Free scoping read. A written assessment of your manuscript in two business days, at no cost.

Start one
Contents

Academy · Research Publication · Editorial Plagiarism Guidance

Editorial Guidance on Plagiarism: A Comparison of COPE, CSE and WAME in Upholding Research Integrity

COPE, the Council of Science Editors (CSE) and the World Association of Medical Editors (WAME) each publish guidance on plagiarism for editors, and the differences between them, particularly regarding self-plagiarism and repetition in methods sections, affect how an editor should handle a specific flagged case. This article compares the three bodies of guidance.

Pubrica AcademyWritten by a publication ethics editor Reviewed bya plagiarism policy reviewer Published10 October 2026 Last checked10 October 2026 Reading time8 minutes Sources10 peer-reviewed

Editorial guidance on plagiarism sets out how a journal's editors should define, detect, and respond to suspected plagiarism in submissions and published papers. Three bodies publish the guidance most journals draw on: the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), the Council of Science Editors (CSE), and the World Association of Medical Editors (WAME), and while their core definitions overlap substantially, each addresses specific edge cases, particularly self-plagiarism and the reuse of standard methodological language, with enough nuance that an editor relying on only one source may miss guidance directly relevant to a specific case.

Learning objectives

  • How COPE, CSE and WAME each define and address plagiarism, and where their guidance diverges
  • Why self-plagiarism and repetition in methods sections require more nuanced handling than copied results or discussion text
  • The characteristics of a properly handled plagiarism investigation at the editorial level

Common misconceptions

  • “Any repeated wording between an author’s previous paper and a new submission constitutes plagiarism.” WAME’s publication ethics guidance explicitly treats self-plagiarism differently according to what is repeated, stating that reuse of methodological details already established in an author’s own prior work is not counted as a violation where there is no intent to duplicate the substantive findings; this distinction separates necessary procedural repetition from genuine self-plagiarism of results or conclusions.

Requirements of COPE guidance for editors

The Committee on Publication Ethics publishes a discussion document and accompanying flowcharts for editors handling suspected plagiarism, recommending that journals define plagiarism explicitly in their own author guidelines rather than relying on an assumed common understanding, and that all co-authors, not only the author responsible for the copied text, be held jointly accountable once plagiarism is confirmed in a submission or published paper1. The COPE flowcharts set out a stepwise process: contacting the relevant co-authors and, where appropriate, their institution once plagiarism is suspected; giving the accused author an opportunity to respond; and using detection software as one input into, rather than the sole basis for, a final editorial decision2. This structured, documented process exists so that an accusation of plagiarism, which carries serious professional consequences, is handled consistently rather than through an individual editor’s unstructured judgement on a case-by-case basis.

Additional distinctions in CSE and WAME guidance

The white paper on publication ethics of the Council of Science Editors treats plagiarism and the related concept of “piracy” (the unauthorised use of another’s ideas, methods, data or graphics, even without verbatim copying) as a violation of publication ethics distinct from, but closely related to, verbatim textual plagiarism, a distinction that is important in cases in which the copied content is a data figure or an unattributed methodological approach rather than prose3. The CSE guidance also discusses the possibility of shared cross-journal blacklists of authors with confirmed findings of plagiarism, while raising the same concerns about data protection and fairness that appear in the parallel literature on paper mills, since a shared record carries greater reputational consequences than a single journal’s internal finding3. WAME’s recommendations on publication ethics policies for medical journals oppose both published and unpublished plagiarism, so that copying from a rejected or unpublished manuscript to which an editor or reviewer had access is treated as seriously as copying from a published source, a distinction of direct relevance to reviewers and editors, whose role involves access to unpublished work4.

Self-plagiarism as the most difficult case to handle consistently

Self-plagiarism, the reuse by authors of their own previously published text, is the area in which the guidance of the three bodies departs most clearly from a simple, absolute rule, because some repetition of an author’s own prior work is functionally necessary and not evidence of misconduct. The empirical study of academic text recycling by Serge Horbach and Willem Halffman found that a considerable proportion of apparent self-plagiarism cases involve methods sections describing procedures that an author has used consistently across a related series of studies, repetition that reflects methodological continuity rather than an attempt to inflate publication output through duplicate claims5. WAME’s guidance reflects this directly, explicitly declining to treat repetition in methods sections without intent to duplicate substantive findings as a violation, while Miguel Roig’s widely used ORI-published guide to avoiding self-plagiarism recommends that authors nonetheless disclose and cite their own closely related prior work transparently, even when the repeated text would not itself be considered a violation, since transparency prevents reasonable readers from being confused about what is new in the current paper6.

