Targeted literature searches are a fundamental part of writing clinical manuscripts that will meet the standards of high-quality journals and contribute meaningfully to evidence-based practice. When physicians write clinical manuscripts, utilizing a targeted literature search can identify high-quality, relevant, and current evidence. While a general literature review is useful, a targeted literature search is specific to the clinical question and should be completed through frameworks established, such as PICO (Population, Intervention, Comparator, Outcome) and PRISMA[1].
Choosing the Right Journal Based on Manuscript Type: A Must-Know Guide for Authors
- Home
- Academy
- Research Impact
- Choosing the Right Journal Based on Manuscript Type: A Must-Know Guide for Authors
High-Impact Journals
Interesting topics
Choosing the Right Journal Based on Manuscript Type: A Must-Know Guide for Authors
Choosing the right journal for your manuscript is an essential part of the scholarly publishing process. Most manuscript rejections are not due to the quality of the research, but instead from mistake of selecting journals that do not fit the manuscript type. In this guide, we provide authors guidance on the specifics of journal selection, distinctions of the right manuscript types, and tips that can help authors successfully submit a manuscript. [1]
1. Common Types of Manuscripts
It is important to understand manuscript classification first before choosing a specific journal to approach. Many journals indicate the types they accept, and approaching a journal that is not in your classification may lead to desk rejection.
| Manuscript Type | Purpose | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Original Research Article | Reports new, significant, and complete findings | Clinical trial, experimental lab study |
| Review Article | Summarizes and evaluates existing research | Systematic review, scoping review |
| Case Report | Describes a rare or unusual case | Uncommon disease presentation |
| Short Communication | Brief report of new research findings or methodologies | Preliminary results, protocol reports |
| Technical Note | Describes a new technique or modification to existing methods | Novel imaging procedure |
| Perspective/Opinion | Author’s viewpoint or theoretical insight on current issues | AI in healthcare ethics |
| Editorial/Commentary | Invited pieces commenting on published articles or field developments | Response to a research article |
| Letter to the Editor | Critical comments on previously published works | Concern about statistical interpretation |
2. Why Submitting to the Wrong Journal Type Leads to Failure
High-quality manuscripts can still be rejected if submitted to the wrong journal. If the content and the journal’s scope do not match, the potential for visibility and acceptance is diminished.
- Desk Rejection: When editors determine the content is out of scope and reject prior to peer review.
- Publication Delays: Months check and review for a wasted cycle. If the paper is still rejected there is no forward action.
- Reduced Research Visibility: Publishing in non-indexed journals or journals with severely limited reach chances to be cited by other researchers is compromised.
- Credibility Loss: Publishers submitting and resubmitting, when gaps between prior journal and publishing reputations, only showcases insufficient academic strategy.
3. How to Check If Your Manuscript Type Is Accepted by the Journal
To make certain that the manuscript type is harmonized with the journal’s published requirements prior to submitting the manuscript, complete the following four steps.[2]
3.1. Check the "Aims and Scope" Section
Defines, quite clearly, the domain, audience, and structure and type of articles being looked for. Often found on the journal landing page or publisher website.
3.2. Review "Instructions for Authors"
Includes the possible manuscript types (including word limits, abstract format, section headings, etc.).
3.3. Review Recently Published Articles
Look back through the last 6-12 months of published articles – look for the standard article formats and general topics.
3.4. Use Journal Match Tools
Elsevier Journal Finder, Springer Journal Suggester, Wiley Author Services.Input title, abstract and keywords, and the tools will suggest journals.
3.5. Example Table – Journal Acceptance Mapping
| Journal Name | Accepted Manuscript Types | Scope Keywords |
|---|---|---|
| The Lancet | Original, Review, Commentaries | Global health, clinical trials |
| PLOS ONE | Original Research, Protocols, Data Papers | Multidisciplinary science |
| BMJ Case Reports | Case Reports, Clinical Images | Clinical observations, rare conditions |
| IEEE Access | Technical Articles, Review Articles | Engineering, AI, hardware systems |
4. Pubrica Tips for Successful Submission
Pubrica promotes a deliberate stepwise method for authors looking to maximize acceptance and visibility for the article they submit. The steps in Pubrica’s Journal Selection Checklist are as follows: Match the type of manuscript with the Journal description and scope in the journal. Check the Impact Factor, indexing (Scopus, Web of Science) Check the review times and acceptance rate Check that it is not a predatory journal (use the DOAJ or COPE guidelines), Decide whether the journal is open access or subscription model depending on your fundi.
4.1. Focus on One Key Message
Pubrica’s Top 5 Submission Strategies
- Pre-Screen Multiple Journals
Develop 3 tiers of journal lists – primary, secondary, B-level options.
- Match Manuscript Style to Target Journal
Align to the journal’s format, citations, and organization style.
- Include SEO Title and Abstract.
Include 3-5 keywords in the title and abstract to increase the visibility/discoverability.
- Explain the Relevance of Your Manuscript in the Cover Letter
Provide the editor with 1-2 sentences to demonstrate why this article is relevant to the journal’s audience.
- Edit Language from a Professional
Use a professional scientific editing service to comply with the journal’s grammatical requirements.
5. Common Mistakes to Avoid
Failing to follow the target journal’s author guidelines and formatting requirements is one of the most common mistakes in journal submission. [3]
6. Summary Table: Journal Selection Strategy
| Step | Action |
|---|---|
| Identify Manuscript Type | Classify: Original, Review, Case Report, Commentary, etc. |
| Shortlist Journals | Based on scope, indexing, and review time. |
| Verify Acceptance Criteria | Check the “For Authors” section and recent issues. |
| Customize Submission | Tailor the title, abstract, formatting, and cover letter. |
| Use Editorial Support | Consider Pubrica’s editing and submission support services. |
Connect with us to explore how we can support you in maintaining academic integrity and enhancing the visibility of your research across the world!
Conclusion
Selecting a journal appropriate for your manuscript type is arguably the first and most important step to circumvent rejection, time lost and disappearing visibility. You will want to match your paper to the scope of the journal, identify their format and article types. Find journal finder tools using the journal’s name or your keyword search terms, examine their submission guidelines and consider hiring an expert service such as Pubrica’s journal selection service to help you with manuscript transitions and optimize your chances of successful publication.
Choosing the Right Journal Based on Manuscript Type: A Must-Know Guide for Authors? Pubrica offers end-to-end research design, analysis, and reporting support.
References
- Sands, L. P. (2019). How to choose the right journal for your manuscript. Innovation in Aging, 3(Supplement_1), S223–S223. https://doi.org/10.1093/geroni/igz038.820
- Lee, K. P., Boyd, E. A., Holroyd-Leduc, J. M., Bacchetti, P., & Bero, L. A. (2006). Predictors of publication: characteristics of submitted manuscripts associated with acceptance at major biomedical journals. The Medical Journal of Australia, 184(12), 621–626. https://doi.org/10.5694/j.1326-5377.2006.tb00418.x
- Kirillova, O. V., & Association of Scientific Editors and Publishers (ASEP). (2019). How to avoid mistakes when preparing a journal to submit to Scopus. Science Editor and Publisher, 4(3–4), 169–188. https://doi.org/10.24069/2542-0267-2019-3-4-169-188