Home/Insights/Methodology reference/Qualitative case study methodology
Qualitative case study methodology
Where the case study tradition meets interpretive enquiry: the aim is understanding the case from the inside, and the methodology has to say whose understanding.
What distinguishes it
A qualitative case study treats the case as a bounded system to be understood in its particularity. Compared with the more positivist strand of case study research, it places less weight on propositions tested against the case and more on interpretation built from it.
Stake’s distinction is useful: an intrinsic case study is undertaken because this case is of interest in itself; an instrumental one uses the case to illuminate a wider issue; a collective study examines several instrumentally.
Bounding the case
The first methodological act is defining what is inside the case and what is context — by time, by place, by activity, by group. A case study that does not state its boundaries cannot say what it studied.
Generating and handling data
Interviews, participant and non-participant observation, documents, artefacts and field notes. Thick description — recording not just behaviour but the context that makes it interpretable — is what allows a reader to judge transferability to their own setting.
Analysis is usually thematic or interpretive, built from codes to categories to themes, with the analytic process described rather than asserted. Saying "themes emerged" conceals the analysis; themes are constructed by analysts and the construction should be visible.
Judging quality
The criteria are not internal validity and reliability but credibility, transferability, dependability and confirmability.
In practice: triangulation across sources; member checking where appropriate; an audit trail of analytic decisions; attention to disconfirming cases; and a reflexive account of the researcher’s position, since in qualitative work the researcher is the instrument.
Reporting follows COREQ for interview and focus-group studies, or SRQR more broadly.
In practice
Fix, flag or query.
The distinction that keeps an edit defensible: what an editor may change silently, what must be shown to the author, and what only the author can answer.
- State: how the case was bounded.
- Avoid: "themes emerged" — describe how they were constructed.
- Report: disconfirming cases, not only confirming ones.
Reporting standards
- COREQ, for interviews and focus groups
- SRQR, Standards for Reporting Qualitative Research
- Stake, The Art of Case Study Research
Reporting guidelines named here are hosted by the EQUATOR Network. Writing to the checklist for your design before submission is the cheapest available improvement to a methods section.
Related