Free scoping read. A written assessment of your manuscript in two business days, at no cost.

Start one
Contents

Academy · Research Writing · Power and health literacy

Power Relations in Scientific Communication: What Health-Literacy Research Shows

A systematic review of clinical-trial informed consent found reading levels nearly double the demonstrated literacy of many participants — a concrete, documented asymmetry between what researchers write and what patients can understand.

Pubrica AcademyWritten by a scientific communication and health-literacy researcher Reviewed bya senior research publication consultant Published10 October 2026 Last checked10 October 2026 Reading time12 minutes Sources15 cited

Scientific and clinical communication is not a neutral exchange between equally equipped parties: researchers and clinicians control the vocabulary, format, and framing of the information, while patients and research participants must understand it well enough to give genuinely informed consent or to act on findings that affect their health. This asymmetry has been documented directly in health-literacy research. A 2019 systematic review of informed-consent comprehension in clinical trials found that consent materials are routinely written well above the reading level of many participants, and that simplifying the language alone does not reliably close the comprehension gap.

What you will learn

  • The documented gap between how consent and research materials are written and what participants with limited health literacy can actually comprehend
  • Why simplifying vocabulary alone has not reliably improved comprehension in trials that tested it
  • What the asymmetry means in practice for who understands research findings, and who is left to trust rather than evaluate them

What to unlearn

  • “Writing a shorter, simpler consent form or summary automatically closes the comprehension gap.” A systematic review found that simplified consent forms did not produce a clear, consistent comprehension improvement over standard forms across the studies it examined — participants preferred the simplified versions and felt less frightened by them, but understanding did not reliably improve to match.
  • “Comprehension problems with research materials are mainly an individual reading-skill issue, not a communication-design issue.” The same review found that even well-educated or average readers were tested against consent documents written at roughly a 12th-grade level, with only a minority of forms matching the population's actual literacy demands — the mismatch sits as much in how documents are written as in who is reading them.

Power in scientific communication at a glance

Subject of the original article
A critical examination of power relations in educational science communication, using the discourse of “learning styles” as its case
What the evidence says
A major review found virtually no evidence for the claim that matching teaching to a learner’s preferred style improves learning11
How far the belief reaches
93% of 550 pre-service science teachers endorsed learning styles in one survey13
Focus of this article
The same writer-reader asymmetry in health communication, where comprehension gaps are measured directly1
Practical response
Check comprehension (for example with teach-back) instead of assuming it39
Reading time
About 12 minutes, with 4 figures and 2 tables

Learning-styles discourse: the original subject of this examination

This page began as a critical examination of power relations in educational science communication, taking the discourse of “learning styles” as its case. The claim at the centre of that discourse is the meshing hypothesis: that instruction works best when it matches a learner’s preferred mode, such as visual or auditory presentation. Pashler, McDaniel, Rohrer and Bjork, in Psychological Science in the Public Interest, set out the experimental pattern needed to support that claim (Figure 1) and found virtually no evidence for it; of the few studies with an appropriate design, several flatly contradicted it. They concluded that there was no adequate evidence base for incorporating learning-styles assessment into general educational practice, while noting that many versions had simply not been tested11.

1Classify learners by their assessed learning styleGroup
2Randomly assign learners within each style group to more than one instructional methodRandomise
3Give every learner the same final testTest
4Show a crossover interaction: the method that works best for one style is not the best for anotherInteraction
Figure 1. The experimental pattern Pashler and colleagues judged necessary to validate learning-styles-based instruction. Their review found very few studies with this design, and several that used it contradicted the matching (“meshing”) hypothesis.11

The power question is why a claim with so little support remains authoritative. Pashler and colleagues described a thriving industry publishing learning-styles tests and guidebooks and offering professional development built around the concept11. Surveys show how far the idea has travelled: 93% of 550 German pre-service science teachers endorsed it13, as did more than 75% of 501 Malaysian school teachers14. Newton and Miah found that 58% of UK academics believed in learning styles but only 33% reported using them, and that 32% would continue to use them even after being shown the lack of evidence12. Most strikingly, Newton and colleagues found that 91% of 112 recent learning-styles papers in health-professions education were premised on the idea being useful, so that an educator who searched the research literature would be given a consistent but inaccurate endorsement15.

Endorsement and use of learning styles in published surveys

Pre-service science teachers, Germanybelieved learning styles exist (n = 550)93%
Health-professions education paperspremised on learning styles being useful (n = 112)91%
School teachers, Malaysiaendorsed learning in the preferred style (n = 501)>75%
UK higher-education academicsgeneral belief in learning styles (n = 114)58%
UK higher-education academicsreported actually using them33%
UK higher-education academicswould continue despite the lack of evidence32%

Each bar is the percentage reported by the study for its own sample; the Malaysian figure is reported as “more than 75%”. Second colour: one survey of UK academics.

