How Should a Case Presentation Be Structured?
The case presentation is the one section of a case report that already exists before the writing starts, because the clinical record contains most of it. That is exactly why it goes wrong. The record was written to hand a patient on to the next clinician, who can look anything up; the manuscript is written for a reader with no access to the chart and no way to ask. Almost every decision in this section follows from that one difference.
- What happens to each part of the clinical record on its way into the manuscript
- Why the review of systems is cut hardest, and what a pertinent negative is
- Why the assessment and plan cannot be carried across, and what replaces it
- “The case presentation is the easy section, because the information is already written down.” The information exists, but it was selected for a different reader and a different purpose. Eight of its ten parts have to be cut back, rewritten, or supplied from outside the record altogether.
What this article covers
This article is about one section of a case report: the account of what happened to the patient. It takes the headings a clinician already writes under — chief complaint, history of present illness, past medical history, social and family history, review of systems, examination, investigations — and sets out what each one contributes to a published report, what has to be cut from it, and what the record does not contain at all.
It is a narrow subject on purpose. The requirements the whole manuscript has to satisfy, the reporting checklist, patient consent and de-identification, are covered separately and are not repeated here.
It is also a subject that gets skipped. A published curriculum for teaching learners to develop and present a case report covers choosing a case worth reporting, setting learning objectives, authorship, titles and posters; what it does not cover is how to structure the case presentation itself, or which clinical details belong in it.9 That gap is the reason for this article.
Three companion articles cover the neighbouring ground. The requirements the report must meet — the reporting checklist mapped to each section, and what journals demand on consent before they will review a manuscript — are in guidelines to authors in writing an effective medical case report. Deciding whether a case is worth reporting at all, and the components of the finished manuscript, are in how to write a case report. The examination and investigation modalities that appear across specialties are in clinical examination methods in case reports.
What none of them covers is how the clinical record becomes the section, which is the subject of everything below.
Two different things called a case presentation
The phrase means two distinct things, and a great deal of confused advice about structure comes from treating them as one.
The first is the oral case presentation: a clinician presenting a patient aloud to colleagues on a ward round, at a handover or in a teaching session. The second is the case presentation section of a written case report: the part of a manuscript that gives the account of what happened.
They draw on the same clinical material and are shaped by almost opposite constraints.
| Oral case presentation | Written case presentation section | |
|---|---|---|
| Audience | Colleagues present in the room | Readers elsewhere, possibly years later |
| Can they ask? | Yes, and they will interrupt | No, ever |
| Can they see the patient? | Usually | No |
| Shared context | The unit, the local protocols, the abbreviations | None that can be assumed |
| Purpose | To reach the next decision about this patient | To let a reader evaluate a case that is closed |
| Outcome | Not yet known | Known, and part of what is reported |
| Constraint | The listener’s attention, measured in minutes | The journal’s word limit, and permanence |
The practical consequences run in opposite directions. An oral presentation can compress, because a listener who needs more will ask for it, and it can rely on local shorthand, because everyone in the room shares it. A written section can do neither. Conversely the oral presentation must front-load, because attention is finite: a Royal College teaching tool on presenting via the SNAPPS model advises that the presentation “should not occupy more than 50% of the learning encounter”.6
The deeper difference is what the recitation of facts is for. In the written section the facts are the section. In the oral form they are the opening move. SNAPPS, a widely taught model for presenting to a preceptor, makes the facts step one of six: “summarize briefly the history and findings”, then “narrow the differential to two or three relevant possibilities”, “analyze the differential by comparing and contrasting the possibilities”, “probe the preceptor by asking questions about uncertainties, difficulties, or alternative approaches”, “plan management for the patient’s medical issues”, and “select a case-related issue for self-directed learning”.5 Its authors describe the traditional alternative as one where “the majority of the interaction with the preceptor focused on giving the facts of the case”.5
It is worth knowing that there is no settled structure for the oral presentation to compare the written section against. The inherited ordering is the SOAP note — subjective, objective, assessment, plan — and when one group surveyed students and internal medicine residents who had used both it and a problem-based alternative, 69% preferred the alternative and 19% preferred SOAP. On the measure most relevant here, “distills pertinent information”, the alternative was rated 4.63 against SOAP’s 3.17.7 That is one survey at one institution, with 59 respondents answering the comparative questions, so it settles nothing; it does show that the question is open.
