Free scoping read. A written assessment of your manuscript in two business days, at no cost.

Start one
Contents

Academy · Research Data, Analytics & AI · BeHEMoTh Framework

The BeHEMoTh Framework: Behaviour, Health Context, Exclusions, Models or Theories in Systematic Searching for Theory

BeHEMoTh is the framework that Booth and Carroll developed and tested for a particularly difficult form of systematic searching: the identification of theory rather than empirical studies. Their 2015 paper reports that it proved feasible across two independently conducted test reviews.

Pubrica AcademyWritten by an evidence synthesis methodologist Reviewed bya systematic review specialist Published10 October 2026 Last checked10 October 2026 Reading time11 minutes Sources15 peer-reviewed

BeHEMoTh structures a question around four elements, Behaviour of interest, Health context, Exclusions, and Models or Theories, and it was built for a specific, difficult problem that other frameworks do not address: searching systematically for theory itself, rather than for empirical studies of an intervention or exposure. Andrew Booth and Christopher Carroll developed and tested it in a 2015 Health Information & Libraries Journal paper, which asked directly whether systematic, reproducible searching for theory is feasible at all, and concluded that it is, provided the question is structured with an explicit exclusions element that most other frameworks lack.

BeHEMoTh at a glance

Stands for
Behaviour of interest, Health context, Exclusions, Models or Theories
Source
Booth and Carroll (2015), Health Information & Libraries Journal1
Best for
Finding the theories, models and frameworks used to explain a behaviour, for example before a best-fit framework synthesis or realist review
Not for
Finding empirical studies of whether an intervention works (use PICO) or qualitative studies of experience (use SPIDER)
Distinctive feature
An Exclusions element written before searching, to keep a noisy theory search manageable
Reading time
About 11 minutes, with 4 figures and 4 tables

Learning objectives

  • The specific problem BeHEMoTh was designed to solve, and why it differs from PICO-family frameworks
  • Each of the four BeHEMoTh elements, including the unusual ‘Exclusions’ element
  • What the two test reviews by Booth and Carroll found about searching for theory

Common misconceptions

  • “Searching systematically for theoretical literature is basically the same task as searching for empirical studies, just with different keywords.” Booth and Carroll's 2015 paper treats searching for theory as a distinct methodological problem serious enough to require its own framework, built around an explicit 'Exclusions' element specifically because theory-related literature is scattered, inconsistently indexed, and prone to false hits that an ordinary PICO-style search does not anticipate.

The methodological problem addressed by BeHEMoTh

Most systematic review question frameworks, PICO included, are built to find empirical studies that measured an intervention's effect on an outcome. Booth and Carroll identified a different, underserved need: reviews that aim to identify the theories or models used to explain a behaviour or a health context, not studies that tested an intervention against that behaviour1. Theoretical literature is a poor match for standard database indexing, because a paper applying or discussing a theory may never use the theory’s name in its title or abstract, and the same theory can appear across psychology, sociology, management, and health literatures under different disciplinary vocabularies. Booth and Carroll’s 2015 paper frames this as an open methodological question, asking explicitly whether systematic, transparent searching for theory is “feasible” and “desirable” at all, rather than assuming the answer1.

BeHEMoTh compared with frameworks built for empirical studies

FrameworkElementsWhat the search retrievesExclusions element?
PICOPopulation, Intervention, Comparison, OutcomeStudies measuring an intervention’s effect5No
SPIDERSample, Phenomenon of Interest, Design, Evaluation, Research typeQualitative and mixed-methods studies4No
BeHEMoThBehaviour of interest, Health context, Exclusions, Models or TheoriesPapers that propose, apply or discuss theory1Yes, stated before searching

The four elements, including the Exclusions element

Behaviour of interest names the specific behaviour, action, or phenomenon the theory is meant to explain. Health context situates that behaviour within a specific service, policy, or intervention setting. Exclusions is the element that distinguishes BeHEMoTh from nearly every other question framework: it requires authors to state explicitly what should be excluded from the search results, because theory-related searches are especially prone to retrieving large numbers of superficially relevant but ultimately irrelevant records, and an explicit exclusions statement is what keeps the search manageable. Models or Theories is the final element, naming either specific candidate theories already known to be relevant or leaving the slot open to discover unnamed theories through the search itself2. Together, the four elements convert an open-ended question such as “what theories explain medication non-adherence” into a bounded, searchable structure.

