Response to reviewer comments
Response to reviewer comments
Dear Editor and reviewers:
We are very appreciative of the detailed and thoughtful comments made about our submitted article. We have taken quite a while to complete the final revision. We have edited the paper now, ensuring that we address each one of the reviewer comments with care. Moreover, we have increased the number of images for improved illustration of the concepts and added several new references relating to some of the most current work in the field of spectral geometry processing from 2008.The following are detailed comments relating to all the reviewer’s comments. The reviewer comments are shown in blue, and our comments. Please let us know if you have any additional questions or concerns regarding the manuscript. We will happily respond to any comments that we did not address now in a timely manner.
Replying to four referees on a survey of spectral mesh processing
This sample is an authors' response to the referee reports on a survey paper in computer graphics: a review of spectral methods for analysing and processing polygon meshes, built around discrete Laplace operators and their eigenvectors. The letter is addressed to the editor and reviewers, apologises for the time the final revision took, and summarises the main changes at the outset: more images to illustrate the concepts, and new references to recent work on spectral geometry processing. It explains a colour code (reviewer comments in blue, author replies in red) and then works through each report in turn. Although the field is not biomedical, the paper is a narrative review, so the exchange shows how review articles in any discipline are judged: for coverage, structure and accuracy rather than for new data.
How the reports are laid out and answered
Each referee report is reproduced under a heading such as Review #1, together with the reviewer's recommendation, which ranges from Accept to Accept after minor revision. Comments are kept in the reviewer's own order, usually anchored to a page or section number, and every reply begins with a double chevron (>>) so it stands apart from the reviewer's text even when colour is lost in printing. Replies are short and specific. Many simply state where the change now lives: a definition of the graph Laplacian moved to the start of Section 2, a mention of isospectral shapes with a citation in Section 10.1, a new subsection on the generalised eigenvalue problem in Section 9.1, or the "No Free Lunch" result for Laplacians referenced in Section 6.2.4.
Responding even when the recommendation is already 'accept'
Review #1 recommends acceptance without revision but still lists suggestions "in chronological order": writing the abstract and introduction in the present tense, defining the Laplacian before discussing its spectrum, and correcting what appeared to be a numbering error. The authors treat these as seriously as a request for major revision. They make the tense change, move the formalism forward and add two figures illustrating the spectral approach and spectral embedding early in the paper. On the numbering point, they reply that they are unclear about the comment because Section 3 does exist, which is a polite way of correcting a reviewer's misreading without dismissing them.
Correcting a referee with a short derivation
One of the most useful passages for researchers in quantitative fields is a technical disagreement. A reviewer suggests that projecting mesh geometry onto a partial eigenbasis loses rotation invariance, because projection and rotation may not commute. The authors show that the eigenprojection does commute with rotations, setting out the argument in matrix notation (vertex positions, a rotation matrix and the first k eigenvectors) in a few lines, and then note that the result has been added to Section 8.3. The reply is persuasive because it is brief, verifiable and leads to an improvement in the manuscript rather than simply winning the point.
Elsewhere the authors explain why an operator mentioned by a reviewer cannot serve as a smoothing operator in their sense, defining smoothing as low-pass filtering with reference to Taubin's work.
Declining suggestions without dismissing the reviewer
Not every request is accepted. A suggestion to mention that the cotangent Laplacian approximates the mean curvature normal is declined because it would not fit the exposition and has not been tied to spectral processing. A request from Review #4 for many more application images is answered by explaining a deliberate editorial decision: rather than illustrate some applications and not others, the survey consistently avoids result images and instead adds figures for the principal ideas, such as spectral embeddings, eigenvector plots and nodal lines. A comment that Table 1 should list each operator's eigenstructure receives a measured "Perhaps" with a pointer to the surrounding discussion. In each case the reason is stated, which is what editors look for.
What authors of review articles can take from this letter
Survey and review papers tend to attract requests to add references, restructure sections and broaden scope. This sample shows how to absorb those requests efficiently: confirm the change, name the section, cite the added source, and reserve longer replies for genuine disagreements. Authors preparing a similar letter may find Pubrica's responding to reviewers support useful for checking that every comment has a traceable answer, while scientific editing can confirm that new sections and derivations read consistently with the rest of the paper. If a journal asks for a further round, resubmission support helps keep successive versions aligned.
Questions about this sample
Why do the replies in this sample begin with '>>'?
The letter colour-codes reviewer comments in blue and author replies in red, but the double chevron provides a second marker that survives black-and-white printing or copying into plain text. It lets editors scan quickly for the authors' answers beneath each comment.
How should I respond when a reviewer recommends acceptance but adds suggestions?
Treat the suggestions as you would any revision request. In this sample, Review #1 recommended acceptance yet received full replies: the authors changed the tense of the abstract, moved the Laplacian definition earlier and added figures. Addressing optional comments demonstrates care and can prevent the same points resurfacing from the editor.
Is it acceptable to tell a reviewer they are mistaken?
Yes, provided the reply is courteous and evidenced. Here the authors demonstrate with a short matrix argument that eigenprojection commutes with rotation, contrary to the reviewer's concern, and then add the result to the manuscript. Showing the reasoning, and using it to improve the paper, makes disagreement constructive rather than confrontational.
Give yourself the academic edge today
Each order includes
- On-time delivery or your money back
- A fully qualified writer in your subject
- In-depth proofreading by our Quality Control Team
- 100% confidentiality, the work is never re-sold or published
- Standard 7-day amendment period
- A paper written to the standard ordered
- A detailed plagiarism report
- A comprehensive quality report
Enquire Now