Expectations also shift by specialty rather than holding across medicine. A published curriculum for preparing students for clerkships teaches them to “adjust the oral presentation according to the needs of the specialty”, so that it “adapts to the context, timing, content, and format expectations of the specialty” and “relevant data are included and irrelevant data are omitted according to specialty standards”.8
Everything below is about the written case presentation section of a case report: what belongs in it, what has to be cut from the clinical record on the way in, and what the record does not contain at all.
If you have arrived looking for how to present a patient aloud on a ward round, the clinical material in the sections below still applies — the sequence is the same, and so is the distinction between findings and impressions — but the selection rules do not. An oral presentation is edited for a listener who can interrupt you. Nothing on this page is written on that assumption.
Figures: structuring the case presentation
Figure 1 shows which elements of the clinical record carry over into the manuscript and which must be condensed, rewritten or added. Figure 2 maps familiar clinical headings to the topics that reporting checklists require. Authors can use them to turn case notes into a presentation that meets journal requirements.
Only two elements travel unchanged. Most are cut back, one is rewritten entirely, and two have to be added because the record does not contain them.
What to look for. The commonest fault in a case presentation is treating this as a copying exercise, which only two of the ten rows actually are. The record was written to hand a patient on to the next clinician, who can look up anything that was left out. The manuscript is written for a reader who has no access to the chart and cannot ask. That difference decides every selection on this page.
Schematic. The headings used here are the ones most commonly found in clinical documentation; local templates vary.
Clinicians write under the headings on the left. Reporting checklists ask for the topics on the right. They are not in one-to-one correspondence, which is why a well-documented case can still be reported incompletely.
What to look for. Four clinical headings collapse into one checklist topic, and two more into a second. The collapse is not neutral. A heading with no topic of its own, the review of systems above all, survives only as whatever it contributed to the clinical findings, which is usually very little. And the items the checklist asks for that have no clinical heading at all are precisely the ones that go missing, the timeline being the clearest case.
Schematic mapping. Checklist topics are named descriptively; their numbering and sub-items are not reproduced here.
A chart note is not a case presentation
The two documents describe the same patient and almost nothing else about them is the same.
The contrast drawn in this section is this article’s own framing. No reporting guideline states it, and a search of the case-report methodology literature did not find it set out directly. What the guidance does say, repeatedly, is the consequence: a case report “should contain only pertinent information and nothing superfluous or confusing”,2 and authors should “avoid superfluous or other extraneous facts that detract from the understanding of the case”.1 The CARE checklist builds the same filter into its own wording, asking for history “including relevant genetic information”, “relevant past interventions”, and “significant physical examination (PE) and important clinical findings”.3
The instruction to be selective is therefore well established. What is not established anywhere we could find is why the record resists that instruction, which is the question this section answers. Treat it as a working explanation that has proved useful, not as a rule handed down.
A clinical record is written for a colleague who will take over the patient. That reader has the chart, the results system and the ward; anything the note leaves out, they can retrieve. The note is therefore allowed to be exhaustive in some places and telegraphic in others, because its job is to support the next decision rather than to stand on its own.
A case presentation is written for a reader who has none of that. They cannot look up the missing creatinine, cannot ask what the examination showed, and cannot tell whether a symptom was absent or simply not asked about. Everything they will ever know about this patient is on the page in front of them, and the report has to be judged on that alone.
| Clinical record | Case presentation | |
|---|---|---|
| Written for | The next clinician, who has the chart | A reader who has only this page |
| Selection rule | Record what was found, in case it matters later | Include what a reader needs to evaluate the case |
| Omissions | Recoverable: look it up | Permanent, and usually invisible to the reader |
| Orientation in time | Forward: what happens next | Backward: why what happened, happened |
| Abbreviations | Local and assumed | Expanded, or avoided |
| Units and ranges | Supplied by the results system | Supplied by the author, every time |
| Identifiers | Required | Removed, and replaced with intervals |
One further reason not to treat this as a copying exercise is that the source may be thinner than the author assumes. An audit of 150 admission records on a single pulmonology ward found that “only 1% (n = 1) of admission notes met all documentation standards”, and noted in particular “the complete absence of allergy documentation - 0 (0%) of charts recorded known drug allergies”.11
That is one ward in one hospital over one quarter, measured against a locally built standard, and it says nothing about documentation anywhere else. It is offered only as a reason to check the record against what the manuscript is about to claim, rather than to write from memory of the episode.
