Free scoping read. A written assessment of your manuscript in two business days, at no cost.

Start one
Contents

Academy · Research Publication · Editorial Triage & Desk Rejection

How Journal Editors Screen Manuscripts Before Peer Review: Editorial Triage and Desk Rejection

A study tracking 1,008 manuscripts submitted to three elite medical journals found that desk-rejected papers went on to receive fewer citations than those sent for review, yet 12 of the 14 most highly cited manuscripts the journals rejected had been rejected at the desk. Editorial triage is a useful but fallible judgment made under genuine uncertainty.

Pubrica AcademyWritten by an editorial process analyst Reviewed bya publication ethics reviewer Published10 October 2026 Last checked10 October 2026 Reading time13 minutes Sources18 sources

Editorial triage, often termed desk rejection or editorial screening, is the initial decision by a journal’s editors on whether a submitted manuscript is sent for external peer review. It occurs before any external reviewer sees the paper and is typically based on the cover letter, the abstract and a brief reading of the full text against criteria such as fit with the journal’s scope, apparent novelty, methodological soundness and ethical compliance. Because this stage excludes a substantial proportion of submissions before independent experts assess them, it constitutes a significant gatekeeping step in its own right, and the best available empirical evidence on its performance suggests that it is a fallible, judgment-based process rather than a reliable guarantee of quality.

Journal editing at a glance

The subject
How journals review their own editing: submissions, decisions, reasons and the fate of declined papers
What audits show
Between 18% and 75.8% of declined manuscripts were later published elsewhere in six biomedical journal audits16,13
Best evidence on triage
Desk-rejected papers were cited less on average, but 12 of the 14 most-cited rejected papers were desk-rejected1
Commonest stated reason
Poor study design, in 59% of rejections at one orthodontic journal12
This article’s focus
Editorial triage: how editors screen manuscripts before peer review
Reading time
About 13 minutes, with 2 figures and 3 tables

Learning objectives

  • What editorial triage evaluates, and at which stage of submission
  • The documented outcomes of a large tracked sample of desk-rejected manuscripts
  • Why triage decisions are better understood as selection judgments under uncertainty than as a fail-safe filter

Common misconceptions

  • “A manuscript rejected at the editorial screening stage necessarily had a flaw that peer review would also have identified.” Siler, Lee and Bero tracked 1,008 manuscripts submitted to three elite medical journals. Desk-rejected manuscripts did on average receive fewer citations than those sent for review, but of the 14 most highly cited manuscripts that the journals rejected, 12 had been desk-rejected. Triage is right more often than not, and wrong in exactly the cases that matter most.

How journals review their own editing

Journals periodically publish a review of their own editing: how many manuscripts were submitted, how many were accepted, why the rest were declined, and what became of them afterwards. Such audits are the evidence on which an editor’s account of a journal’s current state, and its plans, ought to rest. The earlier version of this page took that form for a single risk and crisis communication journal. Communication journals are largely outside PubMed, and no peer-reviewed audit of that journal could be retrieved for this revision, so the examples below are biomedical journals that have published comparable self-audits.

1Submissions received, by article type and country of originVolume
2Editorial triage: declined without external review, or sent outDesk decision
3External peer review and revisionReview
4Final decision, with the stated reason for each rejectionDecision and reasons
5Where declined manuscripts were later published, how quickly, and how often citedFate of declined papers
Figure 1. The stages a journal’s review of its own editing typically covers. Stage 2 is the subject of the rest of this article. Conceptual summary of the audits in Table 1.

Table 1. Published audits of biomedical journals’ editorial decisions

Journal and studySampleKey finding
J Am Acad Dermatol; Armstrong et al. 200815981 submissions in two 4-month periods; 489 (50%) declined201 (41%) of declined manuscripts published elsewhere by March 2007; 82% of 101 checked had adopted at least one reviewer suggestion
Am J Neuroradiol; McDonald et al. 200917315 rejected-then-published papers vs 441 accepted papers2.4 vs 6.4 citations per journal year (P < .0001)
Br J Surg; Wijnhoven and Dejong 201014926 manuscripts rejected in 2006609 (65.8%) published in 198 journals, mean 13.8 months later; 14 (2.3%) in journals with a higher impact factor
Indian Pediatr; Dewan et al. 201016347 manuscripts rejected in 200262 (18%) published by July 2009; rejection before peer review lowered the chance of later publication
J Bone Joint Surg Am; Okike et al. 201213918 manuscripts not accepted, January 2004 to June 2005696 (75.8%) fully published within five years
Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop; Farjo et al. 201512440 original articles in 2008; 116 (26%) accepted137 of 324 rejected (42%) published elsewhere, a mean of 22 months later
Acad Emerg Med; Grant and Cone 2015111,542 submissions in 2010–2011; 1,052 declined693 (65.9%) published elsewhere, a median of 16.7 months later

Figures as reported in each study’s abstract. Follow-up periods and search methods differ, so the studies are not directly comparable.

