Free scoping read. A written assessment of your manuscript in two business days, at no cost.

Start one
Home·Services·Publication support·Understanding WAME

Navigating WAME: Essential Insights for Medical Editors

The World Association of Medical Editors is a voluntary association of editors that publishes policy statements rather than enforcing standards. Seventeen statements are currently in force, covering editorial independence and conflict of interest. Peer review manipulation, predatory journals and generative artificial intelligence are also addressed. Their value to an author lies in being published: a journal's conduct can be measured against a written standard it did not write itself.

What you will learn
  • Which policy statements WAME maintains, and what each one requires
  • How WAME defines conflict of interest, and why its test is broader than financial disclosure
  • What the 2015 recommendations on reviewer selection anticipated, and what later evidence showed
What to unlearn
  • “WAME enforces standards on journals.” It is a voluntary association that issues recommendations. Its own code of conduct describes no sanction and no enforcement process.
  • “WAME prescribes reporting checklists such as CONSORT.” Its published statements govern editorial conduct and journal policy. Reporting guidelines are maintained separately and selected by study design.

What this article covers

This article describes an organisation through its published instruments. WAME issues policy statements for medical journal editors, and those statements are public documents with dates and identifiable authors. Each is examined here for what it actually requires and what it leaves to the journal. The use an author can make of it is given alongside. The treatment is descriptive rather than promotional. The documents themselves are more useful than any summary of their purpose.

Two framing points shape the rest. The first is that WAME has no enforcement power, which is a limitation and also the source of its usefulness. A published recommendation that no one is compelled to follow is still a standard against which conduct can be compared. The second is that several statements are old and have been revised, so the dates matter and are given throughout.

One topic is deliberately excluded from this account. Reporting guidelines such as the trial, observational and systematic review checklists are maintained by other bodies. They are selected by study design, not by editorial association. They are covered in separate articles and are not among WAME's policy instruments.

Where this sits among the related articles

The declarations a submission carries, and the measured effect of naming reviewers, are covered in the journal submission process. The surrounding publication sequence is covered in the process of publishing a research paper. The checklist for randomised trials, and the designs it does not cover, are set out in CONSORT 2025.

Understanding WAME and Its Policies (infographic)
Understanding WAME and Its Policies (infographic)

The association and its instruments

WAME publishes its policy statements in a single indexed section, grouped by subject. Seventeen statements are listed there as currently in force.1 Two further statements are marked archived, having been incorporated into later documents.1 The grouping is practical rather than theoretical, and it maps onto the problems editors actually encounter.

The published policy set

Six statements sit under ethics and professionalism.1 They cover generative artificial intelligence, predatory journals and transparency.1 A code of conduct, publication ethics policies and the editor-owner relationship complete the group.1 Two concern authors, addressing authorship and ghost writing initiated by commercial companies.1 Two address conflict of interest, one as policy and one as an editorial.1 Three concern global health and political interference.1 Two cover peer review, and two cover impact factor and trial registration.1

The archived pair illustrates how the set has consolidated. A statement on free journal access for poor nations was superseded by one on promoting global health.1 A statement on the responsibilities of medical editors was superseded by the professionalism code of conduct.1 Superseded documents remain visible rather than being deleted, which allows a reader to see what changed.

The code that defines the editor's role

The professionalism code was approved in May 2016 and sets out the editor's duties directly.2 Editors are “accountable and responsible for what they publish”.2 They should use rigorous evaluation and peer review, and correct or retract publications as needed.2 They should establish and disseminate clear and transparent policies for editors, authors and reviewers.2 They should ensure the journal is editorially independent from publishers, owners, corporations and industry.2

Two provisions are less commonly quoted and are worth noting. The code asks editors to pursue lifelong learning and teaching, both formal and informal.2 It also asks them to seek representation of authors, reviewers and editorial board members from low and middle income countries.2 The second provision bears on who gets published and who assesses the work.

