Contents
On this page
- The two distinct roles of experts in grant funding
- Evidence on inter-reviewer agreement
- Implications of low inter-reviewer agreement for applicants
- Variation in expert weighting of assessment criteria
- Organising a pre-submission expert review
- Matching expert type to proposal section
- Briefing expert reviewers to obtain usable feedback
- The funder assessment process
- Ethics and governance as assessed content
- Key points
- Application to your study
- Frequently asked questions
Academy · Research Writing · experts in grant proposals
The Role of Scientific Experts in Writing a Public Health Research Grant Proposal
Expert judgement of grant applications is considerably less consistent than the confidence placed in it suggests: when 43 experienced reviewers each evaluated the same 25 NIH applications, the intraclass correlation for preliminary ratings was 0 and Krippendorff’s alpha was 0.024. This finding supports obtaining expert input before submission rather than dismissing it, because if a panel’s assessment is close to unpredictable, the only assessment an applicant controls is one commissioned in advance.
Nearly all health research funders use external peer review, and the evidence on the consistency of that review is concerning. This does not imply that expert judgement lacks value; rather, it indicates that the panel cannot be treated as a measuring instrument, and that pre-submission expert review is the component of the process that applicants can organise. One university public health research office adopts precisely this approach, with external expert reviewers paid an honorarium of 250 to 500 US dollars and a minimum three-week review period before submission. That arrangement is the practical subject of this article.
Learning objectives
- The evidence on agreement between grant reviewers
- The reasons near-zero agreement supports, rather than undermines, commissioned expert review
- The criteria experts weight most heavily, and the extent of disagreement about that weighting
- Organising and funding a pre-submission expert review with realistic lead times
- The types of expert appropriate for each part of a public health proposal
- Briefing a reviewer so that the feedback is substantive rather than complimentary
Common misconceptions
- “Peer review reliably identifies the best applications.” In a study in which 43 experienced reviewers each evaluated the same 25 NIH applications, the intraclass correlation for preliminary ratings was 0 and Krippendorff’s alpha 0.024. These results indicate that the panel is not measuring a stable property with precision.
- “Reviewers all apply the same criteria.” Among 34 grant reviewers working across nine criterion domains, originality was the single most important criterion for 12, methodology for 10 and feasibility for 4. Different groups of reviewers are therefore assessing applications against different priorities.
- “Scientific merit is what gets weighted highest.” In one analytic hierarchy process panel, ethical standards ranked first at 21.7 per cent, ahead of scientific merit at 19.1 per cent and novelty and innovation at 16.7 per cent. In public health, this ordering is not anomalous.
- “Expert review before submission is a luxury.” One public health research office treats it as routine, with an honorarium of 250 to 500 US dollars and a minimum three-week window. Relative to an application requiring weeks of researcher time, this represents a modest cost.
- “Asking a colleague to look it over counts as expert review.” An unbriefed review tends to produce encouragement. A briefed review against stated criteria, with a deadline and a fee, is more likely to produce the objections the panel would have raised.
The two distinct roles of experts in grant funding
The phrase “the role of scientific experts” in grant proposals covers two things that should not be confused. The first is the expert as a member of the funder’s panel, who reads the application after submission under conditions the applicant does not control, applying criteria the applicant can only infer. The second is the expert as a reader whom the applicant commissions before submission, under conditions the applicant specifies entirely.
The measurable evidence on the first role is discouraging, and it is set out below without qualification. The practical implications for the second role follow from it: if the downstream reading is close to unpredictable, the pre-submission reading is the only expert input the applicant can manage, and it should be organised rigorously rather than treated as a favour requested at the last minute.
A third role also merits identification, because public health proposals depend on it more than most. Experts also appear within the application — as named collaborators, advisory group members, statistical or methodological co-investigators, and community or practice partners 33. That is a feasibility argument rather than a review function, and it is governed by a different rule: a named expert must have a specified contribution and a letter, because an expert listed without a defined role draws attention to the gap that expert was intended to cover 11,15. Our page on clinical research writing on public health covers the wider framing, and advisory board support is where the third role gets structured.
Evidence on inter-reviewer agreement
The strongest single study in this area is simple in design and difficult to dispute. Forty-three experienced reviewers each evaluated the same 25 NIH applications 22. The intraclass correlation for preliminary ratings was 0, and Krippendorff’s alpha was 0.024. In other words, the rating given by one qualified reviewer provided almost no information about the rating another qualified reviewer would give.
The large-scale evidence points in the same direction 3,12. A pre-registered study of inter-rater agreement drew on 134,991 reviews from four national research funders — a dataset large enough that the finding cannot be dismissed as an idiosyncrasy of one panel or one field 3. The funders themselves are aware of the problem: among surveyed health funders, concerns about bias and burden in the review process were reported by 89 per cent of programmes 18.
Two cautions apply to the interpretation of these findings. Low agreement between reviewers does not mean the process is random in its aggregate output — committees deliberate, scores are pooled, and triage removes a tail of applications on which agreement is probably much higher. Nor does it mean that reviewer comments are worthless; a comment identifying a genuine weakness is useful whether or not a second reviewer would have identified the same one. What it does mean is that applicants cannot plan on the assumption that a good application reliably receives a good score, and should not conclude from a rejection that the proposal has been measured 22,25.
