Home/Insights/Evidence synthesis/STROBE, MOOSE, PRISMA and CONSORT: what each one governs
STROBE, MOOSE, PRISMA and CONSORT: what each one governs
Four checklists, four designs. Foot & Ankle International is one of many journals that now require the appropriate one at submission.
Why journals mandate them
Journals increasingly require authors to submit a completed reporting checklist. Foot & Ankle International (FAI), published by SAGE, is one such journal, and its author instructions set out which guideline applies to which submission type. Surveys of surgical journals have found adoption of CONSORT and PRISMA requirements to be widespread and increasing.
The requirement is procedural, not editorial preference: an incomplete methods section cannot be appraised or synthesised later.
Which applies to what
CONSORT — randomised controlled trials. Covers randomisation generation, allocation concealment, blinding, participant flow, and pre-specified primary and secondary outcomes. Extensions exist for cluster, pilot and feasibility, pragmatic and non-inferiority trials, and for abstracts.
STROBE — observational studies: cohort, case–control and cross-sectional. Covers eligibility, sources of data, bias, study size, quantitative variables, statistical methods including handling of confounders and missing data, and participant flow.
MOOSE — meta-analyses of observational studies, where confounding across the pooled studies has to be addressed.
PRISMA — systematic reviews and meta-analyses, with the full search strategy and the flow diagram.
Two others come up constantly in clinical specialties: CARE for case reports, and STARD for diagnostic accuracy studies.
The practical approach
Identify the design honestly, find the guideline on EQUATOR, write to it, and submit the completed checklist with page numbers. A retrospective case series reported to STROBE is a stronger submission than the same series described as a cohort study.
In practice
Fix, flag or query.
The distinction that keeps an edit defensible: what an editor may change silently, what must be shown to the author, and what only the author can answer.
- Identify the design first; the checklist follows from it.
- Check the target journal’s instructions — many now require the completed checklist.
- A case series is not a cohort study; report it as what it is.
Sources
- EQUATOR Network reporting guideline library
- CONSORT, STROBE, MOOSE, PRISMA, CARE and STARD statements
- Foot & Ankle International author instructions, SAGE
Sources are given so each claim can be checked at its origin. Where a tool’s current maintenance status could not be confirmed, the page says to check it rather than asserting it.
Related