Free scoping read. A written assessment of your manuscript in two business days, at no cost.

Start one
Contents

Academy · Research Publication · Reviewer Feedback on Introductions

Peer Reviewer Comments on the Introduction Section of Original Research Articles

Reviewer comments on introduction sections converge on four recurring issues: an unclear background, a vague or absent literature gap, research questions not linked to that gap, and the absence of an overview of the structure of the paper.

Pubrica AcademyWritten by a peer review process writer Reviewed bya manuscript development editor Published10 October 2026 Last checked10 October 2026 Reading time8 minutes Sources10 peer-reviewed

The introduction section of an original research article serves one structural purpose: to move the reader from a broad problem to the specific, answerable question that the study addresses, in a way that makes the gap between existing knowledge and the study’s contribution explicit. Peer reviewers evaluating an introduction assess whether this progression occurs, rather than whether the prose is elegant. Published guidance on writing and reviewing introductions, and accumulated studies of reviewer reasoning across multiple journals, converge on a short, recurring list of problems: insufficient background to establish why the topic matters, a literature gap that is asserted rather than demonstrated, a research question that does not visibly follow from that gap, and no indication of how the remainder of the paper is organized.

Learning objectives

  • The four issues peer reviewers most consistently flag in introduction sections
  • The reasons a literature gap must be demonstrated rather than simply asserted
  • The effect of a clear roadmap sentence on the reading of the remainder of the manuscript

Common misconceptions

  • “An introduction's job is mainly to summarize the field broadly before getting to the study.” Guidance from studies of reviewer reasoning and from the methods-writing literature consistently describes the purpose of the introduction as narrowing from a broad problem to one specific, demonstrated gap and the precise question the study addresses, rather than providing a general literature summary; reviewers repeatedly identify introductions that remain broad and never narrow.

Early establishment of the significance of the problem

Reviewers consistently want a research article's problem statement made explicit within the first few sentences, with the field's current state summarized concisely and anchored to recent, relevant citations rather than a broad historical survey1. A widely used methods-writing guide for anesthesiology and clinical researchers frames this as answering, almost immediately, the question "why does this problem matter to the reader," since a reviewer who cannot answer that question after the opening paragraph is likely to read the rest of the introduction with reduced confidence that the study is well-motivated1. A frequently cited account of manuscript rejection reasons across medical education journals found that weak or unclear problem framing in the opening sections was among the most common issues reviewers identified, well before they reached any assessment of methods or results5. A separate, widely read account of the top reasons manuscripts fail at a major respiratory medicine journal placed an unfocused or poorly justified introduction among its leading causes of rejection, independent of whether the underlying study itself was sound6.

Demonstration rather than assertion of a literature gap

A phrase such as “despite extensive research, little is known about X” is, by itself, an assertion that a reviewer cannot verify; reviewers instead look for a brief, cited account of what the existing literature has and has not established, built from a focused selection of the most relevant and recent work rather than an exhaustive history12. A well-known Clinical Chemistry guide to writing an introduction section describes this as "setting the scene," arguing that the background review exists specifically to make the gap self-evident to the reader by the time it is stated, rather than requiring the author to declare the gap's existence after an unfocused literature summary7. A systematic guide to manuscript review built for radiology reviewers similarly instructs reviewers to check explicitly whether the stated gap is supported by the citations preceding it, and to flag introductions in which the cited literature does not clearly lead to the claimed gap as a specific, recurring weakness that merits comment in review3.

Derivation of the research question from the identified gap

Reviewers look for the stated research question and objectives to read as a direct, almost inevitable consequence of the gap just described, rather than as a new, independently introduced idea28. A practical consequence of this expectation is that the objective or hypothesis statement should be specific enough that a reader could, in principle, judge from the introduction alone whether the study’s later results answered it, rather than being written broadly enough to accommodate any results that emerged8. A well-known series on effective scientific writing published in the Journal of Clinical Epidemiology frames the introduction's final paragraph specifically as the place where background, gap, and objective should converge into a single, traceable line of reasoning, and treats an objective statement that does not clearly connect back to the stated gap as a structural flaw reviewers are trained to notice8.

