Contents
On this page
- Survey sample and methodology
- Factors rated highest by researchers
- Consistency of rankings across groups
- Gender differences identified in subsequent analysis of the dataset
- Influence of open-access fees and funding on journal selection
- Early-career researchers and the increased importance of speed during the pandemic
- Differing priorities of reviewers, industry writers and practitioners
- Qualitative evidence on the reduced importance of prestige
Academy · Research Publication · Researcher Survey Insights
Investigating Journal Selection Decisions: Findings of a Survey of Academic Researchers
A survey of 1,085 Taylor & Francis authors, reviewers and editors, drawn from 73,000 invitees, found that a journal’s reputation and the reliability of its review process outweighed nearly all other factors considered by researchers when deciding where to submit. This article examines the survey’s methodology and findings.
Most guidance on journal selection is written from an external perspective, as a set of recommendations regarding what authors should consider. A 2022 survey took the opposite approach, asking researchers directly which factors drove their own journal-selection decisions and how strongly. The result is a ranked, evidence-based account of researcher priorities rather than a list of recommended criteria, derived from a substantial international sample of individuals who had themselves recently chosen where to submit, review or edit.
Learning objectives
- The response rate and sample size underlying a large journal-selection survey
- Which factors researchers rated highest when choosing where to submit a manuscript
- Why publishing experience, researcher role and discipline had little effect on the ranking of factors
Common misconceptions
- “Early-career and senior researchers prioritise entirely different factors when choosing a journal.” The survey found that publishing productivity, publishing experience, researcher role and discipline all had little effect on how respondents ranked the same set of factors, which the authors interpret as evidence of a relatively homogeneous set of priorities across the research community surveyed.
Survey sample and methodology
Jennifer Rowley and colleagues sent an international survey to 73,000 corresponding authors associated with Taylor & Francis, asking about the factors that shaped their journal-selection decisions1. The survey returned 1,085 usable questionnaires, a response rate of 1.5%1. Respondents were drawn from researchers who had served as Taylor & Francis authors, peer reviewers, and/or journal editors, giving the sample a mix of perspectives on the submission and review process rather than only the author's side of it1. A 1.5% response rate from a mass invitation is low in absolute terms, as is typical of unsolicited survey outreach at that scale; nevertheless, it produced over a thousand responses, a sufficiently large base to compare the relative ranking of different factors.
Factors rated highest by researchers
Respondents rated a set of journal-selection factors on a 10-point scale, and the results showed a clear ordering at the top1. The highest-rated factor overall was the reputation of the journal, with a mean score of 8.671. Close behind was confidence that the manuscript was within the journal's scope, at a mean of 8.451. The reliability of the journal's reviewing process followed at 8.38, and the usefulness of reviewers' feedback scored 8.371. The clustering of these four factors at the top, all within three-tenths of a point of one another on a 10-point scale, indicates that researchers in this sample weighed reputation, scope fit, and the quality of the review process itself as comparably important, rather than treating any single one of them as decisive on its own1.
Consistency of rankings across groups
One of the more notable findings concerned the variables that did not alter the rankings. The researchers tested whether publishing productivity, publishing experience, the respondent's role (author, reviewer, or editor), and academic discipline affected how these factors were weighted, and found that each had little effect on the overall ranking1. The authors interpret this as evidence of a relatively homogeneous set of priorities across the surveyed research community: a highly experienced, frequently published senior researcher and a comparatively new author reported weighing journal reputation, scope fit, and review-process reliability in largely the same way1.
Gender differences identified in subsequent analysis of the dataset
A companion analysis of the same 1,085 responses, published separately by Rowley and Sbaffi in 2021, looked specifically at gender and found that the overall homogeneity described above was not complete: of 49 journal-choice statements, 20 showed a statistically significant difference between men and women at the p<.05 level in a one-way ANCOVA5. Men rated familiarity with the journal, prior reviewing or editorial-board experience, and speed of the review process higher, for example scoring speed of reviewing at a mean of 7.71 versus 7.38 for women (p=.010)5. Women rated authority-related factors higher, including impact factor (8.32 versus 8.03, p=.023) and reputation in their academic community (8.82 versus 8.58, p=.016), along with scope fit, open-access policy, and career-progression-linked factors such as university publication expectations5. The authors frame the pattern as women appearing more focused on what is institutionally required to succeed in academia, while both genders still agreed closely on the very top factors, reviewing reliability and usefulness of reviewer feedback5. The implication for interpreting the original survey is that “little effect” on the overall ranking order is compatible with genuine, statistically significant differences in the underlying scores when a specific demographic split is tested directly.
