Home/Insights/Evidence synthesis/AAFP Clinical Practice Guideline Manual
AAFP Clinical Practice Guideline Manual
How the American Academy of Family Physicians develops and endorses guidelines — and why it declines to endorse some.
What it is
The Clinical Practice Guideline Manual sets out the process the American Academy of Family Physicians uses to develop its own guidelines and to decide whether to endorse those produced by others.
The elements that matter
Evidence-based method. Recommendations are tied to a systematic review of the evidence, with the strength of each recommendation rated. AAFP uses GRADE for its own guidelines.
Conflict of interest management. Panel members declare interests, and the manual constrains who may participate in developing recommendations.
Endorsement as a separate decision. AAFP reviews external guidelines against its own criteria and may endorse, affirm the value of, or decline to endorse them. Declining is a substantive act, usually where a guideline’s recommendations run ahead of its evidence or where the development process does not meet the standard.
Why this is relevant outside family medicine
It is a worked example of the distinction between a guideline and a systematic review. A review synthesises evidence; a guideline adds judgement about benefits, harms, values and resources to reach a recommendation. Conflating the two — citing a guideline as though it were evidence — is common in manuscripts and is a reviewer’s target.
For appraising any guideline, the AGREE II instrument assesses rigour of development, stakeholder involvement, applicability and editorial independence, and is the standard tool.
In practice
Fix, flag or query.
The distinction that keeps an edit defensible: what an editor may change silently, what must be shown to the author, and what only the author can answer.
- Distinguish: a guideline recommendation from the evidence underlying it.
- Appraise guidelines with: AGREE II.
- Note: an endorsement decision is evidence about a guideline’s quality.
Sources
- American Academy of Family Physicians, Clinical Practice Guideline Manual
- AGREE II instrument, for guideline appraisal
- GRADE Working Group
Sources are given so each claim can be checked at its origin. Where a tool’s current maintenance status could not be confirmed, the page says to check it rather than asserting it.
Related