Share of declined manuscripts later published elsewhere

J Bone Joint Surg Am918 declined; within 5 years75.8%
Acad Emerg Med1,052 declined65.9%
Br J Surg926 rejected65.8%
Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop324 rejected42%
J Am Acad Dermatol489 declined; within about 28 months41%
Indian Pediatr347 rejected18%

Bars are drawn on a 0–100% scale. Follow-up windows and search methods differ between studies.

Figure 2. In most published journal audits, a majority or a large minority of declined manuscripts were eventually published elsewhere, usually in journals with lower impact factors.13,11,14,12,15,16

The pattern is not confined to medicine. An audit of 456 manuscripts rejected between 1997 and 2011 by the Journal of Artificial Societies and Social Simulation found that most were published elsewhere in some form, but only 10% in a journal indexed in the Web of Science; manuscripts that had been through more review rounds and received more detailed reports before rejection were later cited more18. The citation gap also runs in the expected direction: at the American Journal of Neuroradiology, rejected papers published elsewhere accumulated 2.4 citations per journal year against 6.4 for the journal’s own articles17.

Why this article concentrates on triage

Of all the stages a journal audit reports, the desk decision is the one made fastest, on the least information and without external reviewers, and it is the one authors most often misread, so the remainder of this article examines how editors screen manuscripts before peer review.

Criteria assessed in editorial triage

Editorial triage is a deliberately rapid assessment, usually completed by one or two in-house or academic editors within days rather than weeks, intended to screen out submissions unlikely to be accepted even after full peer review1. The criteria editors weigh most heavily are whether the topic of the manuscript fits the journal’s stated scope, whether the work appears sufficiently novel or significant relative to what the journal already covers, whether the methodology appears sound on an initial reading, and whether the manuscript meets the journal’s basic ethical and reporting requirements, such as a clear statement of ethics approval for human or animal research2. Because this assessment takes place without the manuscript’s full methods and data being examined in the depth that external peer review provides, it necessarily relies more heavily than a full review on surface indicators: the cover letter, the abstract, the conclusion and the overall clarity of the writing1. Editors describe this as a deliberate trade-off: triage exists to protect the time of external reviewers and to keep turnaround times manageable for all submissions, not to replace the more thorough review that follows2.

Table 2. Stated reasons for rejection at one journal, and what followed

Reason for rejectionShare of 324 rejected articlesLater publication
Poor study design59%Least likely to be published elsewhere
Outdated or unoriginal topic42%Not separately reported in the abstract
Inappropriate for the journal’s audience27%Most likely to be published elsewhere

Source: Farjo et al., American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics, 2015 (original articles submitted in 2008). Reasons overlap, so the shares sum to more than 100%.12

Leaves scope to be inferred

“We believe this manuscript will be of interest to your readers.”

Gives the triaging editor no reason to connect the work with the journal’s stated aims.

States the fit explicitly

“This cohort study addresses [question] in [population]; it extends the trial your journal published in [year] by adding five-year outcomes, and is aimed at readers in [specialty].”

Names the design, the gap and the journal’s own prior content, the signals a rapid assessment relies on.

Illustrative cover-letter sentences written for this page; bracketed items are placeholders.

Outcomes of manuscripts rejected before review

The most rigorous empirical test of how well this screening stage performs comes from a study in PNAS by Kyle Siler, Kirby Lee and Lisa Bero, who used a dataset of 1,008 manuscripts submitted to three elite medical journals to compare citation outcomes for articles that received different appraisals from editors and peer reviewers1. Among rejected articles, those desk-rejected by editors received fewer citations than those sent for peer review, and among both rejected and accepted articles, lower reviewer scores went with fewer citations once the work was published1. Hindsight nonetheless revealed numerous questionable decisions: of the 808 manuscripts eventually published, the journals had rejected many that became highly cited, including the 14 most cited, roughly the top 2%, and 12 of those 14 had been desk-rejected1. The authors concluded that editors and reviewers generally, but not always, made good decisions, and that the case raises concern about whether peer review is suited to recognising the most impactful work1.

