Contents
Academy · Research Publication · Responding to Peer Review
Responding to the Manuscript Peer Review Process: Structure, Disagreement and Disclosure in the Response Letter
Noble’s widely cited “Ten Simple Rules” guidance treats a response letter as a distinct piece of writing: every point should be answered, the full review quoted, and each response should begin with a direct answer. A 2024 F1000Research guide adds specific advice on pausing before responding and on disclosing any AI assistance used.
Responding to peer review is a distinct writing task with its own rules, separate from revising the manuscript itself, and two directly relevant, peer-reviewed guides, Noble's 2017 "Ten Simple Rules for Writing a Response to Reviewers" in PLOS Computational Biology and Hidouri and colleagues' 2024 "Key Guidelines for Responding to Reviewers" in F1000Research, set out specific, actionable guidance for doing it well12. Both guides treat the response letter as a document a reader, the editor and the original reviewers, will judge on its own terms, which means its structure and tone matter as much as whether the underlying scientific concerns were actually addressed.
Learning objectives
- Noble’s ten rules for structuring and writing a response-to-reviewers letter
- The additions made by the more recent guidance of Hidouri and colleagues, including on disagreement and the disclosure of AI tools
- How findings from peer review research on reviewer behaviour and priorities should inform a response
Common misconceptions
- “A response letter just needs to answer the reviewers' questions; its structure doesn't matter much.” Noble’s guidance specifies that the letter should open with an overview of the major changes, quote the reviews in full, answer every point, including difficult or disputed ones, and use consistent typography to distinguish reviewer comments from the author’s response and from the revised text of the manuscript; omitting any of these structural elements makes the letter more difficult for an editor to evaluate quickly and fairly.
Noble’s ten rules for writing the response letter
Noble's widely cited guidance opens with a structural rule: the letter should begin with a short overview of the major new data, analyses or changes made in response to review, followed by the complete, unedited reviewer comments interleaved with the author's point-by-point responses, so that an editor rereading the letter can follow the full exchange without consulting a separate copy of the original reviews1. A second rule addresses tone directly: authors should be polite and respectful to every reviewer and should treat a reviewer's misunderstanding of the manuscript as an indication that the relevant section requires clarification for all readers, rather than as a reviewer's error to be corrected defensively1.
Several of Noble's remaining rules concern completeness and navigability. Every point raised by a reviewer should be answered, including points with which the author disagrees, and a single bullet point raising several distinct issues should be divided so that each issue is addressed individually rather than subsumed into one general response1. The response should be self-contained, quoting any changed manuscript text directly so that a reviewer need not cross-reference the revised paper, and should use clear typographic distinctions (different fonts, colours or indentation) to separate the original comment, the author's response and any quoted manuscript text from one another1. A further rule recommends that each individual response begin with a direct answer (a yes, a no or the specific change made) before the supporting explanation, since this allows a reviewer or editor scanning the letter to confirm quickly that a point was addressed1.
Recent guidance on disagreement and disclosure
Hidouri and colleagues' 2024 guidance, published after several further years of change in how manuscripts are reviewed and revised, reinforces much of Noble's structural advice while adding specific guidance of its own. On timing, the guidance recommends allowing critical feedback to rest for a few days before drafting a response and framing reviewers explicitly as consultants offering an opportunity to improve the work rather than as adversaries; this interval allows an author to assess each comment calmly rather than respond defensively2. On disagreement specifically, the guidance advises authors to “pick their battles,” declining a request only when the refusal is well justified, supporting any refusal with clear evidence, and involving the editor directly when a disagreement is substantive enough to require a third party's judgement2.
The 2024 guidance also addresses two practical matters that Noble's 2017 article could not have anticipated in the same form. First, it recommends that ambiguous or conflicting reviewer feedback be handled by seeking clarification, and that any conflict, or any ethical concern raised by a reviewer, be referred directly to the editor, with guidance from COPE (the Committee on Publication Ethics) and the ICMJE (International Committee of Medical Journal Editors) consulted where the matter concerns publication ethics specifically24. Second, it recommends that authors proofread the final response letter carefully and disclose any use of AI writing tools in its preparation, treating such tools as a supplement to, rather than a substitute for, the author's own judgement; this disclosure expectation reflects the direction in which the author guidelines of several journals have moved over the same period2.
Implications of research on reviewer behaviour
Separate research on the peer review process itself provides context for the effectiveness of these response strategies. Rowley and colleagues' large survey of Taylor & Francis authors, reviewers and editors found that the reliability of a journal's reviewing process and the usefulness of reviewers' feedback both ranked among the most highly weighted factors that researchers consider, each scoring within three-tenths of a point of the highest-rated factor on a ten-point scale. This suggests that reviewers themselves value feedback being taken seriously and engaged with substantively, which is what a well-structured, point-by-point response letter demonstrates5. Jefferson and colleagues' Cochrane-affiliated systematic review of the effects of editorial peer review similarly emphasises that the review process is intended as a substantive quality check rather than a formality, which supports the framing by Hidouri and colleagues of reviewers as consultants whose critiques merit direct engagement rather than minimisation6.
