Contents
On this page
- Scope and limitations of reporting guidelines
- Matching the guideline to the review type
- PRISMA 2020 and commonly omitted items
- PRISMA-S and the reporting of search strategies
- PRISMA-P and the problem of retrospective justification
- Distinction between reporting guidelines and appraisal instruments
- Responsibility for checking reporting quality
- The checklist as a drafting instrument
- Key points
- Application to your study
- Frequently asked questions
Academy · Research Writing · review reporting guidelines
Reporting Guidelines for Biomedical Literature Reviews: Selecting the Appropriate Guideline by Review Type
There is no single reporting guideline for “a literature review”. The EQUATOR Network indexes different guidelines for systematic reviews, scoping reviews, overviews of reviews, syntheses without meta-analysis, qualitative syntheses, meta-analyses of observational studies and realist reviews. Selecting the guideline that matches the review type is the central decision, and an incorrect choice omits precisely the items that readers require.
Authors frequently ask which guideline to follow after the review has been written, which reverses the appropriate sequence. Sutton, Clowes, Preston and Booth, in the Health Information and Libraries Journal, make the structural point that review types form a family whose members carry distinct information-retrieval requirements, so that the reporting expected depends on the type of review produced. The guideline is therefore a consequence of a decision made at the outset, and it is most usefully read while the protocol is being written rather than while the manuscript is being formatted.
Learning objectives
- The guideline applicable to each review type, and the purpose of each
- The components of PRISMA 2020 and the additions made by its extensions
- Reporting a search in accordance with the sixteen PRISMA-S items
- Why PRISMA-P belongs at the protocol stage, and the consequences of omitting it
- The distinction between a reporting guideline and an appraisal instrument, and the extent of agreement between the two appraisal instruments
- The issues raised by methodological peer reviewers that subject reviewers do not raise
Common misconceptions
- “PRISMA is the guideline for literature reviews.” PRISMA 2020, published by Page and colleagues in the BMJ in 2021 as article n71 by a 26-author group, is the guideline for systematic reviews. Scoping reviews, overviews of reviews, syntheses without meta-analysis, qualitative syntheses, meta-analyses of observational studies and realist reviews each have their own, indexed separately by the EQUATOR Network.
- “Following the guideline means the review was done well.” A reporting guideline records what was done; it does not evaluate it. Appraisal is a separate exercise with separate instruments, and those instruments do not fully agree with one another — Perry and colleagues, in Systematic Reviews, found a median Gwet’s agreement of 0.61 between ROBIS and AMSTAR-2 across 31 reviews.
- “Search reporting is a minor formality.” It is the item most often reported inadequately. Rethlefsen and colleagues designed a randomised trial of librarian involvement in peer review, reported in Trials, powered on the assumption that only 5% of control-arm manuscripts would report searches adequately against PRISMA-S, with a target of 20% in the intervention arm. A trial is feasible on those numbers only if inadequate search reporting is close to universal.
- “The checklist can be completed at submission.” Several items require a decision and its justification, and a justification written after the results are known is a reconstruction. PRISMA-P exists for the protocol stage for this reason — 17 checklist items, expanding to 26 with sub-items — and it is the extension that most authors encounter last.
- “Peer review will catch a reporting problem.” Only some peer reviewers are likely to detect it. Ibragimova and Fulbright, in Research Integrity and Peer Review, examined 55 reviewer reports on 13 reviews and found search-strategy issues raised in 84% of methodological peer reviewers’ reports compared with 26% of subject reviewers’ reports, and reporting-guideline issues in 32% compared with 6%. Whether reporting is checked therefore depends on the reviewers the journal assigns.
Scope and limitations of reporting guidelines
A reporting guideline is a list of elements that must appear in the manuscript, usually accompanied by explanatory material stating why a reader needs each one. It governs the report. It does not specify how to conduct the review, and it does not grade the review once conducted 25.
Maintaining that distinction is important because the most common sentence in the review literature conflates it. “This review was conducted in accordance with PRISMA” attributes to a reporting instrument an authority over conduct that it does not claim, and it usually appears in place of a description of what was actually done. The correct construction separates two claims: the review is reported in accordance with the relevant guideline, and the review was conducted following the methodological source actually used. Our page on what PRISMA is and is not works through this in detail.
The second function a guideline does not perform is appraisal. Complete reporting of a weak review produces a clear account of a weak review, which is the intention: transparency exposes problems rather than correcting them. Appraisal instruments exist separately, and the section on them below should be read before assuming that they are conclusive.
Matching the guideline to the review type
The EQUATOR Network indexes reporting guidelines by study design, and for reviews the index is longer than most authors expect 2. For systematic reviews and meta-analyses it lists PRISMA 2020, together with PRISMA for Abstracts, PRISMA-S for literature searches, PRISMA-P for protocols, PRISMA-IPD for individual participant data, PRISMA-DTA for diagnostic test accuracy and the PRISMA harms checklist. For scoping reviews it lists PRISMA-ScR. For overviews of reviews it lists the PRIOR statement 2,27. For synthesis without meta-analysis it lists SWiM. For qualitative evidence synthesis it lists ENTREQ. For meta-analyses of observational studies it lists MOOSE. And for meta-narrative reviews and realist syntheses it lists the RAMESES publication standards.