The recommendations a journal is asked to adopt

A separate document recommends the policies a journal should itself publish.3 Documented review and approval from a formally constituted review board should be required for all studies involving people.3 Data and records must be retained and produced for review on request.3 Journals should publish guidance on what constitutes authorship.3 The corresponding author should be required to state the specific contribution each author made.3 Journals should discourage the award of honorary authorship.3

The requirements for peer review are equally specific. Reviewers should be experts in the scientific topic they review.3 There is no role for review by individuals with a major competing interest in the subject.3 The submitted manuscript is a privileged communication and reviewers must treat it as confidential.3 Editors should strongly consider having a statistician review reports of original research.3 Journals should publish annual audits of acceptance rates and publication intervals.3

The absence of enforcement

No sanction accompanies any of this, and none is implied. The professionalism code describes no enforcement process and no penalty for breach.2 The publication ethics recommendations state the limit plainly in the context of misconduct. Journals do not have the resources or authority to conduct a formal judicial inquiry.3 They are advised instead to share reasonable concerns with those who can investigate.3

WAME also acts jointly with other bodies. It is one of four organisations issuing a statement of transparency principles.4 The others are the publication ethics committee, the open access directory and the open access publishers association.4 That statement sets out sixteen principles, and version three was published in January 2018.4 Joint issue gives a recommendation wider reach without giving it force.

Figures: WAME policies at a glance

Figure 1 groups WAME’s current policy statements by subject. Figure 2 sets one of its recommendations on reviewer selection against later evidence. Authors and editors can use them to find the relevant guidance quickly and to see where it has been tested.

Figure 1 · The policy set, by subject

Seventeen statements currently in force, with two further statements retained as superseded.

Seventeen current statements, in six groupsETHICS AND PROFESSIONALISM · 6Generative AI and chatbotsPredatory or pseudo-journalsPrinciples of transparencyProfessionalism code of conductPublication ethics policiesEditors-in-chief and ownersAUTHORS · 2AuthorshipGhost writing by companiesARCHIVED, SUPERSEDED · 2Free journal access for poor nationsResponsibilities of medical editorsCONFLICTS OF INTEREST · 2Conflict of interest policyConflict of interest editorialGLOBAL HEALTH AND POLITICS · 3Geopolitical intrusion on decisionsPromoting global healthGlobal health editorialPEER REVIEW · 2Definition of a peer-reviewed journalReviewer selection and manipulationOTHER ISSUES · 2Impact factorRegistration of clinical trialsSuperseded statements remain published rather than being withdrawn.

What to look for. The distribution shows where editorial difficulty concentrates. Ethics and professionalism carries six statements between them. Conflict of interest carries two despite being a single subject, because the association issued both a policy and an editorial defending it. Three statements concern political and geographic pressure on editorial decisions. That is a larger share than the subject usually receives in guidance written for authors.

This is a schematic of the published index, with titles shortened. The index itself gives the full wording, and the archived pair with their superseding documents.

Figure 2 · A 2015 recommendation and the 2022 evidence

WAME's safeguard on reviewer selection, set against an analysis published seven years later.

THE RECOMMENDATION · APPROVED JANUARY 2015“Peer review of a manuscript should include at least onereviewer not suggested by the author.”THE EVIDENCE · 7,965 MANUSCRIPTS, ANALYSED 2022All author-suggested89%All editor-suggested67%0255075100Per cent acceptance

What to look for. The recommendation was issued on prudential grounds, before any analysis at this scale existed. The later study did not set out to test it. The gap of 22 percentage points is an association rather than a demonstrated effect of the rule. The sequence is nonetheless instructive. A safeguard adopted because the risk seemed plausible was followed by evidence that the risk is measurable.

The two sources are independent and were not produced together. The acceptance figures describe one section of one large journal and should not be read as a general rate.

Editorial independence and the owner relationship

The oldest statement in the set addresses the relationship between an editor-in-chief and whoever owns the journal. It was posted in June 2000 and revised twice, in May 2006 and July 2009.5 It was formerly titled editorial independence, and the retitling signals its approach. The document treats independence as a property of a relationship rather than as a unilateral right.