Agreement between grant reviewers. The first two figures come from a study in which 43 experienced reviewers each evaluated the same 25 NIH applications; the third from a pre-registered inter-rater agreement study drawing on reviews from four national research funders.
Implications of low inter-reviewer agreement for applicants
Three implications follow, none of which is to abandon the effort.
Write for the whole distribution of readers, not the median one. If reviewers disagree about what matters, the application must be defensible on every dimension rather than excellent on one. A proposal that is outstanding on originality but weak on feasibility succeeds or fails largely according to which reviewer leads; a proposal that is strong on both removes that dependency. This is the single most actionable implication of the reliability data.
Treat a rejection as one draw, not a verdict. Given the agreement figures, a rejected application resubmitted to a differently composed panel is not without prospect, and the comments received are a sample of possible objections rather than the complete set of objections 6,22. They should be addressed, but applicants should also consider what a different reader would have said.
Commission the reading you can control. This is the role of the pre-submission expert. An applicant cannot make the panel consistent, but can arrange for two or three experts, chosen to span the criterion domains a panel would cover, to read the draft early enough for the reading to change it. That is the only part of the review process within the applicant’s control. Our pages on what peer review is for and the economics of grant writing set out the surrounding conditions.
Variation in expert weighting of assessment criteria
Two studies provide insight into the criteria from the reviewers’ perspective. Among 34 grant reviewers, working across nine criterion domains, originality was the single most important criterion for 12 of them, methodology for 10 and feasibility for 4 28. Separately, an analytic hierarchy process panel drawing on 96 survey respondents produced a weighting in which ethical standards came first at 21.7 per cent, scientific merit second at 19.1 per cent, and novelty and innovation third at 16.7 per cent 1.
Taken together, the two studies present a clear practical picture: there is no single dominant criterion 1,28. Originality leads among individual reviewers’ stated priorities but by a plurality rather than a majority, and when weights are elicited formally, ethical standards can outrank scientific merit 1. For a public health proposal that second finding deserves attention: consent, data protection, community involvement, equity of benefit and the handling of vulnerable populations are not compliance sections to be completed late. On one formal elicitation they carry the heaviest weight of anything in the application.
The drafting consequence is the one stated above, expressed in terms of sections. A proposal requires a defensible originality claim, a methods section a methodologist would endorse, a feasibility argument with evidence, and an ethics and governance section written as substantive content rather than as a form. Weak sections are not averaged away; they determine the outcome whenever a reviewer who prioritises that dimension leads the discussion. For the governance material in particular, see the regulatory measures for research involving human participants and writing a proposal for human protection under EU law.
What reviewers weight, from two different elicitations
| Criterion | Ranked first by individual reviewers | Formal weight from an AHP panel | The cost of a weak section |
|---|---|---|---|
| Originality and novelty | 12 of 34 reviewers | 16.7 per cent (novelty and innovation) | The largest group of reviewers prioritises this; a weak claim here loses the leading reader |
| Methodology | 10 of 34 reviewers | — | The second-largest group, and the dimension a non-specialist panel defers to |
| Feasibility | 4 of 34 reviewers | — | Fewer reviewers lead on it, but it is the commonest reason a good idea is not funded |
| Ethical standards | — | 21.7 per cent, ranked first | On this elicitation the single heaviest weight; in public health, substantive content |
| Scientific merit | — | 19.1 per cent | Second on formal weighting, which is lower than most applicants assume |
| Remaining domains | Nine criterion domains in total | Remaining weight distributed | No single criterion dominates, so defensibility across all of them is preferable to excellence in one |
Stated first-priority criteria among 34 grant reviewers across nine criterion domains; and an analytic hierarchy process weighting from a panel drawing on 96 survey respondents. The two exercises used different methods and different populations and are not directly comparable; they should be read as two independent indications that no one criterion dominates.
Organising a pre-submission expert review
A concrete model is available 36. One university public health research office pays external expert reviewers an honorarium of 250 to 500 US dollars and allows a minimum three-week review period before submission 36. Both figures should be taken literally.
The honorarium is important because it changes the nature of the arrangement. An unpaid favour produces a reading timed around the reader’s convenience and pitched to be encouraging; a fee creates an obligation to be useful and makes it reasonable for the applicant to specify what is required. Against an application representing weeks of researcher time, a few hundred dollars for two or three readings is a very small fraction of the cost and the only part of it that reduces risk.
The three-week period is more important. The purpose of expert review is to change the proposal, and a draft delivered four days before submission can only be proofread. Three weeks is the minimum that allows the reader a week to read, the applicant a week to respond, and a week for the institutional submission process — which is itself a fixed constraint that applicants routinely underestimate. If the timetable does not allow three weeks, the realistic options are to defer to the next round or to accept that an unreviewed application is being submitted, and the latter is a decision rather than an accident.
Build it into the project calendar at the point of the go or no-go decision, not later. By the time a draft exists, the lead time has usually already gone.