That list is the practical answer to the question in the title, and the mapping matters for substantive rather than administrative reasons. Each guideline requests the information that a reader of that review type needs in order to judge it 25,27. A reader of a scoping review needs to know how the mapping was structured and how charting was conducted; a reader of an effect review needs the synthesis model and the heterogeneity assessment. Reporting a scoping review against the main PRISMA checklist omits the first set and implies the second, so the resulting manuscript misdescribes itself even where every statement in it is accurate.
The structural reason for this is the one Sutton and colleagues identified: review types form a family whose members carry distinct information-retrieval requirements, so the reporting expected of a review depends on the family member to which it belongs 26. The family member should be decided first. All reporting decisions follow from that choice, and none can be remedied by selecting a guideline at submission. See scoping review, umbrella review, living systematic review and rapid review for what each type involves in practice.
Review type to reporting guideline
| If your review is | Report against | What it adds that the main checklist does not |
|---|---|---|
| A systematic review, typically of intervention effects | PRISMA 2020 | The baseline: main checklist, abstract checklist and flow diagram |
| Any review, for the search component | PRISMA-S | Sixteen items covering sources with interfaces, dates, executed strategies, limits and each supplementary method |
| A protocol for a review not yet conducted | PRISMA-P | 17 items, 26 with sub-items, including the justifications that cannot be written credibly after results are available |
| A scoping review mapping a literature | PRISMA-ScR | 20 essential and 2 optional items on how the mapping and charting were structured |
| An overview of existing reviews | PRIOR | Reporting for a review whose units of inclusion are other reviews, including overlap between them |
| A review synthesising without meta-analysis | SWiM | How studies were grouped and compared where pooling was not done |
| A qualitative evidence synthesis | ENTREQ | Reporting appropriate to interpretive synthesis rather than effect estimation |
| A meta-analysis of observational studies | MOOSE | Items specific to observational designs, including confounding and exposure assessment |
| A meta-narrative review or realist synthesis | RAMESES | Publication standards for reviews that trace how and why interventions work |
| A review of diagnostic test accuracy | PRISMA-DTA | Paired sensitivity and specificity as the unit of result rather than a single effect |
| A review using individual participant data | PRISMA-IPD | Data acquisition, integrity checking and analysis across contributing datasets |
| A review whose outcomes include adverse effects | PRISMA harms | Harms-specific ascertainment and reporting items |
Guidelines as indexed by the EQUATOR Network under systematic reviews, meta-analyses, reviews, HTA and overviews. The retrieval requirements that differ between review types are mapped by Sutton A, Clowes M, Preston L, Booth A in the Health Information and Libraries Journal.
The reporting-guideline sentence in a scoping review’s methods
Wrong guideline, conflated claims
This systematic literature review was conducted in accordance with the PRISMA guidelines. The PRISMA checklist was followed throughout to ensure methodological rigour and transparency of reporting.
Wrong guideline for the review type. A scoping review reported against the main PRISMA checklist omits the items on how the mapping and charting were structured, which is what its readers need.
“Systematic literature review” in the sentence, scoping review in the work. The type is misnamed, so a reader calibrates the conclusions against the wrong standard.
“Conducted in accordance with PRISMA” is not a coherent claim. PRISMA governs reporting; it contains no instruction on how to search, screen, chart or synthesise.
No methodological source named. The guideline’s name occupies the place of the method, so nothing is said about how the review was actually conducted.
No checklist located. “The checklist was followed” cannot be verified without a completed checklist to inspect.
“To ensure methodological rigour” claims what a reporting guideline cannot deliver. Complete reporting of a weak review produces a clear account of a weak review.
Right guideline, claims separated
This scoping review is reported in accordance with the PRISMA extension for scoping reviews (PRISMA-ScR); the completed checklist, indicating the section in which each of the 20 essential items is addressed, is provided as Supplementary File 1, and the two optional items are not applicable for the reasons given there. The search is reported following PRISMA-S, with the full strategy as executed for each database in Appendix 2. The review was conducted following the JBI methodology for scoping reviews, and the protocol was prepared using PRISMA-P and registered prospectively.
The guideline matches the review type, so the items reported are the ones a reader of a scoping review needs.
The review type is named correctly in the same sentence that names the guideline, which eliminates the mismatch.
Reporting and conduct are presented as two separate claims with two separate sources, so that neither substitutes for the other.
The checklist is located and mapped item by item, and the inapplicable optional items are accounted for rather than silently omitted.
PRISMA-S is named and the executed strategies are located, which allows a reviewer to verify the search rather than accept it on trust.
The protocol claim is specific — prepared using PRISMA-P and registered prospectively — so the justifications in the methods are datable.
A reviewer reading the second version can verify every claim in it against a named document. The first version indicates only that the author is aware of PRISMA, and the reviewer is likely to examine the remainder of the methods more sceptically as a result.