Two consequences follow, and they pull in opposite directions. The report has to be shorter than the record, because most of what the record contains is irrelevant to the question the case raises. It also has to be more explicit than the record, because nothing can be assumed, retrieved or inferred. Getting both right at once is the whole craft of the section.
Ask what a reader could conclude if this sentence were deleted, and what they could conclude if it were kept. A detail that changes neither is padding and should go. A detail whose absence would let a reader draw the wrong conclusion must stay, even if it is a negative finding, and especially if it is.
That test does most of the work. The sections below are largely what it produces when applied heading by heading.
The sequence, element by element
What follows is what each heading contributes, what has to go, and the fault that recurs. The order is the clinical one, because that is the order the material arrives in and the order a reader expects. Published guidance agrees on the ordering principle: describe the case “concisely and in chronological order, starting with the chief complaint”,1 and “the case should be described in a concise and chronological order”.2
One thing to be clear about before going through them. The headings below are how clinical information is recorded. They are not the headings a case report is assessed against, and in most journals they will not appear in the manuscript as headings at all. The reporting checklist asks instead for patient information, clinical findings, a timeline, diagnostic assessment, therapeutic intervention, and follow-up and outcomes.3 Figure 2 shows how the two sets line up. Institutional teaching often calls the whole thing the “case description” rather than the case presentation,13 which is the same section under a third name.
There is an argument in the education literature for going further and dissolving the recording boundaries deliberately. One model reorganises the history of present illness into an expanded form that pulls in whatever is relevant from “the social, past medical, surgical, obstetrics/gynecology, and psychiatric histories”, on the reasoning that “the best way to sequence the emerging story is chronologically” and that “the story must never contain redundancies”.4 Whether or not you adopt that, it is a useful corrective to the assumption that the record’s compartments have to survive into the manuscript.
Chief complaint
One sentence: the reason the patient sought care, in their own words where those words are informative, with the duration. “Chest tightness for three days” is a chief complaint. “Rule out acute coronary syndrome” is not: it is a clinician’s hypothesis, and putting it here commits the report to a conclusion before any evidence has been presented.
This is one of only two elements that travel from the record essentially unchanged. It is usually preceded by a line of demographic orientation: published guidance suggests starting “with the patient’s de-identified demographic information”,1 and the checklist asks for “de-identified patient specific information” alongside the “primary concerns and symptoms of the patient”.3
History of present illness
The narrative of the current problem: onset, how it developed, what was tried, what changed. In the record this often runs to a page. In the report it should be one thread — the thread that makes the eventual diagnosis intelligible — and everything that does not belong to that thread belongs somewhere else or nowhere.
The common fault is chronology without causation. A list of what happened on which day is not a history of present illness; it is a timeline, and the timeline is a separate item drawn as a figure. The prose should explain why each step followed the one before it.
Past medical history, medications and allergies
Here the cutting begins. The record lists everything; the report lists what bears on this case, and says why it bears on it where that is not obvious.
- Include a comorbidity if it affects the presentation, the differential, the treatment, or the outcome.
- Include a medication with its dose, strength and duration, not merely its name — particularly where the case concerns an adverse effect, where those three facts are the finding.
- State allergies explicitly, including that none are known. “No known drug allergies” is information; silence is not.
- Omit the rest, and resist the instinct that omitting looks careless. A reader assumes anything not mentioned was not relevant, which is the convention the report is written in.
Social and family history
The same rule, applied harder. Occupation, exposures, travel, alcohol, tobacco and recreational drug use, and family history all belong when they bear on the case, and are noise when they do not.
One attribute deserves singling out. The authors of a recent guide argue that “the patient’s race should not reflexively be included in the first paragraph of the case description”, and add the condition that governs it: “unless race is directly relevant to the case”.1 The same test applies to every other demographic attribute, and it is the test used throughout this section.