Matching expert type to proposal section
Two or three readers, chosen to span the dimensions a panel would cover, are preferable to one generalist. The reliability evidence argues for breadth of reader type rather than depth in the applicant’s own subfield, because the weakest dimension of a proposal is typically the one its authors cannot see.
A subject expert from outside the research group. This reader assesses the originality claim and the literature: whether the gap is real, whether it has already been closed, and whether the question matters to those working in the field. A member of the research group cannot perform this role, because that person shares the group’s view of the field.
A methodologist or statistician who was not involved in the design. This reader assesses the design, the sample size calculation, the analysis plan and whether the measurement can support the inference. Methodology led the priorities of 10 of 34 reviewers, which makes this the reading with the highest expected value if only one can be obtained 28.
A practice or policy reader, for public health specifically. This reader assesses whether the result would be usable: whether the intervention is deliverable in a routine service, whether the comparator reflects current practice, and whether the outcome is one a decision-maker would act on. Public health proposals fail on this criterion more often than on scientific grounds, and academic readers are unlikely to identify the problem.
Where consent, community involvement or vulnerable populations are involved, an ethics or community reader should be added — the weighting evidence places ethical standards at the top of one formal elicitation, and an unexamined ethics section is a significant vulnerability 1. Our biostatistics and statistical review services cover the second reader; public health subject support covers the first and third.
Briefing expert reviewers to obtain usable feedback
The commonest mistake is to send a draft with the message “any thoughts welcome”. That produces encouragement, because an unstructured request invites a social response rather than a critical one. A briefed request produces objections.
Four elements make the difference. State the criteria the reviewer should read against, reproduced from the funder’s call document so that the reading is calibrated to the actual assessment rather than to the reader’s preferences 7. Ask for the objection, not the opinion. The useful question is not “is this good?” but “what is the strongest objection a reviewer could raise, and can it be answered from what is on the page?” Name the suspected weaknesses and ask the reader to confirm or refute them; applicants almost always know where the weaknesses lie, and naming them gives the reader permission to say so. Finally, give a deadline and a format — a date, and a request for comments ordered by severity rather than by page number, because a list ordered by page does not indicate what should be addressed first.
Say explicitly that you do not want line editing at this stage. A reader who spends their hour on commas has not given you anything you could not get later, and will feel they have discharged the obligation. The before-and-after below is this request, in the two forms it usually takes.
The request you send to a pre-submission expert reader
An unbriefed favour that invites encouragement
Hi Priya — hope you are well. I am putting together an application for the community diabetes prevention call and wondered whether you might have a chance to look it over? Draft attached. Any thoughts very welcome, no rush but the deadline is the 14th. Really grateful for anything you can offer.
No criteria, so the reading is calibrated to taste rather than to the assessment. The reader cannot know whether to weigh originality, methodology, feasibility or ethics.
“Any thoughts very welcome” invites a social response. An unstructured request produces encouragement, which is the one thing a pre-submission read must not produce.
“No rush but the deadline is the 14th” leaves no time to act. A reading that arrives days before submission can change the wording and nothing else.
The institutional cutoff is invisible. Applicants routinely forget it, and it is usually a week or more before the funder deadline.
Nothing is named as weak, so the reader has to guess what help is wanted — and politeness will steer the reader away from the parts that most need testing.
No role is specified. A subject expert, a methodologist and a practice reader should each be asked for something different; this request could be answered by a proofread.
A commissioned read against stated criteria
Hi Priya — I would like to commission a pre-submission review of a public health application, and I can offer an honorarium of [amount] through the department for roughly two hours of your time. The draft is attached now; the funder deadline is 14 March and our institutional cutoff is 7 March, so I would need your comments by 21 February — three weeks before the cutoff, so that I can actually act on them. What I need is the practice-deliverability read rather than the science: the panel will have methodologists on it and I have a separate statistical reviewer, but nobody has yet told me whether this intervention could be delivered in a real service. Specifically: is the comparator what practice actually does in these settings, or an idealised version of it; would the facilitator training as specified be realistic for the staff who would deliver it; and is the primary outcome one a commissioner would act on? I have copied the funder’s assessment criteria into the covering note so you can read against those rather than against taste. Two things I already suspect are weak and would value a verdict on: the recruitment rate assumed for the community sites, and the retention plan at final follow-up. Please order comments by severity rather than by page, and please do not spend any of the time on wording — that pass comes later and I would rather have your hour on the objections.
A specific role is commissioned, so the reader knows what they are being asked for and that someone else is covering the rest.
The honorarium converts a favour into an obligation to be useful, and makes it reasonable to specify the format.
Three weeks before the institutional cutoff, not the funder deadline, which is what makes the reading able to change the proposal.
The funder’s own criteria are supplied, so the reading is calibrated to the actual assessment.
Two suspected weaknesses are named, which gives the reader permission to confirm them instead of being tactful.
Comments are requested by severity and line editing is explicitly excluded, so that the available hour is spent where it is most valuable.
If agreement between panel reviewers is close to zero, the only expert reading on which an applicant can rely is the one the applicant specifies — and the difference between a useful reading and a complimentary one lies entirely in how it was requested.