PRISMA 2020 and commonly omitted items
PRISMA 2020 has three components that function differently 25. The main checklist is organised by the sections of a manuscript — which is itself the clearest evidence that it is a reporting instrument rather than a method, since a method would be ordered by the sequence of work. The abstract checklist exists because many readers go no further than the abstract and need different information there. And the flow diagram accounts for records from identification through to inclusion.
Two components are routinely omitted. The first is the abstract checklist: abstracts of reviews frequently omit the number of included studies, the search date, the synthesis approach and the limitations, all of which a reader assessing usability requires 25. The second is the arithmetic of the flow diagram. Numbers that do not reconcile down the diagram rapidly undermine a methodological reviewer’s confidence, and full-text exclusions without stated reasons remove the one place where the reader can observe judgement being exercised.
The statement’s own provenance should be noted: it was produced by a 26-author group and published in the BMJ in 2021 as article n71 10,25,29. Authors should cite the statement itself when claiming to report against it, name the extension where one applies, and place the completed checklist in the supplement with the section in which each item is addressed, that is, an item-to-location mapping rather than a column of ticks. The PRISMA 2020 checklist is the working version.
PRISMA-S and the reporting of search strategies
PRISMA-S adds a 16-item search-reporting extension to PRISMA, developed by Rethlefsen and colleagues in Systematic Reviews through a three-stage Delphi survey, a consensus conference and public review 21,24. The items cover the information sources with their interfaces, the coverage and run dates, the full strategies as executed, limits and filters, and each supplementary method separately 24.
The extent of the deficiency can be estimated from an unusual source: the design of a trial addressing it. Rethlefsen and colleagues’ randomised controlled trial protocol in Trials, testing whether involving librarians and information specialists in peer review improves search reporting, planned 150 manuscripts with 75 per arm, powered on an assumed 5% rate of adequate search reporting in the control arm and a target of 20% in the intervention arm. The baseline assumption is the notable element 23. A trial is only feasible on a 5% control rate if adequate reporting against PRISMA-S is rare in submitted manuscripts, which indicates both the scope for improvement and the limited protection that the current norm provides.
The practical consequence for authors is that the search section is where effort yields the greatest return. It should be written as a set of instructions rather than a description, with the executed strategies in an appendix, and it should be written while the search is being conducted; a search reconstructed later is a plausible strategy rather than the one actually executed. Search strategy peer review and literature search and citation support are where this work is undertaken in full, and the five mistakes that weaken a review covers the construction errors underneath the reporting ones.
The design assumptions of a randomised trial of librarian involvement in peer review. A trial is only feasible on a 5% baseline if adequate search reporting against PRISMA-S is rare. Figures from Rethlefsen ML, Schroter S, Bouter LM, Moher D, Ayala AP, Kirkham JJ, Zeegers MP. Improving peer review of systematic reviews by involving librarians and information specialists: protocol for a randomized controlled trial. Trials.
PRISMA-P and the problem of retrospective justification
PRISMA-P, published by Moher, Shamseer, Clarke and colleagues in Systematic Reviews, sets the protocol-stage reporting standard that precedes PRISMA 2020: 17 checklist items, expanding to 26 when sub-items are counted separately 10,25,29. It is the extension that most reviewers should encounter first but usually encounter last.
Its importance lies not in registration compliance but in the fact that several items in both PRISMA-P and PRISMA 2020 ask not only what was decided but why — the eligibility criteria and their rationale, the synthesis model and the reason for choosing it, the planned subgroup analyses and their justification 25,29. Those justifications are straightforward to write credibly in advance and difficult to write afterwards, because once a forest plot exists the reason for choosing a model is influenced by knowledge of what it produced. A protocol written to PRISMA-P therefore protects against a specific, well-documented failure: the appearance of analytic choices made to suit the results.
It also reduces the cost of writing the eventual manuscript. A completed PRISMA-P checklist contains most of the methods section, and a checklist maintained throughout the review becomes, at submission, a record rather than a reconstruction. Where the review has already been completed, the appropriate course is to state what was pre-specified and what was decided during the review, and to label the latter as post hoc. Such a statement costs less credibility than a reviewer inferring it.
Distinction between reporting guidelines and appraisal instruments
Authors sometimes use ROBIS or AMSTAR-2 in the expectation that they perform the function of a reporting guideline, or the reverse. They answer a different question: not “is this review completely reported?” but “how much should I trust this review?”. For authors writing a review, the reporting guideline is the relevant instrument; for those appraising other reviews — in an overview, or as a peer reviewer — the appraisal instruments are relevant.
The extent of agreement between those instruments merits attention, because it is only moderate. Perry, Whitmarsh, Leach and colleagues, in Systematic Reviews, applied both to 31 reviews and reported a median Gwet’s agreement of 0.61 between them 21. They also differ substantially in cost: a median of 24.4 minutes per review for ROBIS compared with 14.3 minutes for AMSTAR-2. Agreement at the item level was also inconsistent, with substantial agreement reached on 8 of 16 AMSTAR-2 items and 11 of 24 ROBIS items 24.