The division of authority

The central provision is stated in one sentence. Editors-in-chief “should have full authority over the editorial content of the journal”.5 The corresponding restriction on owners is equally direct. Owners “should not interfere in the evaluation, selection or editing of individual articles”.5 A second restriction covers indirect pressure, since owners should not create an environment in which editorial decisions are strongly influenced.5

The basis for decisions follows from that division. Decisions should rest on the validity of the work and its importance to readers.5 The owner's policies and profits are excluded from that basis.5 The same requirement appears in the publication ethics recommendations.3 Decisions should be based only on importance, originality, clarity and relevance.3 Advertising is addressed separately, and editorial decisions should not be influenced by advertising revenue or reprint potential.3

Appointment, dismissal and written terms

The statement does not pretend that editors are unaccountable. Owners have the right to hire and fire editors-in-chief, but should dismiss them only for substantial reasons.5 Dismissal should follow a deliberate process rather than a summary decision.5 The relationship itself should rest on mutual respect and trust, and on recognition of each other's authority and responsibilities.5

Three structural safeguards are recommended to protect that arrangement. The editor's employment terms should be agreed in writing by both parties before appointment.5 The terms covering editorial freedom should be made known to readers.5 Editors should report to the owner's highest governing body rather than to an intermediate manager.5 An independent oversight committee operating transparently is suggested as a further protection.5

The limit the statement concedes

One recommendation acknowledges that independence is not absolute. Editors for their part should accept all legitimate viewpoints.5 The statement also recognises that owners cannot retain editors who consistently oppose the organisation's core values.5 The corresponding obligation falls on the editor. Editors should resist actions that compromise these principles, and report major transgressions to the wider medical and academic community.5 That reporting duty is the only enforcement mechanism the document contains, and it operates through publicity rather than through sanction.

The author's use for the statement

The statement concerns editors, but it gives an author a checkable question. A journal that publishes the terms of its editorial freedom has done something specific and verifiable. A journal owned by a body with an interest in particular findings is in a different position. If it is silent on how that interest is managed, it has done nothing checkable. The document supplies the standard against which the silence can be judged.

Conflict of interest as WAME defines it

The conflict of interest policy was approved in March 2009 and updated in July of the same year.6 It is the most carefully drafted document in the set, and its definition does more work than the familiar disclosure checkbox suggests.

The definition and its test

Conflict of interest is defined as a divergence between two things.6 They are an individual's private interests and their responsibilities to scientific and publishing activities.6 The divergence matters where it is such that “a reasonable observer might wonder” whether the individual's behaviour or judgement was motivated by competing interests.6 The test the definition applies is therefore an external one. It does not ask whether judgement was in fact affected, which no one can establish. It asks whether an informed onlooker would reasonably raise the question.

Interests beyond the financial

The policy argues that journals concentrate too narrowly. Attention commonly falls on payments, stock, patents and industry or government funding.6 WAME holds that other competing interests can be equally damaging and equally hidden.6 The examples given are academic commitments and personal relationships.6 Political or religious beliefs and institutional affiliations are named alongside them.6 Journals are advised to cover these as well as the financial ones.6

Disclosure obligations extend across the whole publication process. Authors must report financial conflicts related to the research and its write-up, together with other relevant competing interests.6 Reviewers must state any conflict with the manuscript's content or its authors.6 Journals must also ask for funding sources, and whether the funder took part in data collection, analysis or reporting.6

The handling of editorial conflicts

Editors are covered by the same rule and by a stricter procedure. An editor should not decide or participate in the process for such a manuscript.6 The bar applies where the editor or a close family member has a conflict.6 Where an editor submits their own work, a colleague should handle it.6 The editor should step back from both discussion and decision.6 Submissions from the editor's own department or a small institution require policies set in advance.6

Several recommendations concern what the journal publishes about itself. Journals should publish their own definition and their policies.6 The standard applied to financial conflicts should be given, including any look-back period.6 Those policies should be easy to find, ideally in the instructions for authors.6 Journals should state what happens if an undisclosed conflict later emerges, including investigation and correction.6 They should also be explicit about which conflicts prevent consideration altogether.6

Reviewer selection carries one further specific caution. Journals should generally avoid reviewers from the authors' institution.6 The exception is an institution large enough that the two are not working colleagues.6 This connects the conflict policy to the reviewer selection statement discussed below. That statement treats the same problem from the other direction.

