Free scoping read. A written assessment of your manuscript in two business days, at no cost.

Start one
Contents

Academy · Research Writing · Levels of Edit Framework

Editing and Proofreading: The Levels of Edit Framework in Manuscript Preparation

The ‘Levels of Edit’ framework, originally developed at NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory to standardise the review of technical documents, still underlies the distinction that professional editing services draw between developmental editing, copyediting and proofreading as separate, sequential stages rather than a single undifferentiated pass. This article describes the framework and its implications for manuscript preparation.

Pubrica AcademyWritten by a scientific editing specialist Reviewed bya manuscript workflow reviewer Published10 October 2026 Last checked10 October 2026 Reading time7 minutes Sources10 peer-reviewed

Editing and proofreading are often treated as a single step, but professional editorial practice separates them into a sequence of distinct levels, each with a different scope and each best performed at a different stage of manuscript preparation. The clearest formal articulation of this idea is “The Levels of Edit”, developed by Robert Van Buren and Mary Fran Buehler at NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory to standardise technical document review across a large organisation producing high volumes of technical reports. Although written for aerospace engineering documentation, the central distinction of the framework, between edits that change content and edits that only verify surface correctness, corresponds directly to the way scientific manuscript editing is organised today.

Learning objectives

  • The origin and structure of the Levels of Edit framework
  • How developmental editing, copyediting and proofreading differ in scope and in timing
  • Why performing these stages out of sequence, such as proofreading before developmental editing is complete, wastes effort

Common misconceptions

  • “Editing and proofreading are the same task performed with different degrees of thoroughness.” The Levels of Edit framework treats them as different in kind, not merely in degree: developmental and substantive editing may change what a document says and how its argument is organised, whereas copyediting and proofreading are explicitly restricted to verifying that what the document already says is expressed correctly, consistently and without surface error.

Origins of the Levels of Edit framework

Van Buren and Buehler developed the Levels of Edit at NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory to address a practical organisational problem: technical editors reviewing a high volume of engineering and scientific reports needed a shared vocabulary to specify exactly what kind of review a given document required, since a full developmental edit takes far longer than a proofreading pass, and assigning the wrong level of effort to a document wasted editorial resources in either direction1. Their solution was to define a hierarchy of nine distinct edit types, later commonly summarised into broader tiers, ranging from the most substantive (checking content accuracy, logical organisation and clarity) to the most mechanical (checking spelling, punctuation and formatting). The lasting influence of the framework is that it reframed “editing” from a single undifferentiated task into a set of distinct, separately specifiable services, a distinction that professional editorial associations still use to define their service tiers.

Scope of each level of edit

Developmental or substantive editing operates at the level of content and argument: whether the structure of the manuscript supports its argument, whether the evidence is organised logically, whether claims are adequately supported, and whether the overall narrative is coherent. This level can involve substantial rewriting, reorganisation of entire sections and queries to the author about gaps in logic or evidence. It is explicitly content-level work, in which the editor evaluates and potentially changes what the document says, not simply how it says it, and it typically requires direct exchange with the author, since only the author can decide how to address a gap in evidence or logic that the editor has identified. Copyediting (sometimes called line editing) operates one level below: it addresses sentence-level clarity, grammar, consistency of terminology and style, and adherence to a style guide, without changing the underlying argument or structure of the manuscript. Proofreading is the narrowest and final level: it checks the manuscript as it currently stands for surface errors, such as typographical errors, formatting inconsistencies, broken cross-references and incorrect page numbers, with no mandate to query content or restructure anything. This is the scope distinction formalised in Van Buren and Buehler’s original framework and echoed in the author guidelines of the European Association of Science Editors, which separate “editing” (content- and language-level) from narrower technical and proofreading checks2.

Formalisation of the levels by professional editing bodies

The central distinction formalised by Van Buren and Buehler persists in the way professional editing organisations define their service categories and codes of practice. The Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP), a leading UK-based professional body for editors, defines a comparable spectrum running from substantive or structural editing, which can involve reorganising content and querying the author about gaps or inconsistencies in argument, through copyediting, which focuses on language, consistency and house style, to proofreading, defined specifically as checking a document intended to be in close-to-final form for remaining errors4. Amy Einsohn’s widely used reference, The Copyeditor’s Handbook, similarly separates “mechanical editing” (correctness and consistency at the sentence level) from substantive issues of organisation and content, and explicitly cautions copyeditors against undertaking substantive revision without the agreement of the author and publisher, since that work belongs to a different, earlier editorial stage with a different scope of authority5.