Figure 2. Belief in learning styles across teachers, academics and the research literature itself. Grospietsch and Mayer (2019); Newton et al. (2021); Amran and Sommer (2025); Newton and Miah (2017).13151412

Peer-reviewed studies of the learning-styles claim and its uptake

StudyWhat was examinedReported finding
Pashler et al. 200811Review of the experimental evidence for learning-styles-based instructionVirtually no evidence for the required interaction; no adequate evidence base for learning-styles assessment in general educational practice; many versions untested
Newton and Miah 201712Survey of 114 academics in UK higher education58% believed in learning styles, 33% used them, 32% would continue despite the lack of evidence
Grospietsch and Mayer 201913Survey of 550 pre-service science teachers in GermanyBelief in learning styles 93%, independent of stage of teacher education
Newton et al. 202115112 recent health-professions education research papers on learning styles91% were based on the premise that learning styles are a useful approach to education
Amran and Sommer 202514Survey of 501 school teachers in MalaysiaMore than 75% endorsed the learning-styles idea; 80% of these endorsed applying visual-auditory-kinaesthetic teaching

PubMed indexes the quantitative literature on the claim and its uptake; a search in this database did not identify critical discourse analyses of learning-styles language, so none is summarised here.

Why this article turns to health literacy

Learning-styles research shows who holds the authority to frame educational knowledge: test publishers, professional-development providers and a research literature that, as Newton and colleagues found, largely endorses the idea. The writer-reader asymmetry that this case illustrates is measured most directly in health communication, where comprehension of consent forms and patient materials can be tested. The rest of this article therefore examines what health-literacy research shows about power in scientific communication.

The documented reading-level gap in consent materials

Burks and Keim-Malpass's 2019 systematic review, published in Nursing: Research and Reviews, brought together the evidence on health literacy and informed-consent comprehension in clinical trials 1. Citing Davis et al., the review reports that trial participants reading at a ninth-grade level or above scored around 72% on comprehension tests of consent material, compared with roughly 21% for participants reading at a third-grade level or below — a gap of more than fifty percentage points tied directly to reading level, not to the complexity of the trial itself 1. Citing Simonds et al., the same review reports that consent documents averaged around a twelfth-grade reading level, while only about 29% of the documents reviewed actually matched the literacy demands of the population they were written for 1. The asymmetry, in other words, is measurable: the people writing consent materials are, on average, writing several grade levels above the people who must understand them well enough to consent.

Why simplification alone has not closed the gap

The review's most striking finding is that making consent language simpler did not reliably fix the problem. Citing Davis et al., it reports no meaningful comprehension difference between standard and simplified consent forms, and citing Coyne et al., only a small, non-significant gain from simplification 1. Participants did prefer the simplified forms and reported feeling less frightened by them, which matters for the experience of consenting, but preference and comprehension tracked separately rather than together 1. The review also cites Krieger et al., who found that the specific framing used to explain randomisation mattered more than overall simplicity: a benign metaphor helped participants with lower health literacy understand randomisation, while a gambling metaphor worked better for those with higher literacy — meaning a single simplified document cannot serve every participant equally, because the gap is not just vocabulary but which explanatory frame lands for whom 1.

Weak explanation of randomisation

“Allocation to study arms will be performed by computer-generated randomisation to minimise selection bias.”

Accurate for the researcher, but it uses technical vocabulary and offers the participant no frame for what will happen to them.

Stronger explanation, with a check

“A computer will decide by chance which of the two treatments you receive, like tossing a coin. Neither you nor your doctor can choose. Can you tell me in your own words how your treatment will be decided?”

Plain wording, a concrete frame and a teach-back question that tests whether the explanation was understood.

Illustrative wording written for this article. The review cited above found that the best frame for randomisation differed by literacy level, so no single metaphor suits every participant.

What the asymmetry means for trust and participation

The review connects comprehension gaps to how participants relate to the research process itself. It cites Evans et al.'s finding that participants with limited literacy were more likely to mistrust medical personnel and to describe trial participants as "guinea pigs," and it notes that limited literacy was independently associated with higher anxiety and lower satisfaction with the consent process 1. The authors argue that stigma attached to low literacy can itself reduce a patient's engagement in shared decision-making — meaning the asymmetry is not only about whether information is understood, but about whether a patient feels able to question it at all. Their practical recommendation is that clinicians and researchers cannot assume a signed consent form reflects true comprehension: they call for routine literacy screening and the use of teach-back methods, where the participant explains the information back in their own words, as a direct check on whether the asymmetry has actually been closed in a given encounter 1.

