Home/Insights/Methodology reference/Reflexivity in qualitative research
Reflexivity in qualitative research
The researcher shapes the data they generate. Reflexivity is the discipline of examining that influence, and reporting it — not a paragraph apologising for bias.
Why it is methodological, not confessional
In qualitative research the researcher is the instrument: they decide what to ask, how to ask it, what to notice and how to interpret it. Their background, discipline, professional role and assumptions therefore enter the data.
Reflexivity makes that influence examinable. It is not an admission of weakness, and it is not satisfied by a sentence stating that the authors were aware of their biases.
The forms it takes
Personal reflexivity: how the researcher’s own background and expectations shaped the enquiry.
Interpersonal reflexivity: the relationship between researcher and participant. A clinician interviewing their own patients will hear different things from an outside researcher — not worse things, different ones — and the paper should say which it was.
Methodological reflexivity: why these design choices, and what alternatives were rejected.
Contextual reflexivity: the institutional and funding setting in which the work took place.
Doing it in practice
A reflexive journal kept during fieldwork and analysis, recording decisions and reactions as they happen rather than reconstructed afterwards.
Positionality stated in the paper: who the researchers are in relation to the topic and participants.
Team debriefing, where multiple analysts surface divergent readings. Note that inter-rater reliability statistics sit awkwardly here — in interpretive work, disagreement between analysts is information to be explored, not error to be minimised.
An audit trail linking raw data to codes to themes to conclusions.
What reporting guidelines ask for
COREQ has a whole domain on the research team and reflexivity: interviewer identity, credentials, occupation, relationship with participants and participants’ knowledge of the researcher. These are reportable facts, not sentiments.
In practice
Fix, flag or query.
The distinction that keeps an edit defensible: what an editor may change silently, what must be shown to the author, and what only the author can answer.
- Report: the interviewer’s role and relationship to participants.
- Keep: a reflexive journal written during, not after, fieldwork.
- Treat analyst disagreement as: information to explore, not error to eliminate.
Reporting standards
- COREQ, domain 1: research team and reflexivity
- SRQR, on researcher characteristics and reflexivity
Reporting guidelines named here are hosted by the EQUATOR Network. Writing to the checklist for your design before submission is the cheapest available improvement to a methods section.
Related