Worked example: substantive edit and copyedit compared

Butcher’s Copy-editing, the long-standing Cambridge University Press reference for professional copyeditors, illustrates the practical boundary with a useful test: a substantive edit can change what a sentence or paragraph says, for example by reordering an argument, cutting a redundant section or asking the author to clarify an ambiguous claim, whereas a copyedit changes only how something already decided is expressed, for example by correcting a dangling modifier, standardising “data is” versus “data are” to the convention chosen by the house style, or correcting inconsistent capitalisation of a technical term6. Applied to a manuscript, this means that a copyeditor who notices that the underlying logic of a paragraph does not support its stated conclusion has identified a substantive-level issue outside the scope of copyediting; the professional convention is to query the author rather than silently rewrite the argument, preserving the boundary between levels even when a single editor handles a manuscript at more than one stage.

Importance of sequencing the levels correctly

Because each level has a different scope, performing the levels out of order wastes effort. Proofreading a manuscript before its content and structure have been finalised through developmental editing means proofreading sentences and sections that may be substantially rewritten or deleted once structural issues are addressed, which wastes the meticulous, time-intensive attention that proofreading requires. The correct sequence runs from the broadest level to the narrowest: developmental or substantive editing first, to settle what the manuscript says and how it is organised; copyediting next, once the content is stable, to refine language and enforce consistency; and proofreading last, as the final check on a version that is not expected to change further before submission. Cochrane’s editorial process for systematic reviews follows a comparable logic, with methodological and content review occurring well before the technical, copyediting-level checks applied immediately before publication, reflecting the same principle that content review and surface-level checking are sequenced deliberately rather than combined into a single pass3. The same logic applies to an author revising a draft without external editorial assistance: completing a full pass of content revision before beginning a separate pass focused only on language and consistency, rather than alternating between the two within the same session, tends to produce a cleaner result for the same total effort. Many experienced self-editors therefore introduce a deliberate pause between the two passes, treating the change from one editorial mode to the other as a distinct transition rather than a continuation of the same activity.

Technical editing within the workflow of a biomedical journal

Many biomedical journals employ an in-house technical editing stage between acceptance and final proof, distinct from both the author’s pre-submission editing and the subsequent typesetting, which confirms that the content, data and conclusions of a manuscript match what was approved during peer review while also checking consistency, abbreviation use and reference accuracy against the journal’s house style. Wager and Middleton’s Cochrane review, despite finding limited controlled-trial evidence for the effect of the practice, surveyed the methods used across journals that employ technical editing and found that this post-acceptance, pre-production stage is typically where a journal’s own style requirements, as distinct from general correctness, are most thoroughly checked; this is one reason why a manuscript accepted by a journal may still be returned with a list of technical queries before final publication1. Understanding this stage helps authors to interpret a post-acceptance query correctly: a technical editing question does not reopen the scientific judgement of peer review; it is a check at the copyediting level described above, applied by the journal rather than by the author. This distinction also clarifies how to respond. A scientific disagreement with a reviewer’s earlier comment has no place in a reply to a technical editing query, which is restricted to accuracy, consistency and house-style compliance, and an author who treats the two kinds of post-review correspondence identically risks either reopening settled scientific debate unnecessarily or failing to engage sufficiently with a legitimate technical correction.

Key points

Key points

Developmental editing, copyediting and proofreading differ in kind rather than degree: the first may change what a manuscript says, whereas the second and third verify only that what it already says is expressed correctly. Performing them out of sequence, particularly proofreading before the content is finalised, wastes the specific and narrow attention that each level requires.

Practical application

Practical application

  1. Authors should identify which level of edit the manuscript currently requires. Where it remains uncertain whether the structure of the argument fully supports the conclusions, developmental editing is required before copyediting or proofreading, not in place of them.
  2. The editing process should be sequenced from the broadest level to the narrowest. Developmental and structural revisions should be completed first, followed by copyediting for language and consistency, with proofreading performed last, once no further content changes are expected.
  3. A proofreader should not be asked to evaluate the logic of an argument. Proofreading is limited to surface correctness; feedback on whether an argument is coherent is a matter for developmental editing and should be requested as such.

Frequently asked questions

Copyediting addresses sentence-level clarity, grammar and consistency, and can involve rewriting individual sentences for readability; proofreading is narrower still, checking the manuscript as it currently stands for surface errors such as typographical errors and formatting inconsistencies, without rewriting sentences for style.

Because the underlying problem, the need to specify precisely which kind of review a document requires, is not specific to any one field; the distinction between content-level and surface-level review applies to any technical or scientific writing, which is why editorial associations in scientific publishing still use a comparable tiered structure.