The appropriate role of plagiarism-detection software

Text-similarity detection software, which produces a percentage-match score against a database of previously published text, is now a standard part of the editorial workflow of most journals, but all three guidance bodies present it as a screening aid rather than a decision-making tool in its own right. The COPE flowcharts describe software-generated similarity scores as one input into an editor’s judgement, not a threshold that automatically triggers rejection or a finding of misconduct, because a high similarity score can reflect legitimate quotation, standard methodological wording, or matches with the author’s own properly cited prior work, rather than plagiarism2. Masic’s review of plagiarism in scientific publishing similarly cautions that similarity-detection software cannot assess intent or context, and that a mechanically high score and a plagiarism violation are related but distinct findings that a human editor must reconcile7. This is important in practice because an editor who treats a software score as a final verdict, rather than as a prompt for the classification of case type that the guidance of COPE, CSE and WAME together supports, risks two kinds of error in opposite directions: wrongly accusing an author whose high score reflects proper quotation or legitimate self-citation, or wrongly clearing a case in which a low score missed paraphrased, non-verbatim copying of the kind that the CSE concept of “piracy” is designed to capture. A widely cited 2010 Nature news report on the early use of CrossCheck similarity software by a Chinese journal found that approximately 31% of submissions showed some degree of textual overlap flagged by the system, a figure that, as the journal’s editors stated explicitly, required individual, case-by-case review rather than blanket rejection, since the flagged set ranged from minor, non-infringing overlap to clear and substantial copying9. The broader recommendations of the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) on scientific misconduct reinforce the same model of software combined with judgement at the level of overall editorial responsibility, expecting editors to investigate seriously once a concern is raised, by whatever means, rather than treating any single detection method as sufficient10.

Characteristics of a properly handled plagiarism case

Taken together, the guidance of the three bodies indicates that a properly handled plagiarism case follows a defined, documented sequence rather than an ad hoc editorial judgement: the suspected passage is checked using detection software as one input; the type of content involved (verbatim text, data, graphics or a methodological approach) is identified, since the CSE concept of piracy extends the analysis beyond prose; it is determined whether the repetition is self-plagiarism or plagiarism of another author’s work; and, in the case of self-plagiarism, it is assessed whether substantive findings or necessary methodological continuity are involved, before any accusation is escalated134. Ivan Masic’s review of plagiarism in scientific publishing and the empirical study by Lidija Bilic-Zulle and colleagues of plagiarism prevalence among medical students both indicate that training authors, particularly early in their careers, in what constitutes plagiarism under this more nuanced framework considerably reduces unintentional cases, since a considerable proportion of the flagged cases in their research arose from unfamiliarity with the standard rather than from deliberate deception78. Both studies recommend introducing this training early, during undergraduate or early graduate coursework, rather than when a researcher is already preparing a first submission, since several of the documented cases involved authors who were unaware that a given practice, such as closely paraphrasing a source without citation or reusing their own prior methods text without disclosure, constituted a violation. An editor who treats every flagged case as presumptively deliberate, rather than first establishing whether the author understood the applicable standard, risks treating a training gap as an integrity violation; this is a different problem requiring a different, more educational response than the formal investigative sequence described in the COPE flowcharts for cases of knowing misconduct. This distinction is important for the relationship between the research community and its editorial institutions: a process perceived as proportionate, evidence-based and capable of distinguishing a training gap from deliberate deception sustains authors’ trust in editorial oversight, whereas a process that treats every flagged similarity score as presumptive guilt risks a deterrent effect on honest, if imperfect, scholarly communication comparable to that which disproportionate retraction practices can create elsewhere in publishing.

Key points

Key points

Together, COPE, CSE and WAME provide editors with a more complete framework for plagiarism than any single source: COPE sets out the stepwise investigation process, CSE extends the definition to data and graphics through its concept of ‘piracy’, and WAME draws the specific distinctions on self-plagiarism and plagiarism of unpublished material that resolve the most difficult cases. An editor handling a case should therefore consult all three rather than the guidance of one body in isolation.

Practical application

Practical application

  1. Journals should define plagiarism explicitly in their own author guidelines. In accordance with COPE’s recommendation, the definition should be stated directly rather than an assumed shared understanding among authors and reviewers relied upon.
  2. The type of repeated content should be classified before a response is decided. CSE’s distinction between verbatim textual plagiarism and ‘piracy’ of data, methods or graphics should be used to determine the appropriate investigative questions for a specific case.
  3. WAME’s distinction regarding self-plagiarism should be applied carefully rather than all repetition being treated alike. Editors should assess whether reused text involves substantive findings or necessary methodological continuity before a concern about self-plagiarism is escalated to a formal allegation.

Frequently asked questions

Under the framework of the Council of Science Editors, this constitutes ‘piracy’, the unauthorised use of another’s ideas, methods, data or graphics, which it treats as a violation of publication ethics distinct from but closely related to verbatim textual plagiarism; such use is therefore addressed under the same broader ethics framework even when no prose has been copied.

Not necessarily. WAME’s guidance explicitly declines to treat repetition in methods sections as a violation when there is no intent to duplicate substantive findings, since some procedural repetition reflects methodological continuity across a related series of studies rather than misconduct.