Two implications follow. First, an appraisal rating should not be treated as a property of a review; it is a property of a review assessed with a particular instrument by particular assessors, and a change of instrument can change the result 21. Second, authors conducting an overview of reviews should name the instrument, state who applied it and how disagreements were resolved, and anticipate that readers will want the item-level results rather than an overall grade 21,34. Reporting checklist review is the reporting-side service; do’s and don’ts for a health care review covers where appraisal belongs in a review’s methods.
ROBIS and AMSTAR-2 compared on the same 31 reviews
| ROBIS | AMSTAR-2 | |
|---|---|---|
| Items in the instrument | 24 | 16 |
| Items reaching substantial agreement between assessors | 11 of 24 | 8 of 16 |
| Median time to apply, per review | 24.4 minutes | 14.3 minutes |
| Agreement between the two instruments | Median Gwet’s agreement 0.61 | Median Gwet’s agreement 0.61 |
Perry R, Whitmarsh A, Leach V, et al. A comparison of two assessment tools used in overviews of systematic reviews: ROBIS versus AMSTAR-2. Systematic Reviews. Both instruments appraise reviews; neither is a reporting guideline.
Responsibility for checking reporting quality
The assumption that peer review will catch a reporting problem is only partly supported, and the part that is not supported is specific.
Ibragimova and Fulbright, in Research Integrity and Peer Review, examined 55 reviewer reports across 13 reviews at a journal using librarians and information specialists as methodological peer reviewers alongside subject reviewers 10. Search-strategy issues were raised in 84% of the methodological reviewers’ reports against 26% of the subject reviewers’ 25,29. Reporting-guideline issues appeared in 32% compared with 6%. Both differences are large, and neither is a criticism of subject reviewers, who assess different aspects — whether the clinical question matters and whether the conclusions are plausible in context 10.
In practice, therefore, whether the search and reporting are scrutinised depends partly on which reviewers the editor assigns. This is a reason for self-checking rather than complacency: a reviewer who does not comment on the search strategy has not endorsed it. It is also a reason to place the completed checklist and the executed search strategies in the supplement, because a reviewer inclined to check will examine what is available and will otherwise accept a methods section without an appendix at face value or not at all.
The issues raised in peer review depend on who conducts it. Figures from Ibragimova I, Fulbright H. Librarians and information specialists as methodological peer-reviewers: a case-study of the International Journal of Health Governance. Research Integrity and Peer Review.
The checklist as a drafting instrument
A reporting guideline used at submission is a formality that adds a day of work. Used at the protocol stage, it is the least costly structural support available, for the reason already noted: the items that require a justification can be answered credibly only before the results exist.
A workable sequence is as follows. The review type should be decided, and the matching guideline read together with PRISMA-P, before the protocol is drafted. The item list should be used as the structure of the protocol, so that completing the protocol completes most of the checklist. The checklist should be maintained as a living document throughout the review, updated when a decision changes, with the date of the change noted. The search should be reported to PRISMA-S as it is conducted. At write-up, each item should be mapped to the section and page where it is addressed, and that mapping placed in the supplement.
The two claims should then be separated explicitly in the methods. One sentence states that the review is reported in accordance with the guideline, names the extension and locates the checklist. A different sentence names the methodological source followed for conduct. Reviewers notice when those two claims are distinct, because their conflation is so common that its absence is informative. Our systematic review support and what a literature review is for cover the conduct side that the guideline deliberately leaves alone.
Key points
Key points
The reporting guideline required follows from the type of review conducted, and the EQUATOR Network indexes the guidelines separately: PRISMA 2020 for systematic reviews — published by Page and colleagues in the BMJ in 2021 as article n71 by a 26-author group — with PRISMA-S for searches, PRISMA-P for protocols and PRISMA-DTA, PRISMA-IPD and the harms checklist for specific designs; PRISMA-ScR for scoping reviews, with 20 essential and 2 optional items; PRIOR for overviews; SWiM for synthesis without meta-analysis; ENTREQ for qualitative synthesis; MOOSE for meta-analyses of observational studies; and RAMESES for meta-narrative and realist reviews. The guideline should be read at the protocol stage, because items requiring a justification cannot be answered accurately later. The search should be reported against the sixteen PRISMA-S items, which a trial powered on a 5% baseline rate of adequate reporting suggests very few authors currently do. Reporting should also be kept separate from appraisal: ROBIS and AMSTAR-2 are appraisal instruments, and they agree with each other only moderately.
Application to your study
Application to your study
- The review type should be identified and its guideline then consulted. Systematic, scoping, overview, synthesis without meta-analysis, qualitative, observational meta-analysis and realist reviews each have a different guideline. Both the type and the guideline should be stated in the protocol.
- PRISMA-P and the type-specific guideline should be read before the protocol is drafted. The item list should be used as the protocol structure, so that completing the protocol completes most of the checklist.
- The search should be reported against the sixteen PRISMA-S items while it is conducted. This includes sources with interfaces, coverage and run dates, executed strategies in an appendix, limits with justifications, and each supplementary method reported separately.
- The reporting claim should be separated from the conduct claim. One sentence should state that the review is reported in accordance with [guideline], with the checklist in Supplementary File n. A separate sentence should state that it was conducted following [methodological source].
