Scientific Editing Sample Work
A tracked-changes edit of a bariatric surgery manuscript
This sample shows a manuscript after Pubrica's editing pass, with every intervention visible. The paper, Perioperative changes of muscle mass after Roux-en-Y gastric bypass: skeletal muscle mass index versus bioelectrical impedance analysis, is a prospective single-centre study from a university surgical department. The file is labelled as a proofreading sample and is presented on this page in the context of scientific editing; in practice it demonstrates both: line-level corrections to language and formatting, and a small number of content-level suggestions that change how the paper positions its findings. Insertions appear in red underlined text, deletions are logged in margin balloons, and line numbers run down the right-hand side so authors can trace each change.
What the study measures and why it matters
Bariatric surgery produces large reductions in body weight, but the composition of that loss matters. Fat mass is expected to fall; loss of skeletal muscle, by contrast, is undesirable and is linked to sarcopenia. The manuscript compares two ways of tracking muscle after Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (RYGB). The skeletal muscle mass index (SMI), calculated from MRI cross-sectional muscle area at the third lumbar vertebra and normalised to height squared, is a direct imaging measure increasingly used as a prognostic factor in oncology and surgery. Bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA) is cheaper and widely used in bariatric practice but is considered susceptible to patient-related and environmental factors. The study asks how well the two agree over the postoperative course.
Design and results as presented in the edited text
Patients undergoing RYGB between January 2010 and December 2011 were eligible. MRI on a 1.5 Tesla scanner and multi-frequency BIA were performed one day before surgery and at 6, 12 and 24 weeks afterwards. Seventeen patients were included (4 male, 13 female), with a mean age of 41.9 years and mean initial BMI of 42.96 kg/m². Statistical methods included repeated-measures analysis of variance with Scheffé post hoc comparisons and Pearson correlation, performed in SAS 9.4. The abstract reports that SMI fell significantly after surgery and that correlations between SMI and body weight, phase angle and body cell mass were stronger at 24 weeks than before surgery. The conclusions present SMI as applicable for direct measurement after RYGB and BIA as a low-cost tool for estimating body composition.
Editorial changes that alter emphasis, not just wording
Several edits go beyond correction:
- An alternative title. The editor offers "Association of sarcopenia with perioperative changes after Roux-en-Y gastric bypass" as an option, foregrounding the clinical concept rather than the two methods.
- A defining opening sentence. A new first line in the abstract defines sarcopenia and links it to postoperative morbidity and mortality, giving readers the clinical reason for the study before the methods.
- Removal of an unsupported novelty claim. The sentence "To our knowledge, this approach is novel in literature" is deleted, a common recommendation because such claims are hard to substantiate and often attract reviewer challenge.
- Clearer comorbidity reporting. The results sentence on comorbidities is restructured so that counts for hypertension, sleep apnoea, diabetes, reflux and joint disease are listed in a consistent order with a pointer to Table 1.
Line-level corrections and consistency checks
The remaining changes are smaller but cumulative: "prior to" becomes "before", missing articles are added, duplicated phrases left over from earlier drafts (for example in the statistical analysis paragraph) are removed, redundant mentions of BIA are cut where the measurement schedule has already been stated, and wording such as "a total of" is tidied. Formatting adjustments, such as centring the title block and deleting stray paragraph marks, are also logged. Each change is small, yet together they shorten sentences and make the methods easier to follow, which is what reviewers notice first in a short clinical paper. Note that the edit keeps the authors' data and interpretation intact; the conclusions remain the authors' own.
Getting the most from an edit of this kind
Authors receiving a tracked-changes file should review content suggestions, such as the alternative title or new definitions, as decisions rather than automatic acceptances, and confirm that any added sentence is supported by a citation. Language changes can usually be accepted in bulk after a scan. Pubrica's manuscript editing covers language and consistency, scientific editing adds subject-expert review of argument and methods, and journal formatting prepares the final file to a target journal's style.
Questions about this sample
Why did the editor delete the claim that the approach was novel?
Statements such as 'to our knowledge, this approach is novel' are difficult to verify and frequently challenged by reviewers, who may know of earlier work. Removing the claim lets the study's contribution rest on its design and results. If novelty is central to the paper, it is better supported by a documented literature search.
What is the difference between SMI and BIA in this study?
SMI is calculated from MRI images as muscle cross-sectional area at the third lumbar vertebra divided by height squared, giving a direct imaging measure. BIA estimates body composition from electrical impedance through the body; it is inexpensive and quick but can be influenced by patient and environmental factors such as hydration.
Do I have to accept every change in a tracked-changes edit?
No. Language corrections are usually straightforward to accept, but content-level suggestions, such as the alternative title or the new sentence defining sarcopenia in this sample, should be reviewed by the authors. You remain responsible for the scientific content, and any added statement should be checked for accuracy and supported with a citation.
Give yourself the academic edge today
Each order includes
- On-time delivery or your money back
- A fully qualified writer in your subject
- In-depth proofreading by our Quality Control Team
- 100% confidentiality, the work is never re-sold or published
- Standard 7-day amendment period
- A paper written to the standard ordered
- A detailed plagiarism report
- A comprehensive quality report
Enquire Now