Influence of open-access fees and funding on journal selection
A separate, earlier survey focused specifically on open-access journals adds a cost dimension the Rowley survey did not isolate. Solomon and Björk surveyed 1,038 authors who had recently published in 74 article-processing-charge-funded open-access journals across seven disciplines, receiving 429 usable responses, a 41% response rate, from 69 of those journals2. They found that fit, quality, and speed of publication were the most important factors driving journal choice, materially the same top tier the Rowley survey later identified, while the journal being open access specifically mattered less on its own, though it remained a significant factor for many respondents2. They also found that journals charging higher publication fees tended to have higher impact factors, and that article-processing-charge levels varied substantially by discipline according to how much grant funding was typically available to cover them2. A 2022 industry-sponsored survey of 62 medical-communications and pharmaceutical-industry professionals found a compatible pattern specifically around speed: 87% said review time affected journal choice and 85% said time to publication did, with 68% considering three months or less from submission to acceptance a reasonable expectation, and 74% expecting to pay between US$2,500 and US$5,000 per article in open-access fees4.
Early-career researchers and the increased importance of speed during the pandemic
Career stage does, however, appear to matter for one specific factor that the main Rowley survey did not isolate, namely urgency. A 2022 study by Nicholas and colleagues interviewed 177 early-career researchers across eight countries about how they chose journals and whether the pandemic changed that process3. For most of these early-career researchers, the pandemic made little overall difference to how they selected a journal; they still generally aimed for the highest-prestige, highest-impact-factor outlet they believed their work could reach, with scope fit being the one major factor not tied directly to journal quality3. The principal change was an increased awareness of the need for faster turnaround, as rapid publication became comparatively more valuable during a period in which timely results mattered more and normal institutional and personal routines were disrupted3. This finding sits alongside a larger 2020 international survey of early-career researchers' scholarly communication attitudes, which drew 1,600 responses with substantial representation from China, Russia, and Poland, underscoring that a single Western-skewed sample, such as the Taylor & Francis-based survey discussed above, may not capture how career stage and country interact in practice6.
Differing priorities of reviewers, industry writers and practitioners
Examining the review side of the process, rather than the authoring side, modifies this picture to some extent. IOP Publishing's 2020 Peer Review Survey Insights, based on over 1,200 researchers who had reviewed or been invited to review for its journals, found that interest in the paper itself was reviewers' top motivator (a weighted average of 4.2 out of 5), with journal reputation second at 3.9, and found that these motivations were broadly similar across career stages, although early-career reviewers placed relatively more weight on recognition and on building a relationship with the editor7. A 2013 survey comparing 316 library and information studies researchers and practitioners found a sharper split: 76% of researchers rated journal impact factor important or very important, compared with only 46% of librarians, and the two groups differed significantly (at the 1% level) on ten separate factors including reputation, peer review, CV value, and speed of publication8. Both groups agreed that peer review and topical fit were the only two factors rated at the maximum median score, reinforcing that, irrespective of other variation by role or sector, confidence that review is rigorous and that the work is genuinely within scope consistently anchors the decision8.
Qualitative evidence on the reduced importance of prestige
Not every study of journal choice places prestige at the top. A qualitative study by Willinsky, Alperin, Moorhead, Maggio, and Chtena conducted five focus groups with 22 medical-education authors and editors and found that participants placed less emphasis on journal prestige than earlier survey-based research had suggested, while giving more active consideration to open-access status, technical submission requirements, and social factors such as personal relationships and prior experience with a journal's editors10. A separate international survey of health professions education authors similarly confirmed that scope fit and perceived quality remain central to journal choice in that field, echoing the broader pattern, even as the specific weighting of individual factors can shift from one disciplinary community to the next9. Considered together with the quantitative survey evidence above, the qualitative work provides a useful check: a ranked list of factors from a large survey describes an average respondent, whereas the reasons individual authors give, in their own words, for choosing a particular journal do not always place the same factor first.
