What the ALD report delivers, section by section
The PDF is a five-page journal selection report for an epidemiological manuscript on the incidence of alcoholic liver disease (ALD) in India and worldwide. Its header records the job code, manuscript title, date and a short summary of the study's focus on trends, risk factors and the public health impact of alcohol-related liver disorders. It then confirms that every recommended journal has regularly published work related to the authors' area of research.
For each recommended journal, the report gives the publisher, a written explanation of why it fits and examples of recent articles from that journal with full citations and DOIs. A comparator table, rationale and scope statements, and an appendix of frequently asked questions complete the document.
Three hepatology journals at different levels of selectivity
| Journal | Publisher | Role in the shortlist |
|---|---|---|
| Journal of Hepatology | Elsevier | The high-impact option, covering basic, translational and clinical hepatology research; the most selective of the three. |
| Liver International | Wiley | A well-established specialist journal publishing clinical, translational and basic science studies across liver disease, including epidemiology. |
| International Journal of Hepatology | Wiley | A peer-reviewed open-access journal with broad scope, offering wide visibility for clinical and epidemiological work. |
This tiered structure lets authors aim high first while keeping credible, well-indexed alternatives ready. The comparator table helps them judge the trade-offs, including rejection rates, review times, open-access charges and word and figure limits, before deciding the order of submission.
Terminology to check before submission
Nomenclature in hepatology has changed recently. In 2023 a multi-society consensus introduced the term steatotic liver disease, with subcategories including metabolic dysfunction-associated steatotic liver disease (MASLD) and MetALD for people with both metabolic risk factors and increased alcohol intake. Many journals and societies also now prefer 'alcohol-associated' to 'alcoholic' liver disease. Authors should check which terms their target journal uses and make sure their case definitions, especially alcohol intake thresholds, are stated precisely, because incidence estimates depend heavily on how ALD is defined.
Reporting expectations for an incidence study
Incidence studies attract close methodological scrutiny. Primary observational studies should follow the STROBE statement. Manuscripts that combine estimates from several sources to describe global or regional patterns should consider the GATHER guidelines (Guidelines for Accurate and Transparent Health Estimates Reporting), and those based on a systematic search of the literature should follow PRISMA 2020. Clear reporting of the denominator population, follow-up time and the distinction between incidence and prevalence is essential; Pubrica's article on understanding incidence and prevalence explains why that distinction matters.
Regional data from India are uneven, a point the report's appendix also notes, so authors should be explicit about data sources and their limitations. Reviewers are likely to ask how representative the included studies or registries are.
What the FAQ appendix adds
The appendix answers four questions that editors, co-authors or students reading the report are likely to have: what ALD covers, from fatty liver and alcoholic hepatitis to cirrhosis and liver cancer; what is known about its global incidence; whether prevalence varies within India; and which prevention measures are recommended. Including this background keeps the report self-contained for readers less familiar with hepatology. Any figures quoted, such as incidence or mortality rates, should be traced to their original source and checked against the latest literature before being reused in the manuscript itself.
From shortlist to submitted manuscript
- Confirm each journal's current impact factor, charges and article types on its website, since these change.
- Read two or three of the recent articles cited in the report to judge the depth and style each journal expects.
- Reformat the manuscript to the first-choice journal's instructions, including abstract structure, word limit and reference style.
- Write a cover letter explaining why the study suits that journal's readership.
Pubrica's journal selection service prepares reports like this for any field, and the cover letter guide covers the final step. To request a report, use the journal selection order form.