Contents
On this page
- Quick answer
- Overview
- Case study 1 (illustrative): aligning a manuscript with UK integrity expectations
- Case study 2 (illustrative): posting a preprint without jeopardising submission
- Case study 3 (illustrative): fixing declarations after a technical return
- Case study 4 (illustrative): choosing a journal beyond the Impact Factor
- Lessons across the case studies
- Frequently asked questions
- Sources
InsightsCase Study
Case studyUK
Publication Support Case Studies (UK): Four Routes to Ethical, Transparent Publication
Four illustrative scenarios: an integrity review against the 2025 Concordat, a preprint posted safely, declarations fixed after a technical return and a journal chosen beyond the Impact Factor.
- Case study
- Publication support
- UK
- Scenarios
- 4, illustrative
- Integrity
- Concordat 2025
- Declarations
- Ethics, registration, AI, COI
- Metrics
- Used with DORA principles
At a glanceCase Study
Explore publication supportDiscuss your project
Quick answer
- Most problems in these scenarios were fixed before submission: missing declarations, undisclosed interests, unchecked preprint policies and journal choice by Impact Factor alone.
- Each fix is a checklist step, not a rewrite.
Overview
Each publication support case study below describes a common challenge for UK researchers, the approach taken and the result in that scenario. The four scenarios cover research integrity, preprints, ethics declarations and journal metrics.
Disclosure
These are illustrative, anonymised scenarios based on typical author challenges. They do not describe identifiable clients or real outcomes, and they are not a promise of acceptance by any journal.
Case study 1 (illustrative): aligning a manuscript with UK integrity expectations
| Scenario profile | Early-career researcher, UK university |
|---|---|
| Topic | Concordat to Support Research Integrity |
| Service focus | Pre-submission integrity review |
Challenge. The manuscript had no data availability statement, unclear author contributions and an undisclosed advisory role held by one co-author. The 2025 Concordat expects researchers to follow their institution’s policies on authorship, data and conflicts of interest1.
Approach.
- Reviewed the manuscript against the institution’s research integrity policy.
- Documented author contributions using CRediT roles.
- Added the advisory role to the conflict of interest statement2.
- Deposited the dataset in the university repository and drafted the statement.
Result in this scenario. The manuscript met the institution’s and the journal’s requirements and was submitted with complete declarations.
Case study 2 (illustrative): posting a preprint without jeopardising submission
| Scenario profile | Clinical research team |
|---|---|
| Topic | Preprint policies |
| Service focus | Preprint and journal policy check |
Challenge. The team wanted to share time-sensitive results on medRxiv but was unsure whether its first-choice journals would still consider the paper. The ICMJE accepts preprints if the journal is told at submission, but individual journal policies vary5.
Approach.
- Checked the preprint policies of three shortlisted journals.
- Confirmed the patient data were fully de-identified.
- Selected a licence compatible with the journals’ requirements4.
- Prepared preprint disclosure wording for the submission.
Result in this scenario. The preprint was posted and the manuscript was submitted to the first-choice journal with full disclosure.
Want your manuscript checked before submission?
Pubrica’s publication support team checks declarations, integrity requirements, preprint and journal policies and journal fit before you submit. Authors keep ownership of and accountability for the manuscript, editorial support is acknowledged, and no provider can guarantee acceptance.
Case study 3 (illustrative): fixing declarations after a technical return
| Scenario profile | NHS-based investigator |
|---|---|
| Topic | Publication ethics declarations |
| Service focus | Declarations checklist and correction |
Challenge. The journal returned the manuscript because the ethics statement lacked a reference number, the trial registration date was missing and AI use was undisclosed2.
Approach.
- Added the Research Ethics Committee name, reference and ethics approval date.
- Reported the ISRCTN number and registration date in the abstract and Methods.
- Wrote an AI disclosure statement describing language-editing use.
- Aligned the conflict of interest statement with the ICMJE forms.