Key points
Key points
When asked directly, researchers ranked journal reputation, confidence in scope fit and the reliability of the review process as the principal factors in deciding where to submit, and this ranking was consistent across career stage, role and discipline.
Practical application
Practical application
- Reputation and scope fit should be weighted most heavily when a shortlist is compiled. This is consistent with the priorities reported by the surveyed research community, which ranked these factors above speed or cost alone.
- Career stage need not alter the priorities applied in journal selection. The survey found little variation in factor rankings by publishing experience, role or discipline, so the same order of priorities is a reasonable starting point at any career stage.
- Review-process reliability should be treated as a concrete, verifiable criterion. Authors should seek information on a journal’s typical review timeline and outcomes before submitting, rather than regarding review quality as assessable only retrospectively.
Frequently asked questions
A 1.5% response rate from a mass, unsolicited invitation is a genuine limitation and should be read as indicative of the respondents who did reply rather than as fully representative of all 73,000 people invited; the survey's value lies in the 1,085 responses being large enough to compare factor rankings against one another, not in the response rate itself.
The original ranked-factors analysis did not report gender breakdowns, but a companion 2021 analysis of the same dataset found 20 of 49 journal-choice statements differed significantly by gender, with men weighting familiarity, experience, and speed higher and women weighting authority, scope fit, and career-progression factors higher.
Cost specifically ranked lower than fit, quality, and speed in the Solomon and Björk open-access survey, but a 2022 industry survey found a large majority of respondents still factored review and publication speed directly into journal choice, and about three-quarters expected to pay US$2,500-5,000 per article in open-access fees.
No single study answers this question definitively, but a 2020 global survey of 1,600 early-career researchers with strong representation from China, Russia, and Poland suggests genuine variation by country and career stage that a single Western-skewed sample cannot fully capture.
References
- Rowley J, Sbaffi L, Sugden M, Gilbert A. Factors influencing researchers' journal selection decisions. Journal of Information Science. 2022;48(3):321-335. read 10 October 2026. View on Journal of Information Science
- Solomon DJ, Björk BC. Publication fees in open access publishing: Sources of funding and factors influencing choice of journal. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology. 2012;63(1):98-107. read 10 October 2026. View on JASIST
- Nicholas D, Herman E, Clark D, Boukacem-Zeghmouri C, Rodríguez-Bravo B, Abrizah A, Watkinson A, Xu J, Sims D, Serbina G, Świgoń M, Jamali HR, Tenopir C, Allard S. Choosing the 'right' journal for publication: Perceptions and practices of pandemic-era early career researchers. Learned Publishing. 2022;35(4):605-616. read 10 October 2026. View on Learned Publishing
- Sheikh N, Gothard D, Timbrell A, Blankenship E. Real-life factors influencing journal selection. 18th ISMPP Annual Meeting poster, 2022. read 10 October 2026. View poster
- Rowley J, Sbaffi L. Investigating gender differences in journal selection decisions: a survey of academic researchers. Learned Publishing. 2021;34(3):294-304. read 10 October 2026. View on Learned Publishing
- Nicholas D, Jamali HR, Herman E, Watkinson A, Abrizah A, Rodríguez-Bravo B, Boukacem-Zeghmouri C, Xu J, Świgoń M, Polezhaeva T. A global questionnaire survey of the scholarly communication attitudes and behaviours of early career researchers. Learned Publishing. 2020;33(3):198-211. read 10 October 2026. View on Learned Publishing
- IOP Publishing. Peer Review Survey Insights 2020. read 10 October 2026. View on IOP Publishing
- Dalton M. A dissemination divide? The factors that influence the journal selection decision of Library and Information Studies (LIS) researchers and practitioners. Library and Information Research. 2013;37(115):33-57. read 10 October 2026. View on Library and Information Research
- Rees EL, Burton O, Asif A, Eva KW. A method for the madness: An international survey of health professions education authors' journal choice. Perspectives on Medical Education. 2022. read 10 October 2026. View on Perspectives on Medical Education
- Willinsky JM, Alperin JP, Moorhead L, Maggio LA, Chtena N. "The Best Home for This Paper": A qualitative study of how authors select where to submit manuscripts. Perspectives on Medical Education. 2024;13(1). read 10 October 2026. View on Perspectives on Medical Education
Every source above is a peer-reviewed article, a publisher’s record of one, or a standard issued by the body that owns it. Each carries the date it was last read. Where a standard moves, this article is revised rather than left up with a note.
