Free scoping read. A written assessment of your manuscript in two business days, at no cost.

Start one
Home·Insights·Study guide·Journal submission

What Are the Processes Involved in Journal Submission?

Submission is usually described as uploading a manuscript. It is closer to completing a form, and several fields in that form have measurable effects on what happens next. Manuscripts reviewed only by reviewers the authors had named were accepted 89 per cent of the time. Panels the editors assembled accepted 67 per cent. This article sets out what the form asks for and what the evidence says about each answer.

What you will learn
  • What a submission consists of beyond the manuscript file
  • The measured effect of naming your own reviewers, and why editors discount it
  • What reformatting for a second journal costs in time, money and delay
What to unlearn
  • “Suggested reviewers are a neutral convenience.” Across 23,964 reviews they rated manuscripts substantially more favourably than editor-selected reviewers, and the gap persists within the same manuscript.
  • “Rejection ends a manuscript.” In one journal's cohort of 554 rejected papers, 56 per cent were published elsewhere, at a mean delay of about 16 months.

What this article covers

This article covers one stage in detail: the act of submitting, from a finished manuscript to the point at which an editor opens it. The surrounding stages are treated elsewhere, and what is examined here is the submission itself. It is a set of files, a set of declarations and a set of choices entered into a web form. Several of those choices are made without much deliberation.

The emphasis falls on the choices that have been measured. Two of them have a substantial literature behind them, and the findings are not what most authors assume. Naming preferred reviewers changes the reviews that come back. Reformatting for each successive journal consumes a quantity of time that has been estimated in aggregate. It is larger than most authors would guess.

The declarations are treated as a second theme. A submission commits the corresponding author to statements about funding, conflicts, registration, consent and the use of software, all of which are archived. Several of them are easier to assemble before the form is opened than during it, and the article notes which.

Where this sits among the related articles

The full arc from completed study to published paper is covered in the process of publishing a research paper. That article gives the handling times, where rejection happens and what peer review detects. The internal structure of the manuscript is covered in how to structure a research article.

The anatomy of a submission

A submission has three parts that behave differently. The first is the manuscript and its supporting files. The second is metadata typed into the system, including title, abstract, keywords and the author list. The third is a set of declarations the corresponding author makes on behalf of everyone named. Authors generally prepare the first thoroughly, the second hastily, and the third at the moment the form demands it.

The title page carries more than a title

Editorial guidance treats the title page as a structured document. General information about an article and its authors is presented there.1 It usually carries the title, author information, any disclaimers, sources of support and a word count.1 Disclosure information for each author needs to be part of the manuscript.1 The listing of persistent author identifiers is encouraged alongside those details.1 Funding sources and affiliations that did not contribute to the work should not be listed.1

That last instruction is more pointed than it appears. An affiliation listed for prestige rather than contribution misstates where the work was done. The same guidance asks the methods section to carry a statement about ethics approval.1 It records that the research was approved by an independent review body.1 Both are matters of record rather than of presentation, and both are checked.

The completed checklist is part of the package

Most journals now ask for a completed reporting checklist alongside the manuscript. Journals are encouraged to ask authors to follow reporting guidelines, because they help authors describe the study.1 The relevant guideline is determined by the study design. A library of them is maintained by the EQUATOR Network, which listed 709 entries at the time of writing.2 Separate guidelines cover trials, systematic reviews, observational studies, case reports and several other designs.2

A checklist completed against the final manuscript is a different document from one completed against an earlier draft. The page numbers in the second will not point at anything. This is a routine cause of queries from an editorial office. It is avoidable by completing the checklist last rather than first.

Figures: evidence on the submission process

Figure 1 summarises research on how reviewers suggested by authors compare with those selected by editors. Figure 2 shows the time authors spend on formatting and reformatting manuscripts. Together they help authors make informed decisions when preparing a submission.

Figure 1 · What author-suggested reviewers do

Two studies, two decades apart, measuring different things and agreeing on the direction.

RECOMMENDATIONS — 788 reviews, 10 journalsEditor-suggested46.0%30.4%23.6%Author-suggested56.9%30.1%12.9%AcceptReviseRejectACCEPTANCE BY PANEL COMPOSITION — 7,965 manuscriptsAll editor-suggested67%Mixed panels79%All author-suggested89%0255075100Per cent

What to look for. The two panels measure different things. The upper one counts what individual reviewers recommended, and the difference there falls almost entirely on the reject column, which halves. The lower one counts what happened to the manuscript, and the gap between the end bars is 22 percentage points. The direction is the same in both, although they are very different studies. One covers ten biomedical journals in 2006, the other a single large journal section analysed in 2022.