Yes, but performing the levels in the correct sequence, and deliberately changing approach between levels, matters more than who performs each one; attempting all three simultaneously in a single reading risks the same kind of oversight that makes self-proofreading generally unreliable.

No. A technical editing query is limited to accuracy, consistency and house-style compliance, operating at the copyediting level; it does not invite reconsideration of the scientific judgement already made in peer review, and it should be answered accordingly rather than treated as a new round of scientific debate.

No. Professional practice, as reflected in references such as Butcher’s Copy-editing, treats this as a substantive-level issue outside the scope of copyediting; the convention is to query the author rather than silently rewrite the underlying argument.

References

  1. Van Buren R, Buehler MF. The Levels of Edit. 2nd ed. Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology; 1980. JPL Publication 80-1. read 10 October 2026. View on NASA Technical Reports Server
  2. European Association of Science Editors. EASE Guidelines for Authors and Translators of Scientific Articles. read 10 October 2026. View EASE Guidelines
  3. Cochrane. Cochrane Editorial and Publishing Policy Resource: Editorial Process for Cochrane Reviews. read 10 October 2026. View Cochrane Editorial Policy
  4. Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP). Editorial Skills: Defining Editing and Proofreading. read 10 October 2026. View CIEP Editorial Skills Guidance
  5. Einsohn A, Schwartz M. The Copyeditor's Handbook: A Guide for Book Publishing and Corporate Communications. 4th ed. University of California Press; 2019. read 10 October 2026. View publisher page
  6. Butcher J, Drake C, Leach M. Butcher's Copy-editing: The Cambridge Handbook for Editors, Copy-editors and Proofreaders. 4th ed. Cambridge University Press; 2006. read 10 October 2026. View publisher page
  7. International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing, and Publication of Scholarly Work in Medical Journals. read 10 October 2026. View ICMJE Recommendations
  8. Wager E, Middleton P. Technical editing of research reports in biomedical journals. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. 2008;(4):MR000002. read 10 October 2026. View Cochrane Review
  9. Pitkin RM, Branagan MA, Burmeister LF. Accuracy of data in abstracts of papers presented at scientific meetings. JAMA. 1999;281(12):1110-1111. read 10 October 2026. View on JAMA
  10. Council of Science Editors. Scientific Style and Format: The CSE Manual for Authors, Editors, and Publishers. read 10 October 2026. View Scientific Style and Format

Every source above is a peer-reviewed article, a publisher’s record of one, or a standard issued by the body that owns it. Each carries the date it was last read. Where a standard moves, this article is revised rather than left up with a note.

How to cite this article

Pick your referencing style and copy it. Your university or target journal may vary the punctuation — check its guide if it has one.

Pubrica Academy. (2026, October 10). Editing and Proofreading: The Levels of Edit Framework in Manuscript Preparation. Pubrica. https://pubrica.com/academy/study-guide/editing-and-proof-reading/

This article is written to be learned from. Cite it if you are referring to what it says; if you are using the evidence behind it, cite the sources listed above instead.

Levels of Edit Sequencing Checklist

This checklist confirms whether a manuscript is at the appropriate stage for the editing request being made.

[ ] Confirmed content and argument structure are finalized before requesting copyediting
[ ] Confirmed language and consistency are finalized before requesting proofreading
[ ] Specified to any editor or service exactly which level of edit is being requested
[ ] Avoided requesting proofreading-level feedback on content or argument structure
[ ] Scheduled editing stages sequentially, not simultaneously, to avoid wasted effort on content that may still change

Pubrica AcademyWritten and maintained by Pubrica’s subject matter experts. Articles are revised when the underlying standards change, and each article states the date on which it was last reviewed.

How Pubrica can help

Pubrica’s editorial team offers each level of edit (developmental editing, copyediting and proofreading) as a distinct, clearly scoped service, and assists authors in identifying which stage a manuscript requires before work begins.

Find something else

Search the Pubrica Academy

Access is free and requires no account. Enter a topic, or open the full library to filter by category, sub-topic or resource type.

Selection of the appropriate level of edit for each stage of manuscript preparation

A scoping assessment is free and takes two business days. It provides a written assessment of what the work requires and which specialist would undertake it.

Get a free quote

Regulations

Check your project against this rule

  1. 1Your work
  2. 2Your details
  3. 3Send
What do you need?

Material you send is held under signed confidentiality, with access limited to the assigned team and encrypted transfer. It is not used to train anything and is not passed to third-party tools. Ask for the agreement before you send anything you would rather cover first.