The funder assessment process
An understanding of the review process allows the document to be targeted appropriately. Among surveyed health funders, external peer review was used by 28 of 29 research programmes — 97 per cent — face-to-face committee meetings by 25 of 29 (86 per cent), and triage by 24 of 29 (83 per cent) 18,22. Concerns about bias and burden in the process were reported by 89 per cent of programmes.
Three features of that process should shape the draft. Triage is near-universal, which means a large share of applications are removed before the full committee discussion, usually on the basis of a quick read by a small number of people 18,23. Whatever makes an application survive triage — a legible question, an obvious significance chain, no visible feasibility problem — has to be in the first page or two. Committees deliberate face to face in most programmes, which means that the application will be summarised by one person to a committee that has not read it closely. The application should give the summariser something to say: a quotable primary objective, a clear deliverable and one distinctive feature. Finally, external review is the norm, so at least some readers will be subject specialists from outside the funder’s standing panel, with their own disciplinary priorities.
None of this is a matter of tactics. It reflects the fact that the application is read in a specific institutional process, by people under time pressure, who have to explain it to each other. For the submission mechanics around that process, see our guide to grant proposal writing for medical research.
How health funders run review, and what each feature means for the draft
| Process feature | Programmes using it | Implication for the application |
|---|---|---|
| External peer review | 28 of 29 (97 per cent) | Some readers will be outside specialists with their own disciplinary priorities |
| Face-to-face committee meeting | 25 of 29 (86 per cent) | One person will summarise the application to a committee that has not read it closely; it should contain something quotable |
| Triage before full review | 24 of 29 (83 per cent) | A quick first read decides whether the application is discussed at all; the question and significance must appear on the first page |
| Concerns about bias and burden | Reported by 89 per cent | Funders know the process is imperfect; this is context, not a complaint to be made in the application |
Survey of review practice across 29 research programmes at health funders.
Ethics and governance as assessed content
One formal weighting exercise put ethical standards at the top at 21.7 per cent, ahead of scientific merit at 19.1 per cent and novelty at 16.7 per cent 1. This is a single elicitation from one panel and should not be treated as a universal weighting, but it is sufficient to refute the assumption that the ethics section is a formality.
In public health proposals this section carries substantive content, and the recurring omissions are specific. Who consents, and how, when the intervention is delivered at population or cluster level and individual consent is not feasible — this requires an argued position, not a single sentence. What the data protection arrangement is, naming the legal basis, the controller, the retention period and the transfer route if data cross a border. How the benefit is distributed, which in public health means stating whether the people carrying the burden of the research are the people who would benefit from the result. What happens to participating communities after the award ends. Finally, how vulnerable groups are included rather than excluded, since excluding them is the easier option and frequently the wrong one.
This section should be written with the same specificity as the methods and reviewed by a governance professional. Consent documentation, data management planning and compliance support are where the detail gets settled, and proposal development is where it gets integrated with the rest of the application.
Key points
Key points
Expert judgement of grant applications is considerably less consistent than the system implies: 43 experienced reviewers rating the same 25 NIH applications produced an intraclass correlation of 0 and a Krippendorff’s alpha of 0.024, and a pre-registered study of 134,991 reviews across four national funders points in the same direction. Since panel consistency cannot be controlled, proposals should be written for the full range of reviewers, defensible on originality, methodology, feasibility and ethics rather than excellent on one criterion alone, and applicants should commission the review they can control. Among 34 reviewers, originality led for 12, methodology for 10 and feasibility for 4 across nine criterion domains, while one formal weighting placed ethical standards first at 21.7 per cent, ahead of scientific merit at 19.1 per cent. An effective model is that of external expert reviewers paid an honorarium of 250 to 500 dollars, with a minimum three-week window before submission, briefed against the funder’s own criteria and asked for the strongest objection rather than a general opinion.
Application to your study
Application to your study
- Schedule the expert review at the go or no-go decision. The review should occur three weeks before the institutional deadline rather than the funder deadline. If the timetable does not permit this, that constitutes a decision about the current funding round.
- Remunerate the reviewers. An honorarium of a few hundred dollars per review is a small proportion of the researcher time an application requires, and it converts an informal favour into a defined obligation.
- Recruit a range of reviewer types. These should include a subject expert from outside the research group, a methodologist not involved in the design and, for public health, a practice or policy reviewer able to judge whether the results would be usable.
- Supply the funder’s criteria with the draft. Reproduce them from the call document so that the review is calibrated to the assessment criteria rather than to the reviewer’s preferences.
- Request the strongest objection rather than a general opinion. Identify the two elements already suspected to be weak, so that politeness does not divert the reviewer from them.
- Exclude copy-editing explicitly. Request comments ordered by severity rather than by page number, and defer language editing to a later stage.
- Write the ethics and governance section as assessed content. Address the consent route at cluster or population level, the legal basis and retention period for data, the distribution of benefit, the position of communities after the award, and the inclusion rather than exclusion of vulnerable groups.
- Ensure that the first page withstands triage. Because most programmes use triage, the research question, the chain of significance and the absence of an evident feasibility problem must be immediately apparent.