Lower panel group sizes: 4,556 all-editor panels, 2,596 mixed panels without author-opposed reviewers, and 762 all-author panels. Positions are to scale on a linear axis.

Figure 2 · What formatting costs the author

Self-reported medians from one survey, and reformatting delay from a separate cross-sectional study.

MEDIAN TIME AND COST PER AUTHOR — 372 respondents14 hoursper manuscript52 hoursper yearUS$477per manuscriptUS$1,908per yearDELAY ATTRIBUTABLE TO REFORMATTINGResubmissions delayed > 2 weeks51%Submissions delayed > 3 monthsabout 20%0255075100Per cent

What to look for. The marked tile is the annual figure, and it is the one that compounds. A median author reported four manuscripts a year and two submission attempts before acceptance. That is what turns fourteen hours into fifty-two. The delay panel comes from a different study and a different sample. The two panels are two independent estimates of the same burden rather than one account.

Costs are self-reported in US dollars and were derived by respondents from their own income. The second study estimated the worldwide aggregate at roughly 23.8 million hours a year.

The declarations the form collects

The declarations are the part of a submission that binds people other than the person typing. They are made by the corresponding author on behalf of everyone named, and they are archived by the journal. Assembling them before the form is opened is faster than assembling them inside it. The list is short enough to prepare in advance.

The corresponding author's responsibilities

The role is defined narrowly and carries real weight. The corresponding author is the one individual who takes primary responsibility for communication with the journal.1 That person handles details of authorship, ethics committee approval and clinical trial registration documentation.1 Those duties may be delegated to co-authors.1 The corresponding author should be available throughout submission and peer review to answer editorial queries promptly.1

Conflicts bind everyone, not only authors

Disclosure is required of all participants in the peer-review and publication process.1 That includes peer reviewers, editors and editorial board members.1 Authors are responsible for disclosing all relationships and activities that might bias or be seen to bias their work.1 Reviewers must disclose anything that could bias their opinion of the manuscript.1 Editors with a potential conflict should recuse themselves from the decision.1

The phrase about being seen to bias is the operative one. It sets the test at appearance rather than at actual influence, which removes the judgement an author might otherwise exercise. Articles should also carry statements of the authors' relationships and activities.1 The sources of support belong there, and whether the authors had access to the study data.1

The declarations that depend on earlier decisions

Several items cannot be produced at submission if they were not arranged earlier. Trials must be registered at or before the time of first patient consent for enrolment.1 Registration is a condition of consideration for publication.1 Manuscripts reporting clinical trial results must contain a data sharing statement.1 Where work overlaps with published or pending material, the letter of submission should clearly say so, and copies should be provided.1 A preprint posting must be reported to the journal.1

Consent to publish is narrower than consent to participate

Identifying information such as names, initials or hospital numbers should not be published unless essential and consented to.1 Consent for this purpose requires that an identifiable patient be shown the manuscript to be published.1 That consent should be written, and archived with the journal, the authors or both.1 Consent obtained at enrolment does not satisfy this. The patient has to see the text that will appear.

Software use is declared in two places

Where an artificial intelligence tool was used, journals are directed to require disclosure.1 Authors should describe the use in both the cover letter and the submitted work.1 Use in conducting the study belongs in the methods section.1 The duplication is deliberate, since the cover letter reaches the editor and the manuscript reaches the reader. Each audience is being told something it needs for a different purpose.

Suggested and opposed reviewers

Most submission systems ask for preferred reviewers and for reviewers to exclude. The fields look administrative and are usually filled in quickly. They have been studied twice at scale, and in both studies the answers changed what came back. This is the part of a submission where an author's input has the largest measured effect on the outcome.