There is a second reason to be sparing here, which has nothing to do with relevance. Occupation, ethnicity, locality and an unusual diagnosis are each unremarkable alone and can be jointly unique, so a rich social history is one of the commonest routes to an identifiable patient. Journal policy sets the boundary in two sentences: “identifying details should be omitted if they are not essential”, and “patient data should never be altered or falsified to attain anonymity”.12 Where a detail is both identifying and clinically necessary, the options are therefore to describe it less precisely or to obtain consent specific to including it. Inventing a substitute is not one of them.
Review of systems
This heading is cut harder than any other, and it is worth being precise about why, because the reason is not a matter of taste.
No reporting guideline asks for a review of systems at all. It is not an item in the CARE checklist,3 and it does not appear as a component in the published guides to writing case reports consulted for this article.12 The checklist asks instead for “significant physical examination (PE) and important clinical findings”,3 and whatever the systems review turned up that meets that description belongs there, under that name.
The reason the record contains one is that it is a screening instrument: its value lies in being comprehensive, because it is administered before anyone knows which answer will matter. By the time the report is written, that is known. What survives is the handful of findings that bear on the differential, in either direction; the rest is noise that lengthens the section and obscures the case. A full systems review reproduced in a published case presentation tells a reader that the author has not yet decided what the case is about.
Physical examination
Report findings, not impressions, and report the ones that discriminate between the possibilities a reader will be entertaining. “Abdomen soft, non-tender, no guarding, no rebound” is a finding set; “abdominal examination unremarkable” is a conclusion that hides which manoeuvres were performed.
This distinction is the one the examination is itself defined by. A standard clinical-methods text describes physical examination as “the process of evaluating objective anatomic findings”, whose results “must be thoughtfully integrated with the patient’s history and pathophysiology”.10 The findings are what belongs in this part of the report; the integration belongs in the diagnostic reasoning, further down.
Vital signs belong with the examination, with units. Where an examination was not performed, say so rather than leaving a silence that a reader will read as a normal result.
Investigations and results
Three requirements, all of them routinely missed because the results system supplies them automatically in clinical practice and nothing supplies them in a manuscript.
- Units, every time. A number without a unit is not a result, and reference intervals differ enough between laboratories that a reader cannot supply it.
- Reference ranges for anything other than the most standardised assays, since an international readership cannot assume yours.
- The tests that were negative or normal, where they exclude something a reader would otherwise suspect. This is the same principle as pertinent negatives, applied to investigations.
Imaging is described in words as well as shown. A figure legend that says “CT abdomen” leaves the reader to find the abnormality; a legend that says what to look at, and where, does the job the author is better placed to do.
The same patient, written twice
Everything above is easier to see in one paragraph than in a list of rules. The two passages below describe the same fictional patient. The first is written the way a clinical record is written; the second is written for a reader who has no access to that record.
| As a chart note | As a case presentation |
|---|---|
| 62M adm 14/03 c/o SOB. PMH HTN, T2DM, OA, cataract surgery 2019. Meds: metformin, ramipril, atorvastatin, PRN paracetamol. NKDA. Ex-smoker. O/E chest clear, HS I+II+0, abdo SNT. Bloods sent. CXR NAD. Imp: ?LRTI. Plan: abx, review am. | A 62-year-old man presented with four days of progressive breathlessness. He had hypertension and type 2 diabetes, both treated, and was taking metformin 1 g twice daily, ramipril 5 mg daily and atorvastatin 20 mg daily. He had no known drug allergies and had stopped smoking eleven years earlier. He reported no fever, no cough and no pleuritic pain, and had not travelled or been immobile. On examination he was afebrile, with a respiratory rate of 24 breaths per minute and oxygen saturation of 93% on room air. The chest was clear to auscultation, with no added sounds and no focal dullness to percussion; there was no calf swelling or tenderness. A chest radiograph showed no consolidation, effusion or pneumothorax. |
Both passages were constructed for this illustration. They describe no real patient, and the values in them are not clinical data.
The second passage is longer, which is the point most often misunderstood about this section. It is longer because it contains things the first merely implies: the duration of the symptom, the doses rather than the drug names, the absence of fever and pleuritic pain, the respiratory rate and saturation that “SOB” stood in for, and the specific normal findings that the single word “clear” concealed. It is also shorter in the places that matter less — the cataract surgery and the osteoarthritis are gone, because neither bears on breathlessness.
Three further differences are worth naming. The admission date has become an interval, because a date and an institution together can identify a patient. The abbreviations have gone, because a reader in another country will not share them. The forward-facing plan has gone entirely, because by the time this is published the question is no longer what to do next.