- An item-to-location mapping, rather than a column of ticks, should be submitted. The section in which each item is addressed should be given, and any item marked not applicable should be accounted for.
- ROBIS or AMSTAR-2 should be used only for appraising reviews, and the instrument used should be reported. The instrument, the number of assessors and the arbitration procedure should be named, and item-level results given rather than a single overall grade.
Frequently asked questions
It depends entirely on the review type. The EQUATOR Network indexes PRISMA 2020 for systematic reviews and meta-analyses, with PRISMA for Abstracts, PRISMA-S for searches, PRISMA-P for protocols, PRISMA-IPD, PRISMA-DTA and the PRISMA harms checklist alongside it; PRISMA-ScR for scoping reviews; the PRIOR statement for overviews of reviews; SWiM for synthesis without meta-analysis; ENTREQ for qualitative evidence synthesis; MOOSE for meta-analyses of observational studies; and the RAMESES publication standards for meta-narrative reviews and realist syntheses. The first decision is therefore not which guideline to use but which type of review is being written. Sutton and colleagues’ point in the Health Information and Libraries Journal is that review types carry distinct retrieval requirements, and reporting expectations follow from that.
No, because PRISMA 2020 is written for systematic reviews, and a narrative review lacks the methodological apparatus it asks authors to report. It is nevertheless worthwhile to report the search to PRISMA-S, since reproducible search reporting assists a reader of any review type, and to state in the methods that the review is narrative and why. Authors should not claim the guideline without the method: writing that a narrative review was “conducted according to PRISMA” asserts both a conduct standard that PRISMA does not set and a review type that was not produced, and a methodological reviewer will treat it as an indication of the quality of the rest of the manuscript.
PRISMA 2020 is the main reporting guideline for systematic reviews: a checklist organised by manuscript section, a separate abstract checklist, and the flow diagram. PRISMA-S is an extension that covers one component in much greater depth — the search. Published by Rethlefsen and colleagues in Systematic Reviews, it has 16 items, developed through a three-stage Delphi survey, a consensus conference and public review, covering the information sources with their interfaces, coverage and run dates, the full strategies as executed, limits and filters, and each supplementary method separately. Both are used: PRISMA 2020 for the manuscript as a whole, and PRISMA-S for the part of it that describes how the literature was identified.
At the protocol stage, which is the opposite of common practice. Several items ask not only what was decided but why — the eligibility criteria and their rationale, the synthesis model and the reason for it, the planned subgroup analyses and their justification — and those answers can be written credibly only before results exist. PRISMA-P, published by Moher, Shamseer, Clarke and colleagues in Systematic Reviews, is the protocol-stage standard: 17 checklist items, 26 with sub-items counted. The item list should be used to structure the protocol and the checklist kept updated throughout the review, so that at submission it is a record rather than a reconstruction. If the review has already been completed, the decisions that were pre-specified and those that were post hoc should be labelled.
No. A reporting guideline records what was done; it does not evaluate it. A review can address every item while having used an inadequate search, screened by a single reviewer and pooled studies that should not have been combined; it will simply have reported all of this clearly, which is the purpose. Appraising a review is a separate exercise with separate instruments, and those instruments are themselves not fully concordant: Perry and colleagues applied ROBIS and AMSTAR-2 to the same 31 reviews in Systematic Reviews and found a median Gwet’s agreement of 0.61, with substantial inter-assessor agreement on only 8 of 16 AMSTAR-2 items and 11 of 24 ROBIS items. A rating is a property of a review-plus-instrument-plus-assessor, not of the review alone.
Poorly, on the best available evidence. Rethlefsen and colleagues designed a randomised controlled trial, with the protocol published in Trials, to test whether involving librarians and information specialists in peer review improves search reporting. It planned 150 manuscripts, 75 per arm, and was powered on an assumed 5% rate of adequate reporting against PRISMA-S in the control arm, with a target of 20% in the intervention arm. Designing a trial on a 5% baseline is reasonable only if inadequate search reporting is close to universal in submitted manuscripts. The practical implication for authors is that reporting this section properly is both unusual and inexpensive, making it the part of the reporting work with the highest return.
Sometimes, depending on who reviews. Ibragimova and Fulbright examined 55 reviewer reports across 13 reviews in Research Integrity and Peer Review at a journal using librarians and information specialists as methodological peer reviewers. Search-strategy issues were raised in 84% of the methodological reviewers’ reports but 26% of the subject reviewers’; reporting-guideline issues in 32% compared with 6%. Subject reviewers assess whether the question matters and whether the conclusions are plausible, which is a different and necessary task. The implication is that a reviewer’s silence about a search does not constitute endorsement of it, and that placing the completed checklist and executed strategies in the supplement enables a reviewer so inclined to verify them.
No; they appraise reviews rather than guide their reporting. For authors writing a review, the relevant instrument is the reporting guideline that matches the review type. For those appraising other reviews, in an overview of reviews or as a peer reviewer, ROBIS or AMSTAR-2 is appropriate, and the instrument used should be stated. Perry and colleagues’ comparison in Systematic Reviews merits reading first: across 31 reviews the two instruments reached a median Gwet’s agreement of 0.61 and differed in cost, with a median 24.4 minutes per review for ROBIS compared with 14.3 for AMSTAR-2. The instrument, the assessors and the arbitration procedure should be reported, and item-level results given.