Provision of a structural overview of the paper

A short closing statement describing how the remainder of the paper is organized is a small addition reviewers frequently note as missing, and its absence is a minor but recurring comment across multiple published guides to writing and reviewing an introduction2. Studies of reviewer reasoning suggest that this comment concerns less the sentence itself than what it signals: an author who has planned the full argument of the paper before writing the introduction also tends to write a tighter, better-justified gap-and-objective sequence, so its absence often correlates with the deeper structural weaknesses described above rather than causing a rejection on its own5. Both the ICMJE Recommendations and COPE's ethical guidelines for peer reviewers frame a reviewer's task as assessing whether a manuscript's stated aims are clear and justified before assessing methodological detail, which is the broader editorial logic that makes introduction-section feedback a routine, expected part of the first substantive round of review rather than a secondary concern49.

Length and citation density of the introduction

There is no fixed universal word count for an introduction, but published writing guidance consistently warns against two opposite failure modes that reviewers flag as often as a missing gap: an introduction so brief that it never adequately establishes relevance or context, and one so long that it obscures the research question beneath an exhaustive literature survey that reads more like a review article than a lead-in to original research17. A practical target many methods guides converge on is three to five paragraphs for a typical original research article: a brief opening establishing relevance, one or two paragraphs synthesizing the most directly relevant prior work, a paragraph stating the gap, and a closing paragraph with the objective and, where space allows, a roadmap sentence2. On citation density, reviewers are generally more satisfied with a smaller number of well-chosen, directly relevant, recent citations than with a long, undifferentiated list intended to demonstrate familiarity with the field, since the latter can read as padding rather than argument-building and makes it harder for a reader to identify which specific prior findings the stated gap responds to78. Authors revising an introduction in response to reviewer feedback about length or citation density should treat cuts and additions as connected decisions: removing a tangential citation often also requires tightening the sentence that referenced it, rather than leaving a gap in the paragraph's logical flow.

A further practical consideration is where the background material of the introduction should end and the discussion’s comparison with prior literature should begin, since authors new to a field sometimes attempt to pre-empt every possible question by discussing results-level comparisons with prior studies within the introduction itself. Methods guidance consistently holds that the introduction should establish only what is needed to justify the study’s objective, leaving detailed comparison of the study’s own findings with specific prior results to the discussion section, where that comparison can be made in light of the actual findings17. Reviewers reading an introduction that strays into this kind of results-anticipating discussion often flag it as a structural issue distinct from, but related to, the core gap-and-objective problems described earlier, since it is frequently a symptom of the same underlying uncertainty about the narrower purpose of the introduction.

A useful self-check before submission is to read the final paragraph of the introduction in isolation, without the rest of the manuscript, and to assess whether it states a specific, falsifiable objective that a reader unfamiliar with the field could understand and that the study’s design could plausibly answer8. If that final paragraph instead reads as a restatement of the paper’s general topic, broad enough to accommodate almost any result the study might produce, this is itself a reliable predictor of the kind of gap-and-objective feedback described throughout this article, and revising that single paragraph before submission is among the most valuable revisions an author can make to an otherwise complete manuscript.

Co-authors reading a draft for the first time can serve as useful proxies for this check, since they are close enough to the work to judge whether the stated objective genuinely follows from the gap described, yet sufficiently removed from the day-to-day analysis to notice when a logical step that the primary author takes for granted is not stated explicitly in the text.

Key points

Key points

Reviewers judge an introduction by whether it narrows from a clearly stated problem to a demonstrated literature gap and then to a research question that follows visibly from that gap, and by whether a brief roadmap indicates that the paper was planned as a whole before it was written.

Practical application

Practical application

  1. The relevance of the problem should be stated within the first few sentences. Reviewers expect to understand why the topic matters before reading further, and delaying this explanation reduces their confidence in everything that follows.
  2. The specific literature that demonstrates the stated gap should be cited, rather than the existence of the gap merely being asserted. A gap supported by a focused, recent set of citations reads as demonstrated, whereas an unsupported claim of a gap reads as unverified.
  3. The objective should be written so that a reader could judge, from the introduction alone, whether the results addressed it. An objective broad enough to accommodate any outcome is a commonly identified weakness, whereas a specific, falsifiable objective is not.

Frequently asked questions

Published writing guidance recommends a concise, focused review built from the most relevant and recent sources rather than an exhaustive history of the field, since length itself is not what establishes relevance.

Across multiple reviewer-reason studies, an unclear or unestablished literature gap, the specific claim of what is missing from existing knowledge, is among the most frequently flagged issues.

