Contents
On this page
Academy · Research Publication · Open Access vs Traditional
Open Access or Traditional Journals: Compliance, Cost and Legitimacy in Journal Selection
Plan S is an open-access initiative supported by cOAlition S, a group of research funding organisations. The choice between open access and a traditional subscription journal is often a compliance question rather than purely a matter of preference, and it should be checked before a journal shortlist is finalized.
The choice between an open-access journal and a traditional subscription journal is no longer purely a matter of author preference, because a growing number of funders and institutions, under initiatives such as Plan S, now require publicly funded research to be made openly accessible on publication or within a defined embargo period. The Budapest Open Access Initiative, which first articulated the open-access model in 2002, defines open access as free, immediate, online availability of research with the right to read, download, copy and distribute it, and this founding definition remains the reference point from which most funder and institutional open-access policies are derived1. Before cost, prestige and audience reach are weighed, the first and decisive step is to establish whether a funder or institutional mandate already determines the choice for a given manuscript.
Learning objectives
- The requirements of the founding definition of open access in the Budapest Open Access Initiative
- The specific requirements of Plan S and the means of establishing whether it applies to a given source of funding
- The practical trade-offs (cost, reach and perceived prestige) that remain once compliance is established
Common misconceptions
- “Open access versus traditional publishing is purely a matter of personal preference.” cOAlition S, a group of national and international research funders, has committed to Plan S, which requires open-access publication of the research it funds. The definition of the Budapest Open Access Initiative underlying these mandates has been adopted in some form by a large and growing number of institutional and funder policies worldwide, so for an author working under an affected grant the choice is frequently a compliance requirement rather than a free preference.
Definition of open access in the Budapest Open Access Initiative
The Budapest Open Access Initiative, drafted in 2002 by a group of researchers and open-access advocates, defines open access as the free availability of research literature on the public internet, permitting any user to read, download, copy, distribute, print, search or link to the full texts, crawl them for indexing and pass them as data to software, without financial, legal or technical barriers other than internet access itself1. The initiative’s statement distinguishes this from merely making a paper free to read, since the broader rights to copy, distribute and reuse are a defining element of the original definition rather than an optional addition; “open access” in its strict founding sense is therefore a more demanding standard than the removal of a paywall1. The Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ) screens journals against criteria consistent with this standard of open licensing and transparency before indexing them, so DOAJ status is a useful first check when evaluating whether a specific open-access journal meets the definition it claims to follow2.
Plan S and the applicability of funder mandates
cOAlition S is a coalition of national and international research funders and organisations that committed in 2018 to implementing Plan S, a set of principles requiring that research outputs arising from their funding be published in compliant open-access journals or platforms, or made openly accessible through compliant repositories, typically without a long embargo period3. Because each funder implements Plan S through its own policy rather than as a single universal rule, the practical first step for any author with external funding is to consult that funder’s current open-access policy directly, rather than assuming either that Plan S applies automatically or that it does not3. Many funder policies also specify which licensing terms are compliant (commonly a CC BY licence) and whether publication in a traditional subscription journal remains acceptable provided that the author also deposits a compliant version in an open repository, which is a materially different requirement from publication in a fully open-access journal3.
Trade-offs between cost and reach once compliance is established
Once any applicable mandate has been identified and addressed, the remaining decision involves concrete, verifiable trade-offs. Open-access journals typically levy an article-processing charge (APC) paid by the author or the author’s institution rather than relying on reader subscriptions, and these fees vary widely between publishers and journals, from modest amounts to several thousand dollars; a direct comparison of costs against any available institutional open-access fund is therefore an essential early step2. Open-access journals generally offer broader, unrestricted readership, including readers outside subscribing institutions, which may be important for research of direct relevance to public health, policy or practice, whereas some traditional subscription journals in certain fields retain greater prestige among specific review committees, a factor that the survey of researcher priorities discussed elsewhere in this cluster found to be rated highly but not independently of scope fit and review reliability4.
Verification of journal legitimacy irrespective of publication model
Because the growth of open-access publishing has been accompanied by predatory publishers exploiting the author-pays model, verification of any open-access journal through DOAJ indexing, the Think.Check.Submit checklist and COPE (Committee on Publication Ethics) membership is a necessary step before submission, as it is for a traditional journal, and the warning signs discussed elsewhere in this cluster (unverifiable editorial boards, opaque fees, aggressive solicitation) apply equally to open-access titles56. A legitimate traditional subscription journal is not inherently a safer choice by virtue of its model; the same verification checklist applies irrespective of the path to which a funding mandate or personal preference ultimately leads.