Frequently asked questions
Much less consistent than the system’s reliance on them suggests. In a study where 43 experienced reviewers each evaluated the same 25 NIH applications, the intraclass correlation for preliminary ratings was 0 and Krippendorff’s alpha was 0.024 — meaning that one qualified reviewer’s rating provided almost no information about the rating another would give. A pre-registered inter-rater agreement study drawing on 134,991 reviews from four national funders points in the same direction, so this is not an idiosyncrasy of one panel or field. Two qualifications apply: committees deliberate and pool scores, which is not the same as individual rating, and a low agreement figure does not make any individual reviewer’s identification of a real weakness wrong.
Yes, but not in the way most applicants assume. Low agreement means that applicants cannot rely on excellence in one dimension, because whether that dimension leads the discussion depends on who reads the application. Among 34 reviewers, originality was the top priority for 12, methodology for 10 and feasibility for 4 — so roughly a third of possible readers prioritise something that a different third does not. The strategy that follows is defensibility across all dimensions rather than distinction in one: the outcome for a proposal strong on originality but weak on feasibility depends largely on chance, whereas one strong on both removes the dependency on which reviewer happens to lead.
There is at least one institutional model that does exactly that: a university public health research office pays external expert reviewers an honorarium of 250 to 500 US dollars and allows a minimum three-week review period before submission. The honorarium is not primarily about compensation. It changes the nature of the arrangement: an unpaid favour produces a reading timed around the reader’s convenience and pitched to be encouraging, while a fee makes it reasonable for the applicant to specify the role, the criteria, the deadline and the format. Against an application that represents weeks of researcher time, a few hundred dollars for two or three readings is a small fraction of the cost and the only part of it that reduces risk.
At least three weeks before the institutional submission cutoff — which is itself usually a week or more before the funder deadline, and is the date applicants most often overlook. The three weeks comprise roughly a week for the reader, a week for the applicant to act on the comments, and a week for the institutional process. The purpose of expert review is to change the proposal, so a draft sent four days before submission can only be proofread. If the timetable does not allow three weeks, the realistic options are to target the next round or to accept that an unreviewed application is being submitted. The date should be built into the project calendar at the go or no-go decision, because by the time a draft exists the lead time has usually elapsed.
No single one dominates, and the two available elicitations disagree in an informative way. Among 34 reviewers working across nine criterion domains, originality was the single most important criterion for 12, methodology for 10 and feasibility for 4. However, when an analytic hierarchy process panel drawing on 96 survey respondents elicited formal weights, ethical standards came first at 21.7 per cent, ahead of scientific merit at 19.1 per cent and novelty and innovation at 16.7 per cent. The two studies used different methods and populations, so they are not directly comparable. Read together, they indicate that originality, methodology, feasibility and ethics each decide outcomes for some readers, and proposals should be planned to be defensible on all four.
The reviewer should be briefed rather than simply asked for comments. Four elements are required. The funder’s own assessment criteria should be supplied, copied from the call document, so that the reading is calibrated to the assessment rather than to the reader’s preferences. The reviewer should be asked for the strongest objection a panel member could raise and whether it can be answered from what is on the page — not whether the proposal is good. The two elements already suspected to be weak should be named, which gives the reader permission to confirm them instead of being tactful. Finally, a deadline and a format should be set: comments ordered by severity, not by page number, and no line editing at this stage. An unbriefed request reliably produces encouragement, which is the one output a pre-submission review must not produce.
Three, and ideally a fourth. A subject expert from outside the research group, to test whether the gap is real and whether it has already been closed — a colleague inside the group shares the group’s view of the field and cannot perform this role. A methodologist or statistician who was not involved in the design, to test the sample size calculation, the analysis plan and whether the measurement supports the inference; methodology led the priorities of 10 of 34 reviewers, so if only one review can be obtained, it should be this one. A practice or policy reader, to judge whether the result would be usable, whether the comparator reflects current practice, and whether a commissioner would act on the outcome. Finally, where consent, community involvement or vulnerable populations are involved, an ethics or governance reader.
More than its usual treatment suggests. In one analytic hierarchy process elicitation, ethical standards carried the heaviest weight of any criterion at 21.7 per cent, ahead of scientific merit at 19.1 per cent. That is a single panel and should not be generalised into a universal weighting, but it is sufficient to refute the view that the section is a formality. In public health the content is substantive: how consent works when an intervention is delivered at cluster or population level and individual consent is not feasible; the legal basis, controller, retention period and transfer route for the data; whether the people carrying the burden of the research are the people who would benefit; what happens to participating communities after the award; and how vulnerable groups are included rather than excluded.