Safeguards against peer review manipulation

One statement in the set addresses a specific fraud. Authors have on occasion supplied reviewer names attached to email addresses they themselves controlled, and then reviewed their own manuscripts. The recommendations were approved by the ethics and policy committee in January 2015 and posted that April.7

The 2015 recommendations

The central safeguard is a composition rule. Peer review of a manuscript “should include at least one reviewer not suggested by the author”.7 A second rule limits when a suggestion may be used at all. An editor should only use author-suggested reviewers where the editor is already familiar with them.7 That familiarity extends to their conflicts of interest and their contact details.7

Verification carries most of the weight. An author-recommended reviewer should not be used unless the contact information comes from an independently validated source.7 The examples given are the reviewer's own publications, or a referral from the journal's editorial board.7 Editors are advised to treat generic email domains with caution.7 They are told at the same time not to require institutional addresses.7 Reviewers should be encouraged to enrol in a persistent identifier scheme, with attention to misrepresented identifiers.7

The statement is careful about inference. A wrong email address should prompt a request for explanation from the author.7 A typographical error or an outdated address does not demonstrate intent to deceive.7 Where deception appears deliberate, editors are advised to take further steps, including contacting the author's institution.7 Suspiciously fast, overly positive or superficial reviews should prompt a response.7 The options given are an additional independent reviewer or a recheck of identity.7

The evidence that followed

A large analysis published in 2022 examined one section of a single high-volume journal.8 It covered 7,965 manuscripts and 23,964 reviews.8 Those came from 46,455 authors and 21,665 reviewers.8 Author-suggested reviewers scored manuscripts higher, with a contrast of 0.364 and an effect size of 0.415.8 The gap persisted within individual manuscripts, at a difference of 0.222.8

The decision-level figures are the relevant ones here. Panels composed entirely of author-suggested reviewers accepted 89 per cent of manuscripts.8 Panels composed entirely of editor-suggested reviewers accepted 67 per cent.8 Mixed panels without author-opposed reviewers fell between the two, at 79 per cent.8 The mixed figure is the one that bears on the recommendation. A mixed panel is what the composition rule produces.

What the sequence does and does not establish

The 2015 statement was written before this analysis existed, and the analysis was not designed to evaluate it. The two sources are independent of one another.8 The association between panel composition and acceptance is not a demonstrated effect of adopting the rule.8 What the sequence shows is narrower and still useful. A safeguard adopted because a risk seemed plausible was followed by evidence that the risk is measurable at scale.

The conflict declaration step

One procedural recommendation is easy to implement and often absent. Journal peer review systems should include a step at which reviewers report potential conflicts of interest.7 Where a conflict is reported, an explanation should be requested and the review blocked without editor intervention.7 Editors should exclude those with significant conflicts.7 The categories named are recent coauthors over roughly ten years and colleagues at the same institution.7 Anyone with a financial interest in the paper is also excluded.7

The identification of predatory journals

The statement on predatory journals was written by Christine Laine and Margaret Winker and posted in February 2017.9 It is unusual among the policy set because it offers no single checklist. It assembles several existing instruments and explains how to use them together. That is a more honest treatment than a scorecard would be.

The core definition

The definition offered turns on a single behaviour. Predatory journals are described as those that “publish all or most submitted material without external peer review”.9 A second characteristic is a failure to follow standard publishing policies.9 Neither criterion concerns quality of appearance, which is where an inexperienced author is most likely to look.