BeBehaviour of interestThe behaviour, action or phenomenon the theory should explain
HHealth contextThe service, policy or intervention setting the behaviour sits in
EExclusionsWhat to leave out, written down before the first search is run
MoThModels or TheoriesNamed candidate theories, or left open to discover them

Combined into one question (illustrative example from this article)Which theories or models explain near-miss incident reporting by nursing staff within hospital patient-safety reporting systems, excluding non-healthcare whistleblowing theories and studies that only describe reporting rates?

Figure 1. The four BeHEMoTh elements combined into one theory-search question, using the incident-reporting example discussed below. The example is illustrative, not taken from a published review.

What each BeHEMoTh element should specify

ElementAsk yourselfTypical contentAvoid
Behaviour of interestWhich behaviour should the theory explain?Incident reporting, medication adherence, purchase intention, help-seekingA broad topic such as “safety culture” that is not a behaviour
Health contextIn what service or policy setting?Hospital reporting systems, primary care, online health marketingOmitting it, which pulls in theories from every setting
ExclusionsWhat will match my terms but not answer my question?Theories from unrelated sectors; descriptive studies with no theory; named populations or designsWriting it after seeing the results without recording the change
Models or TheoriesDo I already know candidate theories?Named theories, or generic terms such as concept, framework, model, theory1Naming only the theories you already know when the aim is discovery

Worked example applying all four elements

Applied to a question about what theories explain why nursing staff do or do not report near-miss safety incidents, Behaviour of interest is incident-reporting behavior among nursing staff. Health context is hospital patient-safety and incident-reporting systems. Exclusions might specify excluding theories developed purely for consumer or non-healthcare whistleblowing contexts, and excluding studies that describe incident-reporting rates without proposing or testing any explanatory theory at all, since these would otherwise inflate the results without addressing the review question. Models or Theories could be left open to discover candidates, or could name known starting points such as the Theory of Planned Behaviour and organizational Just Culture frameworks, both plausible explanatory candidates that merit examination before the search begins. Writing out the Exclusions element this specifically, before running a single search, is what turns an abstract four-letter mnemonic into an operational search strategy that a second researcher could reproduce from the protocol alone4.

Weak BeHEMoTh question

“What theories explain incident reporting?”

No health context, no exclusions and no decision about candidate theories. The search will retrieve every reporting-rate study and every whistleblowing paper in any sector.

Strong BeHEMoTh question

“Which theories explain near-miss incident reporting by hospital nursing staff, excluding non-healthcare whistleblowing theories and purely descriptive reporting-rate studies?”

All four elements are explicit, and the Exclusions are written before searching. Illustrative example.

Two BeHEMoTh questions, element by element

ElementIncident reporting (this article)Medication non-adherence
Behaviour of interestNear-miss incident reporting by nursing staffNot taking medicines as prescribed
Health contextHospital patient-safety and incident-reporting systemsLong-term condition management in primary care
ExclusionsNon-healthcare whistleblowing theories; studies of reporting rates with no explanatory theoryPharmacokinetic “adherence” models; adherence-rate surveys with no theory
Models or TheoriesOpen, or starting from the Theory of Planned Behaviour and Just CultureOpen, to discover which theories exist

Illustrative examples written for this guide, not drawn from published reviews. The non-adherence question extends the example mentioned in the section on the four elements.

Findings of the feasibility test by Booth and Carroll

Rather than proposing BeHEMoTh as an untested theoretical tool, Booth and Carroll developed it and then applied it within two separate systematic reviews to test whether it was workable in practice1. Their 2015 paper reports that the structured, four-element approach was workable across both test applications, giving a documented, applied answer to the feasibility question the paper opens with, rather than leaving it as an open methodological debate. This is of practical importance because a framework that appears sound in principle but fails when applied to a real, heterogeneous evidence base would not merit adoption; the specific contribution of Booth and Carroll is that they tested BeHEMoTh against real review topics before publishing it as usable guidance1.

Why a template was needed: how 34 reviews reported their search for theory

ReviewsShare of 34
Reported
12
35%
Not stated
19
56%
No data
3
9%

Rows: reported a method for identifying theory; did not specify how studies containing theory were identified; data unavailable. The 35% figure is reported by the authors; the other two percentages are calculated from their counts.