How widespread limited health literacy actually is

The asymmetry described above is not a fringe problem affecting a small minority of participants. The 2003 National Assessment of Adult Literacy, the most comprehensive U.S. government measurement of the issue, found that 14% of adults scored at the "Below Basic" health-literacy level and another 22% at "Basic," meaning roughly 36% of U.S. adults, by this measure, would struggle with the kind of material routinely used in consent forms and research summaries 2. A separate, numeracy-specific review by Reyna, Nelson, Han, and Dieckmann estimated that more than 93 million people in the United States lack the numerical skills needed to make well-informed medical decisions, a distinct but related gap, since understanding a percentage, a relative risk, or an absolute risk reduction draws on numeracy specifically rather than general reading comprehension 7. The 2004 Institute of Medicine report that first brought sustained national attention to this issue, Health Literacy: A Prescription to End Confusion, framed limited health literacy as a systemic mismatch between the demands of the health system and the skills of the people navigating it, rather than as a deficit located only in the patient 10.

Teach-back in practice: closing the loop with diabetes patients

The clearest direct test of teach-back's value comes from outside the consent-form literature, in routine diabetes care. Schillinger, Piette, Grumbach, and colleagues audio-recorded real primary-care visits between 38 physicians and 74 English-speaking patients with diabetes and limited health literacy at a public hospital, and found that physicians used an interactive technique, explicitly asking patients to repeat back or apply new information, in only 20% of visits overall and for just 12% of new concepts introduced 3. When physicians did check recall or comprehension this way, their patients were more likely to have good glycemic control, and critically, using the technique did not require longer visits 3. That last point matters for anyone citing "time pressure" as a reason to skip comprehension checks: the documented barrier in this study was not visit length but whether the clinician used the technique at all.

How rarely comprehension is checked, and how often materials meet recommended reading levels

Visits with a comprehension check12 of 61 primary-care visits20%
New concepts checked15 of 124 new concepts12%
Leaflets meeting recommended reading levelof 345 general-practice leaflets24.3%

First colour: audio-recorded diabetes consultations with patients with low health literacy (Schillinger et al. 2003). Second colour: patient information leaflets in 17 general practices (Protheroe et al. 2015).

Figure 3. Two measured gaps between writer and reader. Patients whose physicians checked recall or comprehension were more likely to have good glycaemic control; over 75% of the leaflets were too complex for at least 15% of the English population.36

The documented causal pathway from literacy to health outcomes

The link between literacy and health outcomes is not merely plausible; it has been reviewed formally. The Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality's 2004 evidence report on literacy and health outcomes, led by Berkman, DeWalt, Pignone, and colleagues, concluded that lower literacy is associated with lower health knowledge, worse intermediate disease markers, greater use of acute care services, and less use of preventive services, while cautioning that most of the underlying studies were cross-sectional and often did not fully account for confounding 4. Paasche-Orlow and Wolf's 2007 conceptual model organizes this evidence into an explicit causal pathway: limited literacy constrains a patient's access to care, their interaction with the health system, and their self-care capacity, each of which independently contributes to worse outcomes, rather than literacy affecting outcomes through a single, simple mechanism 8. That multi-pathway framing is one reason a single intervention, like simplifying one document, cannot be expected to close the whole gap on its own.

Limited healthliteracyAccess to careHealth-system interactionSelf-care capacityHealth outcomes
Figure 4. Conceptual diagram, not to scale and with no real values, of the three pathways in Paasche-Orlow and Wolf’s model: limited literacy acts on access to care, interaction with the health system and self-care, each of which contributes to outcomes.8

Why patient materials outside research are still pitched too high

The mismatch documented in consent forms is not unique to clinical trials. Protheroe, Estacio, and Saidy-Khan assessed 345 patient information leaflets distributed in general practice and found Flesch-Kincaid grade levels ranging from 1.3 to 14.2, with a median of 8.3, roughly a 13-14-year-old's reading level 6. Only 24.3% of the leaflets met the commonly recommended threshold of grade 6 or below, and more than 75% were too complex for the estimated 15% of the English population reading below that grade-6 level, with about one in five leaflets written at a level equivalent to a 16-year-old school leaver and some reaching second-year university complexity 6. These figures describe routine clinical handouts, not research consent documents, which suggests the asymmetry documented in the clinical-trial literature reflects a broader, system-wide habit of writing to the author's level rather than the reader's, not a problem specific to the research-consent process.