Pertinent negatives
This is the category most often deleted by an author cutting for length. It deserves its own section because the instinct that removes it is a reasonable instinct applied to the wrong material.
No reporting guideline uses the phrase. It is not in the CARE checklist,3 and the published guides to case-report writing consulted here do not use it either.2 What one of them does give is the governing condition, which is narrower than “include your negatives”: negative findings belong “only when relevant to the case or the diagnosis”.1
The clearest account of what makes one relevant comes from the education literature rather than from publishing guidance, and it is more specific than the way the term is usually used: a pertinent negative does its work “by the skilled use of pertinent negatives” to decrease the probability of the diagnosis being argued for.4 A negative that cannot lower the likelihood of anything a reader is entertaining is not pertinent, whatever else it is.
A pertinent negative is a finding that is absent, where the absence changes what a reader can conclude. “No calf swelling, no pleuritic chest pain and no recent immobility” looks like three sentences about nothing. It is in fact a statement about what was excluded, and without it a reader cannot tell whether an alternative was ruled out, was never considered, or was considered and the answer not recorded.
When a report says nothing about a symptom, a reader cannot distinguish between these:
- It was asked about and was absent.
- It was asked about, was present, and the author judged it irrelevant.
- It was never asked about.
Only the first supports an inference. The other two are gaps, and because all three are written the same way — as silence — a reader who is being careful has to treat every silence as the third. Stating the negative is what converts silence into evidence.
The rule for deciding which negatives to keep follows from what the report is arguing. Keep the ones that bear on a possibility a reader would reasonably entertain; drop the ones that bear on nothing. A report of an unusual drug reaction should say what else the patient was taking and what was not in the history, because a reader’s first objection will be that something else caused it. A report of a rare tumour should say which of the commoner diagnoses were excluded and how.
Negative investigations work the same way. A normal white cell count is not worth reporting in a case where nobody would have suspected infection, and is essential in a case where everybody would. The question is never whether the result was normal; it is whether a reader would otherwise be left wondering.
One practical habit makes this survive the editing stage. Mark the pertinent negatives as you draft, in a way you can see later. The reason they get cut is not that an author decides they are unimportant; it is that two weeks afterwards, when the manuscript is three hundred words over, they are indistinguishable from padding.
The assessment, rewritten
Every other heading in this article survives the move in some reduced form. This one does not survive at all, and the reason is worth stating plainly, because carrying it across unchanged is the single most recognisable sign of a case presentation assembled from notes.
An assessment and plan in the record faces forward. It is written at a moment when the diagnosis is uncertain and a decision has to be made anyway, and its job is to commit the team to the next action. It is provisional by design, and it is superseded by the next entry.
A case presentation faces backward. The outcome is known, the diagnosis is settled, and the reader’s question is not what should be done next but why this turned out to be the answer. What the report needs in place of a plan is the reasoning: which possibilities were entertained, what made each of them more or less likely, which finding was decisive, and why.
| In the record | In the case presentation |
|---|---|
| A working diagnosis, stated so the team can act | The differential as it stood, and what each possibility rested on |
| Investigations ordered | Why those investigations, and what each would have distinguished |
| Treatment started | “Administration of therapeutic intervention (dosage, strength, duration)”,3 and what changed |
| “Review in the morning” | What the review showed, how long follow-up ran, and “adverse and unanticipated events”3 |
| Uncertainty left open for the next entry | Uncertainty resolved, or stated as unresolved and why |
Two things commonly go missing in the rewrite, and both are worth more to a reader than the diagnosis itself.
Both are named in the reporting checklist, which asks for “diagnostic challenges” and for “diagnosis (including other diagnoses considered)”, as well as for “changes in therapeutic interventions with explanations”.3
The first is the investigation that was considered and not performed, with the reason. Access, cost, availability and patient preference are all legitimate reasons, and a reader in a different health system learns more from knowing a test was unavailable than from being left to assume it was not thought of.
The second is the possibility that was wrong. A differential that contains only the eventual answer is not a differential, and a report that never admits to a wrong turn teaches nothing about the diagnostic problem it is supposed to illustrate. The cases worth publishing are frequently the ones where the obvious answer was the wrong one, and that is a finding only if the obvious answer is stated.