1,008manuscripts submitted to three elite medical journals
808eventually published, in those journals or elsewhere
14most-cited manuscripts, all rejected by the focal journals
12of those 14 rejected at the desk, without external review

Siler, Lee and Bero, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2015.1

Variable performance of triage as a quality filter

The findings of Siler, Lee and Bero are consistent with a broader, long-documented set of concerns about the reliability of editorial and peer judgment. Bornmann and Daniel’s review of reviewer and editor biases in journal peer review documents that both editors and external reviewers exhibit measurable, systematic biases related to an author’s reputation, institutional affiliation and the perceived conventionality of a submission’s approach; these biases are subject to even less correction at the editorial-triage stage, since that initial, rapid assessment typically includes no second opinion2.

Journals’ internal studies of their own decisions show how much of rejection rests on judgment: at one orthodontic journal, poor study design was the commonest stated reason (59% of rejections), but an outdated or unoriginal topic (42%) and inappropriateness for the audience (27%) were also frequent, and manuscripts rejected on audience grounds were the most likely to be published elsewhere12.

This does not imply that editorial triage serves no purpose; journals that screen heavily do reduce the burden on external reviewers and accelerate decisions on clearly out-of-scope submissions. It does, however, imply that the stage should be understood as a rapid, resource-constrained judgment rather than a dependable proxy for the eventual scientific value of a paper12.

Implications of a desk rejection for authors

For authors, the practical implication of this evidence is that a desk rejection is considerably more informative about fit and presentation than about underlying scientific merit. Editage’s guidance on handling desk rejections recommends reading any brief editorial comment carefully for indications of scope mismatch as opposed to a stated concern about rigour, since these point to different next steps: selecting a better-matched journal, or revising the manuscript before resubmitting elsewhere4. Because the tracked-manuscript evidence shows that 12 of the 14 most highly cited manuscripts rejected by three elite journals had been rejected at the desk, authors have a documented reason to treat an early rejection as an indication to seek a better-matched venue rather than as a verdict on the quality of the work1. Journal audits point the same way: rejection on grounds of originality or language left good chances of later publication at Indian Pediatrics, whereas rejection before peer review, or for over-interpretation or poor statistical analysis, reduced them16.

Table 3. Reading a rejection: stated reason and the evidence on what follows

Stated reasonWhat the audits foundSensible next step
Outside scope or audienceMost likely category to be published elsewhere12Choose a better-matched journal; revise the framing, not the science
Originality or languageGreater chance of later publication16Sharpen the statement of what is new; obtain language editing
Over-interpretation or poor statisticsLower chance of later publication16Re-analyse or temper conclusions before resubmitting anywhere
Poor study designLeast likely to be published elsewhere12Report limitations candidly; consider a journal that publishes the design type

Evidence from two single-journal audits; next steps are Pubrica’s editorial suggestions, not study findings.

Variation in triage practices across journals and fields

The proportion of submissions a journal screens out before external review, and the structure of that screening, vary considerably across journals and fields, and this variation is itself informative about how much weight any single rejection should carry. Selective, high-volume general journals, such as those studied by Siler, Lee and Bero, typically triage a substantial proportion of submissions because their broad scope attracts far more submissions than their page budget and reviewer pool can accommodate; rapid filtering on scope and significance is therefore a practical necessity rather than a reflection of unusually stringent standards applied to any individual paper1. Specialty and society journals with a narrower scope and a more predictable submission volume often triage less extensively, partly because a narrower scope already deters much of the mismatch that drives triage decisions at broader journals before a paper is submitted2.

Horbach and Halffman’s comparative review of the ability of different peer-review procedures to detect problematic publications found that the structure of journals’ review processes, including the extent to which decisions are made at the editorial stage rather than deferred to external reviewers, varied considerably across the journals and fields examined, with no single model clearly outperforming the others in detecting the specific problems against which each was tested7.

Tennant and colleagues’ broader review of innovations in peer review likewise documents that journals have experimented with markedly different triage models, ranging from a single editor’s judgment to structured in-house review panels and author-suggested-reviewer systems, because no consensus exists on which triage structure best balances speed, cost and reliability8. For authors, a desk rejection from one journal therefore indicates relatively little about how the same manuscript would fare at another journal with a different triage model, which reinforces that fit and choice of venue, rather than a single editor’s rapid judgment, should determine the next submission decision78.

Lee, Sugimoto, Zhang and Cronin’s review of bias in peer review identifies a further, specific reason why triage outcomes vary: editors and reviewers, like other evaluators, exhibit measurable biases related to the prestige of an author or institution, which operate most strongly under the low-information, rapid-judgment conditions that characterize editorial triage, since a brief reading of a cover letter and abstract leaves more scope for a reputational halo effect to influence the decision than a fuller review of the complete methodology9.