References
- Lefebvre C, Glanville J, Briscoe S, Featherstone R, Littlewood A, Metzendorf M-I, Noel-Storr A, Paynter R, Rader T, Thomas J, Wieland LS. 4.S1 Technical Supplement to Chapter 4: Searching for and selecting studies [last updated September 2024]. In: Higgins JP, Thomas J, Chandler J, Cumpston M, Li T, Page MJ, et al, editor(s). Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions version 6.5. Cochrane. 2024;6.5(4.S1). read 9 October 2026. cochrane.org
- EQUATOR Network. Systematic reviews / Meta-analyses / Reviews / HTA / Overviews - reporting guidelines by study design. EQUATOR Network. read 9 October 2026. equator-network.org
- Sabiri K, Sousa F, Rocha T. A systematic review of privacy-preserving blockchain applications in healthcare. Multimedia Tools and Applications. 2025;84(32):39925-39980. doi:10.1007/s11042-024-20541-z read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1007/s11042-024-20541-z
- Houser J, Oja K. Nursing Research: Reading, Using, and Creating Evidence (6th edition). 2025;6th edition. read 9 October 2026. swslhd.libguides.com
- Pan ML. Preparing Literature Reviews: Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches (6th edition). 2025;6th edition. read 9 October 2026. swslhd.libguides.com
- Booth A, Sutton A, Clowes M, Martyn-St James M. Systematic Approaches to a Successful Literature Review (4th edition). 2025;4th edition. read 9 October 2026. collegepublishing.sagepub.com
- Bettany-Saltikov J, McSherry R. How To Do a Systematic Literature Review in Nursing: A Step by Step Guide (3rd edition). 2024;3rd edition. read 9 October 2026. swslhd.libguides.com
- Greenhalgh T, Dijkstra P. How to Read a Paper: The Basics of Evidence-Based Healthcare (7th edition). 2024;7th edition. read 9 October 2026. swslhd.libguides.com
- Aromataris E, Lockwood C, Porritt K, Pilla B, Jordan Z (editors). JBI Manual for Evidence Synthesis. JBI. 2024;2024 edition. read 9 October 2026. jbi-global-wiki.refined.site
- Ibragimova I, Fulbright H. Librarians and information specialists as methodological peer-reviewers: a case-study of the International Journal of Health Governance. Research Integrity and Peer Review. 2024;9(1):1. doi:10.1186/s41073-023-00142-4 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1186/s41073-023-00142-4
- Marusic A (editor). A Guide to Responsible Research. 2023. read 9 October 2026. swslhd.libguides.com
- Aveyard H. Doing a Literature Review in Health and Social Care: A Practical Guide (5th edition). 2023;5th edition. read 9 October 2026. swslhd.libguides.com
- Miller DV, Revelo MP (editors). Doing a Systematic Review. 2023. read 9 October 2026. swslhd.libguides.com
- Jagadeesh G, Pitchai B, Senatore F (editors). The Quintessence of Basic and Clinical Research and Scientific Publishing. 2023. read 9 October 2026. swslhd.libguides.com
- Oermann MH. Writing for Publication in Nursing (5th edition). 2023;5th edition. read 9 October 2026. swslhd.libguides.com
- Holly C, Salmond S, Saimbert M. Comprehensive Systematic Review for Advanced Practice Nursing (3rd edition). 2022;3rd edition. read 9 October 2026. swslhd.libguides.com
- Dekkers R, Carey L, Langhorne P. Making Literature Reviews Work: A Multidisciplinary Guide to Systematic Approaches. 2022. read 9 October 2026. swslhd.libguides.com
- Price C. Syntheses Synthesized: A Look Back at Grant and Booth's Review Typology. Evidence Based Library and Information Practice. 2022;17(2). doi:10.18438/eblip30093 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.18438/eblip30093
- Khan KS, Zamora J. Systematic Reviews to Support Evidence-Based Medicine (3rd edition). 2022;3rd edition. read 9 October 2026. swslhd.libguides.com
- Machi LA, McEvoy BT. The Literature Review: Six Steps to Success (4th edition). 2022;4th edition. read 9 October 2026. swslhd.libguides.com
- Perry R, Whitmarsh A, Leach V, et al. A comparison of two assessment tools used in overviews of systematic reviews: ROBIS versus AMSTAR-2. Systematic Reviews. 2021;10:273. doi:10.1186/s13643-021-01819-x read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1186/s13643-021-01819-x
- Coughlan M, Cronin P. Doing a Literature Review in Nursing, Health and Social Care (3rd edition). 2021;3rd edition. read 9 October 2026. swslhd.libguides.com
- Rethlefsen ML, Schroter S, Bouter LM, Moher D, Ayala AP, Kirkham JJ, Zeegers MP. Improving peer review of systematic reviews by involving librarians and information specialists: protocol for a randomized controlled trial. Trials. 2021;22(1):791. doi:10.1186/s13063-021-05738-z read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1186/s13063-021-05738-z
