Free scoping read. A written assessment of your manuscript in two business days, at no cost.

Start one
Contents

On this page

  1. References

Academy · Medical Research

Reporting guidelines – Manuscript Writing in Medical Research

What reporting guidelines are, how EQUATOR checklists such as CONSORT and STROBE shape a manuscript, and how journal endorsement and adherence are judged.

Pubrica AcademyWritten by the medical writing and biostatistics teamsPublished21 January 2022Reading time3 minutes

Introduction

WHAT ARE REPORTING GUIDELINES?

Reporting guidelines are tools that advise authors publishing a scientific article on particular study items to be disclosed to improve the research rigour, reproducibility, transparency, and scientific community acceptance of the study results and conclusions. Reporting guidelines usually outline the development process and give researchers a checklist of elements that should be reported based on the study design. The checklist is extremely valuable since it offers writers an easy-to-follow structure for planning the research endeavour, from study protocol preparation to study implementation, data analysis, and manuscript writing. Each research design has its reporting standards (Table 1). The Enhancing the Quality and Transparency of Health Research (EQUATOR) Network, a global project aimed at improving published health research reporting quality, has established the most widely used reporting guidelines. The most well-known EQUATOR recommendations are Consolidated Reporting Trials (CONSORT) for randomised clinical trials (RCTs) and STROBE for observational research. Several offers share specific components, such as the experimental research design in the paper title and the participant flow diagram, which shows how many people were screened for eligibility, how many were eliminated, and why they were excluded. Other factors to consider are unique to each research design (e.g., the type of randomisation procedure used in RCTs within the CONSORT guideline)(1)

scientific literature

Figure. 1 Reporting guidelines of EQUATOR(2)

In the context of this systematic review, definitions relevant to the evaluation of reporting guidelines

Endorsement— a journal’s action to show that it supports using one or more reporting guideline(s) by authors submitting research reports for review; generally accomplished through a statement in its “Instructions to authors” section.

Adherence— Action did by an author to ensure that a manuscript complies with the items indicated by the appropriate/relevant reporting guideline (reports all specified items).

Implementation— Journals are taking steps to guarantee that authors follow approved reporting criteria and that published articles are fully documented.

Complete reporting— the status of a research report’s reporting and whether it complies with any applicable reporting standard.

roprting guidelines

Scenario

Researchers conducted a prospective cohort analysis of 101 patients admitted to the ICU at a university hospital in So Paulo, Brazil, and analysed mechanical ventilator waveforms to quantify the prevalence of patient-ventilator asynchrony. According to the researchers, a high majority of asynchrony was linked to more significant weaning failure, but not to death. The study results were published using the STROBE (Strengthening the Reporting of Observational Studies in Epidemiology) reporting criteria (3).

WHY ARE REPORTING GUIDELINES IMPORTANT?

The use of reporting rules ensures that writers disclose all essential components of a research study, allowing the reader to comprehend all relevant parts of the investigation properly. This is critical because other researchers may duplicate methods. Results can be included inefficient reviews or utilised by clinicians to assist clinical decision making when a paper provides accurate and comprehensive study information. For example, when a paper publishes the results of an RCT but fails to mention how many prospective participants were removed from the study, the generalizability and internal validity of the findings may be compromised. Similarly, in our supposed situation, if the publication omitted to indicate how many participants were lost during follow-up, readers would be unable to assess the cohort study’s risk of bias. As a result, the findings would be useless in clinical decision-making. The international research community increasingly recognises that following reporting requirements enhances the quality of research and helps to reduce resource waste in poorly reported projects. As a result, most high-impact medical journals now require RCTs to follow CONSORT standards, and most observational studies incorporate STROBE flow diagrams (4).

Table 1. Reporting guidelines for most study designs.

Study designReporting guidelines
Randomised trialsCONSORT
Observational studiesSTROBE
Systematic reviewsPRISMA
Study protocolsSPIRIT, PRISMA-P
Diagnostic/prognostic studiesSTARD
Prognostic studiesTRIPOD
Case reportsCARE
Clinical practice guidelinesAGREE, RIGHT
Qualitative researchSRQR, COREQ
Animal preclinical studiesARRIVE
Quality improvement studiesSQUIRE
Economic evaluationsCHEERS

Need support with this?

Pubrica’s writers, editors and statisticians work with authors on medical research and related publication tasks. The authors keep ownership of the work and responsibility for its content. Talk to the team.

References

  1. Ferreira, Juliana Carvalho, and Cecilia M. Patino. “Reporting guidelines: essential tools for manuscript writing in medical research.” Jornal Brasileiro de Pneumologia 47 (2021).
  2. Stevens, Adrienne, et al. “Relation of completeness of reporting of health research to journals’ endorsement of reporting guidelines: a systematic review.” BMJ 348 (2014).
  3. Sousa MLA, Magrans R, Hayashi FK, Blanch L, Kacmarek RM, Ferreira JC. Predictors of asynchronies during assisted ventilation and its impact on clinical outcomes: The EPISYNC cohort study. J Crit Care. 2020; 57:30-35.
  4. Equator Network [homepage on the Internet]. Oxford: . Available from: UK EQUATOR Centre; [cited 2021 Feb 2]
Get a free quote

Regulations

Check your project against this rule

  1. 1Your work
  2. 2Your details
  3. 3Send
What do you need?

Material you send is held under signed confidentiality, with access limited to the assigned team and encrypted transfer. It is not used to train anything and is not passed to third-party tools. Ask for the agreement before you send anything you would rather cover first.