Free scoping read. A written assessment of your manuscript in two business days, at no cost.

Start one

Systematic Review Sample Work

Clinical Efficacy of Cochlear Implant Surgery in Pediatric and Adult Patients
A systematic review is designed to summarise the results of available studies and provides a high level of evidence-based findings on the effectiveness of interventions. Our experts can handle any type of research, whether you need systematic review based on controlled clinical trials or review based on observational study designs or community (e.g. psychology) intervention.

A PRISMA-guided review covering cochlear implants in children and adults

This sample is a systematic review manuscript with a structured abstract, introduction, methods, results with a PRISMA flow chart and four summary figures, discussion, conclusion and a full reference list. Its primary aim is to compare the clinical efficacy of unilateral cochlear implantation (CI) with bimodal stimulation, unilateral CI and bilateral CI in paediatric and adult patients. Otologists, audiologists, implant programme leads and commissioners use reviews like this to judge whether the evidence supports offering a second implant, or extending candidacy to more patients.

Implant candidacy and the case for an updated synthesis

The introduction states that more than 550 million people worldwide live with hearing loss. It describes cochlear implants as one of the most significant advances in modern medicine and notes that many children who receive an implant early go on to develop language typically. Candidacy has widened from deaf children to adults and children with severe sensorineural or progressive hearing loss.

The review is open about surgical risk. It names revision surgery for flap necrosis, facial paralysis, electrode failure, meningitis and implant-site infection, and it reports post-implantation dizziness. The research gap is that the previous systematic reviews (Berrettini et al., 2011; Forli et al., 2011) were about a decade old, so an updated synthesis was justified.

Following 2,086 records down to 73 included studies

The search combined MeSH terms and keywords in two sets of citations, one for the implant (unilateral, bilateral, bimodal) and one for its management. Terms were adapted for each database. Eligible studies were original English-language articles published between 2000 and 2020. Abstracts, letters, comments, reviews and meta-analyses were excluded. Two authors screened independently, with an independent third party resolving disagreements.

  1. 2,086 records identified.
  2. 512 remained after duplicates and irrelevant records were removed.
  3. 358 were excluded at title and abstract screening, leaving 154 for full-text review.
  4. 81 full texts were excluded: 42 cost-effectiveness analyses, 7 with no accessible full text and 32 reviews or meta-analyses.
  5. 73 studies were included.

The primary outcome was clinical efficacy, meaning language, communication and audiological results, analysed by implant configuration and age group.

Findings across the four comparison groups

  • Adults, unilateral CI: perceptual ability and quality of life improved, although Park et al. (2011) found the quality-of-life gain was not statistically significant. Roberts et al. (2013) linked a family history of hearing loss with better speech recognition. Dillon et al. (2017) reported quality-of-life gains in unilateral hearing loss, and Dixon et al. (2019) reported a reduced tinnitus burden.
  • Adults, bilateral versus unilateral: benefits for hearing in quiet and for sound localisation, with marked variation between individuals in how much the second implant added.
  • Children, unilateral CI: Scarabello et al. (2020) associated longer device use, younger age at surgery and better auditory processing with stronger oral language.
  • Children, bilateral CI: advantages in quiet, in noise and for localisation.

Across the studies, age was not a decisive factor in post-implant outcomes. Figures 2 to 5 chart the implant types and processing strategies used in each group.

The discussion compares these results with earlier syntheses. The finding that unilateral implants improve hearing in adults matches Gaylor et al. (2013), and the bilateral advantages in children match Forli et al. (2011). The review also cites patient-reported measures, such as the APHAB questionnaire used by Wackym et al. (2007), and work by Huinck et al. (2019) suggesting that patients outside conventional candidacy criteria also gained quality of life. Setting new results against earlier reviews like this helps readers see where the evidence has moved on and where it has simply been confirmed.

Limitations the authors acknowledge, and what a referee would add

The discussion acknowledges that the included studies used a wide range of processing algorithms and devices, and that risk of bias was not formally assessed because study designs differed so much. A version prepared for submission would add a design-appropriate appraisal tool and a certainty-of-evidence rating, as PRISMA 2020 expects. It would also keep the databases named in the abstract, methods and results consistent, and register a protocol in advance.

Pubrica supports reviews at this stage through its systematic review and meta-analysis service and its literature review and gap analysis service. A pre-submission peer review can identify methodological gaps before a journal does. This page is a writing sample and should not be read as clinical advice on implant candidacy.

Questions about this sample

Why were cost-effectiveness studies excluded from this review?

Forty-two full-text articles were excluded because they analysed cost-effectiveness rather than clinical efficacy. The review's question concerned language, communication and audiological outcomes, and economic evaluations answer a different question, about value for money, that would need its own methods and appraisal tools.

Does the review conclude that older age limits implant benefit?

No. Some studies found poorer perceptual results in older patients, but the review concludes that age is neither a predictor nor a limiting factor for post-implant outcomes. It cites work showing that elderly recipients still gain in quality of life and listening ability after implantation.

What does bimodal stimulation mean in this sample?

Bimodal stimulation means using a cochlear implant in one ear and a conventional hearing aid in the other. The review sets bimodal users alongside unilateral and bilateral implant recipients to judge whether a second implant adds benefit over keeping acoustic hearing in the non-implanted ear.

Is this cochlear implant sample a meta-analysis?

No statistical pooling is reported. The 73 studies are summarised narratively by age group and implant configuration, with figures charting device types and processing strategies. The variety of outcome measures and devices across the studies would make a single pooled effect estimate hard to justify.

sample-workimage-for-sidebar

Research your Services with our experts

Delivered on-time or your money back

Give yourself the academic edge today

Each order includes

  • On-time delivery or your money back
  • A fully qualified writer in your subject
  • In-depth proofreading by our Quality Control Team
  • 100% confidentiality, the work is never re-sold or published
  • Standard 7-day amendment period
  • A paper written to the standard ordered
  • A detailed plagiarism report
  • A comprehensive quality report

Enquire Now

Get a free quote

Regulations

Check your project against this rule

  1. 1Your work
  2. 2Your details
  3. 3Send
What do you need?

Material you send is held under signed confidentiality, with access limited to the assigned team and encrypted transfer. It is not used to train anything and is not passed to third-party tools. Ask for the agreement before you send anything you would rather cover first.