The 2006 study of ten journals

An observational study covered original research papers sent for external review at ten biomedical journals.3 Editors chose reviewers as usual, and administrators then requested an extra review from the top of the author's list.3 The study covered 329 manuscripts and 788 reviews.3 Of those reviews, 366 came from author-suggested reviewers and 422 from editor-suggested ones.3

Review quality did not differ between the two groups. Mean scores on a review quality instrument were 2.58 for author-suggested reviewers and 2.64 for editor-suggested.3 The mean paired difference was −0.05, with an interval from −0.15 to 0.04.3 Recommendations did differ, and by a wide margin. Author-suggested reviewers recommended acceptance in 56.9 per cent of cases against 46.0 per cent for editor-suggested.3 They recommended rejection in 12.9 per cent against 23.6 per cent.3

The result that complicates the picture

At the five journals where reviews were blinded, the odds of an accept recommendation were 1.64 times higher for author-suggested reviewers, with an interval from 1.02 to 2.66.3 At the one journal where reviews were open and signed, the odds ratio was 12.4, with an interval from 1.60 to 95.8.3 The difference between the two settings was itself significant.3 The interval on the open-review figure is very wide, so the magnitude is uncertain even though the direction is not.

The 2022 study at scale

A later analysis covered the neuroscience section of a large journal.4 It examined 7,965 manuscripts and 23,964 reviews, from 46,455 authors and 21,665 reviewers.4 Author-suggested reviewers scored manuscripts higher on a five-point scale.4 The contrast was 0.364, at an effect size of 0.415.4 The gap persisted within individual manuscripts, where the difference was 0.222 across 2,488 comparisons.4

The consequence of that difference appears in the decisions themselves. Manuscripts reviewed by panels made entirely of editor-suggested reviewers were accepted 67 per cent of the time.4 Panels made entirely of author-suggested reviewers accepted 89 per cent.4 Mixed panels without author-opposed reviewers fell between, at 79 per cent.4 The authors reached no comfortable conclusion, writing that the results “should make us think about the consequence of this practice for science”.4

The practical reading

The 2006 authors drew the distinction that matters. Editors can be confident that author-suggested reviewers will complete adequate reviews.3 They should be cautious about relying on the recommendations.3 Both findings are consistent with that reading. The reviews are competent and the verdicts are soft. An editor who knows this discounts the recommendation accordingly. A favourable review from a suggested reviewer therefore carries less weight than its wording implies.

One further figure bears on the practical question. Author-suggested reviewers accepted invitations less often, at 45.6 per cent against 59.2 per cent.4 Naming people who will decline slows the handling of the manuscript without improving it. Naming people with a genuine subject match is the use of the field that survives scrutiny. Declaring any relationship with them is part of that use.

Formatting, and what it costs

Formatting is the least intellectual part of a submission and one of the most expensive. Two studies published in 2019 measured it from different directions, one by survey and one by examining journal requirements. Their estimates are rough and they say so. The order of magnitude is nonetheless consistent, and larger than most authors assume.

Time and cost as authors report them

A survey analysed 372 respondents from 41 countries.5 Most were scientists or researchers, with students, research assistants and clinicians also represented.5 The median time spent formatting a single manuscript was 14 hours.5 The median per person per year was 52 hours.5 Respondents reported a median of four manuscripts formatted per year and two submission attempts before acceptance.5

Respondents converted that time into money using their own incomes. The median cost was 477 US dollars per manuscript and 1,908 US dollars per person per year.5 The median reported income band was 61,000 to 80,999 US dollars.5 The authors used the findings to argue for eliminating strict formatting guidelines, at least before acceptance.5

Requirements across ninety-six journals

A cross-sectional study examined submission requirements at 96 journals, twelve from each of eight fields.6 It surveyed first or corresponding authors of three recent manuscripts from each journal, giving 288 authors and 206 responses.6 Among authors reporting on time, 77 of 118 spent at least one to three days reformatting.6 A day is defined there as eight hours.6

The delay figures are the more useful ones. Reformatting delayed publication by more than two weeks in 51 per cent of resubmissions.6 About 20 per cent of submissions were delayed more than three months by format revisions alone.6 The authors estimated the worldwide burden at about 23.8 million hours a year.6 They put the annual cost at roughly 550 million US dollars for corresponding authors.6 Including whole research teams raises that to about 1.1 billion.6

How firmly to hold the money figures

The aggregate costs are described by their own authors as rough estimates.6 They were built from a first-year postdoctoral salary of 48,432 US dollars.6 They also used the lower end of the reported time ranges.6 The survey figures rest on self-report and on respondents valuing their own time.6 The time estimates are the firmer part of both studies. The delay proportions are firmer still, because they describe observed outcomes rather than imputed value.

