Home/Insights/Evidence synthesis/JBI Manual for Evidence Synthesis: scoping reviews
JBI Manual for Evidence Synthesis: scoping reviews
The methodological source for scoping reviews, and the clearest statement of when a scoping review is the wrong choice.
What it is
The JBI Manual for Evidence Synthesis is JBI’s guidance covering the range of synthesis types it supports — effectiveness, qualitative, mixed methods, diagnostic test accuracy, prevalence, economic, text and opinion, and scoping reviews.
Its scoping review chapter is the methodological basis that PRISMA-ScR, the reporting extension for scoping reviews, was built to report against.
What a scoping review is for
Mapping the extent, range and nature of evidence on a topic. Identifying and analysing gaps. Clarifying concepts or definitions. Examining how research has been conducted in an area. Acting as a precursor to a systematic review.
It is not for answering a question about effectiveness. A scoping review does not synthesise an effect estimate and does not grade certainty, so it cannot support a recommendation about whether something works. Using one to do so is the error the JBI guidance is most pointed about.
What it still requires
A scoping review is not a literature review with a wider net. It requires an a priori protocol, preferably registered; a population–concept–context framework in place of PICO; a comprehensive and documented search; screening against stated criteria, generally in duplicate; charting of data using a piloted form; and a structured presentation of results, usually with a PRISMA-ScR flow diagram.
Critical appraisal is optional in a scoping review — a genuine difference from a systematic review — and if it is omitted, the review cannot comment on the quality of what it found, which should be stated.
In practice
Fix, flag or query.
The distinction that keeps an edit defensible: what an editor may change silently, what must be shown to the author, and what only the author can answer.
- Do not use: a scoping review to answer an effectiveness question.
- Use: population–concept–context, not PICO.
- If appraisal is omitted, say so — and do not comment on study quality.
Sources
- JBI Manual for Evidence Synthesis, scoping review chapter
- PRISMA-ScR, reporting extension for scoping reviews
Sources are given so each claim can be checked at its origin. Where a tool’s current maintenance status could not be confirmed, the page says to check it rather than asserting it.
Related