The instruments assembled

Four separate sources are brought together in the statement. The first draws in part on a well-known list of criteria.9 These are grouped under editor and staff, business management, integrity and other concerns.9 One example is a journal that does not identify a formal editorial or review board.9 Others are having no policies for digital preservation, or giving insufficient information about author fees.9 Another criterion is locking published files, which makes checking for plagiarism harder.9

The second and third instruments are the open access directory's seal criteria and a published submission checklist.9 The seal requires permanent identifiers in published papers.9 The checklist asks whether the journal is clear about its fees and its type of peer review.9 It also asks whether the publisher is easy to contact.9 A third question is whether the journal is indexed in the services the author uses.9

The warning signs

The fourth instrument is a list of features that should raise suspicion. No information about author fees in the instructions for authors is one.9 Peer review not being mentioned in those instructions is another.9 Little or no information about the editor or editorial board is a third.9 A fourth is a failure to answer messages to the editor or journal office within a few days.9

Two cautions the statement issues about its own instruments

WAME warns against relying on a journal's past appearance on the well-known list alone.9 Some criteria have unfairly affected journals in low and middle income countries.9 The example given is the lack of geographic diversity on an editorial board.9 Absence from the open access directory does not establish that a journal is illegitimate.9 The statement describes the assessment as subjective.9 Its advice is that the more warning signs present, the more hesitant an author should be.9

The relationship to the transparency principles

The jointly issued transparency principles cover much of the same ground from the opposite direction.4 They describe what a legitimate journal publishes rather than what a predatory one omits. The site should describe the peer review process and should not guarantee acceptance or unusually short review times.4 Ownership and management should be clearly stated, and charges should be visible before submission.4 An archiving plan should exist for the content if the journal ceases publication.4

Generative artificial intelligence and the editor

The newest statement in the set addresses generative tools. It was issued by a named group on behalf of the WAME board and revised in May 2023.10 It sets out five recommendations, and the reasoning behind each is given rather than assumed.

The five recommendations

The first is a prohibition on authorship. Chatbots cannot be authors, because they do not meet authorship criteria and cannot take accountability for the work.10 The second requires transparency, with authors reporting the extent and type of any use.10 Where such a tool drafted new text, the use belongs in the acknowledgement, together with the prompts used.10 Where it performed analysis, reported results or wrote code, the abstract and methods should say so.10 The full prompt, the query date and time, and the tool and version belong there too.10

The third places responsibility on the author. Authors are accountable for accuracy and for avoiding plagiarism.10 They are also accountable for attributing all sources, including the originals behind any generated material.10 The fourth extends the same obligations to editors and peer reviewers.10 They should specify any use of such tools in evaluating manuscripts or writing reviews.10 The fifth concerns detection, and asks that appropriate tools be available to all editors regardless of ability to pay.10

The confidentiality problem

One clause deserves separate attention because it is easily overlooked. Editors and reviewers are told to recognise that submitting a manuscript to a chatbot breaches its confidentiality.10 This connects to an older principle in the publication ethics recommendations. The submitted manuscript is a privileged communication and reviewers must treat it as confidential.3

The practical consequence runs in both directions. A reviewer who pastes an unpublished manuscript into a general-purpose tool has disclosed it, whatever the tool's retention policy says. An author has no way to detect that this happened. The obligation therefore sits with the reviewer and the editor, which is where the statement places it.

The pattern across the policy set

The artificial intelligence statement follows the same structure as the older documents. It identifies a practice and states what must be disclosed. It then assigns responsibility to a named human, and asks journals to publish their position. Nothing in it creates an enforcement mechanism. The fifth recommendation, on detection tools, depends on something WAME cannot provide.10 It is phrased as a call rather than a requirement.10

That consistency is the most useful observation an author can take from the set as a whole. Across statements separated by more than twenty years, the instrument is always the same: a published expectation, addressed to editors, that an author can read and hold a journal to.1 The association supplies the text, and nothing further. Whether a journal honours it remains a question of evidence rather than accreditation.

Take-home message

WAME is a voluntary association that publishes seventeen policy statements for medical journal editors. Two further statements are retained as superseded. Its instruments are recommendations and carry no sanction, and the professionalism code describes no enforcement process. The conflict of interest policy sets its test at what a reasonable observer might wonder rather than at demonstrated bias. It asks journals to cover academic, personal, political and institutional interests alongside financial ones. The editorial independence statement gives editors-in-chief full authority over editorial content and bars owners from interfering in individual articles. The 2015 reviewer selection statement requires at least one reviewer not suggested by the author. Later evidence found that risk measurable at scale. For an author the practical value is consistent across all of them: a published standard that a journal did not write, against which its conduct can be checked.