Figure 2. Booth and Carroll searched PubMed for reviews published between 1998 and 2012 that had explicitly sought to identify theory. Only 12 of the 34 described how they had done so, which is the reporting gap the BeHEMoTh template was built to close.1
2015Template publishedBooth and Carroll, Health Information & Libraries Journal: BeHEMoTh constructed and tested within two systematic reviews1
2018Systematic review of theoriesVotruba et al., Health Research Policy and Systems: frameworks linking evidence and mental health policy in low- and middle-income countries11
2021Scoping review protocolQuasdorf et al., Systematic Reviews: theoretical approaches to process evaluations of complex interventions12
2023Best-fit framework synthesisGülpınar et al., BMC Complementary Medicine and Therapies: social media influencers and purchase intention for complementary medicines13
2024Best-fit framework synthesisBotha and De Wet, Heliyon: the CyPVICS framework for cybersickness in virtual clinical simulation14
2024Realist reviewMashao et al., Nurse Education Today: a programme theory for novice nurses’ transition in emergency departments15
Figure 3. From the 2015 paper to peer-reviewed reviews that report using BeHEMoTh. A selection found in PubMed in November 2026, not a complete list.

BeHEMoTh and the development of a conceptual framework

A BeHEMoTh-structured search is frequently the step that supplies the raw material for a study’s own conceptual framework, since a researcher building a bespoke framework from several existing concepts first needs a systematic, reasonably complete view of which theories and models already exist in the relevant literature, rather than relying on whichever theories are already familiar to them. In this sense BeHEMoTh and the distinction between a theoretical and a conceptual framework are directly linked: a well-conducted BeHEMoTh search allows a researcher to state, with some confidence, that no single existing theory already covers the phenomenon in question, which is the condition under which building a study-specific conceptual framework, rather than simply adopting one existing theory, becomes the more defensible choice. Omitting a systematic theory search and building a conceptual framework from only the few theories already known to the researcher risks missing a closer-fitting existing theory that a more thorough search, using BeHEMoTh’s explicit Exclusions step to keep the search manageable, would have identified.

How peer-reviewed studies have used BeHEMoTh

StudyReview type and topicHow BeHEMoTh was used, as reportedRef
Votruba et al. 2018, Health Research Policy and SystemsSystematic review of theories, frameworks and models on evidence and mental health policy in low- and middle-income countriesSearch based on the BeHEMoTh method across nine databases; of 236 full texts, none met all criteria, and 10 studies were included once “agenda-setting” was dropped11
Quasdorf et al. 2021, Systematic ReviewsProtocol for a systematic scoping review of theoretical approaches to process evaluations in health careSearch strategy to be developed from the BeHEMoTh template, searching MEDLINE, CINAHL and PsycInfo plus hand searching12
Gülpınar et al. 2023, BMC Complementary Medicine and TherapiesBest-fit framework synthesis on social media influencers and purchase intention for complementary medicinesBeHEMoTh strategy used for a priori theory selection; the model drew on the theory of planned behaviour and source credibility theory13
Botha and De Wet 2024, HeliyonBest-fit framework synthesis building a framework to prevent cybersickness in immersive virtual clinical simulationSeparate BeHEMoTh search for models and theories (1,567 titles and abstracts screened, 15 papers used) alongside a SPIDER search for primary studies14
Mashao et al. 2024, Nurse Education TodayRealist review of transition programmes for novice emergency department nursesBeHEMoTh search used to identify theories supporting the programme theory; the main search was framed with PCC15

Descriptions are taken from each article’s published abstract.

What this means for your review

In the published examples, BeHEMoTh is rarely the only search. It usually runs beside a second search for empirical studies (SPIDER or PCC in the examples above), and its output feeds a best-fit framework synthesis or a realist programme theory. Plan for both searches from the start.

Searching across disciplinary databases

Because theories migrate across fields — the same underlying explanatory idea about behaviour can appear in psychology databases under one name, in sociology databases under a related but differently worded name, and in management or health-services databases applied to organisational rather than individual behaviour — a BeHEMoTh search for theory frequently has to be run across several disciplinary databases rather than the single database on which a more conventional empirical search might rely. This is one reason why the Exclusions element is so important in practice: searching multiple disciplinary databases for a loosely defined behaviour and context, without a clear statement of what to exclude, multiplies the number of superficially relevant but off-topic records far more than a single-database search would, since each additional database contributes its own field-specific false hits.