References
- Al Harthi H, Al Nabhani M, Al Sabei S, et al. A peer-review decision support tool for research funding decision-making using the analytic hierarchy process. PLOS ONE. 2026;21(8):e0350938. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0350938 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0350938
- Medeuov D, Rodionova K, Sabitov Z, Rodionov A. Negotiating science funding: The interplay of merit, bias, and administrative discretion in grant allocation in Kazakhstan. PLOS ONE. 2025;20(5):e0318875. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0318875 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0318875
- Hesselberg JO, Ulleberg P, Sorensen O, et al. Registered report protocol: Factors associated with inter-rater agreement in grant peer review. PLOS ONE. 2025;20(5):e0322696. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0322696 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0322696
- Patil SG. Budgeting the Project: Detailing the Required Funding and Expenditure. Grant writing for medical and healthcare professionals (Parija SC, Kate V, eds), Springer, Singapore. 2023:77-91. doi:10.1007/978-981-19-7018-4_7 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1007/978-981-19-7018-4_7
- Rajappa M. Checklist for Grant Proposal: Mandatory Elements. Grant writing for medical and healthcare professionals (Parija SC, Kate V, eds), Springer, Singapore. 2023:161-165. doi:10.1007/978-981-19-7018-4_14 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1007/978-981-19-7018-4_14
- Joshi M, Joshi P, Smith JA. Dealing with the Rejected Grant Proposal: Learning from the Mistakes. Grant writing for medical and healthcare professionals (Parija SC, Kate V, eds), Springer, Singapore. 2023:179-187. doi:10.1007/978-981-19-7018-4_16 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1007/978-981-19-7018-4_16
- Rahi M, Sharma S, Yadav B. Funders' Perspective: What the Funding Body Expects from Researchers? Grant writing for medical and healthcare professionals (Parija SC, Kate V, eds), Springer, Singapore. 2023:21-31. doi:10.1007/978-981-19-7018-4_3 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1007/978-981-19-7018-4_3
- Dubashi B, Ramadass B. Funding Organizations for Science and Health Care. Grant writing for medical and healthcare professionals (Parija SC, Kate V, eds), Springer, Singapore. 2023:33-52. doi:10.1007/978-981-19-7018-4_4 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1007/978-981-19-7018-4_4
- Parija SC, Kate V (eds). Grant writing for medical and healthcare professionals. Springer, Singapore. 2023. doi:10.1007/978-981-19-7018-4 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1007/978-981-19-7018-4
- Weidmann AE, Cadogan CA, Fialova D, et al. How to write a successful grant application: guidance provided by the European Society of Clinical Pharmacy. International Journal of Clinical Pharmacy. 2023;45(3):781-786. doi:10.1007/s11096-023-01543-7 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1007/s11096-023-01543-7
- Singaravelu SLD. Proving the Competency of the Researcher and the Adequacy of the Infrastructure to Carry Out the Research. Grant writing for medical and healthcare professionals (Parija SC, Kate V, eds), Springer, Singapore. 2023:93-101. doi:10.1007/978-981-19-7018-4_8 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1007/978-981-19-7018-4_8
- Tamblyn R, Girard N, Hanley J, et al. Ranking versus rating in peer review of research grant applications. PLOS ONE. 2023;18(10):e0292306. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0292306 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0292306
- Nachiappa Ganesh R. Tips for Improvising the Chance of Getting the Grant. Grant writing for medical and healthcare professionals (Parija SC, Kate V, eds), Springer, Singapore. 2023:167-177. doi:10.1007/978-981-19-7018-4_15 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1007/978-981-19-7018-4_15
- Parija SC, Shrivastava SR. What Is Your Aim (Ambition-Interest-Mission), and What You Want to Do? Grant writing for medical and healthcare professionals (Parija SC, Kate V, eds), Springer, Singapore. 2023:3-12. doi:10.1007/978-981-19-7018-4_1 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1007/978-981-19-7018-4_1
- Barreto SG. Writing a Grant Proposal for a Collaborative Study. Grant writing for medical and healthcare professionals (Parija SC, Kate V, eds), Springer, Singapore. 2023:153-159. doi:10.1007/978-981-19-7018-4_13 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1007/978-981-19-7018-4_13
- Kate V, Gupta D, Balakrishnan G. Writing a Grant Proposal for a Single Centre Study: Step-by-Step Approach. Grant writing for medical and healthcare professionals (Parija SC, Kate V, eds), Springer, Singapore. 2023:63-76. doi:10.1007/978-981-19-7018-4_6 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1007/978-981-19-7018-4_6
- Monavarian M. Basics of scientific and technical writing: Grant proposals. MRS Bulletin. 2021;46(5):455-457. doi:10.1557/s43577-021-00105-4 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1557/s43577-021-00105-4
- Meadmore K, Fackrell K, Recio-Saucedo A, et al. Decision-making approaches used by UK and international health funding organisations for allocating research funds: A survey of current practice. PLOS ONE. 2020;15(11):e0239757. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0239757 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0239757
- Kan P, Mokin M, Mack WJ, et al. Strategies for writing a successful National Institutes of Health grant proposal for the early-career neurointerventionalist. Journal of NeuroInterventional Surgery. 2020. doi:10.1136/neurintsurg-2020-016964 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1136/neurintsurg-2020-016964