Format-free submission

A partial remedy exists and has been adopted unevenly. Format-free submission allows a manuscript to be sent in whatever layout the author has, with formatting handled after a decision.7 One publisher launched such an initiative in 2013, and others have followed.7 One of them reported more than 680 of its journals offering free format.7 Another applied it across roughly 250 journals from inception.7 One large open-access journal requires formatting only after provisional acceptance.7

The practical consequence for an author is a question worth asking before the first submission. Where a journal accepts an unformatted initial submission, the fourteen hours are spent only once. They are also spent only on a manuscript that has survived. Where it does not, they are spent again at each attempt. Checking that policy before the first submission costs a minute.

Rejection and the next submission

Most submissions end in rejection, and most rejected manuscripts are submitted again. The second submission is where the formatting cost recurs and where the declarations have to be reassembled. It is also, on the available evidence, where a majority of rejected papers eventually succeed.

The fate of one journal's rejections

A cohort study tracked every manuscript rejected by one specialty journal's editorial office in a single year.8 The cohort was 554 manuscripts, comprising 251 major studies, 272 case reports and 29 technical notes or reviews.8 Of those, 315 were subsequently published elsewhere, a proportion of 56 per cent.8 Major studies fared best at 62 per cent, case reports reached 53 per cent, and technical notes 55 per cent.8

The delay before that eventual publication was substantial in every category. The mean time from rejection to publication was 15.8 months.8 The standard deviation was 7.5 and the median 14.5.8 Individual delays ran from one month to just over 37.8 The papers were dispersed across roughly 115 journals.8 The single most frequent destination took 37 of them.8 Journals in the same specialty accounted for 190 of the 315.8

Two cautions on this cohort

The study covers one journal in one specialty in 2004, and publishing has changed since. Its own reporting is also inconsistent in places: the abstract gives 115 destination journals while the body gives 116, 118 and 119 at different points.8 The authors summarise their finding as publication within two to three years.8 That is a wider frame than the mean of about 16 months they report.8 The proportion and the direction are the durable parts.

The cost of a second submission

The two cost studies become relevant again at this point. A median author reported two submission attempts before acceptance.5 At a median of 14 hours per manuscript, a second attempt roughly doubles the formatting time for that paper.5 Reformatting delayed more than half of resubmissions by over two weeks.6 The delay from rejection to eventual publication was measured in months rather than weeks.8

Items that carry over, and items that do not

Some of the first submission survives into the second and some does not. The declarations carry over, because registration, consent, conflicts and data sharing describe the study rather than the journal. The reporting checklist carries over, though its page references will need redoing against the new manuscript. The cover letter does not carry over, because it argues fit with a specific journal. Neither does the reviewer list, since the people suited to one readership may not suit another.

The limits of a careful submission

A submission prepared well removes certain outcomes and leaves others untouched. Distinguishing the two prevents a familiar disappointment, since effort spent on presentation cannot compensate for something presentation does not reach.

Failures that preparation removes

Three categories of failure are avoidable at this stage. The first is administrative return, where a submission is sent back for a missing statement, an incomplete checklist or an unsigned disclosure. The second is a mismatch the author could have detected. Scope is readable from the aims statement and recent issues. The third is delay caused by reformatting, which the published policies make predictable.6

Failures beyond its reach

The manuscript still describes a study that was already conducted. No submission choice alters the design, the sample size or the effect that was observed. The reviewer fields are the closest thing to a lever, and the evidence on them cuts both ways. A favourable review obtained from a named reviewer is discounted by an editor who knows the literature.3 That is what the 2006 authors stated directly.3

There is a further reason for restraint. Review panels composed entirely of author-suggested reviewers produced an acceptance rate 22 percentage points above editor-assembled panels.4 A gap of that size is visible to anyone studying a journal's records. Journals respond to such findings by weighting suggestions less, or by requiring that relationships be declared. The practical value of the field therefore declines as the evidence accumulates.

The declarations outlast the decision

One asymmetry between the two outcomes is worth holding in view. A rejected manuscript disappears from the journal's active record, but the declarations made at submission do not. They were archived, and they described the study rather than the submission.1 A conflict omitted at the first attempt and declared at the second leaves two inconsistent records of the same work. The incentive to assemble these carefully is strongest at the first submission. That is also when the temptation to rush them is strongest.

