Free scoping read. A written assessment of your manuscript in two business days, at no cost.

Start one

Home/Insights/Evidence synthesis/The rules for manuscript peer reviewers

The rules for manuscript peer reviewers

Confidentiality, competing interests, and a review that could be shown to the author without embarrassment.

Writing, peer review and data collection

Confidentiality

A manuscript under review is a confidential document. It must not be shared, shown to colleagues without the editor’s agreement, used to inform the reviewer’s own work, or retained after the review is complete.

This now extends explicitly to generative AI tools. Uploading a manuscript under review to a general-purpose AI service is a breach of confidentiality, because the text leaves the reviewer’s control. Several publishers and funders have issued explicit prohibitions, and where any AI assistance is permitted it must be disclosed to the editor.

Competing interests

Decline where there is a financial interest, a recent collaboration, a current or former supervisory relationship, institutional overlap, or a direct competitive interest in the same research question.

Declining is a normal professional act and is more useful to an editor than a conflicted review. Where the conflict is partial, disclose it and let the editor decide.

What a review should contain

A short summary of what the paper claims, which shows the author the review was read as a whole. Major issues, separated from minor ones, each with the specific location and the reason it matters. Evidence or reasoning for each criticism. A clear statement to the editor of whether the work is sound, and what would be required to make it so.

The test for tone: the review should be one you would be content to have signed. It addresses the work, not the authors.

What is not the reviewer’s role

Requiring citation of the reviewer’s own work without clear scientific justification — coercive citation is misconduct. Insisting on the analysis the reviewer would have done where the authors’ is defensible. Rewriting the paper. Delaying a competitor’s work.

Suspected misconduct — plagiarism, image manipulation, data irregularity — goes to the editor, privately, not into the review text or anywhere else.

In practice

Fix, flag or query.

The distinction that keeps an edit defensible: what an editor may change silently, what must be shown to the author, and what only the author can answer.

  • Never: upload a manuscript under review to a general AI tool.
  • Decline on conflict rather than disclosing and proceeding regardless.
  • Write the review you would be willing to sign.

Sources

  • COPE Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers
  • ICMJE Recommendations, on the responsibilities of peer reviewers

Sources are given so each claim can be checked at its origin. Where a tool’s current maintenance status could not be confirmed, the page says to check it rather than asserting it.

Get a free quote

Regulations

Check your project against this rule

  1. 1Your work
  2. 2Your details
  3. 3Send
What do you need?

Material you send is held under signed confidentiality, with access limited to the assigned team and encrypted transfer. It is not used to train anything and is not passed to third-party tools. Ask for the agreement before you send anything you would rather cover first.