- Gross K, Bergstrom CT. Contest models highlight inherent inefficiencies of scientific funding competitions. PLOS Biology. 2019;17(1):e3000065. doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.3000065 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.3000065
- Taylor RB. How to Write a Research Protocol. Medical Writing (Springer, Cham). 2018:239-260. doi:10.1007/978-3-319-70126-4_9 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-70126-4_9
- Pier EL, Brauer M, Filut A, et al. Low agreement among reviewers evaluating the same NIH grant applications. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 2018. doi:10.1073/pnas.1714379115 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1714379115
- Shepherd J, Frampton GK, Pickett K, et al. Peer review of health research funding proposals: A systematic map and systematic review of innovations for effectiveness and efficiency. PLoS ONE. 2018;13(5):e0196914. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0196914 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0196914
- Boyack KW, Smith C, Klavans R. Toward predicting research proposal success. Scientometrics. 2018;114(2):449-461. doi:10.1007/s11192-017-2609-2 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1007/s11192-017-2609-2
- Fang FC, Bowen A, Casadevall A. NIH peer review percentile scores are poorly predictive of grant productivity. eLife. 2016;5:e13323. doi:10.7554/eLife.13323 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.7554/eLife.13323
- Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. Common Problems Identified During Peer Review. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ). 2014. read 9 October 2026. ahrq.gov
- Herbert DL, Barnett AG, Clarke P, Graves N. On the time spent preparing grant proposals: an observational study of Australian researchers. BMJ Open. 2013;3(5):e002800. doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2013-002800 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2013-002800
- Abdoul H, Perrey C, Amiel P, et al. Peer Review of Grant Applications: Criteria Used and Qualitative Study of Reviewer Practices. PLoS ONE. 2012;7(9):e46054. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0046054 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0046054
- National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID). Strategy for NIH Funding: Ten Steps to a Winning R01 Application. National Institutes of Health (NIAID). 2012. read 9 October 2026. ipr.osu.edu
- Proctor EK, Powell BJ, Baumann AA, et al. Writing implementation research grant proposals: ten key ingredients. Implementation Science. 2012;7(1):96. doi:10.1186/1748-5908-7-96 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.1186/1748-5908-7-96
- Hollins Martin CJ, Fleming V. A 15-step model for writing a research proposal. British Journal of Midwifery. 2011;18:791-798. read 9 October 2026. napier-repository.worktribe.com
- Eve J. Writing a research proposal: planning and communicating your research ideas effectively. Library and Information Research. 2009;32(102):18-28. doi:10.29173/lirg92 read 9 October 2026. doi.org/10.29173/lirg92
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Office of Public Health Research. NOT-CD-05-109: Amendment and Corrections to RFA-CD-05-109 Centers of Excellence in Public Health Informatics. NIH Guide for Grants and Contracts. 2005. read 9 October 2026. grants.nih.gov
- SUNY Geneseo Sponsored Research (adapted from Locke, Spirduso and Silverman, Proposals That Work, 2nd ed., Sage, 1987). Common Reasons Grant Proposals Are Rejected. SUNY Geneseo Office of Sponsored Research. read 9 October 2026. geneseo.edu
- National Institute of Mental Health. Grant Writing Assistance. National Institutes of Health (NIMH). read 9 October 2026. nimh.nih.gov
- University of Iowa College of Public Health Research Office. Need an Expert Review for a Grant Proposal? University of Iowa College of Public Health. read 9 October 2026. public-health.uiowa.edu
Every source above is a peer-reviewed article, a publisher’s record of one, or a standard issued by the body that owns it. Each carries the date it was last read. Where a standard moves, this article is revised rather than left up with a note.
How to cite this article
Pick your referencing style and copy it. Your university or target journal may vary the punctuation — check its guide if it has one.
Pubrica Academy. (2026, October 9). The Role of Scientific Experts in Writing a Public Health Research Grant Proposal. Pubrica. https://pubrica.com/academy/medical-writing/the-role-of-scientific-experts-in-writing-a-good-public-health-research-grant-proposal/
Pubrica Academy. “The Role of Scientific Experts in Writing a Public Health Research Grant Proposal.” Pubrica, 9 Oct. 2026, pubrica.com/academy/medical-writing/the-role-of-scientific-experts-in-writing-a-good-public-health-research-grant-proposal/.
Pubrica Academy (2026) The Role of Scientific Experts in Writing a Public Health Research Grant Proposal. Pubrica. Available at: https://pubrica.com/academy/medical-writing/the-role-of-scientific-experts-in-writing-a-good-public-health-research-grant-proposal/ (Accessed: 15 October 2026).
Pubrica Academy. “The Role of Scientific Experts in Writing a Public Health Research Grant Proposal.” Pubrica. October 9, 2026. https://pubrica.com/academy/medical-writing/the-role-of-scientific-experts-in-writing-a-good-public-health-research-grant-proposal/
Pubrica Academy, ‘The Role of Scientific Experts in Writing a Public Health Research Grant Proposal’ (Pubrica, 9 October 2026) <https://pubrica.com/academy/medical-writing/the-role-of-scientific-experts-in-writing-a-good-public-health-research-grant-proposal/> accessed 15 October 2026.