Length, and what gets cut first
Word limits for case reports are set by the journal and vary widely — one guide puts the range as “as low as 500 words or as high as 3000 words”1 — so the figure comes from the target journal before drafting rather than from a rule of thumb afterwards. The reporting checklist is no help here, because it contains no length item at all.3 What is worth settling in advance is the order in which material is sacrificed when the limit binds, because under pressure authors tend to cut in exactly the wrong order.
The instinct is to cut the shortest-looking items first: a sentence of negative findings, the note that an examination was not done, the reference range after a number. These are cheap to remove and they are the ones a reader cannot reconstruct. The expensive items — a long undifferentiated history, a full review of systems, a recitation of normal results — are the ones that should go.
- Comorbidities, medications and social history that bear on nothing in this case
- Review-of-systems content that neither supports nor excludes anything
- Normal results that no reader would have suspected were abnormal
- Narrative repetition between the history and the discussion
- Description in the prose that the timeline figure already carries
What is not on this list, at any length: pertinent negatives, units, reference ranges, doses and durations, follow-up duration, and anything stating that something was not done.
The calibration to aim for is stated well in one guide to the form: there should be “enough detail (but not too much) for the reader to establish his or her own conclusions”.2 That is a test about the reader’s inference rather than about the author’s word count, and it is the one worth applying when the limit binds.
One structural economy is available before any of that. Where the journal permits a figure, the timeline absorbs the dates and intervals that would otherwise consume several sentences of prose, and it carries them more clearly. A case presentation written alongside its timeline is usually shorter than the same case written without one.
Common mistakes
| Mistake | Where it comes from | What it costs a reader | What to do instead |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pasting the admission note | The material is already written | Length without information, and local abbreviations a reader cannot decode | Rewrite for a reader with no access to the chart |
| Reproducing the full review of systems | Comprehensiveness reads as rigour | The findings that matter are buried among those that do not | Keep the pertinent positives and negatives, drop the rest |
| Deleting negative findings to save words | They look like empty sentences | The reader cannot tell what was excluded, or whether it was asked | Cut irrelevant history instead; negatives are the last thing to go |
| Numbers without units or reference ranges | The results system always supplied them | The result cannot be interpreted outside your laboratory | Supply both, every time |
| Carrying the assessment and plan across | It is the clinical habit | A prospective plan where a reader expects retrospective reasoning | Write the differential, the discriminating findings and the outcome |
| A differential containing only the right answer | Hindsight | The diagnostic problem the case illustrates disappears | State what else was considered, and what ruled it out |
| Interpretation in place of findings | Clinical shorthand: “chest clear” | The reader cannot tell what was examined or how | Report what was observed; interpret in the discussion |
| Exact dates and a named unit | They were in the record | A patient who may be identifiable to people who know them | Use intervals, and describe the setting without naming it |
The case presentation is not the clinical record tidied up. That framing is this article’s own, but the instruction it leads to is not: a case report should contain “only pertinent information and nothing superfluous or confusing”.2 The record was written for a colleague who can look up whatever it leaves out; the report is written for a reader who cannot look up anything, cannot ask, and cannot tell the difference between a finding that was absent and a question that was never asked. Everything follows from that. Cut hardest where the record was comprehensive for screening reasons, keep the negative findings that exclude alternatives even when they look like empty sentences, supply the units and reference ranges that the results system used to supply for you, and replace the forward-facing assessment and plan with the backward-facing reasoning a reader actually needs.
How to apply this to your work
- Write the one-sentence version of the case first — what happened, and why it is worth reporting. Everything that does not serve that sentence is a candidate for cutting.
- Draw the timeline before the prose, and let it take the dates out of the narrative.
- Draft each clinical heading separately, then ask of each one what a reader would conclude if it were deleted.
- Mark the pertinent negatives explicitly as you go, so they are not mistaken for padding at the editing stage.
- Add units and reference ranges to every result in a single pass, rather than as you write.
- Rewrite the assessment as reasoning: the differential, what discriminated between its branches, and what was considered and not done.
- Read the section once as a stranger, with the chart closed, and mark everything you could only understand because you were there.
- Check the whole section for identifying material, including dates, the named institution and unusual detail combinations.
Common questions
What is the case presentation section of a case report?