How to cite this article
Pick your referencing style and copy it. Your university or target journal may vary the punctuation — check its guide if it has one.
Pubrica Academy. (2026, October 10). Investigating Journal Selection Decisions: Findings of a Survey of Academic Researchers. Pubrica. https://pubrica.com/academy/concepts-definitions/investigating-journal-selection-decisions-a-survey-of-academic-researchers/
Pubrica Academy. “Investigating Journal Selection Decisions: Findings of a Survey of Academic Researchers.” Pubrica, 10 Oct. 2026, pubrica.com/academy/concepts-definitions/investigating-journal-selection-decisions-a-survey-of-academic-researchers/.
Pubrica Academy (2026) Investigating Journal Selection Decisions: Findings of a Survey of Academic Researchers. Pubrica. Available at: https://pubrica.com/academy/concepts-definitions/investigating-journal-selection-decisions-a-survey-of-academic-researchers/ (Accessed: 15 October 2026).
Pubrica Academy. “Investigating Journal Selection Decisions: Findings of a Survey of Academic Researchers.” Pubrica. October 10, 2026. https://pubrica.com/academy/concepts-definitions/investigating-journal-selection-decisions-a-survey-of-academic-researchers/
Pubrica Academy, ‘Investigating Journal Selection Decisions: Findings of a Survey of Academic Researchers’ (Pubrica, 10 October 2026) <https://pubrica.com/academy/concepts-definitions/investigating-journal-selection-decisions-a-survey-of-academic-researchers/> accessed 15 October 2026.
Pubrica Academy. Investigating Journal Selection Decisions: Findings of a Survey of Academic Researchers. [Internet]. Pubrica; 2026 Oct 10 [cited 2026 Oct 15]. Available from: https://pubrica.com/academy/concepts-definitions/investigating-journal-selection-decisions-a-survey-of-academic-researchers/
Pubrica Academy, “Investigating Journal Selection Decisions: Findings of a Survey of Academic Researchers,” Pubrica, Oct. 10, 2026. [Online]. Available: https://pubrica.com/academy/concepts-definitions/investigating-journal-selection-decisions-a-survey-of-academic-researchers/
@misc{/la_journal_selection_decisions_survey_researchers_2026,
author = {{Pubrica Academy}},
title = {Investigating Journal Selection Decisions: Findings of a Survey of Academic Researchers},
howpublished = {Pubrica},
year = {2026},
month = {oct},
url = {https://pubrica.com/academy/concepts-definitions/investigating-journal-selection-decisions-a-survey-of-academic-researchers/},
note = {Accessed: <span data-cite-acc="iso">2026-10-15</span>}
}This article is written to be learned from. Cite it if you are referring to what it says; if you are using the evidence behind it, cite the sources listed above instead.
Journal Shortlist Scorecard
Score candidate journals against the factors researchers themselves rank highest.
[ ] Scored each candidate journal on reputation within your field (1-10) [ ] Scored your confidence that the manuscript is genuinely in scope (1-10) [ ] Checked available evidence on review-process reliability (published timelines, colleague feedback) [ ] Checked available evidence on the usefulness/depth of past reviewer feedback where known [ ] Compared total scores across your shortlist before deciding
Pubrica AcademyWritten and maintained by Pubrica’s subject matter experts. Articles are revised when the underlying standards change, and each article states the date on which it was last reviewed.
How Pubrica can help
Pubrica’s journal selection advisory service assesses candidate journals against the reputation, scope-fit and review-reliability factors that researchers rank highest, so that the shortlist is evidence-based rather than habitual.