Perlis and colleagues' study of peer review at a general medical journal before and during the COVID-19 pandemic found that the number of reviews rated high-quality per manuscript rose over the study period even as submission volume increased sharply. This finding indicates that reviewer engagement, and not only reviewer availability, can be measured and varies in ways that authors experience directly through the quality of the feedback they receive7. Smith's widely discussed account of the limitations of peer review as a system provides a useful counterweight to this research: peer review, even when functioning well, is not infallible. This is one reason why the guidance of both Noble and Hidouri and colleagues allows for respectful, evidence-based disagreement with a reviewer's specific request, rather than treating every comment as one that must be accepted for a manuscript to be published8.
Responding to the editor’s decision as well as the reviewers’ comments
A response to peer review is addressed to the editor as much as to the individual reviewers, and both Noble's and Hidouri and colleagues' guidance treat the cover letter to the editor as a distinct component from the point-by-point reviewer responses, used to summarise the major changes made, flag any point of disagreement with a specific reviewer, confirm that all co-authors have approved the revised manuscript, and note explicitly where two reviewers' requests conflicted and how that conflict was resolved12. This editor-facing component is important because the editor, rather than the original reviewers, usually makes the final decision to accept, request further revision or reject, and a cover letter that clearly identifies any unresolved tension between reviewers' requests gives the editor the specific information needed to adjudicate it, rather than leaving the matter to be inferred from every individual response.
Where a manuscript is rejected rather than returned for revision, the same discipline applies in a different form: Hidouri and colleagues recommend using the reviewer feedback received, even from a rejection, to improve the manuscript before submitting it to a better-matched journal, rather than resubmitting an unrevised version elsewhere on the assumption that a different set of reviewers will overlook the same concerns2. A formal appeal against a rejection should be reserved for cases with specific, demonstrable grounds, such as a reviewer's factual error or a clear misunderstanding of the methodology, rather than used as a general means of disputing an editorial judgement, since COPE's guidance on editorial decision-making treats an appeal process as a safeguard against identifiable error, not a routine second attempt at the same submission4. Maintaining the distinction between a genuine, evidence-based appeal and a general wish for a different outcome protects an author's credibility with the editorial team for any future submission to the same journal. This consideration should be weighed against the understandable frustration that a rejection produces, because the editors and reviewing communities within a field are often smaller and more interconnected than an author outside that niche may assume, and a reputation for constructive engagement with review tends to follow an author across submissions in a way that a single intemperate reply cannot easily reverse.
Key points
Key points
A response-to-reviewers letter is a distinct piece of writing. It should open with an overview, quote reviews in full, answer every point individually with a direct answer first, use clear typography to separate comments from responses, and address disagreement by citing evidence and involving the editor rather than refusing a request outright.
Practical application
Practical application
- The response should be drafted in two stages: an unfiltered private version, followed by a measured, polished version for submission. This allows frustration or disagreement to be addressed privately before the version that the editor and reviewers will read is written.
- Each individual response should begin with a direct answer, followed by the explanation. This allows an editor or reviewer scanning the letter to confirm quickly that each point was addressed, without first reading the full justification.
- Any substantive disagreement or ethical concern should be raised directly with the editor and supported by evidence. A genuine dispute should not be resolved unilaterally in the response letter; the editor should make the final decision when reviewers’ requests conflict or a request falls outside the scope of the study.
Frequently asked questions
Yes. Noble's guidance is explicit that every point should be answered, including ones the author disagrees with, and that a comment raising several distinct issues should be split and addressed individually.
Yes, when the request is not well justified, but Hidouri and colleagues' guidance recommends supporting any such refusal with clear evidence and, where the disagreement is substantive, involving the editor rather than simply refusing in the response letter alone.
Hidouri and colleagues' 2024 guidance recommends disclosing any such use and treating the tool as a supplement to the author's own judgement, in line with the direction many journals' author guidelines have moved in.
Hidouri and colleagues recommend resubmitting promptly, while the work and the reviewers' comments are still fresh, and thanking reviewers whose feedback substantially improved the manuscript.
