Literature Review Sample Work
Groundwork for an intervention study on operating theatre safety culture
This sample is the literature review and gap analysis chapter for a planned study titled The Effect of Educational Intervention on Operating Theatre Nurses' Perceptions of Patient Safety Culture in the Operating Room. Before testing whether education changes perceptions, a researcher needs to know how safety culture has been measured, what baseline scores look like, and which dimensions are consistently weak. The chapter answers these questions study by study, so it would sit well in a nursing dissertation, a grant application or the background section of a protocol.
HSOPSC and SAQ: the two instruments the review keeps returning to
Most of the reviewed studies use one of two validated self-report tools. The Hospital Survey on Patient Safety Culture (HSOPSC) scores dimensions such as teamwork within units, communication about errors, non-punitive response to error and support from hospital management. The Safety Attitudes Questionnaire (SAQ), which also has an operating room version, scores teamwork climate, safety climate, job satisfaction, stress recognition, perceptions of management and working conditions. Because the review records which tool each study used, readers can see which results are directly comparable. That matters when choosing the outcome measure for an intervention.
Nine surveys, summarised in turn
| Study | Setting and sample | Tool | Headline finding in the sample |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ammouri et al., 2015 | Oman, 414 nurses | HSOPSC | Teamwork within units 83.4% positive; non-punitive response 21.4% |
| Carvalho et al., 2015 | Operating room, 226 professionals | SAQ | Teamwork 59.1 and safety climate 48.9, both below the recommended minimum |
| Khater et al., 2015 | Jordan, 658 nurses | HSOPSC | Teamwork highest, non-punitive response lowest |
| Saleh et al., 2015 | 242 nurses | HSOPSC | 43.3% positive on overall safety perception |
| Güneş et al., 2016 | Turkey, 54 nurses | HSOPSC | Higher scores with more than ten years' experience and in intensive care |
| Elsous et al., 2017 | 210 nurses | Arabic SAQ | 73.1% rated teamwork climate as good |
| Wang et al., 2019 | 492 nurses | Survey | Quality of management linked to safety attitudes |
| Salamat et al., 2019 | 200 ICU and CCU nurses | Questionnaire | Mean score 144.33 ± 10.98; 60% reported no event in a year |
| Önler & Akyolcu, 2019 | 290 operating room staff | SAQ (OR version) | Overall mean 59.22 ± 13.22; nurses less satisfied with teamwork than surgeons |
Each narrative entry follows the same order: design, sample, instrument, results and the authors' conclusion. A consistent structure like this makes it easier to synthesise the studies later.
The narrative goes beyond the table when the detail matters for the planned study. For example, Carvalho et al. found that scores varied by occupation: administrative and environmental support staff scored highest (74.6 and 62.9), while resident physicians and nurses scored lowest (50.4 and 51.1). For an intervention aimed at nurses, this is a useful finding, because it suggests nurses start from a lower baseline than other theatre staff. The chapter uses numbered superscript citations throughout, in line with the Vancouver convention common in nursing and surgical journals.
The gap that justifies an educational intervention
Several patterns emerge. Non-punitive response to error is repeatedly among the weakest dimensions, although Salamat et al. found the opposite. Under-reporting of adverse events is common. Nurses tend to rate teamwork lower than surgeons and anaesthetists do. Experience is associated with more positive perceptions. Güneş et al. note that their participants had received no education on patient safety, and suggest this may explain lower scores. Almost all of the evidence is cross-sectional, so it describes perceptions without testing whether anything changes them. That is the gap a pre- and post-education study, ideally with a comparison group, is designed to fill.
Turning the chapter into a study protocol
To use this sample as a model, carry its findings directly into design decisions. Choose an instrument the literature already uses, preferably the operating room version of the SAQ or the HSOPSC, so that baseline scores can be compared with published values. Set a measurement point before and after the intervention, and report the intervention using TREND for non-randomised designs or CONSORT for randomised ones. The baseline surveys should be reported in line with STROBE.
Pubrica's literature review and gap analysis service produces chapters like this one. The intervention itself can be planned through experimental design support, and clinicians who need a broader evidence summary can use the clinical literature review service.
Questions about this sample
Why does this review rely mainly on cross-sectional surveys?
Safety culture is usually measured by surveying staff perceptions at a single point in time, and the published studies from 2015 to 2019 reflect that. The review uses these surveys to establish baseline scores and recurring weak dimensions, which in turn shows that intervention studies testing whether education changes perceptions are scarce.
Which safety culture dimension scored worst most often?
Non-punitive response to error was among the lowest-scoring dimensions in several HSOPSC studies, including Ammouri et al., where only 21.4% of responses were positive, and Khater et al. Salamat et al. was an exception, with non-punitive response the highest-scoring dimension at 67.5%. A careful review records contrasts like this rather than smoothing them over.
Does the review include operating room studies specifically?
Yes. Carvalho et al. surveyed 226 operating room professionals with the SAQ, and Önler and Akyolcu used the operating room version of the SAQ with 290 nurses, surgeons and anaesthetists. The remaining studies cover hospital nurses more broadly or intensive care staff, which the planned study would need to bear in mind when comparing scores.
How could this sample shape an educational intervention study?
It points to the instruments to use, the baseline scores to compare against and the dimensions most likely to need attention, such as error reporting and teamwork with surgeons. These findings can shape the education content, the choice of outcome measure and the before-and-after timing of data collection.
Give yourself the academic edge today
Each order includes
- On-time delivery or your money back
- A fully qualified writer in your subject
- In-depth proofreading by our Quality Control Team
- 100% confidentiality, the work is never re-sold or published
- Standard 7-day amendment period
- A paper written to the standard ordered
- A detailed plagiarism report
- A comprehensive quality report
Enquire Now
