Home/Insights/Evidence synthesis/EQUATOR guidelines for reviews, meta-analyses, overviews and HTA
EQUATOR guidelines for reviews, meta-analyses, overviews and HTA
Which checklist applies to which kind of review — the distinction reviewers test first, because the labels are used loosely.
Matching the review type to its guideline
Systematic review and meta-analysis of interventions — PRISMA 2020, with PRISMA-P for the protocol and PRISMA-S for reporting the search.
Scoping review — PRISMA-ScR. Maps evidence; does not estimate effects.
Rapid review — report the methodological shortcuts taken, since a rapid review is defined by what was simplified; Cochrane rapid review methods guidance applies.
Overview of reviews — PRIOR, the reporting guideline for overviews of systematic reviews, where the unit of analysis is the review rather than the primary study.
Network meta-analysis — the PRISMA extension for network meta-analyses, which additionally requires the network geometry and an assessment of transitivity and consistency.
Diagnostic test accuracy review — PRISMA-DTA, with QUADAS-2 for appraisal.
Individual participant data review — PRISMA-IPD.
Health technology assessment — HTA is a broader appraisal than a review, covering clinical effectiveness, economics, organisational and ethical dimensions; it follows HTA agency methods manuals alongside the relevant reporting guidelines, and economic evaluations within it follow CHEERS.
Why the label matters
Calling a review "systematic" invokes a set of expectations: a protocol, a reproducible search, duplicate screening, formal appraisal. A narrative review that uses the word will be assessed against those expectations and found short.
The honest options are to meet the standard or to use the accurate label. A well-conducted narrative or scoping review correctly labelled is a stronger submission than a systematic review that is not one.
In practice
Fix, flag or query.
The distinction that keeps an edit defensible: what an editor may change silently, what must be shown to the author, and what only the author can answer.
- Use the accurate label — "systematic" invokes a standard you will be held to.
- For an overview of reviews, use PRIOR, not PRISMA.
- For network meta-analysis, report transitivity and consistency, not just the network.
Sources
- PRISMA 2020 and its extensions (PRISMA-P, PRISMA-S, PRISMA-ScR, PRISMA-DTA, PRISMA-IPD, PRISMA-NMA)
- PRIOR, for overviews of reviews
- CHEERS, for economic evaluations
Sources are given so each claim can be checked at its origin. Where a tool’s current maintenance status could not be confirmed, the page says to check it rather than asserting it.
Related