Free scoping read. A written assessment of your manuscript in two business days, at no cost.

Start one

Gene X in Cancer Progression: Revised Manuscript Ready for Publication

This sample response addresses editorial comments on a manuscript titled “The Role of Gene X in Cancer Progression.” The author, Marry Anne, expresses gratitude for the thorough review and constructive feedback from reviewers. The response includes specific actions taken to address major comments, such as providing a rationale for the control group selection, revising a figure for clarity, and expanding the discussion to include a comparison with previous studies. Marry Anne concludes by expressing hope that the revisions have strengthened the manuscript and requests feedback on the next steps in the review process.

📄 Editorial Comments Addressal SampleOpen in new tab

What this editorial response sample demonstrates

This sample is a response-to-reviewers letter for a revised manuscript, "The Role of Gene X in Cancer Progression". Gene X is a placeholder rather than a real gene, so the document can be read as a template for structure and tone rather than as a scientific claim. It shows how an author thanks the editor and reviewers, sets out each major comment, explains the action taken and closes by inviting the editor's decision on next steps.

A response letter is often read before the revised manuscript itself. Editors use it to judge quickly whether every point has been addressed, and reviewers use it to find the changes they asked for. A clear letter shortens the second round of review; an evasive or disorganised one can turn a "major revision" into a rejection.

How a point-by-point reply is laid out

The sample follows the conventional structure that most journals expect:

  1. Opening note to the editor: a short paragraph thanking the editor and reviewers and summarising the main changes in two or three sentences.
  2. Reviewer comments reproduced in full: each comment is quoted exactly, numbered (for example Reviewer 1, Comment 3) and visually distinguished, often in italics or a different colour.
  3. Response beneath each comment: a direct answer, stating whether the author agrees and what was done.
  4. Location of the change: page and line numbers in the revised manuscript, and where useful the new text quoted in the letter so the reviewer need not search for it.
  5. Closing paragraph: confirming that all comments have been addressed and noting any supplementary files added.

Working through the three major comments in the sample

The three revisions described in the sample are typical of reviewer requests in experimental cancer biology, and each calls for a different kind of answer.

Rationale for the control group. When a reviewer questions how controls were chosen, the response should explain the reasoning (for example, matched tissue type, cell line background or treatment exposure), cite precedent where the same design has been used, and add that justification to the methods section rather than leaving it only in the letter. If a limitation remains, acknowledging it in the discussion is more persuasive than defending the choice at length.

Revising a figure for clarity. Figure comments are usually about readability: axis labels, units, sample sizes per group, the statistical test and what the error bars represent. A good response describes exactly what was changed, for instance "panel B now shows individual data points with mean and standard deviation, and n is stated for each group in the legend", and confirms that image adjustments were applied uniformly in line with the journal's image integrity policy.

Expanding the discussion with previous studies. Reviewers often ask authors to place findings against earlier work. The response should name the studies added, explain briefly how the new results agree or differ, and avoid simply adding a list of citations. Where findings conflict with earlier reports, possible explanations such as different models, assays or patient cohorts should be stated plainly.

Disagreeing with a reviewer without damaging the review

Not every request has to be accepted. If a suggested experiment is outside the scope of the paper or not feasible, say so courteously, give the reason, and offer an alternative such as additional analysis of existing data, a sensitivity analysis or a clearer statement of limitations. Support the position with evidence and references. Avoid language that reads as dismissive, and never ignore a comment: an unanswered point is usually raised again, with less patience, in the next round.

Adapting the sample to your own revision

When using this sample as a model, keep the structure and the courteous, specific tone, but write each response for your own comments. Check the journal's revision instructions, since many ask for both a tracked-changes and a clean version of the manuscript and set a deadline for resubmission. Make sure every change promised in the letter actually appears in the manuscript, and that figure numbers and line references match the final file.

Further guidance is available in the Academy article on responding to reviewers and, if the outcome was not a revision decision, in the guide on what to do after a rejection. Authors who would like help preparing a response letter and revised manuscript can use Pubrica's responding to reviewers service.

Common questions

Should I reproduce every reviewer comment in my response letter?

Yes. Quote each comment in full and number it, even minor points such as typographical corrections. Grouping or paraphrasing comments makes it harder for the editor to check that everything has been addressed and can give the impression that difficult points are being avoided. Brief comments can receive brief answers, but each one should have its own response and a reference to where the change appears.

How long should a response to reviewers be?

Length follows the number and depth of comments, not a target page count. Each response should be long enough to state what was done and where, and to justify any disagreement with evidence. Quoting short passages of revised text is helpful; pasting whole revised sections into the letter usually is not, because the reviewer will read them in the manuscript anyway.

Get a free quote

Regulations

Check your project against this rule

  1. 1Your work
  2. 2Your details
  3. 3Send
What do you need?

Material you send is held under signed confidentiality, with access limited to the assigned team and encrypted transfer. It is not used to train anything and is not passed to third-party tools. Ask for the agreement before you send anything you would rather cover first.