It is the account of what happened to the patient: who they were in clinically relevant terms, what they presented with, what was found, what was done, and what followed. Some journals and teaching materials call it the case description13 and reporting checklists break it into several separately named items,3 but it is the same section. It is the evidential core of the report. The introduction says why the case matters and the discussion says what it means, but the case presentation is the part a reader assesses the claim against.
Is this the same as presenting a patient on ward rounds?
No, and the two are routinely confused because they share a name. An oral presentation is delivered to colleagues who can interrupt, ask questions and see the patient. In the widely taught SNAPPS model the recitation of facts is step one of six, after which the learner narrows the differential, analyses it, and probes the preceptor;5 in the written section, by contrast, the facts are the section. Expectations for the oral form also shift by specialty,8 and its inherited structure is itself contested.7
What should the chief complaint contain?
The reason the patient sought care and how long it had been going on, in the patient’s own words where those words carry information. It should not contain a clinical hypothesis. “Rule out pulmonary embolism” is what the clinician was thinking, not what the patient said, and placing it here commits the report to a conclusion before any evidence has been given.
What is a pertinent negative?
A finding that is absent, where its absence makes a difference to what a reader can conclude. “No calf swelling and no pleuritic pain” is information, because it bears on what was excluded. No reporting guideline uses the term, and the published condition is narrower than the phrase suggests: negative findings belong “only when relevant to the case or the diagnosis”.1 The education literature is more specific still, treating a pertinent negative as one that lowers the probability of the diagnosis being argued for.4
Should I include the full review of systems?
No, and there is a stronger point than length: no reporting guideline asks for one. A review of systems is not an item in the CARE checklist3 and is not named as a component in the published guides to case-report writing.12 It is comprehensive in the record because it is a screening instrument, administered before anyone knows which answer will matter. Whatever it turned up that counts as a significant clinical finding belongs under clinical findings; the rest does not belong anywhere.
Do I need to give units and reference ranges for every result?
Units, always: a number without one is not a result. Reference ranges for anything other than the most standardised assays, because intervals differ between laboratories and an international readership cannot supply yours. In clinical practice the results system attaches both automatically, which is exactly why authors forget that a manuscript does not.
Can I paste the admission note into the case presentation?
It is the commonest shortcut and it is visible to every reviewer. The note carries local abbreviations, identifiers, exact dates, a forward-facing plan and a great deal of material irrelevant to the point of the case, while lacking the units, reference ranges, reasoning and follow-up a reader needs. The section has to be written, not transferred.
How long should the case presentation be?
Shorter than the record and more explicit than it, within whatever limit the target journal sets; one guide puts the range across journals as “as low as 500 words or as high as 3000 words”.1 Take that limit before drafting rather than cutting afterwards. When the limit binds, cut irrelevant history, screening-level review-of-systems content and normal results that no one would have suspected were abnormal. Do not cut pertinent negatives, units, doses, durations or the length of follow-up.
Declared interest: Pubrica provides medical writing and publication support commercially. Nothing on this page should be read as suggesting that a service can supply clinical detail that the record does not contain. Where the notes do not support a date, a dose or a duration, the honest course is to say so in the manuscript rather than to reconstruct it.