Take-home message

A submission is a manuscript, a set of metadata and a set of archived declarations. The declarations bind everyone named, and several depend on decisions taken long before. Registration must precede first consent, and identifiable patient material needs written consent. The reviewer fields are the one place where an author's entry has a large measured effect. Author-suggested reviewers write reviews of equal quality but recommend acceptance far more often. Panels composed entirely of them accepted 89 per cent of manuscripts, against 67 per cent for editor-assembled panels. Formatting costs a median of 14 hours per manuscript and 52 hours a year. Reformatting delayed more than half of resubmissions by over two weeks. Rejection is not the end: in one cohort of 554 rejected papers, 56 per cent were published elsewhere at a mean delay of about 16 months.

How to apply this to your work

In order, from finished manuscript to upload
  1. Check whether the journal accepts a format-free initial submission. That decides whether the formatting hours are spent now or after a decision.
  2. Assemble the declarations before opening the form, covering conflicts, funding, registration, data sharing, consent and any software used.
  3. Confirm that every listed affiliation contributed to the work, and remove those that did not.
  4. Complete the reporting checklist against the final manuscript, not against an earlier draft, so the page references resolve.
  5. Name suggested reviewers on subject match alone. Declare any relationship with them rather than relying on the field going unexamined.
  6. Write the cover letter for this journal specifically, disclosing overlapping work and any preprint with its link.
  7. Confirm the corresponding author will be reachable through submission and review, since editorial queries are time-limited.
  8. Keep the declarations in a reusable file. They describe the study and will be needed again at the next journal.

Common questions

Does naming preferred reviewers actually change the outcome

Measurably so, in both of the studies that have examined it. Across 788 reviews at ten journals, author-suggested reviewers recommended acceptance in 56.9 per cent of cases.3 Editor-suggested reviewers did so in 46.0 per cent.3 Rejection ran at 12.9 per cent against 23.6.3 In a later analysis of 7,965 manuscripts, panels made entirely of author-suggested reviewers accepted 89 per cent against 67 per cent for all-editor panels.4

Are reviews from suggested reviewers lower quality

No. On a review quality instrument the means were 2.58 for author-suggested and 2.64 for editor-suggested reviewers.3 The paired difference was −0.05, with an interval from −0.15 to 0.04.3 The authors concluded that editors can be confident such reviewers will complete adequate reviews.3 They advise caution about relying on the recommendations.3

How much time does formatting a submission take

A median of 14 hours per manuscript and 52 hours per person per year.5 That comes from a survey of 372 respondents across 41 countries.5 Respondents valued that at 477 US dollars per manuscript and 1,908 per year using their own incomes.5 A separate study of 96 journals estimated about 23.8 million hours a year worldwide.6

What is format-free submission and who offers it

It allows a manuscript to be submitted in whatever layout the author has, with formatting handled after a decision.7 One publisher launched such an initiative in 2013.7 Another reported more than 680 journals offering it, and a third applied it across roughly 250 journals from inception.7 One large open-access journal requires formatting only after provisional acceptance.7

Which declarations have to be arranged before submission

Those that describe events rather than intentions. Trial registration must occur at or before the first patient's consent to enrolment as a condition of consideration.1 Written consent to publish identifiable material requires that the patient be shown the manuscript.1 Clinical trial reports must carry a data sharing statement.1 None of these three can be produced retrospectively.

Who is responsible for the conflict of interest declarations

Everyone in the process, not only the authors. Disclosure is required of all participants in peer review and publication, including reviewers, editors and editorial board members.1 Authors must disclose all relationships and activities that might bias or be seen to bias their work.1 The corresponding author takes primary responsibility for communication with the journal, though duties may be delegated.1

What happens to a manuscript after rejection

Usually another submission, and usually eventual publication. In a cohort of 554 manuscripts rejected by one specialty journal, 315 were published elsewhere, a proportion of 56 per cent.8 The mean delay from rejection to publication was 15.8 months, with individual delays from one month to just over 37.8 That cohort is from one journal in 2004 and should be read as indicative.

What carries over from one submission to the next

The declarations do, because registration, consent, conflicts and data sharing describe the study rather than the journal.1 The reporting checklist carries over, though page references need redoing against the new manuscript. The cover letter does not, since it argues fit with a specific journal. Nor does the reviewer list, because suitability depends on the readership.