Resnik and Elmore’s analysis of the editor’s role in the integrity of peer review recommends several concrete safeguards, including structured, criterion-based triage checklists in place of unguided impressions, periodic internal audits of triage decisions against eventual outcomes, and explicit training for new editorial staff, because unguided, rapid judgment is where bias has the greatest scope to operate unchecked10. Authors cannot control which of these safeguards, if any, a given journal has adopted, but the extent to which triage quality varies between journals is itself a reason not to generalize unduly from a single rejection.

Key points

Key points

Editorial triage is a rapid, resource-constrained judgment made before external review, and the best available tracked evidence indicates that it separates weaker from stronger work on average but misses some of the most influential papers: 12 of the 14 most-cited manuscripts rejected by three elite journals were desk-rejected. A desk rejection is therefore an indication of fit and framing rather than a dependable verdict on scientific merit.

Practical application

Practical application

  1. The cover letter and abstract should be matched explicitly to the stated scope of the journal. Because triage relies heavily on these surface signals, the fit between the manuscript and the aims of the journal should be made explicit rather than assumed.
  2. Any editorial rejection comment should be examined for an indication of fit as distinct from rigor. A comment on scope mismatch indicates the need for a better-matched journal; a stated concern about methodology indicates the need for revision before resubmission elsewhere.
  3. An early rejection should not be treated as proof that the work is weak. Journal audits show that between 18% and 75.8% of declined manuscripts are later published elsewhere, and that the most highly cited papers a journal rejects are often rejected at the desk.

Frequently asked questions

Rates vary widely by journal and field, often reported in the range of 30 to 70 percent at selective journals, though no single figure applies universally; authors should check a specific target journal's own published acceptance and triage statistics where available.

No. Triage is a rapid assessment based on the cover letter, the abstract and a brief reading of the manuscript, and is not intended to substitute for the detailed methodological scrutiny provided by external peer reviewers.

The published abstract describes them only as three elite medical journals. The study tracked 1,008 manuscripts submitted to those journals, 808 of which were eventually published somewhere.

Partly. In the same PNAS study, desk-rejected manuscripts were cited less on average than those sent for peer review, but 12 of the 14 most-cited manuscripts the journals rejected had been desk-rejected. The authors suggest that screening strategies which raise the average quality of published work may also increase the risk of rejecting unconventional or outstanding work.

Many journals permit a brief appeal if an author considers that the editor has misunderstood the scope or significance of the manuscript, although appeals against triage decisions succeed far less often than appeals following full external review.