It is common, expected practice in most empirical research articles and is noted when missing, though its absence alone rarely causes rejection; it tends to correlate with other structural weaknesses rather than standing alone as a critical flaw.

Standard guidance places the gap first and the research question immediately after, so the question reads as a direct response to the gap rather than an independently introduced idea.

ICMJE and COPE guidance both frame assessing a manuscript's stated aims and justification as an early step in review, generally addressed before or alongside the detailed methodological assessment.

References

  1. Cals JW, Kotz D. Effective writing and publishing scientific papers, part III: introduction. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology. 2013;66(7):702. read 10 October 2026. View on Journal of Clinical Epidemiology
  2. Tullu MS, Karande S. Writing the introduction section of a research paper. Journal of Postgraduate Medicine. 2020. read 10 October 2026. View on Journal of Postgraduate Medicine
  3. Provenzale JM, Stanley RJ. A systematic guide to reviewing a manuscript. American Journal of Roentgenology. 2005;185(4):848-854. read 10 October 2026. View on AJR
  4. International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing, and Publication of Scholarly Work in Medical Journals. read 10 October 2026. View on ICMJE.org
  5. Bordage G. Reasons reviewers reject and accept manuscripts: the strengths and weaknesses in medical education reports. Academic Medicine. 2001;76(9):889-896. read 10 October 2026. View on Academic Medicine
  6. Pierson DJ. The top 10 reasons why manuscripts are not accepted for publication. Respiratory Care. 2004;49(10):1246-1252. read 10 October 2026. View on Respiratory Care
  7. Annesley TM. It was a cold and rainy night: set the scene with a good introduction. Clinical Chemistry. 2010;56(5):708-713. read 10 October 2026. View on Clinical Chemistry
  8. Yaddanapudi LN, Yaddanapudi S. Peer review: an introduction and important issues. Indian Journal of Anaesthesia. 2015. read 10 October 2026. View on Indian Journal of Anaesthesia
  9. Hall GM, ed. How to Write a Paper. 5th ed. BMJ Books; 2012. read 10 October 2026. View publisher record
  10. Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers. read 10 October 2026. View on publicationethics.org

Every source above is a peer-reviewed article, a publisher’s record of one, or a standard issued by the body that owns it. Each carries the date it was last read. Where a standard moves, this article is revised rather than left up with a note.

How to cite this article

Pick your referencing style and copy it. Your university or target journal may vary the punctuation — check its guide if it has one.

Pubrica Academy. (2026, October 10). Peer Reviewer Comments on the Introduction Section of Original Research Articles. Pubrica. https://pubrica.com/academy/original-research-article/suggestions-given-by-peer-reviewers-in-the-introduction-section-of-the-original-research-article/

This article is written to be learned from. Cite it if you are referring to what it says; if you are using the evidence behind it, cite the sources listed above instead.

Introduction Section Review Checklist

Before submission, the introduction should be checked against the issues that peer reviewers raise most often.

[ ] Stated the problem's relevance within the opening sentences
[ ] Cited focused, recent literature that makes the gap visible rather than asserted
[ ] Confirmed the research question/objective reads as a direct response to the stated gap
[ ] Written an objective specific enough to be judged against the eventual results
[ ] Added a brief closing roadmap sentence describing the paper's structure
[ ] Re-read the introduction as a reviewer would, checking the narrowing logic end to end

Pubrica AcademyWritten and maintained by Pubrica’s subject matter experts. Articles are revised when the underlying standards change, and each article states the date on which it was last reviewed.

How Pubrica can help

Pubrica’s manuscript development team reviews introduction sections before submission against the gap-and-objective logic applied by peer reviewers, so that common reviewer comments are addressed in advance rather than in a second round of revision.

Find something else

Search the Pubrica Academy

Access is free and requires no account. Enter a topic, or open the full library to filter by category, sub-topic or resource type.

Demonstration of the literature gap in the introduction

A scoping assessment is free and takes two business days. It provides a written assessment of what the work requires and which specialist would undertake it.

Get a free quote

Regulations

Check your project against this rule

  1. 1Your work
  2. 2Your details
  3. 3Send
What do you need?

Material you send is held under signed confidentiality, with access limited to the assigned team and encrypted transfer. It is not used to train anything and is not passed to third-party tools. Ask for the agreement before you send anything you would rather cover first.