Hybrid and green open access as intermediate options
Between a fully open-access journal and a fully closed subscription journal lies an intermediate category that should be considered before the choice is assumed to be binary. A hybrid journal is a subscription journal that offers an open-access option for individual articles in return for an article-processing charge, so that an author may publish in a traditional subscription title while making the specific article openly accessible; the Plan S implementation guidance of cOAlition S has historically treated hybrid open access with specific conditions and transitional arrangements rather than full, unconditional endorsement, so a funder’s current position on hybrid journals should be checked rather than assumed3. Green open access, by contrast, refers to the deposit of a version of the manuscript, typically the author’s final accepted version rather than the publisher’s formatted version, in an institutional or subject repository, often after an embargo period specified by a subscription publisher; this route can satisfy some funder mandates without requiring publication in an open-access journal.
Determining which of these routes (gold, a fully open-access journal; hybrid; or green, repository deposit) satisfies a specific funder’s or institution’s mandate requires reading the current text of that mandate, since the acceptable routes and embargo terms vary between funders and have changed over time as the implementation of Plan S has evolved3. An author who assumes that “my funder requires open access” necessarily means “I must publish in a gold open-access journal” may overlook a green-route option that permits publication in a preferred traditional subscription journal while meeting the mandate through a timed repository deposit, a materially different and sometimes less costly means of satisfying the same requirement.
A funder’s position on all three routes (gold, hybrid and green), together with its position on acceptable licences and the permitted length of any embargo period, should be checked early enough in a project for the answer to inform where the manuscript is submitted, rather than being discovered only after a preferred traditional journal has been chosen and a conflict with the mandate emerges. Many funders and institutions now publish this policy as a short, regularly updated page rather than a single static document, which indicates that a mandate’s requirements should be rechecked close to the time of submission rather than recalled from the policy in force when the grant was awarded, since the terms have changed as the implementation of Plan S has matured since 2018.
Authors should also check whether their institution, as distinct from their funder, maintains a separate open-access policy or repository mandate, since university-level and funder-level requirements are not always identical and a manuscript may in principle be subject to both simultaneously. Many universities maintain an institutional repository and a green open-access policy of their own, independent of the terms of any specific grant, so an author whose current project does not carry externally mandated open-access funding may nonetheless have an institutional deposit requirement to satisfy. Both levels, funder and institution, should therefore be checked rather than assuming that compliance with one ensures compliance with the other, since the two requirements, although related, are enforced and monitored separately. The institution’s research office is usually the most direct source of a definitive answer regarding its current policy, and is more reliable than a colleague’s recollection of the requirements of an earlier grant cycle.
Key points
Key points
Any applicable funder or institutional open-access mandate should be checked first, since it may resolve the question directly. Article-processing costs should then be weighed against broader readership and any remaining considerations of prestige, and legitimacy should be verified through DOAJ, Think.Check.Submit and COPE status irrespective of the model chosen.
Practical application
Practical application
- The specific open-access policy of the funder should be checked before a journal shortlist is compiled. Plan S and similar mandates are implemented by individual funders, so the current requirement should be confirmed rather than assumed to apply or not to apply.
- Article-processing charges should be budgeted early against any available institutional open-access fund. Article-processing charges (APCs) vary widely between publishers, so an actual cost figure should be obtained before a specific open-access journal is selected.
- Legitimacy should be verified through DOAJ, Think.Check.Submit and COPE irrespective of the model chosen. Predatory practices occur specifically in open-access publishing, but the same verification checklist applies to any journal, whether open access or subscription-based.
Frequently asked questions
No; many funder policies under Plan S permit publication in a subscription journal provided that the author also deposits a compliant version (often the accepted manuscript) in an open repository, so the specific funder’s policy should be checked rather than assuming that subscription journals are automatically excluded.
No; publishing model and quality are independent, verifiable attributes of a journal, and the criteria for evaluating legitimacy (verifiability of the editorial board, transparency of peer review, DOAJ and COPE status) apply equally to both models.
This varies: the charge may be paid by the author, by the institution’s open-access fund or directly by the funder, depending on institutional and funder policy, so the funding available for APCs should be checked before submission to avoid an unexpected cost after acceptance.
