Free scoping read. A written assessment of your manuscript in two business days, at no cost.

Start one

Effective Methods for Metabarcoding Fungi

Experimental Design Sample Work

Effective methods for metabarcoding fungi: from experimental design to outcomes
Abstract

The advancement of high-throughput Sequencing (HTS) technology has dramatically improved our ability to detect fungi and reveal their ecological research importance in a wide range of habitats.

Overview:

From experimental design to molecular and computational analyses, we present an overview of current best practices in the metabarcoding investigation of fungal communities. We show that operational taxonomic units (OTUs) outperform amplified sequence variants (ASVs) in recovering fungal diversity, especially for lengthy markers, by reanalyzing published data collection sets. Furthermore, as compared to the ITS2 sub region, examination of the whole ITS region allows for more precise taxonomic placement of fungus and other eukaryotes. Finally, we show that specialized strategies for analyzing compositional data yield more trustworthy estimations of community structure alterations.

Conclusion:

We conclude that fungus metabarcoding investigations are especially promising for integrating fungi into the complete microbiome and larger systematic ecosystem functioning environment, recovering new fungal lineages and ancient species, and barcoding old specimens, including type material.

Experimental Research | Genome Sequencing | Bioinformatics | Statistical Analyses |

Related Topics:

A methods review that runs from field plot to statistical model

This experimental design sample is a methods review of how to study fungal communities by DNA metabarcoding. It covers study design, sampling, molecular work, bioinformatics, statistics and future directions, and its keywords are biodiversity, bioinformatics, community ecology, experiment setup, molecular identification and statistical analyses. The abstract makes three claims drawn from reanalysis of published datasets. First, operational taxonomic units (OTUs) recover fungal diversity better than amplicon sequence variants (ASVs), especially for long markers. Second, the full ITS region places fungi more precisely than the ITS2 subregion alone. Third, methods designed for compositional data give more reliable estimates of shifts in community structure. Mycologists, microbial ecologists and doctoral researchers planning high-throughput sequencing projects are the main readers.

From Sanger barcodes to high-throughput surveys of fungal communities

The introduction traces how fungi have been identified. Identification began with the morphology of fruiting bodies or cultures. From the late 1980s, PCR and Sanger sequencing of the 18S and 28S rRNA genes and the internal transcribed spacer (ITS) region allowed species- and genus-level identification. Cloning then made it possible to survey mixed substrates such as soil, roots and water. These studies produced tens to hundreds of reads, far fewer than the thousands needed to characterise soil fungal diversity accurately. High-throughput sequencing changed the scale of the work and made dedicated bioinformatic pipelines essential.

Design and sampling decisions to settle before fieldwork

  • Representativeness and independence: sites should span the geographical and ecological scope of the question and avoid spatiotemporal autocorrelation. The number of biological replicates can be estimated from variance reported in earlier studies or from pilot data.
  • Pooling: pooling 7 to 25 subsamples is common and improves estimates of richness. The review advises against pooling heterogeneous material, such as leaves from different plant species, and against pooling for co-occurrence analyses.
  • Field hygiene: wear disposable gloves; sterilise tools with bleach, DNase solutions or flame rather than alcohol, which does not denature DNA; sample in dry weather; include field controls; keep samples cool in transit.

Laboratory and bioinformatic safeguards against artefacts

For DNA extraction, the review recommends thorough homogenisation, keeping backup material and not filling extraction kits to their maximum capacity. It reports that 0.25, 1 or 10 g of well-homogenised soil gives similar richness, but that replicate extractions give more reproducible estimates. Extraction and PCR should take place in separate rooms, with blank controls. On primers, it explains that many date from early Sanger work and mismatch some fungal groups. It singles out ITS1F as problematic, notes that an intron near the end of the 18S gene can block amplification, and suggests degenerate positions to reduce bias.

Index switching, where reads are assigned to the wrong sample, is described as the most damaging artefact in high-throughput data, with about 0.01–0.1% of switches persisting even with careful indexing. The review lists UNCROSS, spike-ins, positive controls and pseudosamples from unused indexes as ways to estimate the rate. A figure compares OTU-based clustering with ASV methods such as DADA2 and UNOISE.

Statistical recommendations, including what to avoid

The statistics section favours Hill numbers and conventional diversity indices. Unless data are rarefied, it recommends including log- or square-root-transformed sequencing depth as a covariate. It advises against richness extrapolations such as Chao1 and ACE, because these depend on the rarest OTUs, which are often artefacts. For phylogenetic diversity, it lists PD, MPD, UniFrac and MNTD, computed with tools such as phylocom and the R package picante. The closing section points to stable-isotope probing, ancient DNA and barcoding of century-old type specimens as areas where metabarcoding is extending mycology.

Adapting the sample for a grant methods section

A researcher can treat the review as a checklist of decisions to justify in a proposal: replication, pooling, controls, primer choice, how index switches will be handled, and the statistical model. Its figures are credited to Tedersoo et al. (2022), and any reuse should cite the primary methods papers in the same way. Every recommendation in the sample is tied to a citation, which helps reviewers who will want to know whether a choice such as removing singletons or rarefying reads rests on evidence or on habit.

Pubrica supports projects like this through experimental design consulting. The modelling plan can be developed with the biostatistics and statistical programming team, and the background reading can be organised through a literature review and gap analysis.

Questions about this sample

Why does the sample favour OTUs over ASVs for fungi?

Based on reanalysis of published datasets, the review reports that clustering reads into operational taxonomic units recovers fungal diversity better than amplicon sequence variants, especially for long markers such as the full ITS region. Exact-variant methods can split one fungal species into several variants or lose sequences in long, variable amplicons.

Should soil subsamples be pooled before DNA extraction?

Often, yes. Pooling 7 to 25 subsamples improves estimates of richness and composition at low cost. The review warns against pooling heterogeneous material, such as leaves from different plant species, against pooling when low-DNA samples hold distinct rare taxa, and against pooling for analyses of co-occurrence between organisms.

Why is alcohol not recommended for cleaning sampling tools?

Alcohol does not denature DNA, so traces from one sample can carry over to the next. The review recommends oxidising agents such as bleach, DNase solutions or flaming between sampling events, together with disposable gloves and field controls, to reduce cross-contamination.

Which richness estimators does the review advise against?

It advises against extrapolated richness estimators such as Chao1 and ACE, because they depend on the number of very rare OTUs, which are often sequencing or PCR artefacts. It prefers observed richness modelled with sequencing depth as a covariate, together with Hill numbers and phylogenetic diversity measures.

sample-workimage-for-sidebar

Research your Services with our experts

Delivered on-time or your money back

Give yourself the academic edge today

Each order includes

  • On-time delivery or your money back
  • A fully qualified writer in your subject
  • In-depth proofreading by our Quality Control Team
  • 100% confidentiality, the work is never re-sold or published
  • Standard 7-day amendment period
  • A paper written to the standard ordered
  • A detailed plagiarism report
  • A comprehensive quality report

Enquire Now

Get a free quote

Regulations

Check your project against this rule

  1. 1Your work
  2. 2Your details
  3. 3Send
What do you need?

Material you send is held under signed confidentiality, with access limited to the assigned team and encrypted transfer. It is not used to train anything and is not passed to third-party tools. Ask for the agreement before you send anything you would rather cover first.