Yes. WAME’s recommendations explicitly oppose both published and unpublished plagiarism, so copying from a manuscript seen only during peer review or editorial handling is treated as seriously as copying from a published source.

The COPE flowcharts recommend using the software flag as one input into a broader investigation rather than as an automatic final verdict, which includes contacting the relevant authors, giving them an opportunity to respond, and escalating to institutional contact or publication of a notice only once the investigation supports it.

Empirical studies of plagiarism prevalence among medical students and reviews of plagiarism in scientific publishing both attribute a considerable proportion of flagged cases to unfamiliarity with the standards of publication ethics rather than to deliberate deception, which is why training in the specific, nuanced framework, rather than a general prohibition on copying, is recommended as a preventive measure.

References

  1. Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). Plagiarism: Discussion Document. read 10 October 2026. View COPE's plagiarism guidance
  2. Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). What to do if you suspect plagiarism (flowcharts). read 10 October 2026. View COPE's flowcharts
  3. Council of Science Editors. CSE's White Paper on Publication Ethics, Section 3: Plagiarism. read 10 October 2026. View the CSE White Paper
  4. World Association of Medical Editors (WAME). Recommendations on Publication Ethics Policies for Medical Journals. read 10 October 2026. View WAME's recommendations
  5. Horbach SPJM, Halffman W. The extent and causes of academic text recycling or 'self-plagiarism'. Research Policy. 2019;48(2):492-502. read 10 October 2026. View on Research Policy
  6. Roig M. Avoiding Plagiarism, Self-Plagiarism, and Other Questionable Writing Practices: A Guide to Ethical Writing. Office of Research Integrity, 2015. read 10 October 2026. View the ORI guide
  7. Masic I. Plagiarism in Scientific Publishing. Acta Informatica Medica. 2012;20(4):208-213. read 10 October 2026. View on Acta Informatica Medica
  8. Bilic-Zulle L, Frkovic V, Turk T, Azman J, Petrovecki M. Prevalence of plagiarism among medical students. Croatian Medical Journal. 2005;46(1):126-131. read 10 October 2026. View on the Croatian Medical Journal
  9. Zhang Y. Chinese journal finds 31% of submissions plagiarized. Nature News. 2010. read 10 October 2026. View on Nature News
  10. International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing, and Publication of Scholarly Work in Medical Journals. read 10 October 2026. View the ICMJE Recommendations

Every source above is a peer-reviewed article, a publisher’s record of one, or a standard issued by the body that owns it. Each carries the date it was last read. Where a standard moves, this article is revised rather than left up with a note.

How to cite this article

Pick your referencing style and copy it. Your university or target journal may vary the punctuation — check its guide if it has one.

Pubrica Academy. (2026, October 10). Editorial Guidance on Plagiarism: A Comparison of COPE, CSE and WAME in Upholding Research Integrity. Pubrica. https://pubrica.com/academy/study-guide/research-writing/editorial-guidance-plagiarism-integrity/

This article is written to be learned from. Cite it if you are referring to what it says; if you are using the evidence behind it, cite the sources listed above instead.

Editorial Plagiarism Investigation Checklist

This stepwise sequence should be followed when a submission or published paper is flagged for suspected plagiarism.

[ ] Checked suspected passage against detection software as one input, not a final verdict
[ ] Classified the content type: verbatim text, data, graphics/figures, or methodological approach (CSE 'piracy')
[ ] Determined whether this is self-plagiarism or plagiarism of another author's work
[ ] If self-plagiarism, assessed whether it involves substantive findings or necessary methodological continuity
[ ] If applicable, confirmed whether the source material was published or only seen during peer review (WAME)
[ ] Contacted relevant co-authors and, where appropriate, their institution, giving an opportunity to respond
[ ] Documented the full investigation and decision per COPE's flowchart process

Pubrica AcademyWritten and maintained by Pubrica’s subject matter experts. Articles are revised when the underlying standards change, and each article states the date on which it was last reviewed.

How Pubrica can help

Pubrica’s editorial consulting service assists journals in developing plagiarism-handling procedures that integrate COPE, CSE and WAME guidance, and trains authors in the nuanced standards on self-plagiarism and unpublished material.

Find something else

Search the Pubrica Academy

Access is free and requires no account. Enter a topic, or open the full library to filter by category, sub-topic or resource type.

Journal plagiarism procedures integrating COPE, CSE and WAME guidance

A scoping assessment is free and takes two business days. It provides a written assessment of what the work requires and which specialist would undertake it.

Get a free quote

Regulations

Check your project against this rule

  1. 1Your work
  2. 2Your details
  3. 3Send
What do you need?

Material you send is held under signed confidentiality, with access limited to the assigned team and encrypted transfer. It is not used to train anything and is not passed to third-party tools. Ask for the agreement before you send anything you would rather cover first.