How to apply this to your work

In order, when assessing a journal or preparing a submission
  1. Read the journal's own published policies first. The recommendations ask journals to publish definitions, standards and procedures that can then be compared.
  2. Check that peer review is described in the instructions for authors. Its absence is listed among the warning signs for a predatory journal.
  3. Confirm that author fees are stated before submission, or that their absence is stated explicitly.
  4. Look for a named editorial board with affiliations, and for an archiving plan covering the content if the journal ceases.
  5. Disclose beyond the financial, covering academic commitments, personal relationships and institutional affiliations where a reasonable observer might wonder.
  6. Expect at least one reviewer you did not suggest. Treat a panel drawn entirely from your own list as a reason for caution rather than satisfaction.
  7. Record any use of generative tools in the right place. Drafting assistance goes in the acknowledgement, and analytical use in the abstract and methods.
  8. Keep the prompts, dates and tool versions, since the statement asks for them specifically and they cannot be reconstructed later.

Common questions

Does WAME enforce standards on medical journals

No. It is a voluntary association that issues recommendations, and its professionalism code describes no sanction or enforcement process.2 The publication ethics recommendations state the limit directly in the context of misconduct: journals do not have the resources or authority to conduct a formal judicial inquiry, and should share reasonable concerns with the authorities who can investigate.3

How many policy statements does WAME maintain

Seventeen are listed as current, in six groups.1 These are ethics and professionalism, authors, conflicts of interest, global health and politics, peer review, and other publication issues.1 Two further statements are marked archived, having been incorporated into later documents, and remain published rather than withdrawn.1

How does WAME define conflict of interest

As a divergence between an individual's private interests and their responsibilities to scientific and publishing activities.6 The divergence counts where it is such that “a reasonable observer might wonder” whether behaviour or judgement was motivated by competing interests.6 The test is what an informed onlooker would reasonably ask, not whether judgement was actually affected.

Which non-financial interests should be disclosed

Academic commitments, personal relationships, political or religious beliefs and institutional affiliations.6 WAME argues these can be as damaging and as hidden as financial ties.6 Journals are advised to cover them in policy rather than concentrating on payments, stock, patents and funding alone.6

What does WAME say about author-suggested reviewers

That at least one reviewer in the review of a manuscript should not have been suggested by the author.7 Suggested reviewers should only be used where the editor is already familiar with them and their conflicts.7 Their contact details should come from an independently validated source, such as their own publications.7

Can a generative tool be listed as an author

No. Chatbots cannot be authors because they do not meet authorship criteria and cannot take accountability for the work.10 Use for drafting belongs in the acknowledgement, with the prompts used.10 Analytical use belongs in the abstract and methods, with the full prompt, query date and time, and tool version.10

What makes a journal predatory under this definition

Publishing all or most submitted material without external peer review, together with a failure to follow standard publishing policies.9 Warning signs include no fee information in the instructions for authors, and no mention of peer review there.9 Others are little information about the editorial board, and no reply to messages within a few days.9

What authority does an editor-in-chief hold over content

Full authority over editorial content, which the statement calls editorial independence.5 Owners may hire and dismiss editors-in-chief, but should dismiss only for substantial reasons.5 They should not interfere in the evaluation, selection or editing of individual articles.5 Employment terms should be agreed in writing before appointment.5

Declared interest: Pubrica provides medical writing and publication support commercially. The policy statements described here are summarised from WAME's own published documents. Those carry dates ranging from 2000 to 2023 and may be revised. The dates are given so a reader can check for a later version. The acceptance figures in the second figure come from one section of one journal. They are an association rather than evidence that adopting the reviewer rule changes outcomes. Nothing on this page should be read as indicating that Pubrica holds any WAME membership or accreditation.