- Rethlefsen ML, Kirtley S, Waffenschmidt S, Ayala AP, Moher D, Page MJ, Koffel JB; PRISMA-S Group. PRISMA-S: an extension to the PRISMA Statement for Reporting Literature Searches in Systematic Reviews. Systematic Reviews. 2021;10(1):39. doi:10.1186/s13643-020-01542-z read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1186/s13643-020-01542-z
- Page MJ, McKenzie JE, Bossuyt PM, Boutron I, Hoffmann TC, Mulrow CD, Shamseer L, Tetzlaff JM, Akl EA, Brennan SE, Chou R, Glanville J, Grimshaw JM, Hrobjartsson A, Lalu MM, Li T, Loder EW, Mayo-Wilson E, McDonald S, McGuinness LA, Stewart LA, Thomas J, Tricco AC, Welch VA, Whiting P, Moher D. The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. BMJ. 2021;372:n71. doi:10.1136/bmj.n71 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1136/bmj.n71
- Sutton A, Clowes M, Preston L, Booth A. Meeting the review family: exploring review types and associated information retrieval requirements. Health Information and Libraries Journal. 2019;36(3):202-222. doi:10.1111/hir.12276 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1111/hir.12276
- Tricco AC, Lillie E, Zarin W, O'Brien KK, Colquhoun H, Levac D, Moher D, Peters MDJ, Horsley T, Weeks L, Hempel S, Akl EA, Chang C, McGowan J, Stewart L, Hartling L, Aldcroft A, Wilson MG, Garritty C, Lewin S, Godfrey CM, Macdonald MT, Langlois EV, Soares-Weiser K, Moriarty J, Clifford T, Tuncalp O, Straus SE. PRISMA extension for scoping reviews (PRISMA-ScR): checklist and explanation. Annals of Internal Medicine. 2018;169(7):467-473. doi:10.7326/M18-0850 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.7326/M18-0850
- Clark I. Book review: Systematic Approaches to a Successful Literature Review (Booth A, Sutton A, Papaioannou D). Educational Psychology Research and Practice. 2016;2(2):67-68. read 9 October 2026. uel.ac.uk
- Moher D, Shamseer L, Clarke M, et al. Preferred reporting items for systematic review and meta-analysis protocols (PRISMA-P) 2015 statement. Systematic Reviews. 2015;4:1. doi:10.1186/2046-4053-4-1 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1186/2046-4053-4-1
- Grant MJ, Booth A. A typology of reviews: an analysis of 14 review types and associated methodologies. Health Information and Libraries Journal. 2009;26(2):91-108. doi:10.1111/j.1471-1842.2009.00848.x read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1111/j.1471-1842.2009.00848.x
- Kelly WN, Arellano FM, Barnes J, Bergman U, Edwards RI, Fernandez AM, Freedman SB, Goldsmith DI, Huang KA, Jones JK, McLeay R, Moore N, Stather RH, Trenque T, Troutman WG, van Puijenbroek E, Williams F, Wise RP. Guidelines for Submitting Adverse Event Reports for Publication. Drug Safety. 2007;30(5):367-373. doi:10.2165/00002018-200730050-00001 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.2165/00002018-200730050-00001
- GRADE guidelines: 1. Introduction - GRADE evidence profiles and summary of findings tables. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology. read 9 October 2026. jclinepi.com
- Roga E, Pruis K. Introducing Scoping and Systematic Reviews. read 9 October 2026. swslhd.libguides.com
- User experience of applying AMSTAR 2 to appraise systematic reviews of healthcare interventions: a commentary. doi:10.1186/s12874-023-01879-8 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1186/s12874-023-01879-8
Every source above is a peer-reviewed article, a publisher’s record of one, or a standard issued by the body that owns it. Each carries the date it was last read. Where a standard moves, this article is revised rather than left up with a note.
How to cite this article
Pick your referencing style and copy it. Your university or target journal may vary the punctuation — check its guide if it has one.
Pubrica Academy. (2026, October 9). Reporting Guidelines for Biomedical Literature Reviews: Selecting the Appropriate Guideline by Review Type. Pubrica. https://pubrica.com/academy/research/what-are-the-reporting-guidelines-to-be-followed-while-writing-a-biomedical-literature-review-for-a-manuscript/
Pubrica Academy. “Reporting Guidelines for Biomedical Literature Reviews: Selecting the Appropriate Guideline by Review Type.” Pubrica, 9 Oct. 2026, pubrica.com/academy/research/what-are-the-reporting-guidelines-to-be-followed-while-writing-a-biomedical-literature-review-for-a-manuscript/.
Pubrica Academy (2026) Reporting Guidelines for Biomedical Literature Reviews: Selecting the Appropriate Guideline by Review Type. Pubrica. Available at: https://pubrica.com/academy/research/what-are-the-reporting-guidelines-to-be-followed-while-writing-a-biomedical-literature-review-for-a-manuscript/ (Accessed: 15 October 2026).