Behaviour of interestincident reportingnear misserror reporting
AND
Health contexthospitalpatient safetynursing staff
AND
Models or Theoriestheory / theoreticalmodelframework / concept
("incident report*" OR "near miss*" OR "error report*")
AND (hospital* OR "patient safety" OR nurs*)
AND (theor* OR model* OR framework* OR concept*)
/* Exclusions: add NOT terms, or apply at screening */
Figure 4. Behaviour, Health context and Models or Theories become OR-clusters joined by AND; the generic theory terms are those Booth and Carroll identified as candidates. Exclusions are applied as a NOT line or at screening. Illustrative search for the incident-reporting example.1

Application of BeHEMoTh in a review

The Behaviour of interest and the Health context should first be named as specifically as the question allows, since vague versions of either element will produce an unmanageably broad search. The Exclusions statement should then be written before searching begins, not after the first batch of results has been seen, listing the kinds of records, by study type, population or disciplinary angle, that are not relevant even though they might superficially match the Behaviour and Health context terms. Finally, it should be decided whether Models or Theories should name specific candidate theories (if some are already known from preliminary reading) or remain open (if the purpose of the review is partly to discover which theories exist in the literature). This order, defining what to exclude before searching rather than after, is the specific methodological contribution that distinguishes BeHEMoTh from question frameworks built for more straightforward empirical questions3.

A protocol that records all four elements, including the Exclusions, should let a second reviewer rebuild the same search. Exclusions written before searching can still be refined once early results arrive, as long as each change is recorded.

Protocol checklist for a BeHEMoTh search

  • Name the framework in full: Behaviour of interest, Health context, Exclusions, Models or Theories.
  • Cite Booth and Carroll (2015) as the source of the template1.
  • Write the Exclusions statement before running any search.
  • Record whether Models or Theories names candidate theories or is left open for discovery.
  • Date and log every revision to the Exclusions, so the final protocol shows how the search boundary evolved.
  • List each disciplinary database searched, since theories appear under different names in different fields.
  • Report the empirical-studies search separately if, as in most published examples, one runs alongside the theory search.

Key points

Key points

BeHEMoTh is a tested, purpose-built framework for systematically searching theoretical literature rather than empirical studies. Its distinguishing feature, an explicit Exclusions element defined before searching begins, is what makes this otherwise difficult form of search feasible.

Practical application

Practical application

  1. Define the Behaviour of interest and Health context as specifically as possible before searching. Vague versions of either element will produce a search too broad to manage, since theoretical literature is poorly indexed by discipline-specific vocabulary.
  2. Write the Exclusions statement before running any searches, not after reviewing initial results. This is the distinguishing step of BeHEMoTh, and omitting it reproduces the exact problem that the framework was built to solve.
  3. Decide explicitly whether Models or Theories should name candidates or stay open for discovery. This choice changes whether the search is confirmatory (testing known theories' relevance) or exploratory (finding which theories exist at all).

Frequently asked questions

Booth and Carroll developed and tested it within health-related systematic reviews, but its four-element logic, naming a behaviour, a context, explicit exclusions, and candidate theories, applies to any field where a review aims to identify theoretical or model-based literature rather than empirical intervention studies.

Adding ‘theory’ as a single keyword fails to address the core problem for which BeHEMoTh was designed: theoretical literature rarely identifies itself in that way in titles or abstracts, and a single added keyword does not filter out the large volume of superficially related but irrelevant records that theory searches tend to retrieve, which is specifically what the Exclusions element is designed to handle.

Yes; a review can use PICO to search for empirical intervention evidence and BeHEMoTh separately to search for the theoretical literature explaining the mechanism behind that intervention, running the two searches as distinct, separately reported strands.

Their 2015 paper reports that the approach proved workable across two test reviews, establishing feasibility; it should be read as a methods and feasibility paper rather than one reporting a specific numeric search-performance metric comparable to a sensitivity/specificity study.