References and sources
- Chait R, Donini G, Flynn MG. A guide to writing quality case reports. HCA Healthcare Journal of Medicine. 2023;4(1):61–68. doi:10.36518/2689-0216.1485 read 20 October 2026. The journal’s landing page numbers this as volume 4, issue 1, article 9; the printed pagination 61–68 is taken from the running head of the article itself.View the full text
- Rison RA. A guide to writing case reports for the Journal of Medical Case Reports and BioMed Central Research Notes. Journal of Medical Case Reports. 2013;7:239. doi:10.1186/1752-1947-7-239 read 20 October 2026.View the full text
- CARE Group. The CARE checklist, 2013, and the accompanying guidance on writing a case report. care-statement.org. read 20 October 2026.View the checklist
- Kilian A, Upton LA, Sheagren JN. Reorganizing the history of present illness to improve verbal case presenting and clinical diagnostic reasoning skills of medical students: the all-inclusive history of present illness. Journal of Medical Education and Curricular Development. 2020;7. doi:10.1177/2382120520928996 read 20 October 2026.View the full text
- Wolpaw TM, Wolpaw DR, Papp KK. SNAPPS: a learner-centered model for outpatient education. Academic Medicine. 2003;78(9):893–898. read 20 October 2026 from a full-text copy hosted by Boston University Medical Campus Faculty Development, the publisher’s own copy being unreachable. The six steps are independently corroborated by the Royal College teaching tool listed below.View the full text
- Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada. CanMEDS Teaching Tool 5 — Ward rounds: oral case presentation via SNAPPS. Teaching tool, no named author or date printed. read 20 October 2026.View the teaching tool
- Appold B, Saint S, Ratz D, Gupta A. Comparing oral case presentation formats on internal medicine inpatient rounds: a survey study. BMC Medical Education. 2023;23(1). doi:10.1186/s12909-023-04292-3 read 20 October 2026. The abstract was read from the DOAJ record and the comparative ratings from the article’s own Table 3; the full text was not reachable, so nothing is quoted from the body of the paper.View the record and abstract
- Daniel M, Heney R, Kwan B, et al. Preparing for clerkships: learning to deliver specialty-specific oral presentations. MedEdPORTAL. 2015;11:10261. doi:10.15766/mep_2374-8265.10261 read 20 October 2026.View the record
- Luciano G, Jobbins K, Rosenblum M. A curriculum to teach learners how to develop and present a case report. MedEdPORTAL. 2018;14:10692. doi:10.15766/mep_2374-8265.10692 read 20 October 2026. Cited here for what its published curriculum does and does not cover.View the record
- Campbell EW Jr, Lynn CK. The physical examination. Chapter 4. In: Walker HK, Hall WD, Hurst JW, eds. Clinical Methods: The History, Physical, and Laboratory Examinations. 3rd ed. Boston: Butterworths; 1990. read 20 October 2026. A textbook chapter on performing the examination; it says nothing about case reports, and is cited here only for what the examination is.View the chapter
- Ali S, Ullah S, Aslam S, Muhammad S, Ahmad M, Asim M. From history to plan: a comprehensive audit of admission documentation practices in the pulmonology department at Medical Teaching Institute (MTI) Mardan Medical Complex, Pakistan. Cureus. 2025;17(9):e92860. doi:10.7759/cureus.92860 read 20 October 2026. A quality-improvement audit of 150 admission records on one pulmonology ward in one hospital over one quarter, using a locally built audit tool. It is cited here as a single illustrative audit and nothing wider. Its narrative text and its tables disagree on several figures; only figures stated in the text of the paper are used here, and the contradicted ones are not quoted.View the full text
- Oxford Medical Case Reports. Journal policies, including patient anonymity. Oxford University Press. read 20 October 2026.View the policies
- Ninetto A. Writing case reports. Department of Scientific Publications, MD Anderson Cancer Center. Institutional teaching material, no date printed. read 20 October 2026. Teaching material rather than scholarship; cited here only for the section naming it uses.View the material
How to cite this article
Pick your referencing style and copy it. Your university or target journal may vary the punctuation — check its guide if it has one.
This article is written to be learned from. Cite it if you are referring to what it says; if you are using the evidence behind it, cite the sources listed above instead.
Work through these with the clinical record open, before the section is drafted.
[ ] Chief complaint in one sentence, in the patient's words, with duration [ ] History of present illness reduced to the thread explaining the diagnosis [ ] Every comorbidity and medication kept has a reason to be there [ ] Medication doses, strengths and durations given, not just names [ ] Allergy status stated explicitly, including when none are known [ ] Social and family history checked for identifying detail as well as relevance [ ] Review of systems cut to pertinent positives and negatives [ ] Examination reports findings, not impressions [ ] Examinations not performed stated rather than left silent [ ] Every result carries its unit [ ] Reference ranges supplied for non-standardised assays [ ] Normal results included where they exclude something a reader would suspect [ ] Imaging described in words as well as shown [ ] Differential stated, including the possibilities that were wrong [ ] Investigations considered but not done recorded, with the reason [ ] Assessment and plan rewritten as retrospective reasoning [ ] Follow-up duration stated, including what was not measured [ ] Dates replaced by intervals, and the institution not named [ ] Local abbreviations expanded or removed
We help you turn a clinical record into a case presentation that a reviewer can evaluate: selecting what belongs, supplying the units and reference ranges, and writing the diagnostic reasoning the record does not contain.