Pubrica Academy. “Reporting Guidelines for Biomedical Literature Reviews: Selecting the Appropriate Guideline by Review Type.” Pubrica. October 9, 2026. https://pubrica.com/academy/research/what-are-the-reporting-guidelines-to-be-followed-while-writing-a-biomedical-literature-review-for-a-manuscript/
Pubrica Academy, ‘Reporting Guidelines for Biomedical Literature Reviews: Selecting the Appropriate Guideline by Review Type’ (Pubrica, 9 October 2026) <https://pubrica.com/academy/research/what-are-the-reporting-guidelines-to-be-followed-while-writing-a-biomedical-literature-review-for-a-manuscript/> accessed 15 October 2026.
Pubrica Academy. Reporting Guidelines for Biomedical Literature Reviews: Selecting the Appropriate Guideline by Review Type. [Internet]. Pubrica; 2026 Oct 9 [cited 2026 Oct 15]. Available from: https://pubrica.com/academy/research/what-are-the-reporting-guidelines-to-be-followed-while-writing-a-biomedical-literature-review-for-a-manuscript/
Pubrica Academy, “Reporting Guidelines for Biomedical Literature Reviews: Selecting the Appropriate Guideline by Review Type,” Pubrica, Oct. 9, 2026. [Online]. Available: https://pubrica.com/academy/research/what-are-the-reporting-guidelines-to-be-followed-while-writing-a-biomedical-literature-review-for-a-manuscript/
@misc{what_are_the_reporting_guidelines_to_b_2026,
author = {{Pubrica Academy}},
title = {Reporting Guidelines for Biomedical Literature Reviews: Selecting the Appropriate Guideline by Review Type},
howpublished = {Pubrica},
year = {2026},
month = {oct},
url = {https://pubrica.com/academy/research/what-are-the-reporting-guidelines-to-be-followed-while-writing-a-biomedical-literature-review-for-a-manuscript/},
note = {Accessed: <span data-cite-acc="iso">2026-10-15</span>}
}This article is written to be learned from. Cite it if you are referring to what it says; if you are using the evidence behind it, cite the sources listed above instead.
Guideline-selection and methods-wording stub
The first block should be used once, at the protocol stage, to establish which guidelines apply. The second block should be used in the methods section: it keeps the reporting claim and the conduct claim separate, which is the distinction most published reviews conflate.
REVIEW REPORTING GUIDELINE WORKSHEET
PART 1 - SELECT (do this at protocol stage)
My review type is: ______________________
Tick the one that matches, then add the extensions:
[ ] Systematic review / meta-analysis ....... PRISMA 2020
[ ] Scoping review .......................... PRISMA-ScR
[ ] Overview of reviews ..................... PRIOR
[ ] Synthesis without meta-analysis ......... SWiM
[ ] Qualitative evidence synthesis .......... ENTREQ
[ ] Meta-analysis of observational studies .. MOOSE
[ ] Meta-narrative / realist synthesis ...... RAMESES
Extensions that also apply:
[ ] PRISMA-S (the search - applies to essentially every review)
[ ] PRISMA-P (the protocol)
[ ] PRISMA for Abstracts
[ ] PRISMA-DTA (diagnostic test accuracy)
[ ] PRISMA-IPD (individual participant data)
[ ] PRISMA harms (outcomes include adverse effects)
Methodological source I will follow for CONDUCT: ______________
Protocol registry and number: ______________________
PART 2 - METHODS WORDING (fill the blanks, keep the two claims apart)
REPORTING CLAIM
"This ______________ [review type] is reported in accordance with
______________ [guideline]. The completed checklist, indicating the
section in which each item is addressed, is provided as
Supplementary File ____. The search is reported following PRISMA-S,
with the full strategy as executed for each database in Appendix ____."
Items marked not applicable, and why: ______________________
CONDUCT CLAIM (a SEPARATE sentence)
"The review was conducted following ______________ [methodological
source]. The protocol was prepared using PRISMA-P and registered
prospectively (______________)."
IF THE REVIEW IS ALREADY FINISHED
Pre-specified decisions: ______________________
Decisions made during the review (label as post hoc): ______________
PART 3 - BEFORE SUBMISSION
[ ] Checklist completed with SECTION NUMBERS, not ticks
[ ] Abstract checked against the abstract checklist
[ ] Flow diagram arithmetic reconciles at every stage
[ ] Full-text exclusions carry reasons
[ ] Executed search strategies in the supplement
[ ] Phrase "conducted in accordance with PRISMA" removed
[ ] Phrase "PRISMA-compliant" removed
[ ] Appraisal instrument (if any) named, with assessors and arbitration Pubrica AcademyWritten and maintained by Pubrica’s subject matter experts. Articles are revised when the underlying standards change, and each article states the date on which it was last reviewed.
How Pubrica can help
Pubrica maps a draft against the guideline that matches its review type rather than the guideline most frequently cited, returns the completed checklist with section-level locations, and separates the reporting claim from the conduct claim in the methods wording. The search section is written to the sixteen PRISMA-S items and the flow diagram arithmetic is reconciled before review. Where the checklist exposes a gap in conduct rather than in reporting, this is identified, because the two require different remedies.