A universal-precautions approach instead of guessing who needs help

Because limited literacy is common, unevenly distributed, and not reliably visible from how a person presents in person, the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality's Health Literacy Universal Precautions Toolkit recommends treating every patient encounter as if literacy support might be needed, an analogy deliberately borrowed from blood-safety universal precautions, where staff cannot know in advance who carries a risk and so apply the same protective practice to everyone 9. The toolkit's 23 tools, organized around simplifying communication and confirming understanding, making the system easier to navigate, and supporting patients' own self-management efforts, operationalize exactly the practical response this body of research points toward: build comprehension checks like teach-back into every encounter by default, rather than trying to first identify who specifically needs them 9.

Responses to the writer-reader asymmetry and what the evidence on this page shows

ResponseWhat the cited evidence showsSource
Simplify the wordingPreferred by participants and less frightening, but comprehension did not reliably improveBurks and Keim-Malpass 20191
Check comprehension (teach-back)Used in 20% of visits; associated with better glycaemic control and did not lengthen visitsSchillinger et al. 20033
Measure readabilityOnly 24.3% of 345 general-practice leaflets met recommended reading-level criteriaProtheroe et al. 20156
Apply universal precautionsAssume any encounter may need literacy support and build comprehension checks in by defaultAHRQ toolkit9
Question received claimsLearning-styles belief persisted among academics even after the lack of evidence was shownNewton and Miah 201712

Checklist for participant-facing scientific communication

  • Run every consent form and plain-language summary through a readability check and compare the result with the target population, not only an internal style guide.
  • Test comprehension directly with a teach-back step rather than inferring it from a signature or a stated preference.
  • Prepare more than one explanation for concepts such as randomisation, because the frame that works differs by literacy level.
  • Present numerical findings in a form that does not assume high numeracy.
  • Treat every encounter as one in which literacy support may be needed, rather than trying to identify who needs it.
  • Before passing on an educational or communication claim, check whether the peer-reviewed evidence supports it.

Take-home message

Take-home message

Documented reading-level gaps between consent materials and participant literacy do not close through simplified wording alone, so comprehension should be actively checked, for example with teach-back, rather than assumed from a signature.

How to apply this to your work

How to apply this to your own work

  1. Check the actual reading level of participant-facing materials. Run consent forms and plain-language summaries through a readability check and compare the result against the target population's likely literacy range, not just an internal style guide.
  2. Test comprehension directly, not just preference. Where possible, use a teach-back step — asking the participant to explain the material in their own words — rather than relying on a simplified form alone to confirm understanding.
  3. Match explanatory framing to the audience, not just the vocabulary. Recognise that a single metaphor or explanation (for concepts like randomisation) will not work equally well across literacy levels; plan for more than one explanatory approach where comprehension is critical.

Common questions

No — the review found participants preferred simplified forms and felt less frightened by them. The finding is only that simplification alone did not reliably raise measured comprehension to match.

The strongest documented evidence here is from clinical-trial informed consent specifically, but the underlying mechanism — writing pitched to the author's level rather than the reader's demonstrated literacy — applies to any plain-language summary or public-facing research communication.

Teach-back is having the person being consented or informed explain the material back in their own words. The review's authors recommend it because a signed form does not verify comprehension, while a correct teach-back explanation does.

The 2003 National Assessment of Adult Literacy found about 36% of U.S. adults scored at Basic or Below Basic health literacy, and a separate review estimated more than 93 million people in the U.S. lack the numeracy skills needed for well-informed medical decisions.

In the Schillinger et al. study of real diabetes visits, using teach-back-style comprehension checks did not require longer visits; physicians simply used the technique in only 20% of visits despite that.

It shows up broadly. A study of 345 general-practice patient leaflets found a median reading level of grade 8.3, with only 24.3% meeting the recommended grade-6-or-below threshold, indicating the same author-level-not-reader-level pattern outside the consent-form context.