References
- Budapest Open Access Initiative (BOAI). Budapest Open Access Initiative, 2002, and the 2012 and 2022 recommendations. read 10 October 2026. View BOAI
- Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ). About DOAJ and inclusion criteria for indexed journals. read 10 October 2026. View on DOAJ
- cOAlition S. Plan S: Making full and immediate Open Access a reality. read 10 October 2026. View coalition-s.org
- Rowley J, Sbaffi L, Sugden M, Gilbert A. Factors influencing researchers' journal selection decisions. Journal of Information Science. 2022;48(3):321-335. read 10 October 2026. View on Journal of Information Science
- Think.Check.Submit. A checklist for researchers to identify trusted journals and publishers for their research. read 10 October 2026. View Think.Check.Submit
- Grudniewicz A, Moher D, Cobey KD, et al. Predatory journals: no definition, no defence. Nature. 2019;576:210-213. read 10 October 2026. View on Nature
- COPE, DOAJ, OASPA, WAME. Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing. read 10 October 2026. View on OASPA
- San Francisco Declaration on Research Assessment (DORA). Putting science into the assessment of research. read 10 October 2026. View DORA
- Clarivate. Journal Citation Reports: Impact Factor basics [LibGuide]. read 10 October 2026. View on Clarivate
- International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE). Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing, and Publication of Scholarly Work in Medical Journals. read 10 October 2026. View the ICMJE Recommendations (PDF)
Every source above is a peer-reviewed article, a publisher’s record of one, or a standard issued by the body that owns it. Each carries the date it was last read. Where a standard moves, this article is revised rather than left up with a note.
How to cite this article
Pick your referencing style and copy it. Your university or target journal may vary the punctuation — check its guide if it has one.
Pubrica Academy. (2026, October 10). Open Access or Traditional Journals: Compliance, Cost and Legitimacy in Journal Selection. Pubrica. https://pubrica.com/academy/open-access-vs-traditional-journals-guide/
Pubrica Academy. “Open Access or Traditional Journals: Compliance, Cost and Legitimacy in Journal Selection.” Pubrica, 10 Oct. 2026, pubrica.com/academy/open-access-vs-traditional-journals-guide/.
Pubrica Academy (2026) Open Access or Traditional Journals: Compliance, Cost and Legitimacy in Journal Selection. Pubrica. Available at: https://pubrica.com/academy/open-access-vs-traditional-journals-guide/ (Accessed: 15 October 2026).
Pubrica Academy. “Open Access or Traditional Journals: Compliance, Cost and Legitimacy in Journal Selection.” Pubrica. October 10, 2026. https://pubrica.com/academy/open-access-vs-traditional-journals-guide/
Pubrica Academy, ‘Open Access or Traditional Journals: Compliance, Cost and Legitimacy in Journal Selection’ (Pubrica, 10 October 2026) <https://pubrica.com/academy/open-access-vs-traditional-journals-guide/> accessed 15 October 2026.
Pubrica Academy. Open Access or Traditional Journals: Compliance, Cost and Legitimacy in Journal Selection. [Internet]. Pubrica; 2026 Oct 10 [cited 2026 Oct 15]. Available from: https://pubrica.com/academy/open-access-vs-traditional-journals-guide/
Pubrica Academy, “Open Access or Traditional Journals: Compliance, Cost and Legitimacy in Journal Selection,” Pubrica, Oct. 10, 2026. [Online]. Available: https://pubrica.com/academy/open-access-vs-traditional-journals-guide/
@misc{/la_open_access_vs_traditional_journals_guide_2026,
author = {{Pubrica Academy}},
title = {Open Access or Traditional Journals: Compliance, Cost and Legitimacy in Journal Selection},
howpublished = {Pubrica},
year = {2026},
month = {oct},
url = {https://pubrica.com/academy/open-access-vs-traditional-journals-guide/},
note = {Accessed: <span data-cite-acc="iso">2026-10-15</span>}
}This article is written to be learned from. Cite it if you are referring to what it says; if you are using the evidence behind it, cite the sources listed above instead.
Open Access Compliance Checklist
This checklist should be completed before a choice is made between an open-access and a traditional journal.
[ ] Checked your funder's specific current open-access policy [ ] Confirmed whether a repository deposit can satisfy the mandate instead of direct OA publication [ ] Checked available institutional open-access funding for any article-processing charge [ ] Verified the specific open-access journal via DOAJ, Think.Check.Submit, and COPE status [ ] Compared readership reach against any remaining prestige considerations for your field [ ] Confirmed licensing terms (e.g., CC BY) meet your funder's specific requirement
Pubrica AcademyWritten and maintained by Pubrica’s subject matter experts. Articles are revised when the underlying standards change, and each article states the date on which it was last reviewed.
How Pubrica can help
Pubrica’s publication strategy team checks funder and institutional open-access mandates against the specific circumstances of a manuscript and then verifies the legitimacy of candidate open-access journals before a final submission decision is made.