References

  1. Booth A, Carroll C. Systematic searching for theory to inform systematic reviews: is it feasible? Is it desirable? Health Information & Libraries Journal. 2015;32(3):220-235. read 10 October 2026. View on Health Information & Libraries Journal
  2. Booth A. Searching for qualitative research for inclusion in systematic reviews: a structured methodological review. Systematic Reviews. 2016;5:74. read 10 October 2026. View on Systematic Reviews
  3. Booth A, Noyes J, Flemming K, Moore G, Tunçalp Ö, Shakibazadeh E. Formulating questions to explore complex interventions within qualitative evidence synthesis. BMJ Global Health. 2019;4(Suppl 1):e001107. read 10 October 2026. View on BMJ Global Health
  4. Cooke A, Smith D, Booth A. Beyond PICO: the SPIDER tool for qualitative evidence synthesis. Qualitative Health Research. 2012;22(10):1435-1443. read 10 October 2026. View on PubMed
  5. Richardson WS, Wilson MC, Nishikawa J, Hayward RS. The well-built clinical question: a key to evidence-based decisions. ACP Journal Club. 1995;123(3):A12-A13. read 10 October 2026. View via DOI
  6. Page MJ, McKenzie JE, Bossuyt PM, Boutron I, Hoffmann TC, Mulrow CD, et al. The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. BMJ. 2021;372:n71. read 10 October 2026. View on BMJ
  7. Sisson H. How helpful are mnemonics in the development of a research question? Nurse Researcher. 2017;25(3):42-45. read 10 October 2026. View via DOI
  8. Baylor University Libraries. Question Frameworks for Evidence Synthesis. read 10 October 2026. View the library guide
  9. Deakin University Library. Developing a Research Question for Evidence Synthesis. read 10 October 2026. View the library guide
  10. Imenda S. Is There a Conceptual Difference between Theoretical and Conceptual Frameworks? Journal of Social Sciences. 2014;38(2):185-195. read 10 October 2026. Read the paper (PDF)
  11. Votruba N, Ziemann A, Grant J, Thornicroft G. A systematic review of frameworks for the interrelationships of mental health evidence and policy in low- and middle-income countries. Health Research Policy and Systems. 2018;16(1):85. read 13 November 2026. View via DOI
  12. Quasdorf T, Clack L, Laporte Uribe F, Holle D, Berwig M, Purwins D, Schultes MT, Roes M. Theoretical approaches to process evaluations of complex interventions in health care: a systematic scoping review protocol. Systematic Reviews. 2021;10(1):268. read 13 November 2026. View via DOI
  13. Gülpınar G, Uzun MB, Iqbal A, Anderson C, Syed W, Al-Rawi MBA. A model of purchase intention of complementary and alternative medicines: the role of social media influencers’ endorsements. BMC Complementary Medicine and Therapies. 2023;23(1):439. read 13 November 2026. View via DOI
  14. Botha BS, De Wet L. CyPVICS: a framework to prevent or minimise cybersickness in immersive virtual clinical simulation. Heliyon. 2024;10(8):e29595. read 13 November 2026. View via DOI
  15. Mashao K, Botma Y, Filmalter C, Heyns T. A programme theory for a transition programme for novice nurses in emergency departments: a realist review. Nurse Education Today. 2024;144:106475. read 13 November 2026. View via DOI

Every source above is a peer-reviewed article, a publisher’s record of one, or a standard issued by the body that owns it. Each carries the date it was last read. Where a standard moves, this article is revised rather than left up with a note.

How to cite this article

Pick your referencing style and copy it. Your university or target journal may vary the punctuation — check its guide if it has one.

Pubrica Academy. (2026, October 10). The BeHEMoTh Framework: Behaviour, Health Context, Exclusions, Models or Theories in Systematic Searching for Theory. Pubrica. https://pubrica.com/academy/concepts-definitions/behemoth-behaviour-health-context-exclusions-models-or-theories/

This article is written to be learned from. Cite it if you are referring to what it says; if you are using the evidence behind it, cite the sources listed above instead.

BeHEMoTh Question Worksheet

Fill in all four elements, in order, before searching for theoretical literature.

Behaviour of interest: ____________________
Health context: ____________________
Exclusions (define BEFORE searching): ____________________
Models or Theories (named candidates, or left open for discovery): ____________________
[ ] Wrote the Exclusions statement before running any search
[ ] Decided whether Models/Theories names candidates or stays open
[ ] Checked multiple disciplinary vocabularies for the same theory under different names
[ ] Documented the full BeHEMoTh structure in the review protocol

Pubrica AcademyWritten and maintained by Pubrica’s subject matter experts. Articles are revised when the underlying standards change, and each article states the date on which it was last reviewed.

How Pubrica can help

Pubrica's evidence synthesis team applies the BeHEMoTh framework to structure and document searches for theoretical and model-based literature, including the explicit exclusions step that keeps a theory search from becoming unmanageable.

Find something else

Search the Pubrica Academy

Access is free and requires no account. Enter a topic, or open the full library to filter by category, sub-topic or resource type.

Specification of exclusions before searching

A scoping assessment is free and takes two business days. It provides a written assessment of what the work requires and which specialist would undertake it.

Get a free quote

Regulations

Check your project against this rule

  1. 1Your work
  2. 2Your details
  3. 3Send
What do you need?

Material you send is held under signed confidentiality, with access limited to the assigned team and encrypted transfer. It is not used to train anything and is not passed to third-party tools. Ask for the agreement before you send anything you would rather cover first.