References

  1. Siler K, Lee K, Bero L. Measuring the effectiveness of scientific gatekeeping. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 2015;112(2):360-365. read 10 October 2026. View on PNAS
  2. Bornmann L, Daniel HD. Reviewer and editor biases in journal peer review: an investigation of manuscript refereeing at Angewandte Chemie International Edition. Research Evaluation. 2009;18(4):262-272. read 10 October 2026. View on Research Evaluation
  3. Horbach SPJM, Halffman W. The ability of different peer review procedures to flag problematic publications. Scientometrics. 2019;118:339-373. read 10 October 2026. View on Scientometrics
  4. Editage Insights. Desk Rejection: Reasons, Next Steps, and How to Avoid Rejection Without Peer Review. read 10 October 2026. View on Editage Insights
  5. Weller AC. Editorial Peer Review: Its Strengths and Weaknesses. American Society for Information Science and Technology, 2001. read 10 October 2026. View publisher record
  6. Opthof T, Coronel R, Janse MJ. Editors and editorial policies: let us not confuse policy with lack of courage. Cardiovascular Research. 2004;63(1):1-4. read 10 October 2026. View on Cardiovascular Research
  7. Horbach SPJM, Halffman W. The ability of different peer review procedures to flag problematic publications. Scientometrics. 2019;118:339-373. read 10 October 2026. View on Scientometrics
  8. Tennant JP, Dugan JM, Graziotin D, et al. A multi-disciplinary perspective on emergent and future innovations in peer review. F1000Research. 2017;6:1151. read 10 October 2026. View on F1000Research
  9. Lee CJ, Sugimoto CR, Zhang G, Cronin B. Bias in peer review. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology. 2013;64(1):2-17. read 10 October 2026. View on JASIST
  10. Resnik DB, Elmore SA. Ensuring the Quality, Fairness, and Integrity of Journal Peer Review: A Possible Role of Editors. Science and Engineering Ethics. 2016;22(1):169-188. read 10 October 2026. View on Science and Engineering Ethics
  11. Grant WD, Cone DC. If at first you don’t succeed: the fate of manuscripts rejected by Academic Emergency Medicine. Academic Emergency Medicine. 2015;22(10):1213-1217. doi:10.1111/acem.12763 read 13 November 2026. doi.org/10.1111/acem.12763
  12. Farjo N, Turpin DL, Coley RY, Feng J. Characteristics and fate of orthodontic articles submitted for publication: an exploratory study of the American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics. American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics. 2015;147(6):680-690. doi:10.1016/j.ajodo.2015.01.020 read 13 November 2026. doi.org/10.1016/j.ajodo.2015.01.020
  13. Okike K, Kocher MS, Nwachukwu BU, Mehlman CT, Heckman JD, Bhandari M. The fate of manuscripts rejected by The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery (American Volume). Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery (American Volume). 2012;94(17):e130. doi:10.2106/JBJS.L.00078 read 13 November 2026. doi.org/10.2106/JBJS.L.00078
  14. Wijnhoven BPL, Dejong CHC. Fate of manuscripts declined by the British Journal of Surgery. British Journal of Surgery. 2010;97(3):450-454. doi:10.1002/bjs.6880 read 13 November 2026. doi.org/10.1002/bjs.6880
  15. Armstrong AW, Idriss SZ, Kimball AB, Bernhard JD. Fate of manuscripts declined by the Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology. Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology. 2008;58(4):632-635. doi:10.1016/j.jaad.2007.12.025 read 13 November 2026. doi.org/10.1016/j.jaad.2007.12.025
  16. Dewan P, Gupta P, Shah D. Fate of articles rejected by Indian Pediatrics. Indian Pediatrics. 2010;47(12):1031-1035. doi:10.1007/s13312-010-0178-z read 13 November 2026. doi.org/10.1007/s13312-010-0178-z
  17. McDonald RJ, Cloft HJ, Kallmes DF. Fate of manuscripts previously rejected by the American Journal of Neuroradiology: a follow-up analysis. AJNR American Journal of Neuroradiology. 2009;30(2):253-256. doi:10.3174/ajnr.A1366 read 13 November 2026. doi.org/10.3174/ajnr.A1366
  18. Casnici N, Grimaldo F, Gilbert N, Dondio P, Squazzoni F. Assessing peer review by gauging the fate of rejected manuscripts: the case of the Journal of Artificial Societies and Social Simulation. Scientometrics. 2017;113(1):533-546. doi:10.1007/s11192-017-2241-1 read 13 November 2026. doi.org/10.1007/s11192-017-2241-1

Every source above is a peer-reviewed article, a publisher’s record of one, or a standard issued by the body that owns it. Each carries the date it was last read. Where a standard moves, this article is revised rather than left up with a note.

How to cite this article

Pick your referencing style and copy it. Your university or target journal may vary the punctuation — check its guide if it has one.

Pubrica Academy. (2026, October 10). How Journal Editors Screen Manuscripts Before Peer Review: Editorial Triage and Desk Rejection. Pubrica. https://pubrica.com/academy/journal-editing/review-of-the-journals-editing-current-state-and-future-plans/

This article is written to be learned from. Cite it if you are referring to what it says; if you are using the evidence behind it, cite the sources listed above instead.

Pre-Submission Triage Readiness Check

This checklist should be completed before submission to reduce the likelihood of a scope-based desk rejection.

[ ] Confirmed the journal's published aims and scope explicitly cover this manuscript's topic
[ ] Checked the cover letter states fit and significance clearly and specifically
[ ] Confirmed the abstract reads clearly without requiring the full text for basic comprehension
[ ] Checked ethics approval and reporting-guideline statements are present and unambiguous
[ ] Reviewed recent issues of the journal for comparable published work

Pubrica AcademyWritten and maintained by Pubrica’s subject matter experts. Articles are revised when the underlying standards change, and each article states the date on which it was last reviewed.

How Pubrica can help

Pubrica’s publication support team reviews cover letters, abstracts and scope fit before submission to reduce the risk of an avoidable desk rejection, and advises on next steps when a manuscript is rejected without review.

Find something else

Search the Pubrica Academy

Access is free and requires no account. Enter a topic, or open the full library to filter by category, sub-topic or resource type.

Distinguishing rejection for fit from rejection for rigor

A scoping assessment is free and takes two business days. It provides a written assessment of what the work requires and which specialist would undertake it.

Get a free quote

Regulations

Check your project against this rule

  1. 1Your work
  2. 2Your details
  3. 3Send
What do you need?

Material you send is held under signed confidentiality, with access limited to the assigned team and encrypted transfer. It is not used to train anything and is not passed to third-party tools. Ask for the agreement before you send anything you would rather cover first.