Examples
Annotated real work with the reasoning marked up — the same passage handled well and badly, and what a reviewer sees in each. This library is now complete: every item below is published and free to read, with the standard it is built to and the date that standard was read stated on the item itself.
Each item names the standard it is built to and the date that standard was read.
The library
Planned contents of this library
This library is published as a list of planned items rather than as a finished collection, because advance notice of forthcoming material is more useful than a page that appears only when complete. Items that readers request are moved forward in the queue.
Filters
A Case Report of Type 1 Diabetes During the COVID-19 Vaccine
A verified summary of a published case report of new-onset type 1 diabetes following COVID-19 vaccination, covering the patient timeline, diagnostic workup, and the authors' proposed mechanism.
Posted 10 October 2026Reading time 7 minBy Pubrica Academycase reporttype 1 diabetesCOVID-19 vaccinationautoimmune diabetesExampleResearch Data Analytics & AIPubrica AcademyAvailableA Critical Review of a Major Meta-Analysis on Physical Activity and Chronic Disease Risk
A verified critical review of Kyu and colleagues' 2016 BMJ meta-analysis on physical activity and chronic disease risk, covering its design strengths and its own stated limitations.
Posted 10 October 2026Reading time 9 minBy Pubrica Academymeta-analysis critiquephysical activitydose-responsechronic disease riskExampleResearch PublicationAvailableAnnotated rebuttals
A real objection answered two ways, with the reasoning for each marked in the margin.
Posted 10 October 2026Reading time 6 minBy Pubrica Academyannotated rebuttal exampleconcede or defend reviewer commentrebuttal letter exampleresponding to reviewers examplepeer review responseResponse to reviewersExampleResearch WritingAvailableBefore and after editing
The same paragraph proofread and copyedited, so the difference stops being a word on a price list.
Posted 10 October 2026Reading time 6 minBy Pubrica Academyproofreading vs copyediting examplebefore and after editingediting service comparisoncopyediting exampleproofreading exampleManuscript editingExampleResearch PublicationICMJEAvailableDeclarations that satisfy and do not
Real disclosure wording, with what each publisher actually asked for alongside it.
Posted 10 October 2026Reading time 6 minBy Pubrica Academydeclarations that satisfy exampleconflict of interest statement exampleAI disclosure wording exampleICMJE disclosure exampledeclaration wordingCompliance statement checkingExampleResearch WritingAvailableFigures that passed and failed production
The same figure at review resolution and at production resolution, with the fault named.
Posted 10 October 2026Reading time 6 minBy Pubrica Academyfigure resolution examplefigure passed review failed productionDPI production requirementsfigure preparation faultresolution check exampleFigure and artwork preparationExampleResearch Data Analytics & AIPubrica AcademyAvailableHow Can SD for the Change Score Be Estimated From Baseline and Post-Intervention Values?
A verified explanation of how to estimate the standard deviation of a change score from baseline and post-intervention SDs and a correlation coefficient, with alternative methods when no correlation is available.
Posted 10 October 2026Reading time 8 minBy Pubrica Academystandard deviationchange scoremeta-analysismissing data imputationExampleResearch Data Analytics & AIPubrica AcademyAvailableReal-World Examples of QUADAS-2 Risk-of-Bias Assessments
A verified look at how QUADAS-2 risk-of-bias assessments are actually applied and reported in practice, including a documented case of inconsistent use in AI diagnostic accuracy reviews.
Posted 10 October 2026Reading time 7 minBy Pubrica AcademyQUADAS-2diagnostic accuracyrisk of biassystematic review methodologyExampleResearch Data Analytics & AIPRISMA 2020AvailableSearch strategies that can be repeated
A full strategy with every database, string, limit and record count, as an assessor would need it.
Posted 10 October 2026Reading time 7 minBy Pubrica Academyrepeatable search strategy examplesystematic review search examplePRISMA search reportingsearch strategy documentationreproducible searchSystematic reviewHow these are built
Reasons for naming a standard and a date in each item
Templates and flow charts encode rules, and such rules change. Each item that depends on a reporting guideline, a funder policy or a publisher requirement states the edition to which it was built and the date on which that edition was consulted, so that readers can determine whether it remains current before relying on it.
The four rules
The other libraries
The categories served by the library
The same material is organized in two ways: by format and by subject.
Elsewhere in Academy
Prioritisation of items according to reader requests
The order of the queue is determined by reader requests. Items that readers identify as useful are moved forward.