References and sources

  1. Burks AC, Keim-Malpass J. Health literacy and informed consent for clinical trials: a systematic review and implications for nurses. Nursing: Research and Reviews. 2019;9:31-40. read 10 October 2026. View on PubMed Central / View source
  2. Kutner M, Greenberg E, Jin Y, Paulsen C. The Health Literacy of America's Adults: Results from the 2003 National Assessment of Adult Literacy (NCES 2006-483). National Center for Education Statistics, 2006. read 10 October 2026. View source
  3. Schillinger D, Piette J, Grumbach K, et al. Closing the loop: physician communication with diabetic patients who have low health literacy. Arch Intern Med. 2003;163(1):83-90. read 10 October 2026. View source
  4. Berkman ND, DeWalt DA, Pignone MP, et al. Literacy and Health Outcomes. Evidence Report/Technology Assessment No. 87. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, 2004. read 10 October 2026. View source
  5. Buljan I, Tokalić R, Roguljić M, et al. Framing the numerical findings of Cochrane plain language summaries: two randomized controlled trials. BMC Medical Research Methodology. 2020;20(1):128. read 10 October 2026. View on BMC Medical Research Methodology
  6. Protheroe J, Estacio EV, Saidy-Khan S. Patient information materials in general practices and promotion of health literacy: an observational study of their effectiveness. Br J Gen Pract. 2015;65(632):e192-e197. read 10 October 2026. View source
  7. Reyna VF, Nelson WL, Han PK, Dieckmann NF. How numeracy influences risk comprehension and medical decision making. Psychological Bulletin. 2009;135(6):943-973. read 10 October 2026. View source
  8. Paasche-Orlow MK, Wolf MS. The causal pathways linking health literacy to health outcomes. American Journal of Health Behavior. 2007;31(Suppl 1):S19-S26. read 10 October 2026. View source
  9. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. Health Literacy Universal Precautions Toolkit (3rd edition). read 10 October 2026. View on AHRQ
  10. Institute of Medicine (Nielsen-Bohlman L, Panzer AM, Kindig DA, eds). Health Literacy: A Prescription to End Confusion. Washington, DC: National Academies Press, 2004. read 10 October 2026. View on National Academies Press
  11. Pashler H, McDaniel M, Rohrer D, Bjork R. Learning styles: concepts and evidence. Psychological Science in the Public Interest. 2008;9(3):105-119. read 13 November 2026. doi.org/10.1111/j.1539-6053.2009.01038.x
  12. Newton PM, Miah M. Evidence-based higher education - is the learning styles 'myth' important? Frontiers in Psychology. 2017;8:444. read 13 November 2026. doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2017.00444
  13. Grospietsch F, Mayer J. Pre-service science teachers' neuroscience literacy: neuromyths and a professional understanding of learning and memory. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience. 2019;13:20. read 13 November 2026. doi.org/10.3389/fnhum.2019.00020
  14. Amran MS, Sommer W. Seen through teachers' eyes: neuromyths and their application in Malaysian classrooms. Trends in Neuroscience and Education. 2025;38:100250. read 13 November 2026. doi.org/10.1016/j.tine.2025.100250
  15. Newton PM, Najabat-Lattif HF, Santiago G, Salvi A. The learning styles neuromyth is still thriving in medical education. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience. 2021;15:708540. read 13 November 2026. doi.org/10.3389/fnhum.2021.708540

Every source above is a peer-reviewed article, a publisher’s record of one, or a standard issued by the body that owns it. Each carries the date it was last read. Where a standard moves, this article is revised rather than left up with a note.

How to cite this article

Pick your referencing style and copy it. Your university or target journal may vary the punctuation — check its guide if it has one.

Pubrica Academy. (2026, October 10). Power Relations in Scientific Communication: What Health-Literacy Research Shows. Pubrica. https://pubrica.com/academy/scientific-communication/power-relations-in-educational-scientific-communication-a-critical-examination-of-learning-style-discourse/

This article is written to be learned from. Cite it if you are referring to what it says; if you are using the evidence behind it, cite the sources listed above instead.

Participant-facing material comprehension checklist

Use when drafting or reviewing consent forms or plain-language research summaries.

[ ] Reading level checked against target population's likely literacy, not just internal style guide
[ ] Key concepts (e.g. randomisation) have more than one explanatory framing available
[ ] Comprehension check (e.g. teach-back) planned, not assumed from a signature
[ ] Document reviewed for stigmatising or alienating language toward lower-literacy readers
[ ] Simplified version tested for comprehension, not just readability score

Pubrica AcademyWritten and maintained by the subject matter experts of Pubrica who do this work. Articles are revised when the standard underneath them moves, and each one carries the date it was last checked.

How Pubrica helps

Pubrica's plain-language and participant-communication support drafts consent and summary materials to a verified reading level and checks them against the intended audience.

Find something else

Search the rest of the Academy.

Open with no account. Type what you are working on, or open the full library to filter by category, sub-topic or resource type.

Will your participants actually understand this?

A scoping read costs nothing and takes two business days. You get a written view of what the work needs and who would hold it.

Get a free quote

Regulations

Check your project against this rule

  1. 1Your work
  2. 2Your details
  3. 3Send
What do you need?

Material you send is held under signed confidentiality, with access limited to the assigned team and encrypted transfer. It is not used to train anything and is not passed to third-party tools. Ask for the agreement before you send anything you would rather cover first.