Pubrica Academy. The Role of Scientific Experts in Writing a Public Health Research Grant Proposal. [Internet]. Pubrica; 2026 Oct 9 [cited 2026 Oct 15]. Available from: https://pubrica.com/academy/medical-writing/the-role-of-scientific-experts-in-writing-a-good-public-health-research-grant-proposal/
Pubrica Academy, “The Role of Scientific Experts in Writing a Public Health Research Grant Proposal,” Pubrica, Oct. 9, 2026. [Online]. Available: https://pubrica.com/academy/medical-writing/the-role-of-scientific-experts-in-writing-a-good-public-health-research-grant-proposal/
@misc{the_role_of_scientific_experts_in_writ_2026,
author = {{Pubrica Academy}},
title = {The Role of Scientific Experts in Writing a Public Health Research Grant Proposal},
howpublished = {Pubrica},
year = {2026},
month = {oct},
url = {https://pubrica.com/academy/medical-writing/the-role-of-scientific-experts-in-writing-a-good-public-health-research-grant-proposal/},
note = {Accessed: <span data-cite-acc="iso">2026-10-15</span>}
}This article is written to be learned from. Cite it if you are referring to what it says; if you are using the evidence behind it, cite the sources listed above instead.
Pre-submission expert review: commissioning brief and feedback form
The template has two parts. Part 1 is the brief sent with the draft; the role paragraph should be adapted to the reader being commissioned. Part 2 is the form the reader is asked to return, which prevents the feedback from arriving as a page-ordered list of wording suggestions.
PART 1. COMMISSIONING BRIEF (send with the draft)
TO: ______________________ ROLE COMMISSIONED: ______________________
(subject expert outside my group / methodologist not in the design /
practice or policy reader / ethics and governance reader)
HONORARIUM OFFERED: ______________ route: ______________________
(benchmark: 250 to 500 US dollars per read at one public health
research office)
ESTIMATED TIME ASKED FOR: ______ hours
DATES
Funder deadline ................................ ______________
My INSTITUTIONAL cutoff ........................ ______________
Comments needed by ............................. ______________
(at least 3 weeks before the institutional cutoff, so that the
reading can still change the proposal)
WHAT I AM ASKING YOU TO READ FOR (one role, stated plainly)
____________________________________________
Covered by someone else, so please do NOT spend time on:
____________________________________________
THE FUNDER'S OWN ASSESSMENT CRITERIA (copied from the call document,
so the read is calibrated to the assessment and not to taste)
1. ______________________________
2. ______________________________
3. ______________________________
4. ______________________________
WHAT I ALREADY SUSPECT IS WEAK (please confirm or deny)
1. ______________________________
2. ______________________________
FORMAT REQUESTED
[ ] Comments ordered by SEVERITY, not by page number
[ ] The single strongest objection a reviewer could raise, stated first
[ ] For each objection: can it be answered from what is on the page?
[ ] NO line editing or wording suggestions at this stage
PART 2. REVIEWER FEEDBACK FORM (ask them to return this)
Q1. THE STRONGEST OBJECTION
The single most damaging thing a panel reviewer could say about this
application is:
____________________________________________
Can it be answered from what is currently on the page? yes / no
If no, what would have to be added or changed:
____________________________________________
Q2. THE QUESTION
After reading the first page, state the primary question in your own
words: ____________________________________________
[ ] I could not confidently do this
(if so, the application will not survive triage)
Q3. BY CRITERION (mark each: strong / adequate / thin / absent)
Originality and novelty of the question .............. ______
Has anyone already closed this gap? yes / no / unsure
If yes or unsure, where to look: ______________
Methodology and design ............................... ______
Does the measurement support the inference? yes / no
Is the sizing justified? yes / no
Feasibility and resources ............................ ______
Which single claim would you most want evidenced: ______
Ethical standards and governance ..................... ______
Consent route adequate for the delivery level? yes / no
Data protection arrangement stated? yes / no
Distribution of benefit addressed? yes / no
Practice deliverability (public health reads only) .... ______
Is the comparator what practice actually does? yes / no
Would a decision-maker act on the primary outcome? yes / no
Q4. THE EXECUTION PLAN
[ ] Each unit of work has an owner, a duration and a deliverable
[ ] Each has a stated consequence of failure
[ ] The timeline is consistent with the budget
Weakest point in the plan: ______________________
Q5. WHAT I WOULD CUT
The section that earns its space least: ______________________
What I would spend that space on instead: ______________________
Q6. VERDICT, AS IF SCORING
If I were on the panel I would rank this:
[ ] clearly fundable [ ] borderline [ ] not competitive
The one change with the largest effect on that judgement:
____________________________________________
PART 3. APPLICANT'S ACTION LOG (complete after all reads return)
Objection raised Raised by Action taken / why not
______________________________ _________ ______________________
______________________________ _________ ______________________
______________________________ _________ ______________________
______________________________ _________ ______________________
[ ] Every objection has an action or a written reason for declining it
[ ] Objections raised by only ONE reader were still considered
(reviewer agreement is low; a single objection is not a minor one)
[ ] Changes made before the institutional cutoff, not after Pubrica AcademyWritten and maintained by Pubrica’s subject matter experts. Articles are revised when the underlying standards change, and each article states the date on which it was last reviewed.
How Pubrica can help
Pubrica conducts the pre-submission review as a commissioned exercise rather than a courtesy. Reviewers assess the draft against the funder’s own criteria and return objections ordered by severity, with an assessment of whether each can be addressed from the existing text. The review covers the dimensions across which a panel would be divided: originality and literature, design and sample size, feasibility evidence, and the ethics and governance material that one formal weighting placed above scientific merit. Pubrica also advises when the timetable no longer permits meaningful improvement of the proposal.