Result in this scenario. The resubmission passed the journal’s technical checks and went to peer review. Table 1 shows the wording before and after.
Table 1. Declaration wording before and after revision in Case study 3 (identifiers illustrative)
| Statement | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Ethics | “Ethical approval was obtained.” | “Approved by [Name] REC (ref. 23/NW/0456) and the HRA (IRAS ID 312345).” |
| Registration | “Registered with ISRCTN.” | “ISRCTN87654321, registered 4 September 2023, before the first participant was enrolled.” |
| AI use | Not stated | “[Tool, version] was used for language editing; the authors reviewed all output and take full responsibility.” |
| Competing interests | “None.” | “EF received speaker fees from [Company] outside the submitted work; other authors declare none.” |
Case study 4 (illustrative): choosing a journal beyond the Impact Factor
| Scenario profile | Research group, UK |
|---|---|
| Topic | Journal metrics |
| Service focus | Journal selection |
Challenge. The group planned to target journals by Impact Factor alone, despite poor scope fit for an interdisciplinary study. DORA advises against using journal-based metrics as a surrogate for the quality of individual articles3.
Approach.
- Compared CiteScore and the Journal Impact Factor within the relevant field.
- Assessed scope, readership, open access options and turnaround times.
- Applied DORA principles to the decision3.
- Shortlisted three journals with strong scope fit.
Result in this scenario. The paper went to a journal whose scope matched the study, reducing the risk of a desk rejection for poor fit.
Lessons across the case studies
The same principles recur in every scenario123.
Table 2. Lessons across the case studies
| Principle | In practice |
|---|---|
| Check integrity early | Review authorship, disclosures and data before submission. |
| Verify policies | Confirm preprint and journal policies on the date of submission. |
| Complete every declaration | Use a checklist for COI, ethics, consent, registration, data and AI. |
| Use metrics responsibly | Combine metrics with scope fit and expert judgement. |
For more scenarios, see our publication support case studies on authorship, peer review and submission.
Pubrica team verdict
In each scenario the fix is the same: check integrity, policies and declarations before submission rather than after a journal returns the paper.
Frequently asked questions
Sources
Sources were checked on 18 November 2026. Requirements and guidance may change after that date; confirm the current version with the issuing body.
- 1UK Committee on Research Integrity. (2025). The Concordat to Support Research Integrity (2025). https://ukcori.org/research-integrity-concordat/
- 2International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. (2026, January). Recommendations for the conduct, reporting, editing, and publication of scholarly work in medical journals. https://www.icmje.org/recommendations/
- 3DORA. (2013). San Francisco Declaration on Research Assessment. https://sfdora.org/read/
- 4medRxiv. (n.d.). Frequently asked questions. Retrieved November 18, 2026, from https://www.medrxiv.org/about/FAQ
- 5International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. (2026). Overlapping publications. In Recommendations for the conduct, reporting, editing, and publication of scholarly work in medical journals. https://www.icmje.org/recommendations/browse/publishing-and-editorial-issues/overlapping-publications.html
publication support case studyresearch integritypreprintconflict of interest statementethics approvaldata availability statement
How to cite this article
Pick your referencing style and copy it. Your university or target journal may vary the punctuation, so check its guide if it has one.
Dr. Charlie. (2026, November 18). Publication Support Case Studies (UK): Four Routes to Ethical, Transparent Publication. Pubrica. https://pubrica.com/insights/case-study/publication-support-case-studies-uk/
This article is written to be learned from. Cite it if you are referring to what it says; if you are using the evidence behind it, cite the sources listed above instead.
Next steps
Want your manuscript checked before submission?
Pubrica’s publication support team checks declarations, integrity requirements, preprint and journal policies and journal fit before you submit. Authors keep ownership of and accountability for the manuscript, editorial support is acknowledged, and no provider can guarantee acceptance.
This article is general information for researchers, not legal, regulatory or funding advice. Check the current requirements of your journal, funder, ethics committee or regulator before you act on it.
More in Case Study