Free scoping read. A written assessment of your manuscript in two business days, at no cost.

Start one

Response to Reviewer

Response to Reviewers

Dear Frank

We appreciate the opportunity to submit a revised draft of the manuscript, “Poetry and the Cognitive Psychology of Metrical Constructs” for publication in the Journal of Poetry and Psychology. We appreciate the time and consideration you and the reviewers put into feedback on our manuscript, and we are grateful for the thoughtful comments on and contributions to this article. We incorporated most of the suggestions made by the reviewers; those changes are highlighted in the manuscript. Please see below in blue, for a point-by-point response to the reviewers’ comments and concerns. All page numbers refer to the revised manuscript file with tracked changes.

A fill-in-the-blanks template for revision letters

Where other response samples reproduce a finished exchange with real reviewers, this one is a reusable template. It opens with a cover note to the handling editor about a revised manuscript (a placeholder title in a placeholder journal), thanks the editor and reviewers, explains that changes are highlighted in the manuscript and that responses appear in blue, and states that all page numbers refer to the revised file with tracked changes. Below that, each reviewer comment is represented by a description of the type of comment, followed by a model author response with square-bracketed gaps to complete. The aim is to give authors a ready vocabulary for the situations they will meet most often, rather than an example tied to one paper.

Eleven kinds of reviewer comment and how the template answers each

The template is organised around the categories of comment that recur in peer review. For Reviewer 1 it covers:

  • an error or omission the reviewer has correctly identified, answered by acknowledging the point and quoting the revised text with its exact location;
  • a specific change, answered by explaining what was done and where;
  • a general change needed in several places, such as reordering study variables or renaming a term throughout;
  • a request for analysis outside the limits of the paper or the data, answered by thanking the reviewer and giving a clear reason the suggestion was not adopted;
  • a typographical, spelling or grammatical correction;
  • a recommendation for improvement, answered by describing the change and its location.

For Reviewer 2 it adds a broadly negative overall verdict, a request for analysis the available data cannot support, a suggestion to add content to the introduction or discussion, a request to modify a particular section, and a limitation the authors had not addressed.

Disagreeing with a reviewer while staying courteous

The most instructive entry is the reply to a reviewer who considers that the study contributes nothing useful. The model response thanks the reviewer, states respectfully that the authors disagree, and then directs them to set out the specific knowledge, insights or answered questions their findings provide. This reflects how editors usually weigh a disagreement: they look for evidence and reasoning, not tone. Similarly, when a request falls outside the study's scope, the template asks for a justification (beyond scope, not appropriate for inclusion, or not analysable) rather than a bare refusal. The final entry shows how to accept an unaddressed limitation gracefully, by adding a sentence to the limitations paragraph that names the issue and how future work could tackle it.

The case report shared alongside the template

The page also includes a second document: a case report summary, A CSPP1 variant associated with metabolic dysfunction in Joubert syndrome, attributed to the Journal of Medical Case Reports. Its abstract describes a 16-year-old patient with CSPP1-related Joubert syndrome who presented with insulin resistance, early-onset diabetes, dyslipidaemia and metabolic dysfunction-associated steatotic liver disease, without the typical neurological features, and in whom genetic testing identified a heterozygous CSPP1 variant. It gives authors an example of the kind of manuscript a response letter might accompany. Case reports bring their own reviewer questions, often about consent, completeness of the work-up and adherence to reporting guidance, and Pubrica's case report writing support addresses those points before submission.

This page is a writing sample and does not offer medical advice.

Filling the gaps without leaving traces of the template

The bracketed prompts are where most of the work lies. Each should be replaced with the actual change, the actual reason, or the actual location, and the generic opening phrases ("We think this is a great suggestion") should be varied so that the letter does not read as boilerplate. Authors should also check that every page or line reference matches the final tracked-changes file, since pagination often shifts during revision. It is also worth keeping the template's order of comments identical to the order in the decision letter, even where several points overlap, so the editor can match each reply to its source; cross-referencing an earlier answer is better than silently merging two comments. For a letter that needs a careful read for tone and completeness, the responding to reviewers service can review drafts built on this structure, and journal submission support can help assemble the revised files the journal requires.

Questions about this sample

How is this response template different from a worked example?

A worked example shows one author's replies to one set of comments. This template instead names common types of reviewer comment, such as an identified error, a request for out-of-scope analysis or a typographical correction, and supplies a model reply with bracketed gaps, so it can be reused across different manuscripts and journals.

What should I write when a reviewer says my study adds nothing to the literature?

The template suggests thanking the reviewer, stating respectfully that you disagree, and then explaining concretely what the study adds: the knowledge gained, the insights provided or the questions answered. Editors are persuaded by specific evidence of contribution rather than by general assertions or a defensive tone.

Why does the cover note say page numbers refer to the tracked-changes file?

Revised manuscripts are often submitted in clean and marked-up versions with different pagination. Stating which file the references point to prevents confusion and lets the editor find each change quickly. Authors should confirm the references after the final edits, because pagination can move as text is added or removed.

Why is a Joubert syndrome case report included on this page?

The page pairs the response template with a separate case report sample on a CSPP1 variant associated with metabolic dysfunction in Joubert syndrome. It illustrates the type of clinical manuscript that might go through peer review and revision; the template itself is generic and can be applied to case reports, original research or reviews.

pubrica services with experts

Research your Services with our experts

Delivered on-time or your money back

Give yourself the academic edge today

Each order includes

  • On-time delivery or your money back
  • A fully qualified writer in your subject
  • In-depth proofreading by our Quality Control Team
  • 100% confidentiality, the work is never re-sold or published
  • Standard 7-day amendment period
  • A paper written to the standard ordered
  • A detailed plagiarism report
  • A comprehensive quality report

Enquire Now

Get a free quote

Regulations

Check your project against this rule

  1. 1Your work
  2. 2Your details
  3. 3Send
What do you need?

Material you send is held under signed confidentiality, with access limited to the assigned team and encrypted transfer. It is not used to train anything and is not passed to third-party tools. Ask for the agreement before you send anything you would rather cover first.