target journal may vary the punctuation — check its guide if it has one.

Pubrica Academy. (2026, October 20). Indexed vs. non-indexed journals: why it matters for your research. Pubrica. https://pubrica.com/academy/journal-submission/indexed-vs-non-indexed-journals/
Pubrica Academy. “Indexed vs. Non-Indexed Journals: Why It Matters for Your Research.” Pubrica, 20 Oct. 2026, pubrica.com/academy/journal-submission/indexed-vs-non-indexed-journals/.
Pubrica Academy (2026) Indexed vs. non-indexed journals: why it matters for your research. Available at: https://pubrica.com/academy/journal-submission/indexed-vs-non-indexed-journals/ (Accessed: 20 October 2026).
Pubrica Academy. “Indexed vs. Non-Indexed Journals: Why It Matters for Your Research.” Pubrica. October 20, 2026. https://pubrica.com/academy/journal-submission/indexed-vs-non-indexed-journals/.
Pubrica Academy, ‘Indexed vs. Non-Indexed Journals: Why It Matters for Your Research’ (Pubrica, 20 October 2026) <https://pubrica.com/academy/journal-submission/indexed-vs-non-indexed-journals/> accessed 20 October 2026.
Pubrica Academy. Indexed vs. non-indexed journals: why it matters for your research [Internet]. Pubrica; 2026 Oct 20 [cited 2026 Oct 20]. Available from: https://pubrica.com/academy/journal-submission/indexed-vs-non-indexed-journals/
[1] Pubrica Academy, “Indexed vs. non-indexed journals: why it matters for your research,” Pubrica, Oct. 20, 2026. [Online]. Available: https://pubrica.com/academy/journal-submission/indexed-vs-non-indexed-journals/
@misc{pubrica_indexedjournals_2026, author = {{Pubrica Academy}}, title = {Indexed vs. Non-Indexed Journals: Why It Matters for Your Research}, year = {2026}, month = {oct}, day = {20}, howpublished = {\url{https://pubrica.com/academy/journal-submission/indexed-vs-non-indexed-journals/}}, note = {Accessed: 2026-10-20} }

This article is written to be learned from. Cite it if you are referring to what it says; if you are using the evidence behind it, cite the sources listed above instead.

Indexing verification checklist

Work through these before you submit, and record the date you checked.

[ ] Every database the journal names is written down
[ ] Any claim naming no database is set aside as uncheckable
[ ] "PubMed indexed" resolved into MEDLINE, PMC or neither
[ ] Print ISSN and electronic ISSN both taken from the masthead
[ ] MEDLINE status checked at NLM, not on the journal site
[ ] Scopus checked in the Scopus source title list
[ ] Scopus discontinued-sources list checked as well as the active list
[ ] Web of Science claim resolved to ESCI, SCIE, SSCI or AHCI
[ ] DOAJ listing checked for the journal's ISSN
[ ] "Indexed in Google Scholar" discounted as not an indexing claim
[ ] Any quoted impact factor checked in its own source
[ ] Any unfamiliar index checked for published criteria and a searchable list
[ ] Institution's current requirement checked, not a list used previously
[ ] Date of each check recorded alongside the result
PA
Pubrica Academy

Written and maintained by the subject matter experts of Pubrica who do this work. Articles are revised when the standard underneath them moves, and each one carries the date it was last checked against its sources.

How Pubrica helps

We help you shortlist journals that fit your scope and audience, verify their indexing against the databases themselves, and prepare a submission that meets the target journal’s requirements.

Explore

Related reading in the Academy.

Picked from the same sub-topic and category as this piece, newest first.

Find something else

Search the rest of the Academy.

Open with no account. Type what you are working on, or open the full library to filter by category, sub-topic or resource type.

Get a free quote

Regulations

Check your project against this rule

  1. 1Your work
  2. 2Your details
  3. 3Send
What do you need?

Material you send is held under signed confidentiality, with access limited to the assigned team and encrypted transfer. It is not used to train anything and is not passed to third-party tools. Ask for the agreement before you send anything you would rather cover first.