References
- Noble WS. Ten simple rules for writing a response to reviewers. PLOS Computational Biology. 2017;13(10):e1005730. read 10 October 2026. View on PLOS Computational Biology
- Hidouri S, Kamoun H, Salah S, Jellad A, Ben Saad H. Key Guidelines for Responding to Reviewers. F1000Research. 2024;13:921. read 10 October 2026. View on F1000Research
- International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing, and Publication of Scholarly Work in Medical Journals. read 10 October 2026. View on ICMJE
- Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). Core Practices. read 10 October 2026. View on COPE
- Rowley J, Sbaffi L, Sugden M, Gilbert A. Factors influencing researchers' journal selection decisions. Journal of Information Science. 2022;48(3):321-335. read 10 October 2026. View on Journal of Information Science
- Jefferson T, Alderson P, Wager E, Davidoff F. Effects of editorial peer review: a systematic review. JAMA. 2002;287(21):2784-2786. read 10 October 2026. View on JAMA
- Perlis RH, Kendall-Taylor J, Hart K, et al. Peer Review in a General Medical Research Journal Before and During the COVID-19 Pandemic. JAMA Network Open. 2023;6(1):e2253296. read 10 October 2026. View on JAMA Network Open
- Smith R. Peer review: a flawed process at the heart of science and journals. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine. 2006;99(4):178-182. read 10 October 2026. View on Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine
- Fox CW, Meyer J. The influence of the global COVID-19 pandemic on manuscript submissions and editor and reviewer performance at six ecology journals. Functional Ecology. 2021. read 10 October 2026. View on Functional Ecology
- Schulz KF, Altman DG, Moher D; CONSORT Group. CONSORT 2010 Statement: updated guidelines for reporting parallel group randomised trials. BMJ. 2010;340:c332. read 10 October 2026. View on The BMJ
Every source above is a peer-reviewed article, a publisher’s record of one, or a standard issued by the body that owns it. Each carries the date it was last read. Where a standard moves, this article is revised rather than left up with a note.
How to cite this article
Pick your referencing style and copy it. Your university or target journal may vary the punctuation — check its guide if it has one.
Pubrica Academy. (2026, October 10). Responding to the Manuscript Peer Review Process: Structure, Disagreement and Disclosure in the Response Letter. Pubrica. https://pubrica.com/academy/response-to-reviewer/peer-review-process/
Pubrica Academy. “Responding to the Manuscript Peer Review Process: Structure, Disagreement and Disclosure in the Response Letter.” Pubrica, 10 Oct. 2026, pubrica.com/academy/response-to-reviewer/peer-review-process/.
Pubrica Academy (2026) Responding to the Manuscript Peer Review Process: Structure, Disagreement and Disclosure in the Response Letter. Pubrica. Available at: https://pubrica.com/academy/response-to-reviewer/peer-review-process/ (Accessed: 15 October 2026).
Pubrica Academy. “Responding to the Manuscript Peer Review Process: Structure, Disagreement and Disclosure in the Response Letter.” Pubrica. October 10, 2026. https://pubrica.com/academy/response-to-reviewer/peer-review-process/
Pubrica Academy, ‘Responding to the Manuscript Peer Review Process: Structure, Disagreement and Disclosure in the Response Letter’ (Pubrica, 10 October 2026) <https://pubrica.com/academy/response-to-reviewer/peer-review-process/> accessed 15 October 2026.
Pubrica Academy. Responding to the Manuscript Peer Review Process: Structure, Disagreement and Disclosure in the Response Letter. [Internet]. Pubrica; 2026 Oct 10 [cited 2026 Oct 15]. Available from: https://pubrica.com/academy/response-to-reviewer/peer-review-process/
Pubrica Academy, “Responding to the Manuscript Peer Review Process: Structure, Disagreement and Disclosure in the Response Letter,” Pubrica, Oct. 10, 2026. [Online]. Available: https://pubrica.com/academy/response-to-reviewer/peer-review-process/
@misc{/la_peer_review_response_guide_2026,
author = {{Pubrica Academy}},
title = {Responding to the Manuscript Peer Review Process: Structure, Disagreement and Disclosure in the Response Letter},
howpublished = {Pubrica},
year = {2026},
month = {oct},
url = {https://pubrica.com/academy/response-to-reviewer/peer-review-process/},
note = {Accessed: <span data-cite-acc="iso">2026-10-15</span>}
}This article is written to be learned from. Cite it if you are referring to what it says; if you are using the evidence behind it, cite the sources listed above instead.
Response-to-Reviewers Letter Structure
This structure may be used as a starting template for a response letter.
[ ] Opening overview summarising major changes made in response to review [ ] Each reviewer's comments quoted in full, numbered, and split into individual points [ ] Each point answered with a direct answer first, then supporting explanation [ ] Changed manuscript text quoted directly, with page/line references [ ] Typography distinguishes reviewer comments, author responses, and manuscript text [ ] Any declined request supported with evidence; unresolved disputes flagged to the editor [ ] Any AI-tool assistance in drafting the letter disclosed
Pubrica AcademyWritten and maintained by Pubrica’s subject matter experts. Articles are revised when the underlying standards change, and each article states the date on which it was last reviewed.
How Pubrica can help
Pubrica’s publication support team drafts response-to-reviewers letters following this structure — point by point, evidence-based and clearly organised — for authors responding to a revise-and-resubmit decision.