Declared interest: Pubrica provides medical writing and publication support commercially. The two reviewer studies describe ten biomedical journals in 2006 and one section of one large journal in 2022. Neither establishes what any particular journal does now. The rejection cohort is from a single specialty journal in 2004. Nothing here should be read as advice to use the suggested-reviewer field to obtain a favourable outcome; the evidence is given so that an author understands how editors weight it.

References and sources

  1. International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing, and Publication of Scholarly Work in Medical Journals. Updated January 2026. read 21 October 2026; sections I.B, II.A.2, II.A.4, II.B.1, II.B.2, II.E, III.D.2, III.D.3.b, III.L.1, III.L.3, IV.A.2 and IV.A.3 were read. The document was truncated partway through IV.A.3.d, so section IV.B on sending the manuscript to the journal was not available and is not cited.View the Recommendations
  2. EQUATOR Network. Library of reporting guidelines, searchable by study type, clinical area and section of report. read 21 October 2026; the listing stated 709 reporting guidelines, and the portion returned covered roughly the first nine-tenths of the page.View the library
  3. Schroter S, Tite L, Hutchings A, Black N. Differences in review quality and recommendations for publication between peer reviewers suggested by authors or by editors. JAMA. 2006;295(3):314–317. doi:10.1001/jama.295.3.314 read 21 October 2026, in full at the journal.View the full text
  4. Acuna DE, Teplitskiy M, Evans JA, Kording K. Author-suggested reviewers rate manuscripts much more favorably: a cross-sectional analysis of the neuroscience section of PLOS ONE. PLoS ONE. 2022;17(12):e0273994. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0273994 read 21 October 2026, in full. The paper reports no odds ratios or confidence intervals for panel composition, so none are given here; the abstract's rounding of the panel gap to 20 points differs slightly from the 22-point gap in the results, and the results figures are the ones used.View the full text
  5. LeBlanc AG, Barnes JD, Saunders TJ, Tremblay MS, Chaput JP. Scientific sinkhole: the pernicious price of formatting. PLoS ONE. 2019;14(9):e0223116. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0223116 read 21 October 2026; 372 of 458 respondents were analysed. The table holding ranges and interquartile values was not in the text returned, so only medians are cited.View the full text
  6. Jiang Y, Lerrigo R, Ullah A, Alagappan M, Asch SM, Goodman SN, et al. The high resource impact of reformatting requirements for scientific papers. PLoS ONE. 2019;14(10):e0223976. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0223976 read 21 October 2026. The results report 206 responses while the abstract and satisfaction analysis cite 203; the results figure is used here. The authors describe their aggregate cost estimates as rough, and that description is carried over.View the full text
  7. Willis M. Format-free submission: gain for some, pain for others? Science Editing. 2023;10(1):92–95. doi:10.6087/kcse.302 read 21 October 2026, in full. This is an editorial commentary rather than a study, and its author is a researcher advocate at one of the publishers it discusses, a conflict the article itself discloses. It is cited here only for which publishers have adopted format-free submission, not for its arguments about the merits.View the article
  8. McDonald RJ, Cloft HJ, Kallmes DF. Fate of submitted manuscripts rejected from the American Journal of Neuroradiology: outcomes and commentary. American Journal of Neuroradiology. 2007;28(8):1430–1434. doi:10.3174/ajnr.A0766 read 21 October 2026, in full. The abstract gives 115 destination journals while the body gives 116, 118 and 119 at different points; the abstract figure is cited here as approximate, and the discrepancy is stated on the page.View the full text

How to cite this article

Pick your referencing style and copy it. Your university or target journal may vary the punctuation — check its guide if it has one.