References and sources

  1. World Association of Medical Editors. Policies: index of current and archived policy statements. read 22 October 2026, in full. The index carries no publication or version dates against individual entries, so the dates given on this page come from each statement's own page.View the index
  2. World Association of Medical Editors. WAME Professionalism Code of Conduct. Posted 12 May 2016; approved by the WAME Board 9 May 2016. read 22 October 2026, in full. The document describes no sanction, enforcement process or penalty for breach, and that absence is reported on this page as a finding.View the code
  3. World Association of Medical Editors. Recommendations on Publication Ethics Policies for Medical Journals. read 22 October 2026, in full. The document carries no adoption date or version number; its own cited sources were accessed in 2003 and 2004. Its conflict of interest provisions are held on a separate page, cited below.View the recommendations
  4. Committee on Publication Ethics, Directory of Open Access Journals, Open Access Scholarly Publishers Association and World Association of Medical Editors. Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing, version 3. 15 January 2018. read 21 October 2026, in full; all sixteen principles were read, and those named here are a subset.View the principles
  5. World Association of Medical Editors. The Relationship Between Journal Editors-in-Chief and Owners (formerly titled Editorial Independence). Posted 19 June 2000; revised 15 May 2006 and 25 July 2009. read 22 October 2026, in full.View the statement
  6. World Association of Medical Editors. Conflict of Interest in Peer-Reviewed Medical Journals. Posted 27 March 2009; updated 25 July 2009. Approved by the WAME Board 25 March 2009 and 15 July 2009. read 22 October 2026, in full.View the policy
  7. World Association of Medical Editors. Best Practices for Peer Reviewer Selection and Contact to Prevent Peer Review Manipulation by Authors. Approved by the WAME Ethics and Policy Committee 21 January 2015; posted 6 April 2015. read 22 October 2026, in full.View the statement
  8. Acuna DE, Teplitskiy M, Evans JA, Kording K. Author-suggested reviewers rate manuscripts much more favorably: a cross-sectional analysis of the neuroscience section of PLOS ONE. PLoS ONE. 2022;17(12):e0273994. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0273994 read 21 October 2026, in full. The paper reports no odds ratios or confidence intervals for panel composition, so none are given here. It was not designed to evaluate the WAME recommendation, and is not presented on this page as a test of it.View the full text
  9. Laine C, Winker MA. Identifying Predatory or Pseudo-Journals. World Association of Medical Editors. Posted 18 February 2017; the suggested citation gives 15 February 2017. read 22 October 2026, in full. The statement assembles four existing instruments rather than offering a single checklist, and issues its own cautions about each, which are reported here.View the statement
  10. Zielinski C, Winker MA, Aggarwal R, Ferris LE, Heinemann M, Lapeña JF Jr, Pai SA, Ing E, Citrome L, Alam M, Voight M, Habibzadeh F, on behalf of the WAME Board. WAME Recommendations on Chatbots and Generative Artificial Intelligence in Relation to Scholarly Publications. Revised 31 May 2023. read 22 October 2026, in full.View the recommendations

How to cite this article

Pick your referencing style and copy it. Your university or target journal may vary the punctuation — check its guide if it has one.

Pubrica Academy. (2026, October 22). Understanding WAME and Its Policies. Pubrica. https://pubrica.com/services/publication-support/understanding-wame-medical-journal-editors/
Pubrica Academy. “Understanding WAME and Its Policies.” Pubrica, 22 Oct. 2026, pubrica.com/services/publication-support/understanding-wame-medical-journal-editors/.
Pubrica Academy (2026) Understanding WAME and Its Policies. Available at: https://pubrica.com/services/publication-support/understanding-wame-medical-journal-editors/ (Accessed: 22 October 2026).
Pubrica Academy. “Understanding WAME and Its Policies.” Pubrica. October 22, 2026. https://pubrica.com/services/publication-support/understanding-wame-medical-journal-editors/.
Pubrica Academy, ‘Understanding WAME and Its Policies’ (Pubrica, 22 October 2026) <https://pubrica.com/services/publication-support/understanding-wame-medical-journal-editors/> accessed 22 October 2026.
Pubrica Academy. Understanding WAME and Its Policies [Internet]. Pubrica; 2026 Oct 22 [cited 2026 Oct 22]. Available from: https://pubrica.com/services/publication-support/understanding-wame-medical-journal-editors/
[1] Pubrica Academy, “Understanding WAME and Its Policies,” Pubrica, Oct. 22, 2026. [Online]. Available: https://pubrica.com/services/publication-support/understanding-wame-medical-journal-editors/
@misc{pubrica_wame_2026, author = {{Pubrica Academy}}, title = {Understanding WAME and Its Policies}, year = {2026}, month = {oct}, day = {22}, howpublished = {\url{https://pubrica.com/services/publication-support/understanding-wame-medical-journal-editors/}}, note = {Accessed: 2026-10-22} }