Pubrica Academy. (2026, October 21). The Journal Submission Process. Pubrica. https://pubrica.com/insights/study-guide/what-are-the-process-involved-in-journal-submission/
Pubrica Academy. “The Journal Submission Process.” Pubrica, 21 Oct. 2026, pubrica.com/insights/study-guide/what-are-the-process-involved-in-journal-submission/.
Pubrica Academy (2026) The Journal Submission Process. Available at: https://pubrica.com/insights/study-guide/what-are-the-process-involved-in-journal-submission/ (Accessed: 21 October 2026).
Pubrica Academy. “The Journal Submission Process.” Pubrica. October 21, 2026. https://pubrica.com/insights/study-guide/what-are-the-process-involved-in-journal-submission/.
Pubrica Academy, ‘The Journal Submission Process’ (Pubrica, 21 October 2026) <https://pubrica.com/insights/study-guide/what-are-the-process-involved-in-journal-submission/> accessed 21 October 2026.
Pubrica Academy. The Journal Submission Process [Internet]. Pubrica; 2026 Oct 21 [cited 2026 Oct 21]. Available from: https://pubrica.com/insights/study-guide/what-are-the-process-involved-in-journal-submission/
[1] Pubrica Academy, “The Journal Submission Process,” Pubrica, Oct. 21, 2026. [Online]. Available: https://pubrica.com/insights/study-guide/what-are-the-process-involved-in-journal-submission/
@misc{pubrica_sub_2026, author = {{Pubrica Academy}}, title = {The Journal Submission Process}, year = {2026}, month = {oct}, day = {21}, howpublished = {\url{https://pubrica.com/insights/study-guide/what-are-the-process-involved-in-journal-submission/}}, note = {Accessed: 2026-10-21} }

This article is written to be learned from. Cite it if you are referring to what it says; if you are using the evidence behind it, cite the sources listed above instead.

Journal submission checklist

Work through these before the submission form is opened.

BEFORE OPENING THE FORM
[ ] Journal's format-free policy checked, and formatting deferred if allowed
[ ] Author list final, with every affiliation checked for actual contribution
[ ] Affiliations listed for prestige rather than contribution removed
[ ] Author identifiers collected for everyone named
[ ] Corresponding author confirmed reachable through submission and review

DECLARATIONS TO ASSEMBLE IN ADVANCE
[ ] Conflict of interest disclosure obtained from every author
[ ] Test applied at appearance of bias, not only at actual influence
[ ] Funding sources listed, and non-contributing affiliations excluded
[ ] Ethics approval statement placed in the methods section
[ ] Trial registration number and register named, where applicable
[ ] Registration confirmed to predate the first participant's consent
[ ] Data sharing statement written, where the study is a clinical trial
[ ] Statement on whether authors had access to the study data
[ ] Written consent held for any identifiable patient material
[ ] That patient shown the manuscript text that will be published
[ ] Consent archived with the journal, the authors, or both
[ ] Use of software tools described in the cover letter and the manuscript
[ ] Use in conducting the study described in the methods

THE MANUSCRIPT PACKAGE
[ ] Reporting guideline for the design located in the guideline library
[ ] Checklist completed against the FINAL manuscript, not an earlier draft
[ ] Page and line references in the checklist confirmed to resolve
[ ] Title page carries title, authors, disclaimers, support and word count
[ ] Supplementary files named and referenced from the manuscript

THE COVER LETTER
[ ] Written for this journal specifically
[ ] Overlap with published or submitted work declared, with copies provided
[ ] Any preprint declared, with a link
[ ] Software use described

THE REVIEWER FIELDS
[ ] Suggested reviewers chosen on subject match alone
[ ] Any relationship with a suggested reviewer declared
[ ] Reviewers likely to decline not named merely to fill the field
[ ] Opposed reviewers listed with a reason, where the system asks

KEEP FOR THE NEXT SUBMISSION
[ ] Declarations saved in a reusable file
[ ] Checklist retained, with a note that page references need redoing
[ ] Cover letter marked as journal-specific and not reusable
PA
Pubrica Academy

Written and maintained by the subject matter experts of Pubrica who do this work. Articles are revised when the standard underneath them moves, and each one carries the date it was last checked against its sources.

How Pubrica helps

We assemble the declarations a submission has to carry. We complete the reporting checklist against the final manuscript, and prepare the cover letter for the specific journal.

Explore

Related reading in the Academy.

Picked from the same sub-topic and category as this piece, newest first.

Find something else

Search the rest of the Academy.

Open with no account. Type what you are working on, or open the full library to filter by category, sub-topic or resource type.

Get a free quote

Regulations

Check your project against this rule

  1. 1Your work
  2. 2Your details
  3. 3Send
What do you need?

Material you send is held under signed confidentiality, with access limited to the assigned team and encrypted transfer. It is not used to train anything and is not passed to third-party tools. Ask for the agreement before you send anything you would rather cover first.