This article is written to be learned from. Cite it if you are referring to what it says; if you are using the evidence behind it, cite the sources listed above instead.

Journal assessment checklist

Work through these against the journal’s own published pages.

THE JOURNAL'S OWN PUBLISHED POLICIES
[ ] Peer review process described in the instructions for authors
[ ] Type of peer review stated, not merely asserted to exist
[ ] Editorial board named, with affiliations
[ ] Editor-in-chief identified, with a contact route
[ ] Ownership and management clearly stated
[ ] Terms of the journal's editorial freedom published
[ ] Author fees stated before submission, or their absence stated
[ ] Archiving plan in place should the journal cease publication
[ ] Permanent identifiers assigned to published papers
[ ] Annual audit of acceptance rates and publication intervals published

CONFLICT OF INTEREST
[ ] Journal publishes its own definition of conflict of interest
[ ] Look-back period for financial interests stated
[ ] Policy reachable from the instructions for authors
[ ] Journal states what happens if an undisclosed conflict emerges
[ ] Journal states which conflicts prevent consideration altogether
[ ] Financial interests disclosed for every author
[ ] Academic commitments disclosed where relevant
[ ] Personal relationships disclosed where relevant
[ ] Institutional affiliations disclosed where relevant
[ ] Funding sources named, with the funder's role in the work stated

PEER REVIEW SAFEGUARDS
[ ] At least one reviewer expected who was not author-suggested
[ ] Suggested reviewers named only where a genuine subject match exists
[ ] Contact details for suggested reviewers verifiable from their publications
[ ] No suggested reviewer who is a recent coauthor, within about ten years
[ ] No suggested reviewer at the author's own institution
[ ] Any relationship with a suggested reviewer declared

GENERATIVE TOOLS
[ ] No generative tool listed as an author or cited as one
[ ] Drafting assistance recorded in the acknowledgement
[ ] Prompts used for drafting recorded with it
[ ] Analytical use recorded in the abstract and methods
[ ] Full prompt, query date and time retained
[ ] Tool name and version retained
[ ] Responsibility for accuracy and attribution accepted by a named author
[ ] Unpublished manuscripts never pasted into a general-purpose tool

WARNING SIGNS TO WEIGH
[ ] Peer review unmentioned in the instructions for authors
[ ] No fee information anywhere before submission
[ ] Little or no information about the editor or editorial board
[ ] No reply to email or telephone within a few days
[ ] Acceptance or unusually short review times guaranteed
[ ] Journal name easily confused with an established title
PA
Pubrica Academy

Written and maintained by the subject matter experts of Pubrica who do this work. Articles are revised when the standard underneath them moves, and each one carries the date it was last checked against its sources.

How Pubrica helps

We assess a candidate journal against its own published policies. We assemble the disclosures a submission has to carry, and prepare manuscripts to the standards that journal has committed to in writing.

Explore

Related reading in the Academy.

Picked from the same sub-topic and category as this piece, newest first.

Find something else

Search the rest of the Academy.

Open with no account. Type what you are working on, or open the full library to filter by category, sub-topic or resource type.

Get a free quote

Regulations

Check your project against this rule

  1. 1Your work
  2. 2Your details
  3. 3Send
What do you need?

Material you send is held under signed confidentiality, with access limited to the assigned team and encrypted transfer. It is not used to train anything and is not passed to third-party tools. Ask for the agreement before you send anything you would rather cover first.